The Justice and Judgement of the Judge

Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached June 7, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: John 12:44-50 0:29
44Then Jesus cried out, “Whoever believes in Me does not believe in Me alone, but in the One who sent Me. 45And whoever sees Me sees the One who sent Me. 46I have come into the world as a light, so that no one who believes in Me should remain in darkness. 47As for anyone who hears My words and does not keep them, I do not judge him. For I have not come to judge the world, but to save the world. 48There is a judge for the one who rejects Me and does not receive My words: The word that I have spoken will judge him on the last day. 49I have not spoken on My own, but the Father who sent Me has commanded Me what to say and how to say it. 50And I know that His command leads to eternal life. So I speak exactly what the Father has told Me to say.”

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

1:19 I was told that my title has been very triggering for some because of Aaron Judge is hurt. And so the justice and judgment of Aaron Judge. It's okay. We have the Knicks now. It's okay now. Good morning and welcome again to Redeemer Lincoln Square. We've been doing a series on the Apostles' Creed the past couple weeks because the Apostles' Creed is one of the oldest statements that the church has. that multiple traditions of Christianity point back to and say, yes, I believe in that. Catholicism, Protestantism, Eastern Orthodox, Greek Orthodox, Russian Orthodox. These streams of the church can point back to one of these earliest statements. that we're going to read later in our service and say, this is what we believe. Now we're going through it because just because you say something doesn't mean you understand it. So we're going through it phrase by phrase. And today we arrive at some of the least popular phrases in the entire text of the Apostles' Creed. The phrase is, he descended into hell. And the phrase, he will come to judge the living and the dead. Now we live in a culture today that officially, the official banner of our culture is that we do not like judgment. We reject the idea of judgment.

2:46 We say, who are you to judge? Who are you to say that you get to judge how someone lives their life, how someone uses their body, how someone decides to make the decisions that they make. And so we say, who are you to judge? And yet what's so, I find ironic, is that we still have the internet, which might be one of the most efficient judgment apparatuses in the world, where you go on there and everyone is incessantly and ruthlessly judging each other.

3:30 Which then begs another question, which is this. How did a culture that wants to say no judgment create one of the most judging spaces ever? And I think that's actually a clue. Because I think we've claimed to have abandoned judgment. We've claimed that we don't judge. but all we've done is democratized it. That now everybody is a judge. We don't call people sinners anymore. You know what we do? We call them problematic. We've changed the vocabulary but we still do exactly the same thing. Now, here's my favorite thing that we do now today is this. Is we say, hey, you do you, you do you. But if you don't do it like me, you're canceled. Which is just so ironic. because on one part of our mouth, we say, hey, do whatever you want. But if you don't do it my way, if you don't do it our way, you're canceled.

4:29 And so I believe that at the end of the day, we still judge. The verdict is the same. We've just changed the vocabulary. And so when people come and say, you know what? I think Christianity is regressive because it has this idea of a judging God. I want you to see before we go anywhere else that we live in a culture. that officially opposes judgment, and yet practically we can't stop doing it. We do it every single day.

4:59 And so today we come to a passage where Jesus steps right in the middle of that tension. Look at verse 47. He says, for I did not come to judge the world. Everybody's like, yay. And the next verse, but there is a judge and there will be a verdict. Boo. You see, we want no judgment, but we still want real justice. And I think Jesus is coming here to say, actually, you can have both. But how? How do you get both? Let's look at three things today. Number one, we judge and need judgment. Number two, no one passes. And so then lastly, then what will? How will we? All right, so number one, we judge and need judgment. Number two, no one passes.

5:45 And so then we'll look lastly on then what will. So first we judge and need judgment. Look at verse 48 here. This text, Jesus is speaking and he says, hey, there is a judge for the one who rejects me and does not accept my words. The very words I have spoken will condemn them. Now many people read that and go, exactly. See, this is what I don't like. This is what I mean by condemnation and religiosity. And this is what I mean by it's regressive because there's all this, all these rules and, you know, there's a judge and if you reject me and does not accept my words, you know, the very words I have spoken will condemn them. And so we live in a culture that says, no, no, I believe in a judgment-free zone. Really? Look at some of the most successful ad campaigns out there. I was talking to my daughter on the way out today, and I said, you know, Nike built their entire empire off of three words, just do it. And that's an imperative, that's a command. It's basically saying that action is more important than inaction. She's like, no, no, no, dad, it's a suggestion. And I said, that doesn't sound like a suggestion. That's like, just do it. Sprite, what does Sprite say? Obey your thirst. It's another imperative. Okay, I got to obey my thirst. Apple, what does Apple say? Think differently. These are all actual, these are direct statements. These are imperatives. And these ad campaigns are actually moral visions dressed up as lifestyle choices. They are actually telling you, they're signaling what you should be, what you should do, what you should buy. It's telling you what kind of person it's worth being. I believe that's the world that we live in. We live in a world where people say out of one side of their mouth, truth is relative, and at the other side of their mouth,

7:51 at the same time, they'll say, hey, judgment is wrong, which by the way is a judgment. That everybody can't stop living this way. Every choice you make, whether you know it or not, what you do at work, who you relate to, what you spend your time on, those are all moral choices that you've decided on and you can't opt out of those. C.S. Lewis points this out. He says, the way that you know that a line is crooked the only way that you can know a line is crooked is because you know what a straight line is. The only way for you to be able to call something unjust is because you have some idea in your head somewhere. of what is just, of what is right or wrong. The ability for you to say that's wrong, the minute you say that, and we all do, proves that you actually hold a standard.

8:45 Even if out of one side of your mouth you say there is no standard. I find it interesting that the people often most loudly saying that we shouldn't judge others, often the same people most passionately wanting to judge people that won't hold to their moral vision of what's right and wrong. And so the next time when somebody says, hey, who are you to judge? You need to realize, it may be you saying it, you need to realize that's a judging statement. you're judging someone else about their judging. That's still judging. You can't get away from it. See, this is what I believe. We never stop believing in judgment. I think we just stop being honest about it. That's the word we live in. But we need to go deeper than this. Because yes, we judge. But why? Why do we judge? Because I think somewhere deep down inside of us, we know that we need a judge as well.

9:42 this is what Yale professor Merslav Volf has pointed out he said that the idea that there's no judgment has to come from a very comfortable place in the west because if you go anywhere else in the world when your tribe is wiped out when your village is flattened when your family is massacred and slaughtered if there is no cosmic judge if you don't believe in that, that's the recipe for you to feel the need to pick up a sword and go get that vengeance, go get that justice yourself, because if you don't do it, no one will.

10:21 That's the world we're living in. That the very cause of the endless cycle of retaliation comes from this idea that if I don't get justice, no, justice won't come. And so what happens is you hurt me, fine, I'm going to hurt you. And then they say, okay, well, you hurt us, so then we're going to hurt you and back and forth and back and forth. And so he says this. He says, the only thing that's going to break the cycle of violence is the conviction that there is a judge and he's not you.

10:55 That there is a judge. And if you don't get vengeance right now, if you don't get justice right now, don't worry because it will come. It will actually come eventually. And so I want us to try to think about the last time someone was cruel, someone was hurtful to you or to someone you loved. I don't know about you, but I've definitely had nights in my life where I can't sleep because I'm just replaying over and over and over again the injustice of it all.

11:26 And in those moments, I want you to see that the reason why you feel that way is because somewhere in you, you deep down wanted an authority to say, that's wrong, and I will make it right. And so I know we judge, but I also think we need and we want judgment. And so the question underneath all the unhealed hurts of your life, all the unanswered wrongs that have ever happened in your life, the question there is, well, who will make it right? What will make it right. Christianity is not regressive for giving you a judge. It's just being honest enough to admit that you actually need one. the truth is everybody already believes in judgment. We just disagree about whose standard that will be used and who gets to be the one to take out the sentencing.

12:23 And so the question isn't, does judgment exist? We already believe that. The real question is, can any one of us pass? And so this is the second point here. Can any of us pass? When you think about judgment, this is what we do. we divide the world often into two categories, right? The good and the bad. And we like it when it's easy. Dictators, bad. Murderers, bad. Often when we get to ourselves, you know what we do? We're very nuanced. We're like, well, you know, I don't do everything right, but you know, I recycle. You know, I pay my taxes. I don't do anything seriously wrong. So I'm, you know, I think I just squeaked in just on the other side. That's what we do. But look at what Jesus says here in verse 47. Go back to our text. And he says again, if anyone hears my words but does not keep them, I do not judge them.

13:19 I don't judge that person. If I didn't come to judge the world, right? But then go on to the, again, you have to keep combining 47 and 48. But there is a judge for the one who rejects me and does not accept my words. The very words I have spoken will condemn them at the last day. If you read that a couple times, you realize what he's saying. He's saying that judgment doesn't necessarily need to come from some arbitrary external system.

13:49 There's this view out there, and I know this because I've lived in New York enough, that there's this view that people think that God has made this sort of external moral vision. He's just going to grate everybody against it even though we don't know what it is. These words are basically saying that no, there's a standard. He's not inventing a standard that you don't know about. It actually comes internally from your own life.

14:15 It's what you've already agreed to that you've applied to others. Francis Schaeffer who is a famous pastor theologian he actually came up with one of the best analogies illustrations of what this looks like he says imagine that every baby that is born gets an invisible tape recorder around their neck he's a little dated I don't know we don't, if you're Gen Z, you don't know what a tape recorder is, you can ask somebody else what that is but imagine there's this tape recorder around your neck and it only records every single thought that that person thinks about another or says about another as a form of judgment. It only captures all the moral judgments that we make about other people throughout our entire lives. So every time you think, you know what, that person should have been more patient.

15:08 Oh man, that person over there is cruel. Oh, why is that person so selfish? They should not be selfish. That person over there, they shouldn't talk behind other people's backs. Whether you say it out loud or non-verbally, Francis Schaeffer says, imagine that's recorded and then at the end of your life, it's played back as the moral standard that you're gonna be judged by. Well, that would be fair, right? Of course it would be fair because we're not being measured by something arbitrary. We're being measured by the very standard that we have, that we've used against other people and therefore we've accepted. And now ask yourself, if that's you, and that recorder is played back, would we pass? Not a chance. Not a chance. We demand patience from others, and then we lose our cool.

16:02 We ask for perfection about others, and then to ourselves there's nuance. we expect loyalty while reserving the right for ourselves to be able to opt out anytime we want when it comes to other people. Tony Soprano in the TV series, The Sopranos, there are 86 episodes. In every single one of them, he goes to counseling. Some level, you see that or you hear the voiceover.

16:31 And you need to, there's actually a change. As you watch these series, he does actually, does he get more self-aware? Of course he does. Is he able to process as a mob boss all the atrocities that he does. Of course he does. Is he able to see the pattern of his life? The answer is yes. But does he actually change? No. He doesn't change. He had all the insight in the world. All the introspection. And by the way, I'm all for insight and introspection. but that those things didn't give him what he needed.

17:41 What he needed, he couldn't reach. Insight without transformation is not salvation. Insight without transformation doesn't work because you can't fix what you are with who you are. It doesn't work that way. The part of you that you want to change is the same part of you that you're going to use to change, and it can't work. It doesn't work. Because your problem isn't just the action on the outside. The problem is the heart. This is what Jesus gets to when he goes to Matthew, sorry, in Matthew chapter 7, there's this like imagery where Jesus says, take the plank out of your own eye before you take the speck out of somebody else's. He's not just talking about actions. He's talking about the heart. He's not saying the plank is just blocking your vision.

18:34 It's forming your vision. It's forming how you see other people and what you do with other people. And so this is why we need to keep asking ourselves, when we judge ourselves, when we're kind of putting people over here into the bad category and ourselves over here, we're looking at our actions, but you need to look underneath. Look at your motives.

18:54 Why is it that when we help people, what's really going on when we help people? Is there a part of us helping other people that secretly gets some satisfaction because other people are seeing us help other people and it makes us feel better about ourselves? Is it possible the reason why we work so hard is because somehow working hard makes us get a sense of worth that is always perpetually eluding ourselves?

19:23 Think about why you come to church. Is there a part of coming to church because you want to be able to manage your own conscience to be known as that kind of person who, like, you know, is a churchgoer. don't just look to the surface. You need to look underneath and beneath them. And if you get it under there, what you will see under the surface is not just in your vices, but actually in your virtues, you're gonna see self-serving motives.

19:53 Which means this, it means this, we don't just fail to meet our standards with that tape recorder. We even fail at the level of why we're even trying in the first place. And I don't think we don't think about that enough. Here's what you need to realize. A world without judgment is a world without justice. And we can't live in a world like that because you know why? There are real wrongs out there that need to be righted and we need that. We have to have that. But a world with judgment, we can't stand. We stand condemned by the very standards that we apply to other people. And by the way, and this isn't just in your worst moments. I'm saying that we are condemned by the gap between the goodness that we've performed and the motives that even drove those good things in the first place. So the question to move on to is this.

20:47 If we need judgment for justice but we can't stand, then what hope do we have? What hope do we have? See, we need to ask this question because I think most of our lives we live with these inconsistencies talking out of both sides of our mouths, wondering why we live in this fragmented world, wondering why there's always this perpetual hurt and heartache and everybody talking past each other and fragmentation and tribalization.

21:14 if we would just see that we are in common humanity. all in the same place with our vices and our virtues standing condemned against our own standard, what do we do? Last point. Go back to the first verse here. And there's this little statement that says, then Jesus cried out. Most people just skip over that. They want to get to the content. But you need to realize that the word cried out here. is the Greek word ekrezen. and a crescent means something more than just speaking loudly. If you go to other times in the New Testament when that word is used, it's used when Peter jumps out of the boat and he's sinking in the water and it says he cried out, Lord, save me. It's in Galatians 4 when the Holy Spirit allows people to be able to cry out, Abba, Father. Every time this word cry out comes out, it's not just talking loudly.

22:11 It's a sound of distress. It's the sound of urgency. There's tears involved. So now come back to our text and say, why is Jesus? By the way, this is the last public statement that Jesus says in the book of John. Before he goes to the cross, this is the last thing he wants everybody to hear coming out of his mouth And he's not just thinking about judgment with tears in his eyes, with urgency with distress he's weeping why think about what it takes to love. Particularly when it's costly to love others because of someone who rejects you. If you have a casual acquaintance, let's say a next door neighbor who just decides to reject you, you know, it doesn't not hurt. It stings. But if it's actually a friend, if it's a close friend who walks out, that cuts more deeply. But if the person that you have given your entire life to, The love of your life looks at you and says, I don't want to be with you anymore.

23:21 That will break you from the inside. And so now you have to ask, what was the kind of relationship that the father and the son had before all of time? Inside the Trinity, inside the Godhead, you had perfect, infinite, beginningless love, a community beyond anything we could possibly think about. Which, by the way, when anybody says, oh, it was only three days. If you have an infinite relationship and it is broken, it is cut off on that cross, it's been severed. If you've been severed from the very source of life and love that you've always understood, that is anguish that's unimaginable. And yet Jesus, I think, in these words, he's already thinking about that. It's already coming. He's already weeping and grieving, not just what it's gonna cost, but the fact that he's talking to the very people who's going to reject him.

24:16 And he's looking them in the eyes and he's like, these are the ones I'm going to die for. These are the ones that I am going to be rejected for. The light of the world goes into the darkness for them. And I think this is where I want to pause for a second because this is what no other worldview in human history has ever proposed. that the judge steps down from the desk. He gives up his gavel.

24:47 He goes down to the people who are on trial. and says with tears in his eyes, I'm going to take the verdict for you. No other worldview in the world proposes this. People don't like this word wrath. When they think of the word wrath, they think of God, you know, sort of callously judging and throwing people and left and right out of his way. But that's a misunderstanding. That's not what you find here. God is angry at evil for the same reason a furious father. I actually didn't understand this until becoming a father myself. Is that when you're a father and you see the children that you love, you see hurt that's happening to them, your wrath is a product of your love. In fact, you're not loving if you don't have wrath against the evil and the suffering and the hurt that's being done to those who you love. This is actually Mersoff Wolf's quote in the front of our bulletin because what he points out is God's anger is precisely the expression of his goodness.

25:44 It's not opposed to his goodness. And that anger against our sin, against the brokenness of the world, it's not opposed to his love. It's a product of his love. But what's so crazy and slightly unexplainable is when all the wrath actually should be rightly poured out on us, which we've already just determined for the tape recorder and all the reasons that we do what we do. It doesn't land on us. It lands on Jesus. And so when the creed says that we're going to read later, he descended into hell. Jesus isn't just touring the underworld. He is there taking the full spiritual consequences for every action and inaction that we gloss over and say, nothing to see here, we're fine. And so go back to that tape recorder.

26:38 All the recordings of your life, all the standards that we apply to others, but not to ourselves, all the excuses that we make on the cross, Jesus Christ takes that tape. The one that's around your neck, he grabs it and says, I'll take it on your behalf. the hypocrisy, the critical spirit, the mixed motives the life that we've built that doesn't take into consideration the God who creates us. he takes the judgment that is demanded and so when you trust him everything that he actually does deserve all the goodness, all the greatness, all the love we get and folks, if that just sounds nice and by the way, a lot of folks maybe you grew up in the Christian church you've heard this statement before, if that just sounds nice, you've missed the point.

27:29 If a friend calls you up one day and says, you know what, hey, you were away for a while, but I paid your bill. How do you respond? It completely depends on what was in that bill. If it was like, hey, there was a delivery charge, I paid five bucks, you're like, hey, gee, thanks, thumbs up. But if that bill was 10 years of back taxes that would have certainly thrown you in jail for a lifetime, you don't just shake your hand, you don't extend your hand to shake this person's hand. You get on your knees and say, thank you. The size of your gratitude depends completely on the size of what was actually paid. And so if you've been a Christian for a while, if you just sort of gloss over this and go, I've heard this before. If this all sounds run-of-the-mill, then you haven't actually grasped what been paid. grasp the weight of what Jesus absorbed to feel the weight of his love.

28:33 To the degree that you understand your own tape recorder, your own mixed motives, that he took it to the cross, to that degree where you actually taste grace and gratitude. That's it. That's all of it. The bigger the bill, the bigger the grace, the bigger the gratitude, the bigger the heart that you're going to have to move out into the world. If you have a small heart today, if you don't feel, if you don't experience this, it's because you haven't actually seen the cost. You haven't seen the cost, you know why? Because our world is designed to think no judgment, no judgment, no judgment. But actually when you do, and you see he took it, that's when the love and the goodness and the gratitude spills out.

29:17 Look back at our text. That's why in verse 50, there's this, I know this command leads us to eternal life. This is not just a pardon where you can mess up again. Jesus has secured eternal life, real life, the life that you were always meant for. Folks, the cross is the only place that I know of, and I challenge you to tell me another place where you get justice and mercy at the same time. You can get either one of those, but not at the same time. And they each have trade-offs, right? Our world, we're moving into a new season where we can get justice and punishment, and you get canceled, and you're gone, and you can't come back from it. You can also, by the way, in our world, get mercy, but then there's no justice because, hey, you got off, you got away with it. We see that a lot still, too. but in Christianity, you get both. The justice is paid.

30:10 It's full. It's real. Jesus pays it. The justice is real, and the mercy is real too. He's the only one that I know of. We're on that cross. That justice could be satisfied without destroying us. Do you know what that means? The tape recorder that's around your neck.

30:32 You have to ask, and you ask regularly, what are you going to do with it? when it's played back, what are you going to do? I want to suggest one thing. Give it up. Give it away. Give it to the one who's already heard it all. He's already heard the whole recording. Will you let Jesus take the verdict for you? Or are you going to keep trying to earn it yourself? Are you going to say, well, maybe later, maybe later. Just let me try to work a little bit harder on my job. Maybe make that relationship. Maybe find that person to get married to. Maybe, or will you just give it up now? This morning, if you're not a Christian, if this is kind of new for you, the day the creed is talking about that day is coming, you need justice. You know this world needs it too, but what are you gonna do with that tape recorder?

31:25 Who's gonna say the verdict to you? I think there's only one person that can take it, but for those of you who call yourself Christians, when was the last time that you've actually felt the weight of that tape recorder off of you? When was the last time you knew that it's off your neck? Because if you really experience this, it changes actually how you move out in this world with justice. So many of my friends that are deep, caring individuals, you tend to do one of two things. You either get jaded because you've burnt out, or you end up getting mad and you end up getting upset at everybody else because they don't care about justice to the same degree that you do. But if you're a Christian, you can hold onto this. You never despair and you never give up and you don't have to attack other people because at the end of the day, there's a sustainable hope here knowing that there's gonna be a judge who will come.

32:20 You can actually go further into that work without despair and dispensing because you already know how it's gonna end because you know one day all the wrongs will be righted. folks if you have this wound if that wound of that person who's hurt you that wound that's unreconciled that slight at work that this is the only solution I know of because he bore what you owed you don't have to carry what other people owe you anymore you can take it off you know it's going to be taken care of this is real release this is how you can have a life that you've always wanted in Jesus give it up, give up the tape recorder this means you don't have to wake up tomorrow auditioning for still wondering are you going to be enough, are you going to be in the verdict is in, it's done the only question left is will you take it will you own it for yourself you can't but he can you won't but he will receive the judge who was judged let it melt your heart to move you out in the world, let's pray Heavenly Father we don't like this topic as a culture it feels icky and yet we so desperately need it we can't get away from it we actually do it all the time we just call it different things help us to realize that we don't have to run away that judgment and justice matters you're a God who sees all and knows all even the hidden things but that tape recorder is around our neck and we need there's no way we can take it off there's no way to do it ourselves so we just pray that we I pray this morning that we would whether we're a Christian this morning or not or somewhere in between that we would see the good news that we can't just if we saw this, we wouldn't just go on humming.

34:23 by ourselves we would just get down on our knees with gratitude and grace saying thank you move this into our hearts it would change how we treat everyone else our enemies, our friends, ourselves move this in our lives in profound ways we pray these things

Machine translated from the source