Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached December 14, 2025
Berean Standard Bible.
1:26 Amen. Thank you, Jess. And good morning and welcome again to Redeemer Lincoln Square to our special Lessons in Carol service. I have a confession to make. I've been having an ongoing yearly dispute, fight, whatever you want to call it, with my wife over when it's appropriate to start singing Christmas carols in the year. To me, it feels like every year it gets a little bit earlier. It used to be, in my mind, December 1st, and then it started turning to November, and then it started turning to June. No, I didn't get that far. But the dispute is that she thinks it's never too early to start. I am an individual of moderation and believe that there is a place where it's too early. But what we both agree is this, is that we know that Once you start singing, it sets the season.
2:23 When you start singing, songs define the season. Now today, we get to go to the very first Christian Christmas carol that's here in Luke. This is Mary's song. Now, we have to ask this question, which is, what is so important about this song that Luke interrupts his story, his narrative, his historical account of Jesus and says, you know what, this is so important, I need to record this and put it down so that everybody knows this was the first hymn ever sung. But why does he interrupt his narrative for a song? If you're here today and you are skeptical of Christianity, maybe you don't know what you believe, maybe you were invited here by a friend, a lot of times you might think that Christianity just creates passivity, It just creates people who are quiet and, you know, follow the opium of the masses. But then how come Mary is singing about overthrowing thrones and scattering the proud?
3:27 Like whatever this is, this is not passivity. In fact, I actually think if you read it a number of times, it poses a problem for us. Every single one of us, whether you're a Christian or not. It poses a problem because deep in our bones, we believe, we were taught that the way up is through power. The way to success is to get it and grab it. It's through accumulation. It's through achievement. And yet here's Mary singing about a God who only meets us on the way down. And the very thrones that we seek to inhabit, he topples over.
4:08 What do we do with this? What we see here is a great reversal. That what we always thought the way the world works, God comes in and reverses it all. And so I want to look at just two points today. Number one, how God reverses our values and how he reverses our verdict. Two points, our values and our verdict. All right, number one, first, he reverses our values. Look at our text here in verse 51. Mary starts singing about how God scatters the proud. In verse 52, it says that he brings down the mighty. In verse 53, he sends away the rich empty. Now, these are all people that society would say is, you know, what we should be aspiring to and to try to be. Now, some people try to read this and say, oh, you know, God hates the rich. He hates the successful. But that's not completely accurate. Because he sends them away because they're already full.
5:03 If you went to a soup kitchen, right, that serves people who need food, but if you brought your own picnic basket full of a seven-course meal, and you sit down at this soup kitchen and you just break out your champagne and your bonbons and you start cutting your brie and crackers and you eat first course and second course and third course, I guarantee you as that server comes by and doesn't serve you, it's not because he hates you. It's because you're already full. It's because you don't need it. You can't receive what you don't feel like you need. And this is, I actually think, the number one problem, whether you're a Christian and you've heard Christianity before and it doesn't seem to really move you, or you're not a Christian or you don't know what you believe and you're like, I don't see the point. In both cases, you don't need what you don't want. In both cases, you don't want what you don't think you need. Either way, whether you're religious or secular, that seems to be the problem.
6:00 that we have. Because we think, why? Because the world operates in the opposite way. The world operates in what I call the right side up kingdom. That the way to power is to get it. The way to wealth is to grab it. That we need to go out and therefore the successful people are in and the unsuccessful people are out. The put together people are in, the unoppressive people are out. All of our institutions, the way our clubs work, the way our schools work, the way our places of employment work, that's the way the world works. And yet Mary shows up here, and she's saying in this text, no. That's not how God's kingdom works. In fact, every single one of the verses here are actually, if you read it enough, they're contrasts. See, look in verse 52 and 53, it says that he lifts up the humble and the hungry. Right?
6:55 It says that he performs mighty deeds and he scatters those who are proud. He brings down the rulers, but he lifts up the humble. He fills the hungry, but he sends away the rich. See the contrast back and forth. What Mary's rejoicing is that the God of the universe, this is not an exception. What she's trying to point out is this is actually how God has always and forever operated. 2,000 years ago, the way the world worked economically, culturally, it was through birthright. that if you were the oldest, you would inherit, you'd get all the status, you'd get all the money, you'd do everything. If you were the second born or the third born, fourth born, you were an afterthought. You got a fraction of that. And so what does God do? Does God say, well, listen, that's how the world works and I'm gonna show you that I'm numero uno. No, what does he do? Throughout the entire Bible, he picks Abel, not Cain. It's always, it's Isaac over Ishmael.
7:51 It's Jacob over Esau. It was David over every single one of his brothers who were all older than him. He also picks the unlovely, the unloved, the socially shamed woman. It was always, you know, old Sarah versus Hagar. It was unloved Leah, not Rachel. Time and time again, it was always the girl that nobody chooses. It was the boy that nobody wanted. Because it was God's way of trying to broadcast. Maybe we weren't receiving it, but he was trying to broadcast. that my salvation this is how it comes, it always works upside down if you think you get it you don't get it If you don't get it, you're actually starting to get it. because that's how God works it's not through strength, it's through weakness and therefore the path of being full is admitting that actually you're empty the path of actually having strength is confessing that you have weakness I regularly get to do membership for those who want to join our church, but I also get to hang out with folks that are skeptical of Christianity and, you know, we meet up for coffee.
8:58 And at times I'll actually ask both groups of people, committed Christians and then actually people who definitely know that they're not, I'll ask them the same exact question. I'll say, what do you actually think that I believe? What do you think Christianity is about? I'm just curious. And interestingly, more often than not, their answers are very similar. I'll hear committed Christians as well as those who are skeptical of Christianity, and they'll say that what it means to be a Christian is to try to live a good life. That you need to, you know, obey the law and do the Ten Commandments and try hard and be good. And they hold that view because that's how they've been trained. That's how we've grown up in this world. We've been taught that throughout your life, that that's how the world works, that salvation is for the strong. It's for those who are put together. It's for those who are the winners. But Mary's song says, that's all backwards. If you go back to verse 51, being proud, the proud who are scattered, it's not just those who are arrogant, it's anybody who thinks that they can do it on their own. When it says the mighty rulers are the ones who are disenfroned, That's not just talking about political rulers.
10:11 It's anybody who thinks that they are on the throne of their lives. What Mary keeps on doing here is she keeps on showing us that this is how God works. And Mary gets it too. You know, it would be very easy for her to say, hey, listen, I'm the poor. I'm the uneducated. I'm this preteen to teenage girl that nobody wanted. And she could be very like, oh, woe is me. or like I feel like I'm centered on that because that's who I am. But look what she does. She says what? My soul glorifies God and my spirit rejoices. Why? Because God is my savior. Have you ever asked this question? Why does Mary need a savior? And don't sleep on this. Even in her lowly state, she knew at some level she too needed a savior. She knew her need.
11:05 And she sings the praises to God because this is actually the categorical key, which is this, that the only thing that you need is to know your need. I'll say that again. The Christian life is the only thing that you need. The only qualification that you need is to know that you need. It doesn't matter your pedigree. It doesn't matter if you're an insider. It doesn't matter if you're an outsider. It doesn't matter your own self-identity. what this is saying is it doesn't matter that God will fill you. If you come empty, he will meet you. But if you come full, you're going to walk away empty. Go through every single one of the verbs here in our text. Let's just walk through them quickly. In verse 49, he says, it says he has done mighty things. It says he has been mindful.
11:59 He has performed. He has brought. He has filled. He has helped. Do you see the pattern? It's all past tense. It's all what God has done. That it's already happened in the past. It's over. You don't earn God, folks. You don't go to him. He comes to you. And that's what Mary is in wonder about.
12:22 She goes, even to me. She's realizing, she's singing, because she says, oh, it was always upside down. It wasn't right side up. It was always upside down. And that God was always a God of grace. He was always a God of wonder. He was always a God of mercy. And so the only question left is really this, is that will you receive that? Will you let yourself have that? Or are you too full? Do you have your picnic basket full of champagne and bonbons and you're like, no, don't need it. I got enough. I'm good. That's the only way you're going to not come Because if you don't know your need
13:34 All right, so last point. Right? He reverses our values. It shows you how it's actually upside down, but he actually reverses our verdict as well. He doesn't just bring down the high, which he says here. It's actually how he lifts up the low. That's actually the stunning part. Look at verse 54. It says that he has helped his servant Israel remembering to be merciful. Now, a lot of us don't know what that's a reference to. But the commentaries will tell you that this is actually a reference to Hosea 11 verse 1. Where Israel is referred to in this Old Testament prophecy as the servant Israel, as the son. That God has a son and the son is Israel.
14:28 And basically it's referring to this, that when Israel went down to Egypt. This is Exodus, right? God brings his son out of Egypt. He's given the Ten Commandments and says, if you obey, you will live. And what did they do? They didn't obey. It's the exact same thing that happened to Adam and Eve. God says, hey, I formed you, I made you.
14:51 Obey and live. And you know what happens? They don't obey. And we don't either. We're all given the same choice every single day in our lives, no matter what you believe, and we choose ourselves. We say, you know what? I'm the master and commander of my own life. I know better than God how to run and rule my life. and the entire human race has done that. And you know what happens? Just look out, just turn on the news. Open up your phone. A bunch of people living for themselves, whether it's nations or individuals, and you have strife, you have hurt, you have a dog-eat-dog world. You have the right-side-up, so to speak, kingdom.
15:32 And yet what you see here, when she's referencing this, what she's saying is this is where hope is so you say where's the hope the hope is is that is it possible that maybe Christmas is the most stunning part of the upside-down movement. When the God of the universe, the king who should have it all, is born in a manger. Because here it is. Jesus, if you go to Luke, if you keep on reading Luke, he actually went down to Egypt.
16:06 Then he came back out. And you know what? Unlike Israel, unlike Adam and Eve, he actually did obey. He loves God with all his heart, soul, and mind, and he loves his neighbor as himself. and he does it perfectly and completely and yet he's the only one therefore that actually earned the blessing of God through his obedience and yet at the end of his life he didn't get it. Why not? Because there was a trade. There was a transfer. We didn't obey and we deserve the curse but Jesus got the curse so that in him we can get the blessing that he deserved. Christmas shows salvation doesn't start on the cross. I think a lot of folks go to the cross and they go, oh, see, look, God saved me. No, actually, it starts here. British pastor John Stott puts it best. He says this, the essence of sin is man putting himself in the place of God. And the essence of salvation is God putting himself in the place of man.
17:05 I've got to say that again. If you want to kind of get a good summary of what Christianity is fully about, the essence of sin is man putting himself in the place that only God deserves to be. as the master and commander of your life. And yet the essence of salvation is God putting himself in the place that we deserve. Folks, until you see that you're empty and that you failed and you're lost and yet you're still loved, you're not gonna understand what love really is. Why? Because love in response to goodness, if you're like, hey, I do these things and you get, if you get love in response to goodness, that's a reward. You will only feel love when you realize that it's undeserved. Real love is undeserved. and yet that's what we find here. That's when Mary starts singing. Look at verse 49.
17:57 She says, it's mesmerizing. She says, for the mighty ones done great things. You know where the mighty one is at the moment she says this? Not in the palace. The mighty one is in her as a baby. The reason why God can bring up people is because he's the one who came down.
18:19 He came down. And he didn't just die the death that you should die. He lived the life that you should live. That phrase is thrown around, Redeemer, without people really thinking through it all. What that means is that you don't just need forgiveness. for what you've done wrong. We need goodness for what we never did right. See, if God just took away your sins on the cross, guess what happens? You go to net zero. You get a clean slate, but now it's still up to you to try harder and be good. That's why some traditions actually do these things called last frights, because you have to get forgiven at the very end, because if you don't, it's up to you to kind of live a good life. but actually, if Jesus actually also lived the life that you should live, and you receive that, now you have his record. That way you can accept both his life and his death.
19:12 If you actually do that, and say, no, no, no, I actually need Jesus to live the life that I should live, and I need him to die the death that I should die, when you receive that, guess what? That's when everything changes in your life. I'll give you one example. How you read the Bible. People have been reading the Bible for centuries. And there's only really two ways to read it. One is this. It's essentially about me. I see people do this all the time. They open the Bible and they look through it and they open it up and they say, okay, what's the Bible going to say to me today? And the way we read that is, okay, what's the law? What do I need to do? How do I earn? How do I get God to see that I'm a good person?
19:50 That's how the world works. That's what we do. What must I do to be saved? or is the Bible essentially about him? What if we started reading the Bible essentially that he actually was the perfect son to be the perfect savior? That means when you do the 10 commandments, you don't do it to be saved. You do it because you already are. when Mary sings in verse 55 here about Abraham and all the descendants forever, what's she referencing? She's referencing the entire Old Testament. And she summarizes it and saying, actually, she puts at the very end, actually, all the things that we were hoping for in Abraham, in David, and all the promises and all the covenantal promises, they're fulfilled in the person of Jesus. Jesus is the true prophet. The prophet tells you like, hey, make way, here's God.
20:46 Thus saith the Lord, Jesus is the perfect prophet. Jesus is the perfect priest. He doesn't just make sacrifices on behalf of us. He is the sacrifice for us. Jesus is the perfect king. You know what kings do? All kings of the world say, serve me, love me. The real king, the best king, is the one who doesn't come to be served, but the one who serves. not by taking power but by giving it away the Bible isn't ultimately about you friends it's all about him do not open the Bible and start saying okay how do I be like David how do I be like Abraham how do I be like Moses you'll never be able to do that unless you first see that there was a greater David for you. looking around at the world if you go to nature if you say, well, let me just live in light of how the world works, How does nature work?
21:42 Strong eat the weak. That's what it says. It's not just out in nature. It's not just, you know, in the wilderness. It's actually how New York works. Which actually begs the question, if that's how the world works, why don't we want movies where the strong eat the weak? Right? If that's the way the world works. Why is it that we have like a soft spot for those movies where the hero dies on behalf of others? It always elicits that cry, right? When Gandalf sacrifices himself, Dumbledore, Dobby, Jon Snow, he comes back to life. But he died. Trish Pryor, the Iron Giant, Spock, Mufasa. I mean, I can keep going. But every single one of those are pictures. they're happy endings, which actually isn't how the world works.
22:40 The world works as death is the end, period. And yet we love this idea that actually death doesn't have the last say. What if the happy endings in all the stories are not fiction but actually real? What if they actually pointed past, that there is actually a rainbow after the storm, that there is light after darkness, that there's a tidal wave of joy that every Christian can actually access in every happy ending movie ever because at the end of the day, we don't have to say, yeah, that's just make-believe. We can say, no, actually, at the end of the day, that's really true.
23:15 That that will actually come. That there will be a happy ending. That the world will be redeemed. That all stories point to this true story. That Jesus actually lived and died for us. Friends, if that's true, guess what? Then your story has hope too. I was up here on stage just today and I heard the trumpet my father used to play the trumpet I normally would just you know it just fills me with grief but if this story is true then I will hear my father play that trumpet again. whatever story that you're in whatever hurt and heartache it doesn't have the last say there's hope for your story too so the question is will you receive it will you receive the story remember if the nature of sin isn't just doing bad things it's placing ourselves in the only place God should be and the nature of salvation is God put himself in the only place where you should be taking what we deserve and Mary was the first one to sing this song but she doesn't have to be the last you could sing it too if you let it grip you.
24:28 And when it does, your mind doesn't disagree. Your soul magnifies. Your spirit rejoices. This word glorifies, my soul glorifies in verse 46. It's the Greek word for magnify. When was the last time you let yourself be moved like Mary? When was the last time you didn't just sing along with the song because that's what the words say, but actually you meant the words?
24:52 In a few moments, you're going to have an opportunity to try again. we're going to sing again But before we do, I want to give you three practical ways where you can turn mere believing into singing really quick number one come hungry Verse 53 says that he fills the hungry with good things. but the question is are you coming to God hungry or not or are you coming full a hungry person says I need grace I need this I can't live without it a full person says I'm good I have to be here I was dragged along but I'm alright if you come full you're going to leave empty but if you come empty you'll be full number two magnify God not your problems look at verse 46 remember I said my soul glorifies that's actually the word magnify the ESV translates it that way but it's the magnification that matters my kids they love to steal my phone and do the .5 and put it over my head and so they magnify my nose and it makes it bigger than it really is, which is already large enough, but it fills the whole screen.
25:59 Because what magnification does, what Mary is saying is, I'm going to fill my life with the Lord. I'm going to let him be magnified. What are you magnifying this morning? Are you magnifying your careers? Guess what will happen? You do that, you'll feel great when those quarterly reports are looking good. You'll feel terrible when the deals are done. Are you magnifying a relationship or lack thereof? You go up and down in how you're feeling at any moment. Are you magnifying power, approval, comfort, control? Mary says, no, magnify the Lord. What's crazy about, if you think about it, if magnification just makes things bigger, if God's infinite, you actually can't magnify the Lord any bigger than he already is. What you do when you magnify the Lord is that you're actually letting them be what he already is, which is everywhere.
26:55 But if you do that, guess what will happen? It will put all your problems in their proper place. It won't stop your problems, but it'll truncate them. It'll limit them. What lens are you using, friends, today? What are you doing? Adjust your vision to see him, and then your problems will shrink to their proper size. Okay, last point, wonder. Remember the trade? Mary has wonder at the grace that God gives her. Because she's full of joy and astonishment. Why? The Bible says this, that one of the marks of being a Christian is that there's always a note of surprise in your life. If you walk around going, yeah, I'm a Christian. I was born a Christian. I guess I am.
27:39 Actually, I don't know if you are. Because the mark of a real Christian is one who goes and understands and says, wait, he took my place for me? Wait, the God of the universe? What wonder? What splendor? What awe? That's what this is saying here, is that he took your place so that you could have his. If you find God, guess what? There is no surprise or wonder. But if you realize that he found you, me? Little old me? You have that posture. You'll have awe. You'll have wonder. See the wonder here. get the grace. I never would have found him, but he found me. See the trade, be in wonder. That's the invitation of Christmas. Come hungry, magnify the Lord, and sit in wonder.
28:33 Let's pray. Heavenly Father, thank you for, thank you for this invitation. I know this room is full of people who, are on all level the spectrum of belief. And I'm thankful that they're willing just to be challenged and to think. I pray you move in our hearts in all different ways. I pray that you'll see, help us all see that we don't know our need.
28:58 That if we identify as a Christian, it's because we've let this become rote. We've lost the wonder. And if we're not, if we don't know if we need it, I pray that you show us our need. Help us to sit in joy like Mary.
29:19 Thank you for being mindful of the humble state of your servant. I pray that we would just be in wonder and awe. She goes on and does great things, but all she wants to talk about is what you've done. Help us to be the same. Help us to see that it is you. It has always been you. you lived the life we should have lived and you died the death that we should have died. let that move us today and if it does it would move us out in the world in profound ways it would change us but it also change the world through us as we love and serve others we pray these things in your name
Machine translated from the source