Joyful Mission

Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached October 26, 2025

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Luke 18:9-14 0:28
9To some who trusted in their own righteousness and viewed others with contempt, He also told this parable: 10“Two men went up to the temple to pray. One was a Pharisee and the other a tax collector. 11The Pharisee stood by himself and prayed, ‘God, I thank You that I am not like other men—swindlers, evildoers, adulterers—or even like this tax collector. 12I fast twice a week and pay tithes of all that I acquire.’ 13But the tax collector stood at a distance, unwilling even to lift up his eyes to heaven. Instead, he beat his breast and said, ‘God, have mercy on me, a sinner!’ 14I tell you, this man, rather than the Pharisee, went home justified. For everyone who exalts himself will be humbled, but the one who humbles himself will be exalted.”

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

1:21 Good morning and welcome again to Redeemer Lincoln Square. We've been going through a series this fall, looking at our refreshed vision. What does it mean to be rooted in God's love for the joy of the city? And last week we talked about how one of our biggest cultural problems, the things that we're working through, that we're struggling with, It's that we don't just fragment, we don't just divide out politically, we do it ideologically. Today I want to call that othering. Othering is the way that we differentiate, we want to create difference between each other. To say I'm in and they're out. To say I win and they lose.

2:07 And we're so good at this. We're so good at othering, we even other the otherers. If you're sitting here going, yeah, this is great. I hate those people who always other other people. I can't stand them. Guess what you just did? You othered. This is deep-rooted. This is part of who we are. In 2020, 40% of Trump-Biden supporters, sorry, in 2020, 40% of Trump-Biden supporters said they actually had exactly zero friends that actually supported the other candidate. Zero. And four years before that, the number was actually three times less in the previous cycle. And so what we're seeing as they've been keeping these statistics is this is actually an intensifying, this is an increasing phenomenon.

3:03 This is accelerating. Where we no longer believe the other side is just mistaken. We believe they're immoral. We believe that they're evil. And it's part of, a lot of sociologists, they don't know the precise number, but we know it's at least part of the reason why our relationships are thin, why we're scared to get further into them. And it's contributing to this deep sense of instability that we all feel culturally. And so no matter where you are on the spectrum of belief or not belief, everybody's trying to solve, how are we going to not, you know, be perpetually mad at each other? What will actually lead us to stay together? What will allow us to actually live together? We all need this. And Jesus, in the midst of this, he tells this story because this exact problem that we're all having, he illustrates it here. And the answer he gives us, the answer out of othering is radical. So let's look at three things today. Why do we other? The truth that levels, and then the mercy that frees. I'll say it again. Why do we, you know, why do we other people? The truth that levels, and then the mercy that frees. So first, why do we other? Look at our first verse in our text, verse 9. It says, he tells us like who the audience is. He goes, to some who were confident of their own righteousness and look down on everyone else.

4:36 Jesus told this parable. That's the audience. This is for anybody who's ever felt that kind of like secret satisfaction. of being better than others, which by the way is everyone. The word righteousness, I know it's not a word that we use in English much. Maybe if you were a surfer, you'd be like righteous or something like that. But if you're a surfer and I completely just othered you, I did. But that word righteousness, it's not a word we use a lot, but in the Bible it's a loaded word. It means to have approval and acceptance and validation. Right standing. It means to measure up. And so when you are confident in your own righteousness, what's happening in that moment is that you end up looking down at everyone else. I'm up and you're down.

5:34 It's a posture thing. It's that little head tilt in relation to others. The twist of our story in our text is that the audience would have expected that the Pharisee was the hero. I think a lot, you know, today because of Christianity, we are like, oh, Pharisee, they're the bad ones, right? But culturally, they were the good citizens. They were the ones who actually read their Bibles and took their Bibles seriously. They were the ones who cared for others. They were the ones who actually were scholars and serious about their faith. So the fact that Jesus makes him the villain is shocking. Look at the prayer that's in our text here. The prayer goes like this. God, I thank you that I am not like other people. Right?

6:26 God, I thank you that I am not like other people. Robbers, evildoers, adulterers, or even like this tax collector. This is all verse 11. Now, if you read this prayer over and over and over again, you start seeing a pattern here. That God is actually the subject, you know how many times? Once. You know how many times that he's the subject? Look, read it. I thank you that I am not like. I fast. I give.

6:57 Five times in the Greek, the personal pronoun I shows up. Five times. In two sentences. 60% of this prayer, somebody did the percentage, is his resume. 40% is his comparison. All of it is about othering. Because you know what a resume is, right? Here's how I'm different. Here's what makes me special. Here's how I am compared to everybody else. And I think what Jesus is trying to show us here is he's trying to show us that the real problem isn't the things that he's on the surface, the good things. It's beneath the surface.

7:39 It looks like, hey, he's praying to God, but actually he's not God-centered, he's me-centered. In other words, the real trouble here is that you can look spotless on the outside. The world can actually look at you and think that you are a good person, that you're generous, that you're kind-hearted. But on the inside, you're running away from God like everybody else.

8:00 In fact, the better you look on the outside, the harder it might be actually to see the problems that you might have on the inside. The best illustration I have of this is one that I'm reminded of about myself almost every week. I ride my bike everywhere. My bike's parked outside. and I often will ride in the green lane where I'm supposed to. And I'm riding that green lane, you know, up and down the avenues. And once a week, maybe even more than that, some driver tries to turn left. They don't look, and I have to slam all my brakes. or else I'm going to plow into that car. And so I do what every New Yorker should do, is I express my unhappiness. And I say something along the lines of, Hey, I'm riding my bike here. What are you doing? And every single time it feels like, within five minutes of that moment, I'm going through a pedestrian walkway.

8:56 Maybe I get a little too close to somebody walking by. You know what they say to me? Hey, I'm walking here. The exact same thing that I just did to the driver. And what's interesting in my heart, here's the thing, I feel justified against that driver when the pedestrian says that to me. I'm like, well, they just don't understand. I wasn't going to hurt them. I was nowhere near them. Come on. I was at least six inches away.

9:21 But see, what is that? What's going on there? That's the definition of othering. Literally, I'm doing it because I'm differentiating myself from the driver, and then they're doing it to me, and everybody's doing it to everybody else, all thinking that we're in the right, and they're not. We do this all the time. Some of us go like this. We say, listen, I'm not the smartest, but at least I'm not shallow like them. I might not be as successful as them, but at least I'm fun. I might not be the most spiritual, but I'm not judgmental like those other people.

10:02 You see, we look down on people and we don't even know that we're doing it. A lot of it is this running commentary that's going on in our heads. And so what this parable is showing us is often the way we get our identities, the way that we walk around this world, is that we basically have to make difference. We compare and contrast.

10:28 It might be a resume. It might be a moment. It might be a thought. But that's what we're doing. And so my question to you, I just gave you, I showed you mine, at least when I'm riding my bike. What's yours? What are the ways that you do this? What category do you use to measure yourself up with? You know what's interesting when I talk to people? Usually we know the categories we're not good at. So we don't even try to, you know, win on that area. But we always find a category that we are good at. And you know what? Surprise, surprise. That's the one we actually base our identity on because we feel like we're going to do pretty good, at least to some people. And so what Jesus does is he comes here and he shows us the bad people in the Bible tend to get closer to who God is. Not because they're better, but because they already know that they're not.

11:22 That's what's so interesting here. That the people in the Bible, the prostitutes, the tax collectors, that know that they're immoral. therefore they know that they need. And so what Jesus is trying to say to us very carefully is, your biggest problem, the biggest problem in the world is actually not you being immoral. It's how your morals often mask your need.

11:52 And so what this parable is saying is that you aren't in based on your good works. In fact, often your good works are the very thing that are keeping you out. because we get verification and validation by pointing out how they're out and therefore I'm in. And I believe, folks, you want to say, okay, why do we other? This is the foundation of it. It's why we're fragmenting. It's why we're lonely. It's why we other. And so the question is, do you see this? Do you see your hand in it? Do you see how we compare and contrast, like this Pharisee, for our identity? All right, that's the first thing we see. Okay, fine. Number two. Then what's the truth that levels? If that's what's going on, what stops that process? Well, look at the tax collector. Verse 13 here. It says here, the tax collector stood at a distance. He would not even look up at heaven, but beat his breast and say, God, have mercy on me, a sinner.

12:52 Now, it's hard to convey to modern people how negative tax collectors were considered in this period. Tax collectors worked for the Romans. They were given basically a set amount that they needed to raise from a certain region. And then their job was to raise that amount, those taxes from that people group, literally shaking people down, bringing a bunch of folks to rough people up.

13:24 And often, and not often, they always raised more money than they really needed to, and they would pocket that. And so the people knew that this was the definition of a professional cheat. They were universally hated. And so the Pharisee was supposed to be the hero. This man was supposed to be the villain. And yet something's happening to him. It says that he stood at a distance.

13:47 And again, we're comparing and contrasting with the Pharisee. They're standing at a distance because I don't want to soil myself with that person. And they're standing at a distance because I'm unworthy. He feels like he can't even approach. He couldn't lift his head. Why? Because of the gravity of the shame that was too heavy.

14:08 He wasn't posturing. He was broken. And so here's what's going on here. Jesus is showing us the first two steps out of othering in this parable, in this tax collector. Step one is this. Your comparison grid has to change. The man prays. When he prays, he says, God, have mercy on me, a sinner. That's the indefinite article. By the way, I'm terrible at grammar. I learned whole language, by the way, back in the 80s. For those of you who are educators, which means I never learned grammar. I never learned phonics. I never learned, anyway, so that's my excuse for all my problems with spelling. But I learned later that the indefinite article is a, the definite article is the, and actually in Greek, it's the definite article here.

15:01 So you go, why did the translators not translate it that way? Well, I think it would have been kind of strange, they think, to say, have mercy on me, the sinner. But that's exactly the point. That the Pharisee is clearly comparing. But when this man says, have mercy on me, the sinner, the very thing he's doing is he's not comparing.

15:24 And so what this guy is doing is he goes, hey, I actually don't know about that guy or her or him or them. But I know about me. And I know that I'm the problem. I'm the only one I'm going to talk about because I'm the only one I deeply know the most about. And so if you want to know how to end othering, don't just look at what you do out in the world that affects other people. You need to look at all the reasons that you might do things right to build your sense of worth through comparison.

15:57 And I said this before, I've got to say it again because I think it's so ingrained in us. We think sin is just doing bad things. But biblically, sin isn't just bad things. It's going to be anything that we do to be our own Lord. That's what we see in the Bible. It's the centering on self when we're saying, me, myself, and I is what matters, not God, to get our validation. And you say, okay, what does that look like? Well, some people get their identity, not just by being a good parent for our children. I'm a good parent because that's where I get my sense of worth. maybe you have a deep passion for justice and you want to see that coming to the world. But there's a good in and of itself for justice, but maybe you get your identity from being the one who's in the know. And I'm in and those people don't know. They're out.

16:49 Or maybe you're a cultured New Yorker. Maybe you love the arts in this room. And the arts are beautiful. They're wonderful. There's nothing wrong with appreciating culture, but there's also a part of you that likes to be known as the one who's learned, who sees things, who's smart. You see, in each one of those things, what's happening there is we're actually taking good things and we're making them ultimate things. That's why they're so sneaky. Because nobody's going to say, hey, how dare you care about the arts and how dare you care about your children. That's not the problem. It's what you do with those things to have an identity apart from God.

18:01 And so the first step out of othering is to stop comparing. To say to God alone, I'm the problem. Christoph Waltz, years ago, won an Oscar for his role in this movie called Inglourious Bastards, where he plays this terrible Nazi. and he was interviewed on a talk show where the talk show host was saying, how did you come up with this evil, cruel person? He was funny, he was charismatic, but he was also so chillingly devious and brilliant. How did you pull that off?

18:43 And Christoph Waltz in the interview just looked at him like he had no idea what he was asking. And so the host said, well, no, no, seriously, how did you make this character so relaxed and funny? How could you play that evil so effectively? And Waltz said, he said it was really, it's actually pretty simple. The character didn't think he was evil.

19:10 The character thought he was actually good. He thought he was doing the right thing. And I think there was this moment when you kind of, in the interview, you realize, wait a second, that's actually the secret to devianess and evil is that most people who are evil don't think that they are. Very few people walk around going, I know who I am when it comes to evilness. It's the same thing with people across the political spectrum is that everybody thinks the other side is evil, but when you go to talk to those people, they think they're on the good side. And so the truth is, is that if this is how the world works, the first step out is to stop comparing. Stop looking, trying to point the finger and do things. The first step is to change your comparison or grid away from looking at others and just looking at what you've done. It's being curious about what you see on the inside.

20:09 Starting with yourself. Starting with what you're doing, what you've done. In other words, self-awareness is the first step of this change out of othering. That's the first step. Now, the second step is you also have to get a different sense of validation. Look back at the text again. When he says, have mercy on me, a sinner, that word mercy, again, there's a common word for mercy. And then the word that's used here. It's actually a word that is more often used about atonement. And it's the word helasterion, which means to make atonement, to pay for sin. And I think what the writer is trying to get at here is Luke's trying to show us that he's in the temple. His mind was thinking about in that temple, once a year, the high priest would make atonement for the people for all their sins. And so this is really important.

21:03 When he says have mercy, the word mercy sometimes we think it means I get out of jail free card. Hey, just let me out from, you know, what I deserve. His definition of mercy is not, hey, overlook my sins. He's saying I know somebody has to pay for it. I need atonement. I need someone else. I need something else to take my place. and notice what he's not doing. He's not trying to use his resume like the Pharisee. He's not trying to say, get out of jail free card. The source for him, the ability for him to have a different sense of validation is that he changed his source away from his circumstances, his abilities, his resume, nothing that he offers. He just says, I need something or someone else to actually get mercy, to have mercy. That's the second step.

21:59 If the first step is to stop comparing, the second step is to get a different sense of validation. Everybody in this room, if you want to stop othering, if we want to actually stop the fracturing and brokenness of the world, you have to get a different paradigm of how we actually get our sense of self. And that's the question we have to ask. Have we stopped comparing? And have we, do we ask for mercy?

22:23 You know, a lot of people would end a sermon like this. Go and do. All right. Rah, rah, rah. And if I did that, if I did that for myself, I'd be pretty distraught. Because how can we really do that? Last point. The mercy that frees. If we stopped here, you'll either say, man, I'm pretty messed up. I am the sinner. And you'll stay in a state of shame and sadness. Or what you'll do is you'll start comparing yourself and going, well, at least I understand. At least I know that I am the sinner. And you'll weirdly weaponize that and start using that against other people. I do. Why can't you? And then guess what? We're right back to where we started.

23:11 The hope that we have, go back to our text, the only hope I see is in the surprising last verse. when Jesus says in verse 14, I tell you that this man, rather than the other, went home justified. And this is so important because that word justify, again, not a word we use a lot of. It means biblically, it means to be accepted, validated, approved legally. And so Jesus is actually saying, the tax collectors is approved by God, which should force you to say, wait a second, wait a second. What's the difference? What's happening here is Jesus has taken away the good and bad deeds. And if you do that, you know what the only difference is between these two men?

23:56 One person, the tax collector, comes and asks for help. The other one doesn't. See, the tax collector and the Pharisee, one's not better than the other. The only difference is that one asks for mercy and the other doesn't. That's it. That's the only differentiation. And here's how you can apply this. You can apply this to yourself because you know where that word, that word, helastrion, it only shows up one other place in the whole New Testament. It's in Hebrews chapter 2, verse 17. And it applies to Jesus and what he does. What happens on the cross is Jesus becomes that atonement that this tax collector needed. See, the tax collector had a very vague sense. He knew something someone had to actually pay. Jesus in Hebrews 2 verse 17 is the one who absorbs our othering. The Pharisee that's inside all of us, including me, that whispers, at least I'm better than, at least I have this, at least I have that. Jesus took that on the cross. The tax collector's shame that's whispering in his ears saying, you're never going to be good enough.

25:11 You're never going to be accepted. You're never going to be loved. By the way, that's in all of us. Jesus took that too. If you ask for mercy, you get mercy. That's what this text is saying. Not because you're good enough. Not because of your resume. But because Jesus is enough. and then you say, okay, then how does it actually help end othering? I'll tell you how. If you understood that, if you deeply let that resonate in the bowels of who you are, you would be able to hold two truths that often pull themselves apart at the same time, and that's this. You're a sinner but loved. you're out on your own, but actually you're in.

25:56 See, a sinner, if you deeply understood that, then that means you're actually the same as everyone else. Because everybody is. I find it so interesting. The modern world hates the idea that Christians say everybody is a sinner. We say, oh man, that's so self-flaguating. I find it endlessly hopeful. because if everybody's out, then everybody is in, we can't differentiate. There's endless hope. There's endless ability for us to actually be honest and not pretend. There's endless hope that now, because when we deeply understand that, it destroys our comparison models. When we see that I am the sinner, we are, we can't elevate ourselves above anyone else. and yet, and yet, and yet loved.

26:46 Deeply, profoundly, perfectly loved. And when you hold those together, you're no longer going to say, I'm in, but you're out. Here's what you're going to say. Everybody's out. How amazing is that Jesus lets any of us in. That's a completely different way to live. But that's what we get. Because when you're justified, you no longer have to self-justify. Think about this, folks. How many times in your day do you spend basically saying, I'm someone because of my career, because of my relationships, because of my family, because of my money, because of my online persona, because, because, because, because. How many times do we spend ourselves exhausting ourselves to feel like I have that? Not to say that those things aren't important, but you don't need them to actually be accepted.

27:43 Those are all works of self-justification unless you can rest in his love. And the more you do that, here's what happens. Here's the cycle. The more that you can admit that you're out, the more that you see that you're out, the more you actually rest that you're actually in his love. The more that you rest that you're in his love, the more you can admit that actually you're out. And there's this beautiful cycle of honesty leads to further love and acceptance of his grace. The more you can understand his grace and love, the more you can be honest over and over and over again.

28:20 You and I, I don't know about you, but at least for me, I know I tend to oscillate between denying I ever do anything wrong. Or if I actually can finally see myself in the mirror, I'm a puddle on the floor. because all I feel like is I just have the shame and the guilt of all I have done wrong. But what's beautiful about being a sinner but loved is it holds you together.

28:44 And if you have this, guess what? You'll never get too high because no success will make you so prideful, so differentiating and othering because deep down you still know your need. and yet you'll never get so low because you know that nothing can keep you away from the love of of God the Father. I want this for you, but I also think you need this because this is the only way I know of that gets us out of othering. If you go to Luke chapter 23, later on, Jesus is on a cross. And there are two other criminals that are actually on the cross next to him. And one of the criminals, the thief, says, hey, get us off. Which everybody knows, he wasn't really caring about Jesus or the other thief, he was caring about himself. The other thief goes, no, we're here rightly Jesus isn't we're getting the death that we deserve Jesus isn't and so he says remember me which by the way is another way of saying have mercy on me he's saying remember me when you come into the kingdom when the first thief says get me off from me and the second thief says I don't need to I'm getting what I deserve remember me those are two utterly different ways to live And you know what Jesus says to that second thief?

30:04 he says today you'll be with me in paradise and I love the object lesson I do for myself I try to imagine when he's in heaven imagine people going to him hey, how many Bible studies did you do to get here? he's going to say what's a bible study he'll say well okay how many people did you serve in the name of Jesus? what does that look like okay Okay, but at least you pray. You know how to pray, right? I never did that in my life. Well, then how the heck did you get here? He goes, that man on the cross said I could be here with him.

30:41 That is a beautiful thing to remember. It's not what you do. It's not what you bring. It's who he is and what he's done. But when you live that and own that and have that in you, you will want to pray to the one who accepted you. You will read about the one who, because you don't want to read about the one who saved you.

31:02 That's how this changes us. It's the ground of our hope. It's not our Bible knowledge. It's not our service. It's not the strength of our faith. It's only what he did. And if you want to experience that joy of being a sinner but loved, focus not on what you do for him, but on what he has done for you. Rest in the finished work of the cross. And if you do, when we do, we'll see all the kindness and love that he gives us. And we'll be able to move out in the world with all the kindness and love. That's how we can go out of mission, right? Our mission is to be rooted in God's love for the joy of the city. That's our vision. You'll be able to do that to the degree that you understand this. You'll be able to be patient with that family member. Take care of others. To be generous to them. even when they're terrible to you. Why?

31:53 Because when we see how we're accepted by sheer mercy, when you've been brought in with nothing but our need, you can accept those when they have nothing but their need, even when they can't see their need. And so when someone's struggling with addiction, folks, we see people, I walk by them every day. Instead of saying, how could you? You'll be able to say, I might not struggle with that addiction, but I know what it's like to struggle with addiction. I've been enslaved to sin myself. Do you see how the differentiation goes away?

32:29 Othering will end in this city, not through political alignment, not through a bunch of all of a sudden material success. It's going to happen through a community of people who no longer have to because we've been brought in. and that sends us out. And so the last thing I want to ask you is this. I'm going to ask you just two questions to close. one have you ever asked for this mercy not vaguely not theoretically not conceptually but have you personally been able to say to yourself, like the tax collector Lord have mercy on me I'm the sinner I have nothing but my need because if you haven't you can you can do it right now it's the shortest simplest prayer It's so fast, and we actually already know what the answer will be. you'll walk away justified. Not because you're all of a sudden better. In fact, I'm sure this man didn't walk away all of a sudden feeling like elated. But you can still walk away in the promises of what he's done for us.

33:28 The second question is this. Maybe you have actually prayed this. Maybe you have actually said this before. But then are you living it? Are you living justified lives? Do you walk out experiencing the freedom that actually you have offered to you? Or are you still living like this Pharisee, exhausted and othering to feel better about yourself through comparison? Remember, remember you're in, not because of you, but because of him. That's the mercy that frees. That's the truth that levels. And that's the only way I know how othering ends.

34:03 Let's accept this together. Let's pray. Heavenly Father, thank you for this powerful parable that is so hard for us to understand because it's so ingrained in us to differentiate, to compare and contrast. Father, you're not asking us to check our brains at the door.

34:26 We're able to make assessments. It's when we make them for our own validation. That's where the world breaks, and it starts with us. help us to do deep, not be afraid to do a deep dive into where we've done it not to be afraid of what we might see if we look inside because we already know what the answer will be when we admit it let us be able to be honest because of your grace and then out of your grace be able to be honest. move in our hearts in profound ways we pray these things in your name

Machine translated from the source