Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached October 25, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
1:36 If you ask people in New York City, what is the number one barrier to believing that Christianity is true? The answer isn't some argument against the goodness of God. It's not the problem of evil. It's not about suffering. It's not about how science and faith can actually go together. Barna asked Americans with no faith what keeps them from Christianity. And the number one answer was the hypocrisy of religious people. It was Christians. It was Christian individuals. And the criticism usually comes in two forms. First is character. People look at the character of Christians and they say, if Christianity was true, shouldn't Christians actually be better people than people who are not Christians? And yet so many non-Christians actually, we have verifiable proof that they're kinder and nicer than Christians.
2:42 The second criticism is about religious fanaticism. fanaticism. It seems to many that the more you believe in your faith, the more you hold it, the more intolerant that you get. And so these failures don't just turn people away. What they do is they keep people from even considering that Christianity is true. And the cure that our culture offers for these problems, the cure is pretty obvious. They think, well, if religion makes people intolerant, if religion makes you like this, then maybe you need less of it. Or at the very least, maybe you shouldn't hold it so tightly. You can believe, just don't believe too much. I've been asked that many times. Like, oh, you're a Christian, okay. But like, what kind of Christian are you?
3:39 Surprisingly, what I think our text does today is it shows us that Jesus actually might be one of the biggest critics of religious people. Look at how the parable starts. It says, to some who were confident in their own righteousness and looked down on everybody else. What I think is interesting is that he doesn't just aim this at the Pharisees. He could have said to the Pharisees. He doesn't do this. He says, this is to anyone and everyone who are confident of their own righteousness. In other words, this is aimed at anyone who is sure that they're one of the good ones. See, the problem with being a hypocrite is most hypocrites don't know that they're hypocrites. So this is addressed to the hypocrites that you know and to the hypocrite that you might actually be.
4:34 That's what this is saying. And the question we need to ask then is this, is when the faithful fail, what's the cure? The world has an answer. Religion has an answer. And I want to propose that Jesus has a different answer. And so those are the three lenses I want to look at this text. Let's look at less, more, or real. Less, more, or real. So first, less. what would less religion look like? If religious people are judgmental, then it seems like the cure would be less religion. So what does that look like? Well, look at that parable. The parable starts in verse 10, and it says two men went up to the temple, which whenever you see phrases like that, that means you are meant to compare these two individuals. Now, the problem for us in modern times is when we read the word Pharisee, a lot of us have already been sort of enculturated that that means that's a bad person.
5:37 But you need to put yourself in the original listeners' shoes. The original listeners would have interpreted Pharisee with the good person. The Pharisees at the time were considered the upstanding citizens. They were considered the individuals that cared about other people. They were respected individuals in their community. And the tax collector was always a member of a particular community, in this case the Jewish community, who would go around and shake down other members of their community to give taxes to Rome. And they would always give themselves a healthy margin. And so this person literally was selling out his neighbor. So everyone would have known this was the bad guy. But then out of the good guy's mouth, look at verse 11. This is what's said.
6:30 God, I thank you that I am not like other people. Robbers, evildoers, and adulterers. Or even like this tax collector. So what the Pharisee is doing is pretty clear. Is that he's looking down at all these other people groups. And he's saying it out loud. And this is where a lot of you go, well, here we go. This is exactly what we're talking about. This is what religion does. It judges and it looks down on. And so we need to get rid of God. And I was thinking this week, okay, well, how do we, what does that look like? And I thought, let's do a thought experiment. Let's actually take the word God out of this Pharisee's mouth and re-say the phrase. So let's just say God's gone. Let's read it again. I thank you that I am not like other people, robbers, evildoers, and adulterers, or even like this tax collector.
7:25 what happens when you take God out? The greedy, the crooked, the unenlightened. When you take God out, this phrase still works. When you take God out, it actually, the sentence continues to work. And actually we know people, we ourselves have said phrases like this with no reference to God. So wait a minute, shouldn't judgment stop when you delete God? And the truth is, it does not.
7:58 People say versions of this all the time. Modern secular call-out culture, and I think we've lived in this for a couple years now, publicly shames. It excommunicates. It literally throws stones at people. And it does it with the best of religions without calling itself a religion. And here's what was the prediction. The prediction was, lose God, and then we will finally, finally be an open-minded and empathetic culture. And what's so interesting is we've actually been playing out this story. Culture has secularized, and yet as culture has secularized, it hasn't gotten better. In fact, in a lot of ways, it's gotten worse. The Gallup polls just reported that Americans, this is just this week, Americans trust their fellow citizens' judgment at an all-time low.
8:58 It used to be decades ago that we trusted each other 86%. Now it's hovering around 50%. In other words, the Pharisees' prayer is now our national mood. Half the country looks at the other half of the country and says, God, thank you that I am not like them.
9:20 And what I find so fascinating growing up in New York City is that we love the value of tolerance. The culture that prizes tolerance above all else is more intolerant than ever. Why? Because we don't realize. that being non-judgmental is itself a judgment. We don't realize that when we say, you know what, I can't stand those judgmental people over there. That's a judgment where you conveniently are on top, and they're not.
10:00 That's what's so interesting. We're always like, well, I can't stand those people. Those people over there are terrible. That's a judgment. We never stopped sorting people. We thought, oh, you know, all these people that talk about the righteous and the unrighteous, that's all that religious mumbo jumbo. You know what? We never stopped doing that. We still have the righteous and the unrighteous. We just don't use that language anymore.
10:24 For me, when I was trying to put myself into this, it's with my bike. It happened again this week. I ride my bike everywhere. It's parked outside right now. And I was in the green bike lane right where I was supposed to be. And yet again, some driver turns left onto a cross street without looking at me coming down. I'm in the right of way. And I have to slam on my brakes and I do a little like, you know, cause I'm fun and cool. I do like, you know, the, the, the, the little turn with, and I put my hand on the car and I do what every New Yorker says, which is, hey, I'm biking here. And yet again, 30 seconds later, I'm biking through a crosswalk. I know I'm being safe, but somebody feels like I got a little too close to them. And they say, hey, I'm walking here. And of course I'm like, whatever. I'm justified.
11:23 They're not. Right? I'm in the right. But when it's called out on me, I'm like, no, they're not in the right. No. It's just so easy to do this. And yet we do it in so many different ways. We do this in so many other ways. Maybe yours isn't the bike, but maybe you're like this. I'm going to be successful, but at least I'm fun. Maybe it's this, I might work really, really hard, maybe I overwork, but you know what, at least I care about my job.
11:55 Or maybe you say, hey, I might not be the most spiritual, but at least I'm not judgmental like those other people. What is, my question to you is this, what is your I might but at least? That's a comparison. Where you give your, you acknowledge the truth. See, it's so sneaky because you're like, oh, look, I'm being honest, I might be this way, but then at least I'm not like that. What's your version? What's yours? Because whatever that is, that's how you're measuring yourself. It's just so easy to be self-righteous about self-righteous people. You know what? There's a part of me, maybe it's a part of you right now going, I'm so glad we're talking about this this morning because I really don't want to be like those self-righteous people. We just did it again. See, somebody said somewhere, the devil is so interesting. The devil can get you coming and can get you going. it can get you by saying, oh, no, no, I'm going to do that.
12:52 It can get you by kind of throwing yourself in, but also like, no, no, no, no. And then feeling good about it, looking down at everyone else. deleting God doesn't delete the courtroom that's inside your heart. The only difference is instead of God giving down the verdict, now you get to be the one to give the verdict. You don't need God to do the judgment. And you don't need to believe in God to do this. You just need someone to look down on to feel better about yourself. So less doesn't actually cure the problem. Fine. All right. Maybe the opposite. Maybe more religion fixes the problem. So point two, what would more religion look like? Well, go back to our text. Look at what the Pharisee actually does. He says, I fast twice a week and give a tenth of all I get.
13:49 Those two things are religious practices. But what you might not know is the law required you to fast one time a year on Yom Kippur. And yet he's like, no, no, no, no, I fast twice a week. And the law also required to tithe from whatever you made in your fields. You were supposed to tithe, tithe. You're supposed to give a percentage. from your yearly income. And yet he's like, no, no, no, I give from all my total assets. I give from everything I have, not just what I made this year. And so why does, in verse 14, why does this man go home unjustified? That's translation. Why does he go home not declared right with God? some of the clues are in his prayer. Look at the grammar.
14:42 In his prayer, he has such interesting phrases. Look at how many times he says the word I. I thank you that I am not like. I fast, I give a tenth, I get. There are five I's. He literally is praying to himself. His prayer isn't about God. It's about himself. So if you've been sitting here saying, you know what? None of this really applies to me because I'm not actually fasting or doing these religious practices. What you need to ask yourself is, what actually makes him religious? because there's nothing wrong necessarily with fasting or tithing. It's how he uses those things as a means to judge other people and create comparison and look down on other people.
15:45 And if that's what it means to be religious, then I would argue that everyone in this room and everyone in this world... has a scorecard that we judge to make sure that we know that our life matters. And then you're the one who's trying to make sure that I'm one of the good ones. See, that's your temple. So that means you can be, for some of you, it's religion. It's your goodness. It's how much you served and how much other people think you're nice. For others of you, it's your job. It's the gym. It's the resume. Whatever it is, you use those things to measure others against, and you tend to always come out ahead. And if you don't, that's when the anxiety, the depression, the heartache steps in. Those can step in as well for other reasons, but one of the ways that those things are offset is because we don't add up to our own scorecard.
16:44 So here's what you need to see. the Pharisee doesn't want to be near God to be near God he doesn't want God to want God wanting things from God which is what he does do here is not the same thing as actually wanting God and this is where we say at Redeemer this is a pretty common phrase There is not one way to be your own Savior. there's actually two there are two ways to reject God one is by breaking the rules but the other way is actually by keeping them you can run away from God by saying, forget you, it's all about me. But you can also run away from God by saying, it's about me, and now, God, you owe me.
18:02 This is what Robert Louis Stevenson gets to, I think, in his book, Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. The book is fascinating because Dr. Jekyll wants to hold up, hold his upstanding righteousness of a good doctor. So he creates this potion so that Mr. Hyde comes out. But then what ends up happening is Hyde starts coming out, not just with the potion, but any kind of evil thought. And yet at the end of the book, Dr. Jekyll says, okay, we've got to change this. I'm going to do the straight and narrow. I'm going to, quote, redeem the past. So he starts doing all these good works. And afterwards, he's sitting on a park bench in the January sun, and this is what he says. He said, I smiled, comparing myself with the other men, comparing my act of goodwill with the lazy cruelty of their neglect.
19:02 And in that moment, he's transformed into the monster, Mr. Hyde. And what I love about that is the monster didn't come out just with evil thoughts. It came out when he compared his goodness to others. Why? Because moral pride is closer to the monster than open sin. See, rule breakers tend to know that they don't want God. It's the rule keepers who don't realize that they don't really want God either, which makes them actually farther away from him. because here's why, we'll take anything and everything that we feel like we're doing right, and we will weaponize it and look down on others through it. That's why being religious doesn't actually fix the problem, because it does, all it does is just give you more ammunition to do the very same thing.
20:02 It just gives you more to look down on others. And so the answer to one of the first questions, which is why are so many non-Christians, why do they look kinder and nicer than Christians? I think we have to realize this, is that the church was never supposed to be a museum. for your perfection to be on display. The church was always supposed to be a hospital for sinners. who just know that they're sick.
20:29 I think when people come to the church looking for perfection, that's where they're gonna be disappointed because people in the church should be the people who most know that they can't do it on their own. because the greatest danger to your soul, I'm going to say this as slowly as I can, the greatest danger to your soul isn't that you're too bad to be saved. It's that you're just good enough to think that you don't really need to be.
20:56 I'll say it again. The greatest danger to your soul is not that you're too bad to be saved. It's that you're just good enough to think that you really don't need to be. Or maybe just a little bit. Or maybe just on the side. So less doesn't work either. And more doesn't work. So then what does? Last point, real faith. Why does the other guy go home justified? Look at verse 13. The tax collector stands at a distance. He wouldn't even look up at heaven, but beat his breast and he says, God have mercy on me, a sinner. He doesn't say, I'm so glad I'm not like that Pharisee. He doesn't make an excuse. He doesn't make an offer. He doesn't make a payment plan of fasting. Just seven words. God, have mercy on me, a sinner. And if you read the commentaries, they'll point out, if you're a grammar nerd, it's actually the definite article.
21:54 So the literal translation is, have mercy on me, the sinner. That matters because a sinner, I'm one of many. You're still comparing like the Pharisee. When you say I'm the sinner, what's happening there is he's not ranking himself the worst. He's just stopped ranking himself. And I think this is incredibly difficult for us in today's day and age where everything is comparison. Because what this man does is he doesn't compare. Also, the word for mercy is not the normal word that you normally would have used in Greek. It's a temple word for atonement. for sacrifice, which means by using this word, as he's watching the smoke of sacrifices go up in the temple, what he's saying is, I can't fix myself. I can't do this, Lord.
22:49 You have to somehow provide atonement for me. Somehow I need you to atone, to pay, to transfer, to substitute. And that means then when you step back for a second and say, then what's the real difference between the tax collector and the Pharisee? It wasn't one was more morally right. They both were pretty messed up people. The difference is that one asked for mercy and the other did not. That's the only difference. Jesus says in verse 14, that's why he goes home justified. And again, for those of you who's like, we don't use that term, justification, justified is a legal term of the judge saying that you are now in right standing. but how can this judge say, this tax collector is in right standing when he hasn't paid back what he stole? That's not a good judge, by the way, if he just lets people off and doesn't hold them accountable.
23:45 And the answer is, we're told five chapters later, when Jesus is arrested, look at our verse nine. In verse nine, it says, to some who are confident in their unrighteous and look down on everyone else. That phrase, look down, is a Greek word that means contempt. that word only shows up one other time in the book of Luke. It's in Luke 23, 11, when Jesus is on trial before Herod, it says they treated him with contempt. In other words, the contempt that we do when we compare in this parable lands on Jesus all the way to the cross. And what do you find on the cross? When you get to the cross, he's between two evildoers, the very people that the Pharisee was trying to get away from, Jesus puts himself in between. One says, what does one say? One says, you know what?
24:38 Moxham says, save us all. But it doesn't really mean it. The other one says, no, no, no. We're here because we should be. Jesus, remember me. Jesus, remember me when you're in paradise. Sorry, remember me when you come into your kingdom. And this is what Jesus says. Truly, I tell you, you'll be with me in paradise.
25:00 Notice that that thief didn't get in because of how many Bible studies that he did, because of how many good deeds that he did. If he gets to heaven and is asked, why do you get to be here? He can't point to anything and say, that's why I'm in. And the only reason would be because Jesus said I could be. and folks that's that's the grounds by which we're into that's the grounds by which we hope in If you want to experience the joy of being the sinner, but loved, focus not on what you do for him, but on what he actually has done for you. after the crucifixion, it says that people who gathered to watch, it says that they beat their breasts and went away. We're the only two places in all of New Testament where people beat their breasts, here in our text and at the cross.
26:02 is trying to show us with all these parallels. that the only really righteous man was sentenced as the sinner so that the man who called himself the sinner could actually be righteous. Verse 14, look at verse 14. He says, I tell you. I tell you is not a report, it's a declaration.
26:28 And that's exactly the same declaration that is said on the cross. Remember? Truly, I tell you, you'll be with me in paradise. He says, I tell you here, and he says, I tell you there. Once from the cross, and once this man right here. same verse sorry same voice same verdict In April 1985, again, I'm a child of the 80s. in St. Louis it's 12 year old Darren Ellis and his 16-year-old friend, Timothy Murphy, were climbing a 65-foot mountain of industrial sand. Suddenly the sand pile collapsed, they fall through. And if you've ever been in giant piles of very loose sand, the more you try to climb up, the further you sink down. 16-year-old Timothy dropped underneath there and put him on his shoulders. Every push that Timothy did to lift there and pushed him further down to the ground.
27:21 when rescuers finally dug out and found Darren with his face poking out of the sand they asked him, where's Tim? how are you able to stand high enough to still breathe? And he says, I'm standing on his shoulders. Every time I tell the story, I choke up.
27:42 Because Timothy died so that Darren didn't. Jesus saw every single one of us sinking in the sand of our own comparison. And he didn't stand above saying, here's how to get out. He dived in. to the pit and put us on his shoulders. He was driven down to death so that we could be lifted up. The God of the universe is not asking you to climb on up to him. He sank down into the darkness of our hearts to put us on his wounded shoulders so that his shoulders would be our ground.
28:23 That's the cost. And folks, when that beauty breaks into your life, it answers where we began, which is this, that grace doesn't make you better people. It just makes you not need to be better than everybody else. That's what I want for you. It stops making you needing to be better than everyone else. Have people in the name of Christ, have they been intolerant and oppressive and enslaved and been hypocrites? Yes. But the core of Christianity... is a man who dies for his enemies. And so if you call yourself a Christian, if you don't die for your enemies, then you're not actually believing your faith too much. You're not believing it enough.
29:05 It's not that you're too Christian. You're not Christian enough. You can't look down on someone if you're looking up to your Savior. You never would. And so when this verse sinks in, two things happen to you. First, you remember what it costs. You will regularly go back and your heart will stop saying, I'm in, so they're out. And you'll start saying, wait a second, nobody deserves to be in.
29:34 Why, why does he let us in? Everybody's out, so why does he let us in? That's when you start marveling. That's where you start, when you realize you're justified, you stop having to self-justify. So the next time that you're cut off in the bike lane, I say that to myself The next time that you're wrong the next time you want to look down, remember whose shoulders that you're standing on. His shoulders are are where your feet are And when you do, you remember, you'll never get too high because you know that you have to be on his shoulders, But you'll never get too low Because he's lifted you up Lastly you need to experience Look at verse 14 one more time. I find it so interesting that this tax collector walked down from those steps justified, but he never knew he was. He went on through life not knowing.
30:27 We do. Because Jesus gave us his record, God doesn't merely tolerate us. God delights in you, and so now you get to delight in him. Please, please don't leave here saying, whew, I'm so glad I know what Christianity is about. I feel so much better. That's missing the point.
30:49 If your heart feels cold or joyless today, don't look inside your feelings. Look back at the altar and ask your soul, have you really received atonement for your sin? If you have, accept it. Let it move you. Let it be the lens by which you look out into everything else in this world.
31:09 If you've never prayed this prayer ever, maybe you've never prayed ever, you can start here. with these seven words, God, have mercy on me, the sinner. Every Christian breathes and stays above the sinking stands, not because I've kept the rules, but because we're standing on his shoulders. The cure, folks, is not trying harder to believe. It's to look at him longer until the beauty melts your pride, empties your hands, and lifts you home. Let's pray. Heavenly Father this is so hard because we want justice we want the perpetrators to have an accounting. There is real evil and suffering in the world. you care about it and you do something about it.
32:05 And yet we have this propensity to take any of those differentiations. and use them in our hearts. to not really have to deal with our own issues, to not have to admit. I pray that we would start with ourselves, not a sinner, but the sinner. Help us to admit. And as soon as we can admit, we will see the grace has already been offered. We will see, we can look back and know what you've done. This man never knew that he was justified because he walked down from that temple and Jesus hadn't died yet, but we, we do. Help us to lay into that. Let us experience it and move us in new and profound ways.
Machine translated from the source