Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached May 10, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
2:22 I have even seen, a couple years ago, I saw two men fighting on the subway platform. They were red in the face. They were about to really just start throwing punches. And one of them looks at the other one and says, come on, man. God is love. And it worked. But I actually think there's a problem here. And the problem is this. That phrase is one of the most quoted, but also one of the most misunderstood phrases in the entire Bible. because the way we use it, even if there's positive outcomes at times, is we use it any way we want. We fill it with any of our own content. God is love often just means God is whatever I want him to mean. It means that God basically agrees with my choices. That God, if there's a God, doesn't really have a strong opinion about me or my actions. That God is exactly who I would design him to be if he was myself. That is how that phrase is often used. One philosopher said so much of religion is just what we want and we call it God. And that seems to be very true.
3:42 That we can take one of the most beautiful three-word constructions in the Bible. and bend it into a mirror that reflects us, that reveals more about us. But here's the truth. John did not give us this text for it to be bent.
4:02 He had a very specific and purposeful meaning when he said this phrase. And if we actually let it, if we actually follow what it actually means, it'll change everything about how we understand ourselves and how we understand the world around us. We've been doing a series on the Apostles' Creed. We just started it. The Apostles' Creed is one of the most ancient Christian creeds that we have. We say it during communion, but we're going to start saying it every week because of the series. And it's one of the few ones that all Christian traditions point to and say, yes, that's true. Catholics, Protestants, Eastern Orthodox, Russian Orthodox, every major denomination agrees with the Apostles' Creed. But even though we say it, what does it mean?
4:59 It becomes rote if you don't understand the words inside. And so today we get to the Trinity. The Creed that we're going to read right after our sermon today, it says, yes, I believe in God the Father Almighty, but it also says, and in Jesus Christ, His Son, our Lord, who was conceived by the Holy Spirit. I want to take those three phrases, put them together, and say, let's talk about the Trinity today. The Trinity is one of those mysterious doctrines in the Bible that most of us are like, what does that even mean? Why does it even matter? At the heart of the Trinity, it's structured around a relationship between the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. So let's look at it in three ways. Let's look at love is relational, love is costly, love is sacrificial. We're going to look at love is relational, costly, and sacrificial. So first, love is relational.
5:54 Look at the very first phrase here in verse 7. Jesus, sorry, not Jesus, John opens the text with an, in Greek it's called an imperative. It's a command. It says, dear friends, let us love one another, for love comes from God. And then the next verse, it says, whoever does not love does not know God, because God is love. Now we have to stop here. Because a lot of us, John is not saying what a lot of us think he's saying. Be very careful with the constructions of the words here. Because here's what he's not saying. He is not saying God is just loving. As if it's an attribute that is one of many attributes. That God is powerful and God is holy and God is wise. The Bible actually never says God is power.
6:47 The Bible never says God is mercy. For John, not once, twice, in our passage here, he says God is love. Which means, for John, the Greek, the language here is, this is his essence. This is not just a feature of who he is. It means there is something about God. that this is the core of his being. In other words, this is not something he can just turn on and off like if he's in the mood for it.
7:24 Everything he does flows from this, his creating, his ruling, his wrath, his judgment. Everything flows out of this because God is love all the way down. But if that's true, we have to ask the next question, which is this, okay, well, when did that start? A lot of people think that the way it goes is like this. God in the beginning was alone. He was pure spirit. He was powerful. He was eternal, but he was alone. And yet at some point, God creates. beings, humans, because he needed them to relate to them. Of course, that creates a problem, doesn't it? Because if God created you to fill a void, then God created you because he had a need within himself. that his love for you is not rooted for you, it's rooted for him.
8:27 So whatever love would be in this context, if this is the reason why God created, then love ultimately isn't about you, it's about him. It's a need love. And a love that needs you is a love in the end for one who gives it, not one who receives it. And I think this is exactly where the Christian doctrine of the Trinity... offers something that no other view of God does because go back to the text again look at verse 7, it says God, right, God's present but then skip down to verse 9, this is how God shows his love he sent his one and only son okay, so there's his son and then if you skip down to verse 13 it says, this is how we know that we live in him and he in us. he has given us of his spirit. And so here we have, in 10 verses, you have all three persons of the Trinity.
9:26 And the implication is this. Whatever else the Trinity means, it means this. God was never alone. God was never lonely. At the core of who God is, if God is this Trinitarian nature, then at the core who God is is relationship eternally, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Which means this, love didn't start at creation. Love has always been.
9:57 That means love will always be. And that means before the first molecule that was created, Before the first photon of light that was created The Father was pouring himself into the Son The Son was glorifying the Father And the Spirit was illuminating them both In mutual, perfect, beautiful delight Overflowing love I've read sermons from hundreds of years ago where God is conceived of as just this overflowing love, pouring itself out into each other.
10:36 And that means this. It means that love is not just God's favorite attribute. If love is without beginning, if it's without end, if love is his nature and it always has been, that means here's what we know about love. Love is at the core, therefore, relational because God is relational in Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Which then, of course, begs the next question, which is this. If that's the nature of who God is, then why did he create in the first place?
11:06 And logically, here's what you get to do. If he didn't create because he needed you, if he didn't create because he had to, why would he create? If he was already complete, if he was already overflowing with Trinitarian love, then there is only one possible reason left. The only possible reason left is that the nature of love, whatever it is, if it's relational, if it's about pouring itself out, then the only reason to create is to spread that love. In other words, love... was given. Creation then is not the product for God to get love. It was the way for him to give love and to move it out and to spread it. And for us to be able to partake in the riches of what he already had overflowing in him.
12:06 Folks, there is no other reason in the Christian understanding. Creation is not God needing to fill something of a need. You and I are here because God looked at the overflow of his love within himself and he said, you know what? I want to share this. I want others to partake in it. And that means you,
12:32 whatever it means to be you, you are the destination of love. You are not supposed to be the supplier of it. You're the interminus of love. You're not the one who's supposed to procure it. All right. Why am I bringing all this up? Because I'm like you. You should be saying this. So what? So what? So what?
12:54 I believe that you and I, we don't live every single day in light of this truth. And I don't think we do because here's why. I think you and I, we wake up every single morning still running on the assumption. that love has to be earned. That it's what we do that gives us what we need. That you have to perform for it. That's why we have to grab it. We have to get it. And everything we do about it is because ultimately we think that's the only way we're going to get love. That's why you and I feel like we have to go to work. Not just to pay the bills, but because that's how we're going to get that satisfaction and that verdict and that need that still bugs us in the back of our mind. That's why we feel like we need intimacy from someone else.
13:46 That's why we do what we do, because we think that's the only way we're going to get love. So here's the question I want to ask you. How many more days will you go on addition-y for an approval and for a love that you already have?
14:06 When will you wake up? When will we wake up? that the love that you are exhausting yourself to try to get, to try to earn, has actually already been given, if you just actually receive it. It's like what the old hymn says, you know, the old hymn that says, lay your deadly doing down, down at Jesus' feet. Stand in Him and Him alone, gloriously complete. Will we do that? Can we do that? Step into this love, experience it. You were always the destination all along. Now, that's the first point, love is relational. secondly
15:49 in love that you say? Where is this perfect love that's overflowing throughout all of eternity? I don't see it. We don't see it. And the answer is, the reason why that love feels so distant from us is this. Love, even though it's relational, it only can be received if it becomes visible. Right? You have to be able to see it. Look at verse 9. John even agrees with this. He says, this is how God showed his love among us. He has to show his love. And the word show here is the Greek word for revealing something that's been in hiding, that something has been invisible and it's being made visible. Think of invisible ink. I don't know if you still use invisible ink these days, but if you write on a piece of paper with invisible ink, there are words on that paper.
16:46 You can't see it. You need a decoder or you have to put it up to light or something has to reveal the words that were already there. God is the exact same, operates the same way. His love is real, but it's invisible until it's expressed. and it becomes most visible through cost. Anyone can say loving words. Anybody can speak, right, sweet nothings into your ear about who you are and how much they love you. But that love doesn't come home. It's not experienced until it's made visible through cost.
17:29 And not just made visible through cost, but then you actually have to see that cost. During World War II there was a Scottish soldier His name was Ernest Gordon He spent three years as a prisoner of war In a Japanese camp And he wrote about it later He talked about how the conditions there were brutal That the heat, the starvation Forced labor And the men had to just survive It was a dog-eat-dog world They would steal rations from each other They would be ruthless towards each other to try to live. Those were the conditions, every man for himself. Now, one day, a company of them, they were trying to build this railroad in impossible conditions. And at the end of the day, they always take an accounting of the tools they used. And as they took an accounting, one shovel was missing.
18:24 And so the guard lines up this company and says, unless the person who stole that shovel comes forward, I'm going to kill every single one of you. Seconds felt like an eternity. It felt like they were all going to die. And right when it looked like they were going to all die, one man steps forward.
18:48 The guard beats that man to death. and then they start putting everything away And there was a new accounting of all the equipment. and it turns out that shovel was never missing. it turns out that that man stepped forward and sacrificed himself to die for his brothers. And the effect was immediate. Men who had been brutal towards each other became gentle. Men who were stealing from each other's rations started giving them. People started caring for the sick and looking out for the weak. Even when the war was over, none of those men actually went after their captors to try to retaliate. And interestingly, not everybody was there for this moment. Only some of them were eyewitnesses, but the story itself was enough to break the logic of self-preservation. The man who stepped forward made the invisible visible.
19:50 And it changed everything. You see, God's overflowing love most shows itself through cost. Look at verse 10. It says that he sent his son, right, as an atoning sacrifice for our sins. That's cost. The night before the cross, in a garden outside of Jerusalem, the Garden of Gethsemane, Jesus is praying and we're told that he's sweating blood, which is a real physiological response to extreme stress. It's when the capillaries burst around the sweat glands and you can actually sweat blood. His body is breaking under the weight and he prays. He says, Father, not my will but your will. Let this cup pass from me. Any other way. Is there any other way? And when the answer came back That there was no other way To bring us home He goes to the cross The one whom All things were made That he had this overflowing nature Of joy and love within the Trinity From all the time You know what it is?
21:03 He doesn't walk away And he With the Trinity decided before the foundations of the world, before you and I even existed, before you had done even one thing to disqualify yourself, he said, this is worth it. He would have known that it was worth it for them.
21:30 Because why? Here's the reason why. What did God have before the cross? He had all love and joy. You know what He didn't have? He didn't have you. You were the only thing He didn't have. And yet he said, you are worth it for him to die for. And so here's the thing. You cannot look at the Garden of Gethsemane, you cannot look at the cross and say that God's love is vague. No, it is a very specific and purposeful way to show you the cost. The cost was everything to get you. And so the cross is not a symbol of love. It is very literally the price tag for it.
22:17 The costness of love. All right, lastly, the sacrificial nature of love. If love is only real when visible, and it's only visible through cost, for Christianity, that cost of where you see God's love, it's actually, it becomes visible in the cross. But I want to ask us a question, just more generally. What did it cost your God to love you? There are people in this room. There are people out in New York, they have a more vague understanding of God's love. They like that idea, that God is love, but it's just, you know, God's a force, not the God of the Bible, just God is love. But God, the God of love, that doesn't, that it doesn't cost anything. That means that God stays at a safe distance. So how do you know that love is real? all love for it to become real to you it has to be shown to you through the costliness of what it takes to secure it.
23:16 if you're a parent and you change diapers your love is very tangible because A, you have to change those diapers and you have to pay for those diapers and those things are expensive but if you're a spouse the fact that you stay that's costly love too see all real love is costly God's love in the cross shows that cost in us. But if you don't have that, how do you know God actually loves you? Because a feeling of love is not the same thing. as the evidence of love. You know what happens to feelings? Feelings come and go. They will definitely go at 3 a.m. when you can't get over that gnawing sense of doubt, when anxiety is overflowing flowing your sense apparatus, when the hurt and hardships come, when that terminal diagnosis comes, what did it cost you? Sorry, what did it cost God to love you? The cross is that for Christians. It's the moment that God's love becomes externally verifiable through a very historical price. Now, we said God's love is relational, it's costly, it's sacrificial. Now, you should ask, okay, but what's the difference between costly love and sacrificial love? Those sound kind of similar. Well, here's the difference. If you and I are walking down Broadway, and I decide to just step in front of a bus and die, that's costly love. It's not sacrificial love.
24:52 Sacrificial love is if that bus is about to hit you and I push you out of the way from that bus and I take the hit and I die so that you live. That's sacrificial love. The first one costs me, the second one saves you through sacrifice. And here's what you need to hear then. The cross is not just costly, it's also substitutionary, which means it's sacrificial. When you and I live our lives the way that we live our lives, which is unto ourselves, when we try to earn it, when we try to do it apart from God, it always ends up centering on ourselves. The selfishness, the self-centeredness, and it breaks us, and it breaks the world. And the bus that's bound to hit us all, Jesus pushes us away from that bus and takes the hit himself. That is what separates Christianity from all other frameworks that I know of. If you go through a few of them, watch this, if you go through and look at secular humanism.
25:55 What does that say? Secular humanism says, hey, all that's here is just material. The world is matter in motion. But you have no personal origin, and therefore when you die, you will not be missed. The love that you and I might feel, it's a neurological feeling that is shaped by evolution. It feels important, but it really is not. And the universe ultimately does not know your name.
26:25 And it becomes problematic. Why? Because in love, whatever it is, it's not relational. It's not real. Maybe your framework is more spiritual but not religious. People love that phrase. Hey, I'm spiritual but not religious. Maybe you believe in karma. Maybe you believe in divine energy that holds everything together. But again, that love is still impersonal. A force cannot push you out from the bus. A force can't bleed for you.
26:59 You see, every other religion or non-religious framework that I know of, at its core essentially is this, it's a ladder. It essentially says, be devout enough, be moral enough, be enlightened enough. And if you do that, perhaps maybe one day you'll be able to get to the divine. The burden is always on you. Only Christianity says this. It says, yeah, be moral, be devout. But you'll never be able to.
27:33 And so you can't get to God. God has to come to you. And that's what actually happens. And the cost of that is the cross. If you look down at verse 10 again, it says in verse 10 that this love, this is love not that we love God, but that he loved us and sent his son as an atoning sacrifice for our sins. Look at the, there's a directional movement here. We did not get to him. He came looking for us. He came to pay. He does pay. In John 17, there's this beautiful passage, I was reading it recently, where Jesus prays the night before the cross, and he's praying for the people that he was about to die for. And he thinks of them, he talks about them as if they're already home. This is what he says. He says, I want those that you have given me to be with me where I am.
28:34 I love that. That Jesus is conceiving of you. You haven't been born yet, and yet he speaks of you as if you're already belonging to him. Why? Because love is relational. But okay, fine, fine. How does that actually change how we live? Here's how. Manhattan. I love this town. I grew up here, but it has a gospel too. Here's the gospel of Manhattan. You are what you produce. You are what you do. And therefore, you can have love if you produce enough, if you do enough, if you achieve enough, if you work hard enough. You will get what you always wanted. But that's actually why we live with this low-grade anxiety, this fear of, have I done enough? You also, maybe you feel like you are doing enough, but you're like, I don't know if I can keep this up. there's this fear of what happens if i can't and we worry that the love will leave.
29:36 Former U.S. Senator Ben Sasse recently was diagnosed with terminal diagnosis. He was told that he has months to live because he has stage 4 pancreatic cancer. It's the very same diagnosis that killed my father. And in a recent interview, he talked about how death is evil. He calls death wrong. And yet in the same breath, he also says his diagnosis has been a touch of grace. Why is that? He goes on and he says it's because it has stripped him of the illusion that he has this omni-competence. The delusion that if he just does enough, then he'll be okay. That he can pay for his own brokenness. he talks about how his terminal diagnosis forces him to realize the truth that you cannot perform out of this one and yet facing the terrors of leaving his family facing the grave he has peace. And he has this phrase that just guts me when he says it he's quoting another pastor but it's a great phrase he says this he says there are no maverick molecules in the universe
30:54 There are no maverick molecules in the universe, not one. See, if the triune God is actually exercising absolute control over even aggressively mutating cancer cells, then your suffering is never meaningless. We don't necessarily know why God lets the hurt happen, but we know what it can't be. It can't be that he doesn't love you because the God who upholds every molecule is the same God who enters into the brokenness around us and does something about it. He destroys the powers and principalities, but he also destroys the only real cosmic death that can actually get you. If local death can bring you closer to him, cosmic death is the only thing that can keep you far away from him. And the cross solves that cosmic death,
31:44 substituting himself to save you. That's why Ben Sasse can face death. That's actually why you and I can look at the grave. And as hard as that might be, we will know that our eternity is secured because God's plans are never thwarted. and his love is never going to be exhausted. And when that reality sets in, folks, that's when you can stop performing. That's when you can start receiving. That's when you can finally rest. Not stop working, but working in rest.
32:17 In 2019, there was a nine-year-old boy who was on the spectrum. His name was Ronan. And he attended a performance in Symphony Hall in Boston. I believe it was Mozart's funeral music. Very somber, very dark, but at the very end, it turns bright. It turns light. There's this warmth of blazing beauty that shows up.
32:47 And when the performance was over, there's always this silence. And this boy who is nonverbal, mostly, he couldn't contain himself. You know what he said? In the space of silence, everyone in the room, he says, wow.
33:07 And what was beautiful was rather than reacting with irritation, the entire audience and the orchestra burst out in applause for the boy. Because everybody in the room understood in their bones that what the boy had done was right. That when you become faced with immense beauty, you can't help but to respond with awe.
33:35 That is what this text is. If we read this text over and over and over again, when taken to heart, it has given you the space to say, wow. to be filled with awe and wonder that the maker of the stars is the one who bleeds for rebels who reject him. And the love that's been running throughout all of time. absorbed what you owed to fix you. And now you can call him by name. And now he calls you by name. wow how do we know that we actually believe this here's what you need to ask how often, how many times have we been in awe and wonder about that and to be clear, having those experiences do not save you but reflecting on how you've been saved gives you those experiences stop trying to earn love Stop trying to extract it from the world that can't give it.
34:34 just receive it in Christ and when you do you will not be able to stay quiet you will move out in love and service and kindness and tenderness out into the world in the same way that our Lord did as well wow let's pray Heavenly Father Wow. thank you so much. We see this phrase, God is love, but it is not just a generic, vague phrase. It is a specific truth of relational, costly, sacrificial love that you have shown us. Father, so much of this world is noise because we can't see it. There's so much hardship. There's so much hurt.
35:25 Help us to see you. Help us to see you that you did not stay distant. you showed us the costness of love you showed us the sacrificial nature of love you entered into it help us to taste it help us to see it help it to move us we're so busy this town is full of busyness and that is a good thing because you've made us to work but help us to work and rest and we can rest when we don't have to use work to get love work can just be the process by which we show the love that we've already received, that we can do it well for others and for you. Change our hearts. Move in us in profound ways. We pray these things in your name.
Machine translated from the source