Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached September 20, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
Berean Standard Bible.
3:35 Amen. Good morning and welcome again to Redeemer Lincoln Square. We've been doing a series, or we started a series, looking at some of the major complaints that people have about the Christian faith. I want you to imagine this. Imagine you're out to eat here in New York City, and if you've lived here long enough, this has actually probably happened to you. is you're enjoying yourselves, you're having a good time with mixed company, maybe it's coworkers, people from different backgrounds. And someone in that group basically shows and says that they're a Christian that goes to church. And then there's that extra question that comes out. And that extra question is, do you really believe, is it really true that you think Jesus is the only way? And there's always that silence, that what's going to happen next, what do we do?
4:37 And the reason why it goes like that is because of this. Today, we live in a world where it's okay to be spiritual, just not religious. It's okay to believe for you, just you can't believe that exclusively as if it needs to be applied to everyone else. And the reason why is because who's to say? who's to say which view is actually right? So people say, I can accept Christianity for you. I can accept that's your faith. But I don't accept that it's the only way. That claim, allegedly, is the root of why we have the problems that we have. It's the root of the Crusades. It's the root of colonialism. It's the root of so much violence, centuries of violence. And what about those amazing Buddhists who are kinder than Christians?
5:34 What about those amazing Muslims, those amazing other people that are doing wonderful, beautiful things in the world? Are you saying that all those other faiths have nothing to offer, that they're actually wrong? And so the view is this. The only humble position is that nobody has the whole truth. The only humble position is that nobody has the whole truth. That's the accepted belief in our culture. And by the way, the statistics prove it. There is a Pew study that asked all Americans their view. And 70% of Americans, which is still most churchgoers, 70% of Americans say that actually that, 70% of Americans basically say that there's different ways to get to God. that all different views can get to God.
6:28 And the fastest growing sort of spiritual assumption is those who say they're spiritual but not religious. And they say, most of them say, it's religion that divides. And we know culturally, again, statistically, we are dividing. And so what I want to look at today is this. How can we in good conscience hold an exclusive view of faith? I want to look at that. I want to analyze it. I want to go through. Using these two passages, I would like to try to work through this objection. So let's look at three things. The charge against religion, the claim of Christianity, and the cross of Jesus. The charge, the claim, the cross. All right? So first, the charge against religion. John here in his letter, which is the second paragraph here, in the letter, actually technically both of them are letters, but he's talking to people that are living in the Roman Empire.
7:30 And the Roman Empire is actually very similar to today. There is many different views. There's many different faith assumptions. And what he says in 1 John 4, verse 1, he says what? He says, test the spirits, test them. And he says, test them because there are rival views out there, each saying a different thing. each saying that they were right. And so the charge against religion is this. Religion divides because it leads to violence. It leads to hurt. Because what happens is if you hold your faith, if you believe you're right and other people are wrong, you will weaponize that and use it against other people. who don't have the truth like you do. Now I'm going to say something here that might be a little bit surprising. And that's this. I actually agree with that claim. I actually agree with that charge.
8:26 And now you might push back and say, you're the pastor, how can you agree with that statement? And I can agree with that statement because I want, I say, look at history. History is littered with examples of religious violence, of people weaponizing their truth against each other. And that's because anytime you actually believe that you're saved by thinking and believing right things, by performing right practices, something seems to happen that's really dark in the human heart. where you look down on people who don't. I think that's a verifiable fact. I actually don't disagree with that charge. We tend to, when we have that differentiation, then what happens is we start distancing ourselves from others. And when we distance ourselves, what are we doing? We're separating. And when we separate, there's a divide. And when we divide and we're no longer talking to each other, that's when it's easier to marginalize and mock and oppress. Religion does this.
9:27 And so the question then asked is, well, then, well, how do you solve that divisiveness? Culture has been trying to do this for centuries. How do you solve that divisiveness? Well, one view for a long time was this. Well, we don't have to do anything. Let's just wait it out. Religion will go away. That view was at the turn of last century, and it's actually not a super held view anymore among scholars and elites. And the reason why is because the statistics don't show that. Religion is not decreasing. Religion is actually increasing. There's a book by a secular demographic or political scientist. He says, his name is Eric Hoffman. It's a book called, Shall the Religious Inherent the Earth? And what he does is he shows statistically and demographically that the future is actually not secular. The future is more religious, not less.
10:24 And so what ends up happening is that a lot of people go, what about strictly secular governments? Should we be trying to instill those all over the world? Well, look at their track record. Maybe they'll do a better job than religion. But again, look at history and you can find Stalin, you can find Mao, you can find Pol Pot, and you can find so many different secular governments who do not need religion to actually oppress and slaughter millions. So go back to our text. The spirits here, when you look at the commentaries, they're not just talking about spiritual reality. Spirits are anything that is your message that you want allegiance to. So the spirits that are going on that John is talking about weren't just spiritual assumptions. They were political. They were cultic. They were personal.
11:16 And I think the reason why he's alluding to that is this. Humans have the uncanny ability to take any kind of truth and actually weaponize it and use it against someone else. A week or two ago, Sarah and I went to an English soccer game over in England. And our team is Arsenal. And if you don't like that, I'm sorry. That's because you're not as enlightened as us. See? See? Just did it.
11:44 But what we did was we went to an Arsenal game at an away stadium. So we were rooting for the away team, but we were sitting actually in the home stands. And there's actually rules that you're not allowed to wear your colors in the home stands. And you can't even root for your team in the home stands, in those spaces. And the reason why, ultimately, is because sports allegiance incites violence.
12:11 Sports allegiance, the truth of your team, creates friction against the other team. And so there we were. We were in the homestand. And every time our team would score, I would put my hand on my head going, oh. Because I knew around, that was kind of ambiguous, you know, because they didn't know if it was, oh, no, you know, against. or when they would get close to scoring against my team, I'd go, oh.
12:37 I think I was okay, right? There was like an eight-year-old behind me. I was like, he's going to kill me. Don't show who I was rooting for. But my point is this, is that the problem isn't just religious people. Any truth can be weaponized against others. My mother would, if you go talk to her, she still tells the story about one of her three boys picked up a Bible and beat his other brother over the head. And in that moment she realized, wait, the Bible is a good thing. It's a good thing. And he weaponized this book against his brother. She will also tell you who that son was, and that son was me.
13:20 I did it last week. No, just kidding. No, it was a long time ago. But again, the point is you can do this with anything. You can do this with anything. So what's the strategy? What's the strategy to fix it? The most common strategy to fix religious divisiveness, the most common strategy is to say all religions are equal. All religions are equal. All paths lead up to the mountain of God. And if there's no right way, here's the benefit for you. You don't have to worry about insurance if you have the right view or not the right view. Because, hey, they all kind of go the same direction. So it kind of gets you off the hook in this sense. But John shows us the problem of the view. Go back to verse 1. When he says test the spirits, if all paths were equal, he wouldn't have to say that.
14:15 He clearly is telling them to test them because he's saying they're not equal. Now, a lot of people would push back and what they would say is, well, that's the problem. That's the problem right there. But look at now at verse 5. He says what about these spirits? He says, they are from the world and therefore speak from the viewpoint of the world. And the world listens to them. They're from the world and they're from the viewpoint. What's he getting at? He's saying these voices, they're not neutral. They come from somewhere. They have a viewpoint. Nobody speaks from nowhere. And so let me try to put the problem with this view. The problem with this view is this. If you say that no one has the right to say that they have the truth, that statement itself is an exclusive claim of truth. When you say, hey, nobody has the truth, that's a claim to truth.
15:11 Now, what a lot of people say is, okay, I'm not saying that. I'm saying, well, I'm saying everybody has, you know, part of the truth. Everybody does. And how to illustrate that, a lot of times people use an analogy. They talk about the blind men and the elephant. And the way this analogy, this illustration goes is like this. You have these blind men around an elephant and say, now describe what an elephant is like. And one blind man takes the leg of the elephant and holds it, and it's like, oh, well, the elephant is like a tree, you know, sturdy, and, and, and, you know, I can barely get my arms around it. Another blind man takes the trunk, right, and the trunk, it's like, oh, well, actually, an elephant's more like a hose. It's like a hose, because I got, you know, it's a trunk. Another one holds the ear, and the ear is flat, and it's like, oh, it's more like a pancake. And it's used to say, well, okay, the moral is that every religion thinks they're right, but they only have part of it. And a missionary in India, his name was Leslie Newbegin, heard this all the time in the people that he was with.
16:14 This illustration was used all the time. And he said, he wrote in a book, he said, it was at one point he realized, wait a second. the only way that you can explain that story is who's telling the story. The only way that you can say that none of the blind men have the whole elephant is if you can see the whole, if you can see actually the whole elephant. In other words, to say no religion has the whole can only be said if you have the kind of superior knowledge about all religion that you're saying that no religion is allowed to have. that's actually a really, really good point. Because it looks kind, it looks so humble. Oh, they all have the same, they all have part of the truth, or they're all equal. No, that belief is an exclusive belief. That belief has an insider and outsider.
17:10 That belief is saying everybody who holds an exclusive view is out, but your view is in. So if you say, I don't believe in anything, A lot of folks around here, you know, in New York City, they're like, oh, I don't believe in anything. I'm glad that you believe that. They don't realize that that view itself is an exclusive view that is putting friction by saying, I think I'm right and you're wrong. No, no, no, no, you can believe whatever you want to believe. I'm just believing this. Yeah, but you don't realize that that still is saying anyone who holds an exclusive view that thinks they're right, they're wrong. which means that everybody, I'm just, I'm going to put us all in the same boat here. Everybody's in the same boat. Everybody holds an exclusive view. Everybody has a team that has attention with other teams out there, which means we should not be asking the question, well, which view is exclusive and which ones are not exclusive that are more like, okay, everybody's in.
18:12 The better question to ask is, which exclusive view out there is the most loving inclusive one? Because they're all exclusive.
18:53 And so let's go to point two because we've got to look at the claim of Christianity. Let's compare Christianity now. Look at John 14, which is the first paragraph. And John says this. He says, do not let your hearts be troubled. The very first line. What's the context? The context is Jesus basically just said, after washing the disciples' feet, the disciples are wrecked because he said, hey, Peter, you're going to deny me. hey, I'm going to leave you. They're completely discouraged.
19:22 And so what does Jesus say to comfort them? What he says is, I'm going to prepare a place for you, right? There are many rooms in my house. I'm going to go prepare a place for you. And then, look at verse 6. He says, I am the way, the truth, and the life. I want to unpack that a little bit. The way, the truth, and life. Here's what he's not saying.
19:46 He's not saying I've come to point you the way, like a map. I'm going to point you and you just need to get there on your own. When he says I am the way, I had to look this up. The Greek word for the way. Is a road It's the greek word hodos Which means then this. He's saying, I'm the ground by which you walk to get there. I never thought of it that way. Jesus is saying, I'm actually, if I'm the way and I'm the road, that means... You gotta tread on me literally so to Martha when Martha is talking to Jesus at the grave and she says, if you'd been here, my brother wouldn't have died you know what he doesn't say? He doesn't say, hey, don't worry, the resurrection is over there. it's coming what does he say? he says I am the resurrection when people are hungry and spiritually hungry and physically what does he say? he doesn't say hey go get bread over there what does he say?
20:40 I am the bread of life. Right? I am the truth of life. So what he's doing, he's not actually giving, he's not giving us the blueprint for how to live life. What he's doing is he's saying, I am life itself. But this is where I want to pause a little bit. Because I want to be careful, because I know there's people in this room and people in general. This is what ends up happening is people say, okay, What I'm going to do is I'm going to try to live for God. I'm going to strive to go to church when it's rainy. I don't feel like it. I'm going to try to get up and read my Bible and pray. And those might be good practices. But we have to be careful because there's a certain way that we actually wield those practices that will actually crush us.
21:35 Because he's not saying I've come to help you strive. He's saying, I've done all the striving that you need to do. He said, I didn't come to teach you how to live a good life and then die a good death. He's saying, I lived the perfect life and died the perfect death. So this is the claim, folks. The claim is this. The gospel doesn't say, do and then it will be done.
22:04 He's saying it's done, which enables us to do. Notice where this way is pointing. Go back to verse 6. And the way, the truth, and life. Where is it going? No one comes to the Father except through me. what Jesus is saying here is, the road ends at my father's house. So many people in this town, when I really kind of ask them, I'm like, well, what's your belief? They think of the divine as like a force, as an energy.
22:38 But Jesus says, actually, it's the father. He turns a force into a father. A force can't love, can it? It won't wait up for you. Do you know what you can do with this father that will make him stop being yours? You know what you can do? Nothing.
23:05 That's the benefit of a good father. My dad wasn't perfect, but I'm positive that he would have jumped in front of a bus if it meant saving me. and the best father that you can think of is just a hint of this one. Only through Jesus can you actually know how God actually feels about you. How can you know? Because, again, now go to verse 7. If you know me, then you know the father. That means Jesus is saying there's something about the character of who I am that reveals about the character of who God is. What's that? So what does Jesus do? Jesus is the kind of person who gets down and washes your feet. That means Jesus is saying God is the kind of God who isn't up on the mountain. He's come down through him.
24:00 He has a home with many rooms. Look at verse two. My father's house has many rooms. there's a book by a guy named Lame Sane. He grew up Muslim in Gambia. He was a professor at Yale for a while. And he has a book called Whose Religion is Christianity? And he shows, and it's very small. It's an easy book to read, actually. But he tries to show that, actually, Christianity is unique because it doesn't have a holy language of its own. and it's the only major religion that has no home culture. If you think about all the major religions out there, there is a, its home is still where it started. Judaism with Jerusalem, right? You have Islam as a focal point, Mecca.
24:56 Buddhism is still mainly in the East. Christianity though has no home culture. Why? Because it's been translated everywhere. Why? Because it has many rooms. There are many rooms for you. but you will push back and I think, and you should and say, but yeah, yeah, yeah. But I don't like this phrase. No one comes to the father except for me. That's exclusive.
25:20 What about the good Hindu? What about the good Muslim? What about the good friend that you have that's not a believer? Last point, the cross of Jesus. Christianity is exclusive. I'm just going to come out and say that it is exclusive. But I think we've shown you that I think everybody is. So which one is the most inclusive, exclusive you? Go back to the second paragraph here, 1 John 4. Look at verse 10, last line. This is love. Not that we love God, that he loved us and sent his son as an atoning sacrifice for our sin. This is, by the way, temple language. Temple language is that the sacrifice atones, it pays for what keeps us out. Key words are not we And sent Religion, what does religion do?
26:13 Religion tells you we get to God John says no, not we God has come to you That's the opposite Religion is advice about how you get to climb up. John just says right here No, no, he's actually sent down John's words are not a vice about how you have to love God better. It's showing us, it's news about how he has loved us. Love is not a feeling here, by the way. It's not the lovey-dovey butterflies in the stomach. It's a man dying for his enemies. And when he's nailed down, he's not cursing under his breath. As the soldiers are rolling dice for his garments, as the people who put him up there are laughing at him. What is he saying? He's saying, Father, forgive them for they know not what they do.
27:08 He's praying for them, speaking words over them. If you think... Some of you are like, those are nice distinctos, but if... Many of you are still saying, yeah, but if you think Christianity is true, won't you actually still oppress people? Won't you oppress and, you know, just like everybody else? And this is where we just need to get down to the essence, the core of Christianity. is not a command for you to love your enemies. The core of Christianity is the God of the universe. in the person of Jesus. who comes and dies for his enemies. And if you put him at the center of your life, if you put that at the center of your life, what happens? You will die for your enemies.
28:01 What are the other possibilities? Put moralistic religion at the core of who you are, and what you will do is you will look down on people who are not as religious as you. If you put secularism at the core of who you are, what will you do? You will look down at people who are those stupid religious people. But if you put the gospel at the center of your life, it is an exclusive truth, but it's the most inclusive exclusive truth because when we really know that he died for us, you will die for others. You will seek to serve the people who don't believe what you believe. Why? Because God served us when we didn't believe. You'll love people who don't love you. Why? Because he loved you when you didn't love him.
28:49 Now, you're going to still say, well, but haven't people in the name of Christianity, haven't they not died for their enemies? Haven't they oppressed? And the answer is 100% yes. History shows it. Many, many people in the name of Christianity have done terrible things to other people. But I want to make the argument if the core of Christianity is a man who dies for his enemies. if you turn around and oppress other people then that's not because you're acting too Christian it's that you're not actually acting Christian enough you can't you can't turn around and oppress if the core of Christianity is a man who dies for his enemies. right? If you crush someone in the name of a man who was crushed for his enemies, you definitely have missed the point and you've missed grace.
29:47 Every other view, and we're happy to have these convos in Q&R, is exclusive. And the way it works is when you hold it, you have to perform it. You have to believe right. You have to act right. And that's how you become right. But Christianity is the opposite. It basically says nobody performs enough. Everybody's out. The priest and the prostitute, the elder and the atheist, everybody's out.
30:15 And so go back to that good Hindu, that good Muslim. I'm so glad they are. That makes the world a better place. It's called common grace. But as far as a standard, no one is good enough. Not you, not me, not them. And you say, well, how's that good news? The good news is if everybody's out, folks, that means anybody can be brought in. Not by performance, but by grace. All you need is to see your need. Go to God and say to him, I want this to be true. And if you do, guess what's amazing about this faith is that that's enough. And that's kind of wild if you think about it. If you get in because you're good enough, you will look down on everyone who's not. but if you get in because you're so bad he had to die for you, who's left for you to look down on?
31:08 Right? You don't beat yourself up though because you were so loved that he was willing to die for you. Every other truth will oppose others that don't hold their truth and will oppress. If you believe the gospel, you put this at the core of your life, you die for your enemies because it's the God of your heart.
31:31 Folks, if you don't believe the gospel, I would love for you to consider believing this morning. And I want to make the argument because it's what the world needs. it's an exclusive truth, but it's so inclusive. It brings everybody in, and out of gratitude, you go out and serve. Think about this, put it this way, this is the last thing I wanna say.
31:55 Every exclusive view that's ever been put on you, that's kept you out. What have people said to you? You're not smart enough, that's kept you out. You're not pretty enough, that's kept you out. You're not good enough, you're not funny enough, you're not kind enough. every love has conditions and it's kept you out. But if the center of the universe is a God. who isn't trying to keep you out. No, he comes down on the cross. Jesus says, what does he do? He comes down on the cross to let us in. And if that's at the center of the universe, we never have to be in fear of not being smart enough or pretty enough or good enough anymore. those statements no longer have claim over our lives they don't, they don't have the final say, he does, and you know what he did, he decided that you were worth dying for, every word of the world says not enough, but replace that by what we see here, I'm going to prepare a place for you, and he prepares it by giving up his room so that we have a room,
33:06 if today, this morning, if you're feeling like you never had a home, he's preparing a place for you. If this morning you feel far from home, you feel lost, you feel astray, he's gone to prepare a room for you. If this morning you feel like you got that letter that said no at the job with that person, with that family, if your performance is not enough, if you are tired and you've been searching for your own room, he's gone to prepare that room for you. Every truth claim is exclusive. But hear the most inclusive, exclusive view. And what he's saying to you is, I've gone to prepare a room. Will you go? Will you go in?
33:59 Stop performing for a room. You're already invited in. Let's pray. Heavenly Father. This is so hard. It's hard because the stories we live by, the stories that we swim in every day.
34:19 We live in New York City where there's so many different views and everybody's trying to figure out how do we make sure this... doesn't explode. We think on the surface it looks safer to just sort of make a big broad statements of... everything's the same. Help us to see that that view itself has caused violence. We've seen it in history. We've seen it in governments. We've seen it in politics. We've seen it in sports teams. if we are Christians this morning, I pray that we recommit to making the God of the universe. who dies for his enemies, the core of who we are. And when we see that we were an enemy, but we were brought in, that gratitude, that experience pushes us out in new form ways to be curious, to stay, to persevere, move in our hearts in profound ways.
35:24 If we're not a Christian this morning, I pray that we will really first think about what exclusive view we hold. And is it holding? Is it enough? Turn our hearts and minds towards you in all that we do.
Machine translated from the source