Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached November 8, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
Berean Standard Bible.
3:22 We've been going through a series this fall looking at the biggest objections. New Yorkers have to Christianity. And today we get to perhaps the most personal one. It is what Christianity says about sex. Now here's a fact. Over half of regular church attenders actually disagree with the historic claim that Christianity has about sex. Right? This disagreement, this particular one, it's the number one by a mile that the average attender of a church actually disagrees with. It's also the main reason why people leave the church. It's also the main reason why most people stay away from the church in New York City. And because everybody's afraid to talk about it, very few people actually know what the Bible actually says.
4:23 It's one of the least understood ethics in the Bible. Yet we have to talk about it. Because underneath all this talk about sex is actually a bigger question. And that question is this. What does it mean to be human? What role does my body play in who I am? And this question for our culture today, we are at a crossroads culturally. Because on one hand, there's the story that has been told to us for decades. And that is this. That a long, long time ago, oppressive Christians tried to keep us from our authentic sexual selves. and they limited sex within marriage between one man and one woman. We used to be much more free, but they restricted us until brave people fought for the freedom to do whatever we want.
5:26 with whomever we want with our bodies, as long as it's consensual. That's what our culture says on one hand. On the other hand, the very people living out that freedom today that have been living these relationships that culture said will actually make you the most free, those individuals are actually now walking away from it. The New York Magazine, no conservative outlet, ran a piece about people choosing celibacy. The Atlantic has dubbed this era the sex recession. Because people are opting out of these relationships that they were told would make them free. Americans right now are having less sex across every demographic than a generation ago.
6:26 And so the question I want to look at, because we're talking about the doubts that people have about Christianity. Yes, we have to look at, does the Bible's view of sex, is it actually outdated? But I also want to address another question, and that is, why is our culture's story of sexual freedom, why is it leaving so many of us feeling more alone and more used? I think those questions are related. Paul's letter to the church in Corinth which was the Manhattan city of the ancient Mediterranean area I think can give us some color here. It can show us a way forward. So let's look at three things.
7:18 Let's look at our small story of sex, the actual design of sex and the better story of sex. So our small story, the actual design, and then the better story. So first, our small story. Go to our text here. And Paul is addressing a city that was as sexually permissible as New York City. And yet they're swinging between the two extremes that I just detailed. Look at our text. In verse 12, it says, I have the right to do anything. Verse 13, food for the stomach and stomach for food. These are phrases meaning that sex is just an appetite. Sex is just something that I can do like hunger. I eat when I want to eat. I sleep when I want to sleep. Or look at verse 1 of chapter 7, the last paragraph here. Or it is good for a man to have sexual relations.
8:17 Sorry, it is good for a man not to have sexual relations with a woman. And you need to be very conscious that these are in quotations. What Paul's doing here, he is quoting slogans, right? In verse 7, he says, for the matter that you wrote about. But he's also making the same quotations in verse 12 at the very beginning of our passage. What he's doing is he's quoting their slogans and saying, yeah, I know there's these two polarities. One grabs, the other one detaches. Our culture says that Christianity restricted people from being free sexually. But there's some recent books that have come out that have, I believe, proven that that wasn't the case. Kyle Harper in his book, From Shame to Sin, and Tom Holland in his book, Dominion, point out that sex before Christianity was permissible, but only for those who had power.
9:17 back then what you could do if you were a married man yes you could have sex with whomever you wanted of a lower status boy, girl, male, female it didn't matter but if you weren't a married man that wasn't the case women existed to be wives to bear children which means this it was back then sex followed a rule the strong over the weak. Feminist writer Louise Perry, in her book, A Case Against the Sexual Revolution, points out a very bitter irony that when culture reduces sex to disfulfillment, whoever has the power uses it against those who don't. Whoever has the power uses whoever doesn't, and it's always been that way.
10:17 our culture tries to say two things that are different sides of its mouth. On one hand, sex and sexuality is everything. It's your whole identity. At the same time, it's like, actually, it's nothing. It's just like food. It's just an appetite. It's not a big deal. The problem with that is it doesn't work. Something can't be everything and nothing at the same time. that nobody builds an identity from just the food that they eat. I know there's a lot of foodies in here, but very few of you will say that's my core identity. And nobody, by the way, cries to a therapist about a slice of pizza that didn't text them back. I bring that up because I'm showing you this has a lot more power. than what our culture wants to actually say. Which then brings us to our second slogan here in verse 1 of chapter 7.
11:17 When the slogan that says it is good for man not to have sexual relations. This is people who are opting out The share of Americans under the age of 35 who are reporting no sex for an entire year has actually doubled in over a decade. It's 2x'd But when you're being burned, time and time again, I believe, at least the people I talk to, the vault feels safer. It feels safer to lock it down. No matter how cold and lonely that might be. Not long ago, there was a pop-up cafe. It was near Central Park. That their whole shtick was, tables were only for one. But you could put your phone. They had little phone carrier places where you could put your phone in, where you could talk to your AI chatbot. And particularly, your romantic AI chatbot.
12:18 Sociologist Sherry Turkle points out that, actually, if you can look up the news articles on this, there was a waiting list to get in. We want to be in community, right? We want to go out together, but we want what she calls frictionless intimacy, which is feeling wanted without actually ever feeling like we could get hurt.
12:43 That's the vault. But zoom out for just a second here and try to look at both slogans. One slogan says, my body is mine. I can do whatever I want with it. The other one says, my body is mine. I'm going to lock it down. Different sentence, same story. at the end of the day the story is about me that's why I believe our culture story is too small because our cultural story can only fit you in it it's only big enough to fit you and at the end of the day in both stories you're still alone
13:27 If sex isn't just an appetite, and if sex isn't just something to hide from and lock it down, then okay, then what is it designed for? Point two.
14:04 The design of sex. Go to verse 18 here. And Paul says flee from sexual immorality. In verse 18, what's his definition? He defines it in verse 16. In verse 16 he says the order, the design of sex is that the two will become one flesh. If you do a little word study of the word flesh in the Bible, it doesn't mean mere physicality. Flesh is a word that means the whole person. Paul's actually quoting Genesis 2 verses 24 and 25 where Adam and Eve become one flesh. And in that context it says, both were naked and did not feel shame. Why?
14:58 because they weren't just being naked physically. That word naked, we only apply it physically, but biblically, in marriage, they were actually naked in every single way. If you're naked physically with someone and you're not naked financially, if you're not naked emotionally, if you're not naked legally, you're not actually liberating yourself. You're fracturing yourself, splitting your soul because you're asking your body to say, I belong completely to you, but you're asking your life to still say, I belong to myself.
15:44 It's like saying, hey, I'm cool giving you an hour of my life, But real marriage says I'm actually giving you every hour of my life. You don't want to say I want part of you but not all of you. But that's essentially what we're saying in our modern version of this. But Paul's saying that's actually not how you were designed.
16:09 Christine Emma in her book, Rethinking Sex, calls this splitness. That getting naked physically but not in these other ways, you're essentially saying you can see my physical wobbly bits. You can see my physical imperfections, but I'm not going to show you, I'm not going to let you in to my financial, my emotional, my spiritual, my other wobbly bits. And so what you end up doing is you end up using each other. Anthropologist Helen Fisher in Why We Love says that when you have sex, your brain is flooded with dopamine and oxytocin. She calls these super glues designed to bond you to your partner. Which means, interestingly, I find this fascinating. We're all about data and about science.
17:03 In God's design, when you break the bond of a relationship, you're actually breaking and operating against your chemistry, how you were made, which no wonder there just feels like a disjointedness there. And culture said, don't worry, that's just your oppressive historical cultural background. If you just free yourself, you'll be fine. And we've been doing this for decades and decades and decades, and here we are. Now people, this is where, by the way, people push back at this point. They usually say, listen, Mike, you're overdoing it. You're asking too much. If people just consent. if it's mutual consent there's no harm everybody's safe
17:52 Everybody's going to be okay. And we say that because we use consent as our ethic, as if something is right or wrong in these type of relationships. But what I want to tell you is this, where does that idea of consent come from? You have to know where it comes from to know how to use it. Well, it doesn't come from Greco-Roman culture of domination. It doesn't come from evolutionary survival of the fittest. And it doesn't come from, researchers have looked for this, it doesn't come from any other civilization that's ever existed. Where does it come from? Look at verse 4 here of chapter 7. 2,000 years ago, no one would have batted an eye if you read the first part of verse 4. The wife does not have authority over her own body.
18:47 Everybody would have thought, yeah, yeah, yeah, in ancient times. What no one had ever heard of was the second part of this verse. Look at the second part. It says the wife does not have authority over her own body, but yields it to her husband. in the same way. The husband does not have authority over his own body, but yields it to his wife.
19:10 There is no other text. I challenge you to find this. There is no other text in all of ancient literature. that teaches A, that the husband must surrender his body to his wife. And B, that, and this is verse five, that sex must be governed by mutual consent. This is where it shows up. Researchers trace it to right here. Which means, for Paul, consent wasn't just a Christian idea. It was put inside the promise of marriage because that is where real commitment doesn't leave you lonelier than before.
19:55 Consent without commitment, I believe, does leave you lonelier than before. because what you're doing is you're saying, yeah, yeah, yeah, with no further relationship or possibility or togetherness.
20:16 Paul, by the way, if you're like, well, Paul's just waving his finger, who's he talking to? He's actually technically not, he's not talking to single people in this text. He's talking to married people. For Paul, everybody actually misses the proper design of sex. He's talking to married people because sex is broken in every relationship, including Christian married couples, because their tendency is to take sex and turn it into a transaction as well. Tit for tat. Or, you know, I'm going to withhold this because I'm trying to use it. I'm going to do power against you. Or, I'm going to push myself. I'm going to want it and force you. Married Christian couples just as easily can make a transaction or lock it away in a vault. Paul is saying that's not actually the design. The design of real marriage is for spouses to serve one another in mutual consent, caring about the other person for who they are. And when you do, what Paul is saying is that's the only safe place.
21:29 to do life it's in this in this physicality it's within the safe confines of a full life commitment where a trans marriage isn't just a transaction for you to complete. It's a vow that you get to repeat over and over and over again. It's in that confines, that safety of knowing that person's going to be with you that you can actually reveal all the different wobbly bits. that as we don't know about time over time increased, they don't decrease. I'm not talking about this physically. I'm talking about it in every way. So when Paul in verse 18, go back down to verse 18, and he says, flee from sexual immorality. He's not saying that because he's anti-sex. He's so pro-sex. He says, I see it as part of a larger, longer, bigger love.
22:31 Where you bind not just your bodies, you're binding your futures together. The real adventure isn't a thousand one-night stands. The real adventure is when every person looks at the other and says, my body and my life for you. Let me be very clear. You can be in marriage and you don't actually do this. That's what Paul is saying as well. But biblical marriage has the ability to shield us and protect us from how we tend to use each other, whether you're in ancient times or modern times, Corinth or New York, because the love designed for marriage. is part of the reality and fabric of reality of the world. And again, no other culture came up with this.
23:27 So you say, well, why did it come out of this one? Why did it come out of Christianity? Because it was in Christianity for the first time, and only time that says you, every single one of you in this room, you were made by a triune God. What is a triune God? Three persons, perfect unity and diversity. That's the triune God. That you have there the harmony that we so desire out in the world. I find it fascinating that our world, we love racial diversity. We love biodiversity. and yet so ironically, we fail to be in awe of the greatest unity in diversity possibility and that is between a man and a woman, different but equal, offering each other the unique glories and mysteries of each other that the other needs and they don't have.
24:29 That's the possibility and that's the wonder and that's the beauty of it. And yet we look at it and go, I'm, eh, don't really care. That's the design of marriage. And to be clear, Paul is having to say this to this church because nobody, no one is actually living this out. No one is loving others the way they should love. No one is actually caring for people and mutually putting themselves out for the other. Which then raises two questions for me. One, what do you do if you're in a marriage and you keep failing this selfless love? What do you do? Two, what do you do if you're not married? What if you never get married? Does that mean, does that consign us to just a half empty life? Last point, the better story.
25:24 How is it a better story? Look at the stunner here in verse 6 and 7 towards the end. Paul says here at the very end, last few verses, he goes, I wish, I wish that all of you were like as I am. Which is what? Single. But each of you has your own gift from God. This is such a stunner. In ancient times, singleness was a curse. In fact, there was a Roman emperor at one point that outlawed it. Said you're not allowed to be. This was the economic engine. This was the empire engine. You had to have babies. You had to have people to work the fields. All of society would have fallen apart. And yet here's Paul saying, I wish that you were like me.
26:19 Religion idolizes marriage. Our secular culture idolizes sex. Christianity does neither. Because look, follow Paul's logic here. Start in verse 13. And he says, your body is for the Lord. And he will raise you up in verse 14. Which means, right now, you are joined to Christ himself. This is verse 15. Which means then, the spirit of God dwells in you right now. This is verse 17 and 19. So see that flow. What he's saying is, as great as sex and marriage might be. It was always the movie trailer, not the actual movie. it was always pointing to, never actually was, the kind of forever relationship that you could actually have.
27:14 As great as marriage is, it ends in death. But what you have in relationship with God, is the main event. It's the main movie. If you missed the movie trailer, you can still have the movie. If you missed the appetizer, you can still have the main banquet. You haven't missed out. Because marriage points to the gospel. It points to your innate humanity. But singleness, the single life actually shows us the sufficiency that the gospel is actually enough. Because the closest union that you could possibly have is already being offered to you. You already can have it.
28:03 Which means the most wonderful, blissful moment of any marital love possible. If you really let yourself believe this, that it can only ever be just a dim hint, a faint expression of the cosmic joy and beauty and wonder that's available to us when we fall into the Lord's arms. When we place ourself into His love. Because that's what you're actually most created for. Unless you see this, I believe you actually can't be married or single well. Why? Because you won't be single well because you're You know, you could possibly want it too much.
28:52 You won't be single because you will either want it too much or you're going to want it not enough. You're going to end up saying, I want this, I want this, and I won't be happy without it. And you'll be forever upset about it. Or you'll say, you know what, it's not a big deal, I don't need it. But if human marriage points to the better union with who God is, this is what you can do as a single person. You can say, I'd like to be married, but I have the ultimate covenantal forever relationship that it was always pointing to. The true marriage feast. And because I believe in Jesus, I know what awaits me. The one I really need. The one who can really satisfy me. The one who I already have. on the other hand if you're actually married faith in Jesus keeps you from crushing your spouse from needing them to be what they could never actually be.
29:52 how many of your marital problems might actually be, if you trace it down to its root, is that you want from them what they can't give you? the Christian idea of marriage, the Christian hope protects us from that. Because of faith in Jesus, you can say, I don't need you to be what you can't be. I can love you for who you are just as I'm being loved for who I am. That's what's actually possible.
30:26 How can we actually know this love? Go down to verses 19 and 20 here in the middle of the passage. This is sort of the climax for Paul's arguments right in the middle. He says, you are not your own. You are bought for a price. That's the climax for Paul of his argument. Because here's why. Our culture says you are your own, which by the way, sounds really freeing until you realize you are your own actually means you are alone.
31:03 You are your own means it's all up to you. It's up to you to have to show your worth. every single day. Which means then what? It means at 2 a.m. in the morning when you're not able to sleep because you're just thinking about what level of worth that you might be to other people.
31:26 You are your own means you're stuck. But if you're not your own, you know what you get to do? You can quit thinking about what you're thinking about. You can quit thinking how much other people might think about you. You can quit thinking even about how much or how little you think about God. All you get to do is you get to start thinking about how much he thinks of you.
31:48 That's the beauty. That's what's on offer for us. Quit thinking about how much you think about yourself. start thinking about how much he thinks about you. Jesus was never married. Do you know why? You were enough. You were enough for him. If you're not married, Jesus will be enough. Not only that, if you are married, Jesus will be enough for you. Because on that cross, when he died, the last phrase we have in the Bible recorded is it is finished, but it's actually one Greek word, tetelestai, which was a word that was used when a payment was fully made. When a really big payment was fully made, it means essentially paid in full.
32:40 Jesus Christ on the cross with his final cry uses this term. because when every other religious and secular voice essentially says, strive without seizing, do, do, do. He says it's done, paid in full. don't you dare try to live your life outside the bounds of this wonderful promise. When you have a spouse that sees you after decades, and sees all those wobbly bits and says, I'm more committed to you, not less, that melts your heart. The Bible is saying, Jesus on the cross,
33:28 The true bridegroom sees every, every type of wobbly bit. Not just your physical ones. The ones where you use people as if they're just bodies. The ones that you just dehumanize others. He saw it all. The things that you try to hide from the world. And he said, I see it and I stay. and that's how you know his love for you. He took the punishment that you deserve so that you could get the love that he deserves. who you are ultimately is enough for him. So at 2 a.m., when your head says that you're only as valuable as what other people think that you are, he says, to Telestai, I paid it all.
34:23 Take that into the core of who you are. And if you do, let me just give you just a quick practical way to live this out. One, if this is true in your life, you're going to want to marry those people who have the same view of marriage as you. Because why? Because if marriage is a depiction of Christ's love and commitment to you, you're going to want to marry someone who has that same commitment apparatus. You're not going to want to put yourself with someone who doesn't actually know how to live that out. People always say to me, both college students when I was working with them and New Yorkers now, But don't I have to be attracted? Don't I have to be attracted? Sure. But you should want comprehensive attraction. Right? The things that normally attract us, as they get older, as you get older, they tend to fall apart. If you say, I'm attracted to this person, fill in the blank.
35:16 It's usually because of their looks or it's because of their money. Why not actually be attracted to something that gets stronger the older you get? Like their commitment to faith. Like their commitment to you. like the commitment to that relationship. People still say, well, but I need to be attracted to them. Sure, but there's nothing more attracted than somebody else's commitment and love by someone that you admire and respect. And you're going to admire and respect someone who has faith under duress, who stays, who can become endlessly fascinating because they do things in such different ways, but in such ways committed to you.
36:05 Lastly, fill the whole in your life with the only one who can. Jesus surrounded himself by tax collectors and a woman that the town hated, which means he's not gonna separate himself out from you. He's saying, come as you are. So now you can go to him. And if you're sleeping with someone that you haven't given your whole life to, he's not asking you to clean up your life before you come to him. He's just asking you and inviting you to stop letting your body to make promises that your life can't keep. And if you're married and you're keeping score, he doesn't audit you so you don't have to audit each other. He's saying it's free. His relationship's free. Come to him. The true bridegroom doesn't want a one-night stand with you. He doesn't want to just see the good-looking, curated aspects of you.
37:00 He wants you. And in the gospel, Jesus isn't your boss. He isn't just your teacher. He's not just your example. He's someone who delights in you. And when you see him delighting in you, you can delight in him. When you see him in wonder of you, you can be in wonder of him. And when you do all this, I think this hymn comes true. come ye weary and heavy laden, lost and ruined by the fall. If you tarry till you're better, you will never come at all. Let's not tarry. Let's go to him. He's already come to us. Nothing, nothing is more beautiful than that. Let's pray. Heavenly Father, thank you for this good word. This is such a hard word because it doesn't feel natural. It's not how we've grown up.
37:53 It's not the culture that we've swam in. And yet the disjointedness of how things have played out in our culture have us asking, where can we find more? Is there more available? Help us to see the beauty, the inherent beauty of the design that's here. doesn't mean we use these structures well, doesn't mean that there's a magic bullet, but helps us see that the profound mystery and ability. that is inside of marriage that points us to the true and better relationship, the forever promised covenant.
Machine translated from the source