Athens, Manhattan, and the Unknown God

Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached September 6, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Acts 17:16-33 0:32
16While Paul was waiting for them in Athens, he was deeply disturbed in his spirit to see that the city was full of idols. 17So he reasoned in the synagogue with the Jews and God-fearing Gentiles, and in the marketplace with those he met each day. 18Some Epicurean and Stoic philosophers also began to debate with him. Some of them asked, “What is this babbler trying to say?” Others said, “He seems to be advocating foreign gods.” They said this because Paul was proclaiming the good news of Jesus and the resurrection. 19So they took Paul and brought him to the Areopagus, where they asked him, “May we know what this new teaching is that you are presenting? 20For you are bringing some strange notions to our ears, and we want to know what they mean.” 21Now all the Athenians and foreigners who lived there spent their time doing nothing more than hearing and articulating new ideas. 22Then Paul stood up in the meeting of the Areopagus and said, “Men of Athens, I see that in every way you are very religious. 23For as I walked around and examined your objects of worship, I even found an altar with this inscription: TO AN UNKNOWN GOD. Therefore what you worship as something unknown, I now proclaim to you. 24The God who made the world and everything in it is the Lord of heaven and earth and does not live in temples made by human hands. 25Nor is He served by human hands, as if He needed anything, because He Himself gives everyone life and breath and everything else. 26From one man He made every nation of men, that they should inhabit the whole earth; and He determined their appointed times and the boundaries of their lands. 27God intended that they would seek Him and perhaps reach out for Him and find Him, though He is not far from each one of us. 28‘For in Him we live and move and have our being.’ As some of your own poets have said, ‘We are His offspring.’ 29Therefore, being offspring of God, we should not think that the Divine Being is like gold or silver or stone, an image formed by man’s skill and imagination. 30Although God overlooked the ignorance of earlier times, He now commands all people everywhere to repent. 31For He has set a day when He will judge the world with justice by the Man He has appointed. He has given proof of this to everyone by raising Him from the dead.” 32When they heard about the resurrection of the dead, some began to mock him, but others said, “We want to hear you again on this topic.” 33At that, Paul left the Areopagus.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

4:42 One of the great atheists of this past century, Bertrand Russell, he was asked once, what would happen? What would you do if you're actually wrong? What would you do if you, you know, die and you meet God and God says, hey, why didn't you believe? And this was his answer. He said, this is what he would say to him. He would say, why didn't you give better evidence? Why didn't you give better evidence? That's the position that I think many of us hold. And what most New Yorkers hold is that it's something that sounds very honest. Because here's what it does, it assumes faith is a blind leap and reason is the valid position. But another atheist philosopher, his name is Tim Crane, he was writing the New York Times a couple years ago, he points out that that demand is false. And his point is this, is that there are so many things that we hold as true that can't be proven in a lab. It can't be proven through a scientific hypothesis.

5:59 So many of you, we hold the idea that our spouses actually love us, but you can't empirically prove that your spouse loves you. You can't empirically prove that beauty is real. You can't empirically prove that your five senses even work. Why? Because you're using your five senses to see things. You can't test what you're already using. And therefore, you can't actually empirically prove many things that you and I hold as real every single day. But the skepticism that we hold, that New Yorkers hold, It still exists. And here's what you need to hear. It's not neutral. It's not neutral. It actually holds so many of its own assumptions that we never actually examine. And this matters because I think that we're actually, everyone in this room, we're all building our lives on assumptions and statements that we can't prove.

6:57 We hold what we think we need in this world. We hold what's wrong with the world. We actually hold what will fix the world, and it all comes from beliefs, a set of assumptions that you can't prove. And we probably have never really ever cross-examined them. And we're betting everything on them. And so this fall, this is what I want to do. We're going to start a new series here at Redeemer Lincoln Square called Reasonable Doubts. And the goal is to cross-examine everything. So I want to encourage you to come weekly. I want to encourage you to bring friends, ask questions, work through, discuss the topics. And today what we're doing, this long passage, it's from when Paul, in the book of Acts, he's in Athens, and he's dialoguing, he's reasoning. And what's happening is that his faith is being cross-examined. There's a word here in the very beginning here in verse 17, it says, so he reasoned.

7:52 That's the word dialogmos, which is where we get the word dialogue, which is actually about asking questions and people asking him questions. He was being cross-examined. His faith was being cross-examined. And so guess what? So should ours. No matter what we believe, we need to be cross-examined as well. And so we're gonna take many of the major objections that people have to Christianity. Maybe you have them as well. And if you're not a Christian, I hope that you'll hear your, what you hold as true. being reasoned with and voiced fairly. fairly. So let's start with Paul. He's here in Athens, and he actually gives us sort of the paradigm about how to do this. So let's look at three things. We're going to look at the altars, the announcement, and the appeal. The altars, the announcement, and the appeal. So first, the altars. Look at verse 16. Paul's in Athens. It's the intellectual and capital of culture in the area. It's the beginnings of the Western world. And Luke, who's the writer of Acts, tells us that Paul is greatly distressed here in verse 16.

8:59 And he's distressed because he's walking around and he's seeing, he's physically moved to the whole city and he's seeing what they're basing their life off of. And so it says in verse 18 that he's interacting. with the two great philosophies of the time. It says a group of Epicureans and Stoic philosophers. You want to know who those were? Stoics were the moralists. They believed in discipline and duty and, you know, be good and, you know, hold the line. The Epicureans were the relativists. They were like, technically they believed in God, but they believed that God wasn't involved or the gods weren't involved in the world. And so functionally they were like, listen, you do you. Follow your heart. Who wants to know? Just, you know, do what feels right. They were the relativists in this space. Do things for pleasure.

9:52 Live your truth now. Now, I would argue that both those views are still alive and well, not just in New York, but in ourselves. We are all moralists. You know why? We love telling other people where they're wrong. We're very good at telling people where they're wrong. Not so good about hearing where we're wrong. We're the best at it online, right? Very good at saying here is how you should live your life, let me tell you. But we're also relativists. Because when it comes to us, you know, it's rules for, not for me, but for thee. That's how we live. So we do both these things as well. And what the text says now, he's talking to both these groups and they're giving him space to discuss these ideas and where he's coming from. And look what he does in verse 22. Very famous statement.

10:44 He says, people of Athens, I see that in every way you are very religious. For as I walked around and looked carefully at your objects of worship, I even found an altar with an inscription to an unknown God. What I love about this is that the Athenians, they obviously believed in many gods, but they were very careful too. They were like, listen, there's probably so many gods, there's probably people we've forgotten. So let's build an altar to just somebody who we might have forgotten. They're hedging their bets. But they're doing it honestly. Years ago there was a cultural anthropologist Secular scholar She was studying African culture And she was in a very particular village And she writes about her experience there And she talks about how That while she was there She saw how women were being treated And she wasn't comfortable with it She felt it was very repressive and bad And so she goes to the village leaders And tells them Hey you're wrong And you know what they said back to her?

11:45 they said, how dare you? How dare you tell us that we're wrong? Because what you're doing here is you're pushing your Western values on us. You're pushing your beliefs on us. And she writes about how she felt stuck because if she had answered, hey, I know that your culture doesn't believe in women's rights, but my culture believes in women's rights and you should follow my culture. How's that not a form of cultural colonialism?

12:18 But she did not, so she, that was one side of it, but the problem for her was she didn't believe in God. She didn't believe in universal truths. And so in her essay, it ended with her admitting that she had no coherent moral basis for what her deepest intuitions were actually screaming at her. She had no basis for it, but she still held it. And what I want to argue to you today is this. Do you know what she was doing? She was building an altar. She had built one. She had a faith that women had dignity and honor and rights universally. but she couldn't prove it and she couldn't ground it in her secular understanding because the secular worldview basically says that truth is relative. It's just the... historical or cultural moment where people have all agreed that this is actually what's right, but that's actually not universally true. And so she couldn't actually say that to everyone else, and yet she still wouldn't give up what she held.

13:53 See, evolutionary biology can definitely tell you where moral statements and values come from, but it can't give you moral obligation. It can't say this is true for everybody. And so she was actually worshiping. She couldn't name it, but her convictions were to an unknown God.

14:15 She had a faith position. So let's do this. Zoom out for a second. Let's compare ancient Athens with New York City today. Ancient Athens put their altars up in the open. My brother and his family went to Athens. They were texting about how Mars Hill, where Paul is making this argument, right in front of them is the Parthenon. You know, you have the temple to the goddess Athena. But on every single hill, there was also another temple. We don't have those, right? If you look out of New York City, you don't see temples, but we've just moved them from the visible onto the job title, onto the bank statement, onto the family obligations we have for those that are in our midst. In other words, we've done this all the while telling ourselves, oh, no, no, no, we've outgrown our whole, this whole religious business. We don't do this.

15:15 You say, what do I mean? Okay, fine. Your career, when it comes to your career, what we do is we say that, oh, it's not religious, it's not religious. But then why are you putting so much time on those emails at midnight? Why are we doing that? We're still part of the religious business. See, growing up here in New York City, I have a lot of atheist friends. They would tell you, I don't believe in God. But if you ask them to prove it, you know what they would say? They would say, well, I can't 100% prove it because there's always a possibility. I can't see it. But if you can't prove something, at some level then you are actually betting that you're right. And you're basing your life off of it. That's a faith position. Right? If you think that you're here by the product of natural selection but you still believe that there are universal values for everybody, you can't actually get that from natural selection.

16:14 In fact, it's the opposite, right? Natural selection says literally some people might not be the fittest for this world. So, you know, it's a dog-eat-dog world. You can't prove it. And David Foster Wallace, who's definitely not a believer, in his very famous commencement speech, this is what he says about this. He says, I'm quoting him. He says, in the day-to-day trenches of adult life, there is actually no such thing as atheism. There's no such thing as not worshiping. Everybody worship. The only choice that you have is what you worship. And I think his point is this.

16:52 His point is that not to just get more religious. That's not his point. His point is that we've always have been. We've just hidden it. We're not using the word anymore. And so here's what I want us to ask ourselves before we move on. What do you worship? What are the things that you hold on to that you crave, that you need If you don't have it, you fall apart I'm not talking about your opinions, I'm talking about your actions How do you live the day to day?

17:22 What's your functional savior? And I'm not just talking to non-Christians I think there's a lot of people who call themselves Christians, you know, on Sundays. But then day after day, we kneel to a different altar. you can call yourself a Christian and do that see skeptics Paul's argument is skeptics are they're worshiping what they can't name Christians think that they name God and yet functionally we're actually still worshiping at some altar of power approval comfort control you name it your real God is whatever whatever falls apart in your life if you don't have that thing what is that for you? that's the functional savior. And whatever, you know, whatever is on that altar is running your life right now. It's what sets what you're afraid of.

18:14 It's what sets your actions. It's what set how you live. It's actually what makes you exhausted too. And so I think the first thing we need to see here with all these altars is that you have a faith, but can that faith hold you? You are holding a faith, but can that faith hold you? Can you tell the difference between a God that you're holding up and a God that holds you up?

18:42 And if you look at Paul, what I find interesting here is he doesn't just say, he doesn't show up in Athens and go, you're all wrong. You know what he does? He actually gives them a test. A test to tell if they are holding gods that they have to hold up if there's a God that actually holds them up. You say, where is that? Well, point two, the announcement. The announcement is the test. Look at verse 24 and 25 here. He says this. He says, the God who made the world and everything in it is what? He says, is not served by human hands. He uses, by the way, the phrase human hands a couple times here. He's not served by human hands as if he needed anything.

19:24 You see the contrast Paul's doing here? He's saying every other God out there, you serve to get something. You give it your hands. You give it your devotion, your time, your money, your worry, your energy. And the goal is to hand something back to you, an identity. It gives you security. It gives you some feeling. And so with an idol, there's actually just some sort of this transaction going on. But Paul's saying, hey, that's not the test. Here's the test. The test is that a real God doesn't need you as if he needed anything. A real God doesn't need you. You need him. You don't hold him. He holds you. And so go back to those other idols. Like if your idol is career, you're holding it up with your hands as you're doing those emails at midnight. As you have to prove yourself once again at work.

20:23 And it works as long as you're performing. But as soon as you're not, as soon as you're not performing, it drops you. And it turns out the reason why it does is because you were always holding it. I don't think people realize this. Is that you have to hold these other things up. So, for instance, another example. If maybe your idol is always being right. You're the kind of person who's correct. And therefore, to hold that, what you have to do is you have to demean people who you think are wrong. You have to speak against them and talk about them online and be part of a community that does all that. You hold up by staying outraged and not giving up an inch. But if you do, if you just, you know, maybe concede just a little bit, that idol, that community will drop you.

21:20 See, idols can be anything. Usually they're good things. They're good things that you've made ultimate. And I want you to ask this deeply over and over and over again. What is that for you? What is that for you? Because every one of them needs your hands holding them up all the time. And underneath them, we don't name this, but underneath them is this crushing fear that if I lose this, if I don't have this, then I am nothing.

21:53 That's part of what propels us is that I will be nothing without them. And that's why we're so tired. is that you've been holding up things that were supposed to hold you up. But you know what I've never said here is that yes, they exhaust you, but they actually cost not just you, they cost other people. That career isn't just costing you because your marriage gets whatever is left over of you. You need to always be correct. It doesn't just cost you. It's whoever you have to flatten because you're right and they're wrong.

22:29 Right, when it's your family, if you put them on a pedestal and they have to be your all in all, they have to walk out with the weight on their shoulders like that, that they could never actually live up to. Idols don't just cost you, they cost other people too. I think Paul knows that. And that's why he's contrasting God with these Athenian altars. So look, his announcement keeps going on. Look at verse 26. He says, from one man he's made all the nations. What's he doing there? He's talking to the Epicureans who are like, oh, you know, who knows? He's like, no, no, no, you were created and you were made. That's why you have dignity. That's why you have honor and rights. The anthropologist earlier doesn't have that as a resource. We do.

23:17 See, an idol says perform by holding me. God says I made you. I hold you. And so the question now is asked this. How then can you find the true God? Look at verse 27. Paul says, hey, you can find the true God. How? God did this so that they would seek him and perhaps reach out for him and find him. That word reach out, in Greek, it's the word groping. It's like everything's dark and you're kind of walking around and you can, and God's there, but you can't, it's hard for you to see him and know where he's at. But he's not hiding and he's not waiting for you to get your life in order first. And so if you add up all these things that Paul's doing, he's actually contrasting the smallness of their idols, of their altars. And he goes on here about, you know, being gold and silver and stone, an image made by humans. He's literally talking to them about the smallness and the carvedness of idols versus the vastness and bigness of God.

24:22 You say, why does that matter? Because of this. if your God is small enough for you to hold, then he's too small for you to actually worship. If your God is small enough for you to hold, then he's too small for you to actually worship. You can reverse that too. If you have a God that's big enough that you can't fully grasp, then you have a God who's also big enough to have reasons that you can't fully understand.

24:49 I grew up here in this town. So many people I know go like this. They go, I don't understand why God's letting this happen, and therefore there can't be a God. Which is actually faulty logic. Or maybe if God is so big, shouldn't we assume that therefore there will be so much that we can't actually understand about his ways and his actions? Of course we can. Folks, a God that you can fully explain is a God that you built. the most likelihood if you can't fully explain God then it means that at least for you you did not build that and so the way that you can tell the real God from the one that you carved is to ask this question who's holding who? who is actually holding who? your career, your kids some power, approval, comfort, control they hold you in the end and I would argue maybe one of the reasons why we're so anxious is because somewhere deep down in the recesses of our psyche, we know we built those things.

25:56 And therefore, we know they can't really ultimately save us. Which then begs the question, then who can? Who can actually hold us? Last point. This is the appeal. Paul is building his argument. It's beautiful. Which, by the way, is a great way to actually how you should do culture. He affirms some things. He says, hey, you have an unknown God. He critiques some things. and then he starts redirecting. And what does he do? He redirects, but interestingly, he never gets to say the name and say who it is. He's actually interrupted. Look at verse 31. It says, this is what Paul says. He says, he has given proof of this to everyone by raising him from the dead. The very next verse, verse 32, when they heard about the resurrection of the dead, some of them sneered and others of them started talking.

26:50 What's going on there? Some people think that they interrupted him because he started talking about the resurrection. The Athenians were actually very comfortable with religious talk and miracles and resurrections. That wasn't a problem. It was because he was saying that that was proof. An interesting thing about the Greek, the word proof here is the word pistis, which is actually every other translation, it's the word for faith.

27:17 Only here, it's not, and here's what Paul's trying to do. He's actually saying, faith is not the enemy of evidence. Faith is what you do with evidence. And the evidence that he's offering, the proof he's offering is the resurrection. You see, how's that proof? It's proof because that's not a feeling or a philosophy. So many of the world's religions, you can do this work yourself, if the foundings of it go away, the philosophy still work. Christianity, the resurrection, it's founded on a historical event. And if therefore, if it didn't happen, then the whole thing doesn't work. It's a verifiable experience.

28:03 That's why Paul in 1 Corinthians, he starts talking about how there's like 500 eyewitnesses. He was writing that in a letter because he was letting people say, go talk to them. Eyewitness accounts. And this, why am I bringing this up? Because this actually breaks how most people in New York City talk about faith. We know how most people talk about faith, here's how they do it. Hey, what's your belief? I believe this. Cool. What do you believe? It's different. Oh, I believe this. Cool.

28:33 End of story. the resurrection, the idea that Jesus was raised from the dead, and the idea that for God is real and grace is real, you can't just agree to disagree with that. That you can't just say that happened and then I won't believe it. Nobody would do that. If the resurrection didn't happen, and Paul even says this in another letter, then the whole thing is a lie, it doesn't matter. But if the resurrection did, that changes everything. Everything. And that's why they interrupted him. They interrupted him because it doesn't let you just sit around. It says here that they were just sitting around talking about the latest ideas. This is verse 21. You can't do that if this is actually true. And you can't say this is just one of many beliefs.

29:31 Athens would have accepted that. New York would have accepted that. But if it's proof, it changes everything. So what I want to do for you all is just, for this season, I would love for you, no matter where you are in your journey of faith, I would love for you to just look at the evidence. Most of us look at our objections. We know what bothers us, but look at what you hold and what's the evidence for it. Compare your experiences with the evidence for these other views. And you say, well, how do you do that? Well, go back to the test. A God that you carved cannot get out of the grave. The empty tomb is not just proof of the past. It's actually an assurance. It's a receipt that your future is secure as well. because when you know the resurrection is true, when you really know that and experience it, it takes that deep panic away.

30:30 You no longer have to exhaust yourself, doing, doing, doing. Why? Think about it. Why are we trying to make a name? Why do we feel like we're working to the bone? Often underneath it all is I have to, or I won't be accepted. The resurrection solves that because you don't have to make a name. you've been given a name. You don't ever have to live in fear of missing out on this life. So many people are like, well, I want this and I want this and I want this. If your future is an embodied, embodied like actual physical you in a new heavens, new earth, you're not gonna ever miss out. That's what's so beautiful.

31:11 The resurrection means this world matters. In 1882, the composer George Matheson wrote one of my favorite hymns. we see in here every once in a while. It's the hymn, Oh Love That Will Not Let Me Go. What a lot of people don't realize is that that hymn was written right after his fiance. He was about to be married, abandoned him because he was going blind and she didn't want to be married to a blind man. That would make life too hard, be too difficult. I don't want it. And so the night that he was abandoned, he pens this beautiful hymn. Try to imagine you being abandoned by the one person that you thought was gonna be there, that you're gonna spend the rest of your life, that you're basing your life off of. And they drop you. You know what he wrote? A love that will not let me go. Why? Because all the other loves of the world will let you go.

32:05 But this one won't. In the imagery, he was losing his sight and he starts, he says, oh joy that seeks me through the pain, I cannot close my heart to thee. I trace the rainbow through the rain and feel the promise is not vain, that mourn shall tearless be. He's speaking and singing about the joy of being sought after, The joy that though he didn't want to be with him. in his hardship, Jesus did. And all the while, we live in the tears of today knowing in the morning one day those tears will be gone be taken away folks you and I might never ever feel the love that we think we deserve we might never have a friend back that was lost you might never get what you think you need you're not going to get the success that you feel like you should have whatever it is whatever is the cry of your heart right now trace the rainbow through the rain The cool thing about rainbows is, just to nerd out for a second, they're actually, it's just white light through a prism, which means rainbows are everywhere, you just can't see them right now.

33:17 Trace that rainbow. It's here. Even if you can't see. Which means we're called to hold on to the beauty and the wonder of this promise. see the color of his love and it changes everything. I find it not a coincidence that if you go, Luke was the writer of this chapter, of the book of Acts and he talks about this groping, right? This Greek word of groping in the dark. There's only one other time he uses that word. It's in Luke chapter 24, verse 39. When Jesus is raised from the dead, he enters into a room with his disciples who are afraid and he says, touch. It's that same word in the dark. Touch. See. I'm here. Take your hands that you've been groping with and place them here. Three days before, these men ran from him. They took their hands away, and the first thing Jesus wants to do is he wants their hands back. Take the hand that you've been groping with and touch.

34:24 He holds out his hands with the holes in it, the very hands that you and I drove the nails through. Every idol that you have ever served made you hold them up. Jesus was held up and nailed on that cross so that he could hold you. Remember how we said all idols don't just cost you, they cost everyone else? He pays that debt. that's the receipt of the resurrection. Folks, some of you here, this is what I want to end. Some of you, you're so tired, you've been holding up so much. You've been holding something for so long and you're shaking. You might not even know that you built an altar. to being what your family needs, to being what you feel like you need. But remember verse 27, God's not far. You're supposed, you're supposed to not have to worry about needing to be enough and looking for comfort enough.

35:16 seeking this approval, seeking all this stuff, what you need to keep saying to yourself is this, God is not far. Maybe you've built an altar out of the sheer refusal. not to give yourself fully to life of God. You can be a Christian and believe this. You can stay around faith. Give up that altar. Whatever it is that you're holding up, give it to him. Take your hands off of it. Realize that you're in his hands. Hands that were nailed open for you. the love that will not let me go. Trace the rainbow through the rain. Let's pray. Heavenly Father, move this into our hearts. we live in a world designed to keep us busy, to keep us focused on something else other than you. So we need the Holy Spirit to come deep into our hearts to show us that we can rest.

36:10 I need that. I need that. The business of the world will never stop. There's always more work to do. There's always more things to do. There's always something to perform. Thank you for building things or giving us the ability to build things. It is okay to work. It's okay to care about family. It's okay these things, but help us to order them rightly. Help us to put you first. And all the other things fall in their right and proper place. Move in our hearts in profound ways. We pray these things in your name.

Machine translated from the source