If God is Good, Why Is There Pain?

Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached October 4, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: John 11:17-43 0:33
17When Jesus arrived, He found that Lazarus had already spent four days in the tomb. 18Now Bethany was near Jerusalem, a little less than two miles away, 19and many of the Jews had come to Martha and Mary to console them in the loss of their brother. 20So when Martha heard that Jesus was coming, she went out to meet Him, but Mary stayed at home. 21Martha said to Jesus, “Lord, if You had been here, my brother would not have died. 22But even now I know that God will give You whatever You ask of Him.” 23“Your brother will rise again,” Jesus told her. 24Martha replied, “I know that he will rise again in the resurrection at the last day.” 25Jesus said to her, “I am the resurrection and the life. Whoever believes in Me will live, even though he dies. 26And everyone who lives and believes in Me will never die. Do you believe this?” 27“Yes, Lord,” she answered, “I believe that You are the Christ, the Son of God, who was to come into the world.” 28After Martha had said this, she went back and called her sister Mary aside to tell her, “The Teacher is here and is asking for you.” 29And when Mary heard this, she got up quickly and went to Him. 30Now Jesus had not yet entered the village, but was still at the place where Martha had met Him. 31When the Jews who were in the house consoling Mary saw how quickly she got up and went out, they followed her, supposing she was going to the tomb to mourn there. 32When Mary came to Jesus and saw Him, she fell at His feet and said, “Lord, if You had been here, my brother would not have died.” 33When Jesus saw her weeping, and the Jews who had come with her also weeping, He was deeply moved in spirit and troubled. 34“Where have you put him?” He asked. “Come and see, Lord,” they answered. 35Jesus wept. 36Then the Jews said, “See how He loved him!” 37But some of them asked, “Could not this man who opened the eyes of the blind also have kept Lazarus from dying?” 38Jesus, once again deeply moved, came to the tomb. It was a cave with a stone laid across the entrance. 39“Take away the stone,” Jesus said. “Lord, by now he stinks,” said Martha, the sister of the dead man. “It has already been four days.” 40Jesus replied, “Did I not tell you that if you believed, you would see the glory of God?” 41So they took away the stone. Then Jesus lifted His eyes upward and said, “Father, I thank You that You have heard Me. 42I knew that You always hear Me, but I say this for the benefit of the people standing here, so they may believe that You sent Me.” 43After Jesus had said this, He called out in a loud voice, “Lazarus, come out!”

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

4:14 Years ago, famous atheist pundit Sam Harris wrote a piece that basically said this. He said either God can't stop evil, that means he's not all powerful, or he could stop evil and suffering but doesn't, which means he's not all good, or Sam Harris proposed maybe there isn't really a God. Any way you slice it, his point is that the God of the Bible that supposedly is all-powerful and all-loving can't be real. Now, this is the question, one of the main questions that people struggle with the most, which is why does a good, all-powerful God allow evil in suffering?

5:12 This particular doubt is one of the most cited doubts. about why people have a hard time believing in and coming to Christianity. For some folks, it's a parent who died early. Maybe it was a marriage that ended early. Maybe it was a diagnosis. Maybe it was a death. Maybe it was nothing personal. Maybe for you, you look out at the world and you see all this sort of senseless violence. You see all this suffering and heartache. And it overwhelms you. The truth is that no matter where you are, everybody carries something. If right now you aren't, you can't actively think of something, just give it some time. Live long enough and heartache finds us all. and when, not if, when this happens to you, the question we have to ask ourselves is what do we do?

6:10 Can Christianity actually answer the problem of evil? And you're like, hey, light topic today, really nice, great, lovely. But this is a big deal. And so therefore we need to look at it. and I want to use three questions and today's text to try to work through it. Let's look at three questions. what we ask, what we need, and what he does. What we ask, what we need, and what he does. So first, what we ask. And we ask questions. And suffering, by the way, suffering is one of the main places when we ask questions. And that's precisely what happens with Mary and Martha. The context for this passage is that their brother, Lazarus, has died, and Jesus has been delayed in getting to them. When he finally shows up, Mary and Martha approach him separately. Look at verse 21.

7:04 Martha runs to Jesus and says, Lord, if you had been here, my brother would not have died. Now that's a statement, but there's a question in there. In other words, isn't it true that if he would have been here, he wouldn't have died? And what's interesting, if you go down to verse 32, Mary utters the exact same phrase. And all the commentaries point this out, that the book of John, the writer of John, the reason why he does this, to make the exact same phrase coming out the mouths of both sisters, with Jesus offering different answers, it means then that whatever the answer is to the problem or the question of suffering, it has two parts to it. And therefore, we need to look at both of those parts. Let's first look at Mary. That when Mary shows up, she says, Lord, if you know, if you had not, if you had been here, my brother would not have died. And what I like about Mary is she tries to answer her own question. She actually tries to, what I preach about her is that she's reaching for an answer, something to hang her hat on. And the reason why I like that is because I think everybody in this room, whether you know it consciously or unconsciously, you have to have an answer as well. Because I grew up in this town, I get asked a lot when people find out I'm a pastor, this question comes up. And my new thing that I do is I'm like, hey, I'm going to answer, I want to answer your question. But before I do, I want to know where you're coming from.

8:32 Where do you think? What do you believe? What's your view? And I do that because I want folks to realize, yes, this is a problem for Christians. It's a big problem. But this is actually a problem for everyone. Everybody, everybody has to answer this question. And I'm going to boldly say this. and so I'm happy if you want to push back in Q&R later, but I believe that you can really boil down the world's answers to suffering to essentially, if you include the Christian answer, five different views. They roughly fit, I'm going to go through four of the other possibilities quickly, just to kind of list them. Number one, maybe suffering, the answer to suffering, secularism says it's just random. That you were, you know, you've evolved out of nothing and one day you're going to go to nothing and therefore ultimately there's no real meaning in between, logically. And since you've evolved out of a process of evolution, the survival of the fittest, then you really can't be mad when it's survival of the fittest.

9:32 When the strong beat the weak, that's nature. That's life. That's natural selection. And therefore our tears, you can put some sort of meaning on them but ultimately it's chemistry. The second option is karma. Karma basically says for the answer to suffering is that the good people get good things and bad people get bad things. So if you're suffering right now, that means there's something you must have done. The problem with that is that the math doesn't math that well. That we look at our lives, we're like, wait a second, why do the good die early and the evil live long and prosper? Why is it that those who cheat, they get the corner office and those who don't, they get the pink slip? so that's karma option three Buddhism says or a lot of Eastern philosophies say your tears ultimately are a symptom of desire and desire is the problem that suffering is an illusion it's unreal so stop clinging stop desiring and to cure grief then you have to detach yourself and as you do if you do detach yourself you do get rid of grief but you also get rid of being active in anybody else's lives because you have to pull yourself away from them as well. Lastly, the last option is fatalism, which there's different philosophies, but also religions that basically say, whether it's fate or God, that's in control, you're not. And so when it comes to your suffering, just accept your fate. Now we don't have time to compare and contrast. It's a whole nother talk to kind of look at through each one of those, but I'll say this at this point. No other view, the fifth view that we're going to go at today, says that suffering is, the answer to suffering is God entering into death.

11:21 See, go back to our text. Martha gives that intellectual answer. She tries to answer that question. The very next verse, she says, yeah, yeah, I know he's gonna be raised. I know that, you know, one day there's a resurrection and stuff like that. And Jesus comes through and says, no, I, I am the resurrection and the life. And the one who believes in me will live even though they die. And by the way, he asked, do you believe this? This is all looked down in verse 27. Do you believe this? And she says, what? Yes, I do. And something that I've never noticed until I looked at this passage this week, if you skip down to verse 39, when Jesus shows up at the tomb, what does Martha do? Martha says, don't open the tomb. Why? There's an odor in there. So this is what I want you to notice. She just says, yeah, I believe you. I believe you. Sure, sure, sure. But then she says, why is there an answer? Don't open the tomb. I don't believe you can actually do this.

12:23 what I think is going on here is that like Martha I think that you can be a Christian and intellectually believe Jesus is the resurrection of life, but then practically and functionally and actually in your day-to-day life. you don't actually live that out in your suffering. But I actually believe you can be sitting here today, you can give your talents you can give your Sunday morning heck, right now, you're giving your Sunday morning you can give that to God but you're still not having actually given your heart to God.

13:00 That you can actually it's possible to do great deeds of service to other people and go out in the world and serve people but you've never actually surrendered your heart to God and trust His throne and trust his ways. I think that's actually what's happening right here. Is that here's Martha and she's standing at the tombs around her and she's telling Jesus, don't roll away the stone because it stinks. I think you and I say the same thing. We can actually be around the tombs of our life, and we go to Jesus and we say, no, no, no, don't open them. Don't do it, don't do it.

13:35 Because I think we might intellectually believe but we don't functionally, actually, really, truly, fully believe and trust when one of my I won't name which one but when one of my daughters was six months old I vividly remember taking her to get her shots and it was actually it was pretty amazing the pediatrician laid out all the the shots in a row and it was something fast because this this doctor took like had two different jabs. And just with wicked quickness, she went boom, boom, boom, boom, boom, boom. And the face of my daughter is seared into my brain. You can actually literally watch the trust that she had in us seep away. And this is her face. I can't, I can't, I'm not going to try to do it, but her face was like this.

14:35 Like, you, you, what? You let this woman stab me? Why would you do that? And I know that it wasn't in spite of our love. It was because of our love. I know as her parent that it was for her greater good, but she couldn't and she didn't. And here's what I want to say to you. If a baby, if a baby can't see all her parents' reasons for why things might happen in their life for their good, how much more is that possible when we look at God?

15:14 How much more is that possible when we see, when we can't see God's reasons? See, I find it endlessly fascinating that there's a lot of people in New York where we believe God is big enough that we can be mad at him. But folks, if you have a God big enough to be mad at, then you also have a God big enough to have reasons that you can't fully understand.

15:37 And that's a humbling thought when you actually put yourself there. What I don't want us to do is I don't want us to use our limited view of reality. to then judge and use that as an argument against the goodness of God. Don't do that. See, Jesus' answer to Martha here is the correct intellectual answer. it's what we look for. It's what we ask for. But what I want you to see before we move on is this, is that you can have that correct intellectual answer and you're still standing at the tombs of your life saying, don't open it.

16:12 You're still standing there and you know it intellectually, but you don't know it. It's a theological answer for our head, but it's not, it's not help for our hearts.

17:20 See already Something different is happening She falls at his feet And unlike Martha's intellectual way She's all emotion She falls at his feet She can't even stand up The Greek word for The word weeping here In verse 33 It's not quiet sobbing Like oh boo hoo No it's It's ugly crying This is wailing She's heartbroken She's a puddle on the floor She can't get up and look him in the face.

17:54 And what does Jesus actually do? What's the difference? In verse 35, in verse 33, minutes before he raises Lazarus from the dead, the shortest verse in all the Bible, Jesus wept. And that's a nice phrase, but I want you to say, I want you to ask the question, why? Why is he weeping? Is he weeping because, oh, I'm sorry too because I don't know what to do? No, he knows he's about to raise Lazarus from the dead. The answer is actually in verse 33. He weeps because it says, when Jesus saw her weeping, he weeps because she's weeping. Because why? Because that's what she needed. Folks, I can't, I can say this to you, but I can't make you experience it. The God of the universe, in the person of Jesus is crying with Mary, we might never ultimately know why bad things happen to us, but we have to know, we have to know what it can't be.

19:00 It can't be he doesn't love us. Because here is the tender, gentle, caring nature of Jesus. Notice what he doesn't do. He doesn't say, puny human, how dare you, watch this. He doesn't do what? He doesn't say, why are you crying? I'm about to raise him from the dead. You know how many times I've said to my own kids, why are you crying? I know better, just trust me, come on. He doesn't do that. No, what a comforter. Mary needs something different from Martha. Martha needed a concept. Mary needed a person. You don't just need an intellectual answer. You need a person there as well. Here you have the personal and the powerful. The power to fix the suffering in the resurrection. The personal comforter to sit with you in it. There's a lot of people out there that says, hey, Jesus, he's a great teacher.

19:57 But if he's just a teacher, he can't be a savior. There's a lot of people out there that are like, hey, Jesus, he wept. But if he's only a sympathizer, again, he can't be a savior. If he's just a power, look on the other side, if he's just a power, then you can't trust him. If God is just, all he is is remote, powerful spirit, you can't relate to him either. Ultimately, you need to have both. And again, you might never know why suffering is happening in your life, but you can know what it can't be. It can't be that he doesn't love you. That's the intellectual answer. but some of you, and folks, that's great for some of you, but others of you, because of the hardness of your life, because of what you're going through, what you will go through, what you have gone through, you need the personal. You need to know that the God of the universe will come down low to you.

20:55 And by the way, you don't always need them equally all the time. I've been very honest with you all up here in the past three years, since my father died, I've had to go to, and I've needed both of these truths at different times in my life. At times I'm Martha. At times I can give you the intellectual answer, but it hasn't actually affected me. It hasn't actually seeped into my life. Other times I'm like Mary, I am a puddle.

21:25 I miss, I grieve, I have heartache and I can't get up off the floor. And I need the Lord of the universe to come down and be with me. You need both. The Christian faith offers you both. It is intellectually satisfying and personally fulfilling. It's resources that I don't think you can find in any other places. Because you can find philosophies and people that will sit with you and you need that. But you also need the power and you can find powerful, you know, arguments and powerful spirits, but you don't ever have both and that's what you have here. Now there's a problem though. And here's the problem that people will push back on. and I'm gonna show you my hand. If Jesus is all powerful and all loving, then why doesn't he stop Lazarus from dying in the first place?

22:18 You see, we can still come back and say, if he really is all powerful and all loving, why does he allow the hurt to still come into my life? by the way the people the crowd says the same thing in verse 36 the crowd says look how he loved them and the very next verse he says yeah but he could open the eyes of the blind men why why can't he also have kept this man from dying ergo in other words if he cared this much if he's all powerful and all loving why does suffering why does pain still remain I think everything hangs on this question It hangs on what does he do and what does it take? so last point what does he do look at verse 33 your Bible says that he was deeply moved in spirit and troubled and unfortunately the Bible is not always equally translated with the best possible words this is a fairly weak translation in Greek the words used to mean deeply troubled. It means deep emotional distress. It means there's actually an image of snorting of a wild animal. There's that kind of anger of a war horse about to charge.

23:41 And the verb is repeated more than once. It's also not just in 33, it's in 38. And you say, okay, well, who's he mad at? Who's he deeply troubled? Who's he upset at? It's not Mary and Martha. He's facing the tomb. He's angry at death itself. He, what's happening is, is Jesus has some experience or concept of death and evil and suffering raging his creation. and it's his enemy. I've come out of a hospital recently, and I've raged. I've screamed. I hate cancer. I hate death. I can't, you know, I'm angry, but you know what? My anger doesn't do anything. His does. You say, why does that matter? Well, go back again to all the handful of ways that there's only a couple handful of ways to deal with suffering.

24:36 If you take the Christian view against secularism, the gospel says your life is not meaningless and therefore your suffering is not meaningless. Against karma, suffering is not fair. Against Buddhism, against Eastern mysticism, your grief is not just an illusion. Against fatalism, God does not stay on the sidelines. He gets involved.

25:03 See, of all the five possible views of suffering, only here do you have God. Look at our broken, bleeding world and with tears on his face has the power to do something about it. every loss every injustice, every hurt every moment of abandonment that you've ever felt he's cried it too and so when he says, and it's such a powerful moving retelling, when he says, take the stone away, and Jesus says, Lazarus come out, and he did. we actually think that's the miracle, right? We think the miracle is that Lazarus comes out, but we couldn't print the whole passage. I want to propose to you, that's actually not the real miracle. We've said this at Redeemer before, but I'll say it again. How miraculous is it if Lazarus is raised from the dead, but eventually he dies again?

25:56 He does. That's actually not a full healing, is it? In fact, suffering, he just delayed the suffering and pain. In fact, since he died and there was suffering and pain, then he comes back and then he dies again he almost intensifies it so you're like okay then what's the miracle well the miracle it's down in verse 53, you can look it up later. it says this one little phrase after all this those in charge plotted to take his life From that day on, they plotted to take his life. then it's out. what you need to see is the arc of the Bible, the climax in the book of John is right here in John 11 because it's by raising Lazarus, those in charge were so angry, they finally decided to kill him. In other words, Jesus knew that bringing Lazarus out of the grave would eventually lead to him going into the grave.

26:55 Some of you might protest and I've talked with people over the years about this exact passage and a lot of people right around here, this is what they do. They go, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. If Jesus is God, he's so all-powerful, why can't he just snap his fingers and take all suffering away? What's up with all this other stuff? And I've thought about this a lot and I have my normal answers. My normal answer is, is your, why is suffering happening? A lot of suffering, but we don't realize, there's a part of our hearts that says this. We're like, well, I'm not that bad. I don't, I'm not that bad. Why does a lot of hurt and cruelty and self-centeredness and me-centeredness happen in this world? Yes, there are monsters out there that have hurt you. And some of you have been hurt by real monsters. But the average person has been hurt by innumerable people who all say, I'm not that bad.

27:56 There's a lot of hurt that's happened to your life. You can probably think of phrases, you can think of deeds that people have done, but I bet you if I went to those people, they would all say, I'm not that bad. They say the same thing that you say. So much of the hurt and cruelty of our systems, of our economics, of our hospitality or lack thereof, all of it is done by people just like us. that say, I'm not that bad.

28:27 And so this is what happens, is that, yeah, God could snap his fingers, Jesus could snap his fingers and get rid of all suffering, but if we're the ones causing the suffering, then he has to get rid of us. how can God wipe away suffering without wiping us away? And the biblical answer is that he can only get us out of death. and suffering by going into it himself. He knew.

28:56 Right? It happens right here. I think it's really interesting that Jesus must have been standing there and he knew if I utter these three words, Lazarus, come out, that's going to set the stage for everything else he could have still stopped he hadn't passed There was still a way to get out of it, and yet he went in and said Lazarus come out and by doing that he put himself in even today if you're not a Christian hopefully you realize that this is actually how all love works all love is substitutionary parents understand this right when that baby is crying when that baby is needing you're sacrificing your sleep and your independence but friendship is this way too real friendship isn't just mutual people rubbing each other's backs real friendship is my life for you and that's what you see here real love works that way at the grave Jesus does just that he substitutes his life for you and here's how you know it cost him that when Jesus came out of the grave he still had the wounds in his hands even resurrected he still has the scars I think a lot of folks feel like faith ultimately is about how hard I hold on to God.

30:13 what if real faith is actually how much understanding how much he infinitely has he holds on to you more Christianity I'm not here hopefully you're not hearing this I am not up here proposing that Christianity is offering you a better philosophy of suffering what it does is it actually offers you a God who bears the scars of it. That's what it actually offers. His wounds are saying, I was there before you. I went in before you. I paid it. I did it. I died so you lived. Alright, just to end. If you believe this, remember how I said the problem is you can know it in your head, but not your heart? Let me just list two ways that if you actually see how he lived and died for you, two ways that you can be different. Number one is you can bring your full self to him. I would love for you today or tomorrow or somewhere, ask yourself, are you the Mary or are you the Martha?

31:13 Whatever your plea is, what's your version of if you had been here, my brother wouldn't have died? Know that he wants to hear it. Know that he didn't rebuke them. He didn't, and since he didn't rebuke them, he's not going to rebuke you. So if you're Martha this morning and you have your arguments, know that he will hear them out. But notice, once he hears you out, he's also going to say, do you believe? Like he said to Martha. And hopefully I've listed for you. If you don't believe in this, that's fine. But realize you believe something. You're putting your trust into something. One of these other views. And how's that doing? Does it actually explain your experiences better?

31:57 If you're married this morning and you just want to fall down and weep, you know what this text is telling you? You can. you can. He's going to get down on that floor with you. in your hard marriage, in your singleness, in your dead-end job, with your kids, without kids, with friends, without friends. but know this, he's not going to stay down there. Jesus went into death, but he was raised up out of it. And if you believe in that, if you understand that and experience it, you can have that in your life as well. All that is sad today will one day become untrue. Because why? Because he's the king of creation. Yes, you can bring your full self to him, but you can only do that if you let the full self of who he is come to you. And you know who he is that we often don't think about?

32:53 He is king of creation. And guess what? If he's king, guess who's not? Me and you. I used to have a habit, I got out of it, maybe I need to get back into it, of writing two questions down at the beginning of every day. The first question was, am I willing to obey God in every area of my life? It was a hard question. but the second question I would write is am I willing to thank God for anything that he sends in my life that's actually even harder am I willing to thank God for anything he sends you see folks if he's God and you're not again just because you can't see the reasons for why God allowed suffering to exist it doesn't mean there isn't one yes bring all of who you are to all of who he is, but here's what you get to say to God.

33:53 You get to say, God, in my wisdom, in how I see the world, there's absolutely no way that I can see how any of what's happening to me right now is bringing any good. But since you're Lord and King, since you're my Father and Maker, I put myself under your Lordship.

34:13 Are you willing to do that? I think if it's just a proposition you can't, but if you can look at the cross and the resurrection you can because without the resurrection I don't think you can but with the resurrection knowing that nothing ultimately will ever be lost that all that is said will become untrue then we can go and trust and wait. Now last thing build on the rock growing up in the house that I grew up in you would always hear stories, platitudes said over and over and again. And one of the ones I tend to forget, but when I do remember it, I go, I really like that story. It's this one. It's more of a parable. It's a story of a lumberjack hired to clear a forest. And every tree in this particular forest was coming down. And he noticed there was a bird in one of the trees building its nest. And he's like, that's not good. I think that's bad for that bird, that tree's coming down. So he takes the blunt end of his axe and starts banging on the tree. And this bird that's trying to rest, it's there. And all of a sudden it starts getting startled. And with enough banging, enough swaying of the tree, the bird finally gets up and flies off and lands in another tree and starts building a nest in that tree. And so what does the lumberjack do? The lumberjack goes over there, starts banging on that tree, trying to get that bird to get away from that tree because it's not good for that bird.

35:41 And the bird's like, what does this lumberjack have against me? Eventually, after doing this over and over and over again, he finally, this bird finally builds its nest on a rock. Folks, is it possible that God is banging on the trees of your life because you are building nests and things that are coming down? And what you're experiencing isn't cruelty. It's love. Is it possible that he's trying to show us that everything in our lives is coming down? Your career one day is going to come down. Your body's going to come down.

36:23 Everything's coming down. But some of the blows that you took are his way of actually showing you what that is. Only the firm foundation of the rock of who Jesus is will stand. Jesus wept. How do you know that God is an all-loving God? Because Jesus wept. That's a God that you can bring your grief to. How do you know God is an all-powerful God? Because he roared. And that means our grief doesn't have the last word. Bring your full self to him. Build on the rock. Let's pray. Heavenly Father, thank you that grief doesn't have the last word

37:08 Thank you for being King and Lord of our life. this is a hard hard statement that you are all powerful and all loving and yet suffering exists help us first see that we need to consider the alternatives but in weighing these different stories help us to see the immense resources and value that we have in having a personal and powerful person to come to us in the person of Jesus. We pray that you turn our hearts and minds towards you. move us if we're apathetic this morning move us to of concerned care if we are on the floor lift us up if we're in the clouds bring us down root us again, root us on the rock.

Machine translated from the source