Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached February 8, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
3:00 When someone wrongs you, when somebody really, really wrongs you, maybe that person did so years ago. Maybe it was yesterday. Whatever it was, when that hurt has happened to you, it doesn't just go away. It doesn't just disappear magically. It changes you. You wait around hoping that that apology will come and it might never come. But here's something that we don't ever think about. And I was doing this a couple of weeks ago. How often do we realize, how often do we think that that feeling that we feel, being deeply wronged by somebody else, making it, it's very vivid in our minds, how often do we realize that there is someone else out there thinking the same thing about us? That there is someone out there thinking about you where the hurt is so vivid to them, they've been wronged and they're waiting for your apology that might never come.
4:05 We are all very much so in the same boat. We are all victims and perpetrators. Now, I know it's not always in the same amount, some more than others, but everybody is both hurt and herters. Everybody is a victim and victimizer. We've all done that. And therefore, we're all sitting around saying, hey, I need justice from others, but we also need mercy from others as well and for ourselves. We've been going through a series on the life of David, and here he's not king yet. He's on the run. He's hiding out in caves. He's going to be the future king, but right now he's being hunted like a dog by the current king, Saul.
4:55 And even though he's in caves and he's running in and out, we actually know what that feels like. You're not in a physical cave, but you've been in career caves where you are working and working and no one recognizes you for what you're doing. You've been in relational, hard relational caves. You've been in caves of betrayal where that person does that thing and you just keep replaying over and over and over again in your mind where you're like, why did it end up this way? And you can't get out of it. It keeps you up at night. It's like on repeat, over and over and over again. And so we ask in the night, this is what we ask. We say, God, if you're so much for me, why are you letting this happen? Or why did you let it happen? And how do I get myself out of it? We keep asking ourselves, we say, okay, and then how am I going to handle the people who did this to me?
5:51 I actually think this is our cultural moment right now. We're living in a world where we deeply, deeply want justice. We just talked about folks that are doing justice in our midst, in our city. It's freezing cold outside. There's so many needs. But we want justice because we feel like there's a lot of wrongs happening. And we want it now. We want the bad men to pay now. and yet at the same time, we don't know how to get it. And everybody, by the way, feels like everyone is wronging each other. Everyone feels wronged by everyone else and so we're in this world where we want justice but we have a problem. New York Times writer Elizabeth Bruggen says this. She says, there's just something unsustainable about an environment that demands atonement but actively disdains the very idea of forgiveness.
6:53 Her point is this, is that we actually know how to cancel. We're really, really, really bad at restoring. We know how to end relationships. We don't know how to redeem them or fix them or reconcile them. And here's where our cultural moment is. We feel like if we forgive, we're letting that person off the hook. So I can't forgive. But if I don't forgive, then that bitterness, that rage just stays inside of me and we end up being perpetually mad at everyone else. And so we feel stuck. This is where we are culturally. And what's the way forward? And I actually think this passage where David is here... can help us. Let's look at three things. The test in the cave, the refusal of the spear, and the cost of the cure. The test in the cave, the refusal of the spear and the cost of the cure. So first the test in the cave. Look in our text here.
7:46 Verse 2, David is in a cave and he's here and there are 3,000 men out there hunting him. He's in a region that's very desolate. It's barren. It's a terrible place to try to live but he's there because he's trying to hide out because in that area there are caves everywhere. And Saul has 3,000 men that are looking for him. And he's with like a couple of hundred. So the ratios are not good. His back is up against the wall. They're closing on him. And then something amazing happens. Look at verse three. It says that fortuitously, Saul went in to relieve himself into the very cave David was actually in. Which is almost like a comical scene. You would think that they would have checked that cave, but clearly they didn't. and so they're in this moment where Saul walks into the very cave David is in.
8:40 he's in the most vulnerable place that he could be in and this is his moment look at verse 4 David's men says basically, this is the day that the Lord has made. this is it this is our chance this is our moment that with one thrust of your sword no more running no more cave hiding no more sleepless night It's bad guy dead. Good guys win. We go home. Everything's good. And look how it's really fascinating. The way they say it, they spiritualize it in verse 4. This is the day the Lord spoke of when he said this to you. Small problem. That actually didn't actually happen. What God spoke was that David was going to be king. What they did was they twisted. That means you kind of have to kill him over here.
9:31 Which isn't necessarily what actually God said. He said, God said, you will be king, not necessarily how you will become king. And they did this, therefore, to twist it to justify killing Saul. And before we start judging them too harshly, I just want to point this out, we all do this. We all, what we do is we look at our circumstances, and if they align with our desires, we baptize them, we stamp God's will on them all the time. This is what God wants for me. if you're not a Christian here you might not use the term God but you'll use fate you'll use destiny you'll use universe maybe luck but either way this is what we do we confuse opportunity with permission what we end up doing is we we we think that if things are aligned the way we want that must be what we should have we don't realize that just because you can do something doesn't mean that you should that's really hard for us to understand Jonah did this by the way if you go to the book of Jonah he's run away from God and there's this great phrase as he's run away from God it says that he found a ship ready at the port so convenient for me to run away from God and what you need to realize is just because there's a boat to Tarshish waiting at the dock it doesn't mean that you should actually take it this is really hard for us to realize but I really wish that you remember this if you want to disobey God, there's always going to be a ship ready to take you away.
11:06 If you want to disobey God, there will always be a boat to take you there. And we do this when we don't trust God's timeline. And so what we do is we create our own and then we say, okay, that's what must be wisdom. I see this as a pastor. I see this in Christian subcultures all the time. They say, you'll hear people say, I think God wants this for me. I think God's will is this. I'm trying to obey God's calling so I'm doing and a lot of times what that is is it's actually what you want it's what your heart desires and you're just sort of throwing the word God in there to kind of justify it David has the knife in this text it's in his hand the boat is ready the fast forward button to him getting the crown is in his grasp with just one thrust Saul will be dead and what does David do?
12:01 what does he do? he creeps forward he slashes his knife and he doesn't kill Saul he just cuts off a corner of his robe just a corner and by cutting that corner it says what's fascinating is in the next verse in verse 5 it says that David is conscious stricken And I think a lot of people get puzzled by this. They're like, why is David so upset that he cut a little corner? like you and I we would have cut off Saul's head and we would have called it justice because this guy is a bad person he's been attacking us and throwing spears at us and doing terrible things we would think it would be fine but he is upset with cutting just a corner of his robe.
12:49 We would not have been worried about cutting off his head. he cuts a corner and calls it sin why is that? I think the reason why he felt this way is because David deeply understood that his main problem, his real issue, wasn't actually Saul. We think whatever circumstances going on in our life, that's our real issue. David knew better. He said, no, my problem isn't Saul. My real problem is my relationship with God. My real problem is about how I feel about God's timeline. what we need to realize is that your main problem isn't your job it isn't that relationship it isn't that family member it isn't that your kids your real problem at the end of the day is will you trust God's timing would God's promise be enough for you?
13:46 That's what David is working through. Because everything in his life is screaming otherwise. Will he still actually stay? Or will he take matters into his own hands? Will he say, okay, I need to do this for myself? And the reason why he's conscience stricken is that he knew... that even by cutting a little bit of that robe, he was actually not trusting God. because what a lot of folks don't understand is if you read all the Old Testament laws, there was tassels on the edge of these robes. And so by cutting off that edge, he was actually making Saul's robe non-Torah compliant. It was one small little way to judge Saul. It was one small little way to say, you know what, you don't deserve. You're not in line with the Lord. And David knew his heart.
14:38 He knew what he was actually doing when he did that. and he was like, that's me taking things on myself. That's me realizing that I'm actually failing to trust God. And I think this, by the way, I think this is the issue for every single believer. I think this is the issue for all non-believers. We actually have the same core issue, which is this. At the end of the day, we don't believe. that God is good. At the end of the day, we don't believe, we don't want God to be God. We don't want to be on his timing. You know, there's this, God, your ways aren't my ways. Okay, so fine, I'm going to have to find my own way. That's what we do. And so before I move on, I want to ask you this question. Are you able to wait on God's timing? Or are we like, no, I have to do it on my timing? Are we like, hey God, you're not going to act fast enough, so I'm going to have to do it my way.
15:32 I'll take the boat. I'll take the knife. Oh God, you're not going to judge. You're not going to do justice in my timing. I'm going to do it in my timing. Sorry, you're not going to do it in your timing. I'm going to do it in my timing. Where are you right now not willing to wait in your life? What part of your life are you not willing to wait in? because that's the test of the cave.
15:58 When you say, I'll take control, because I don't think God's going to do it. When you say, I have to, because you won't. When we worry because we think God's not going to get it right, or when we are angry because we think God actually got it wrong, what's happened in that moment is we're saying we don't trust that God will actually come through. All right, that's number one. Now, fine. Number two.
17:20 he goes face down to the ground. He prostrates himself. I mean, this is a super humble position. And I think David can do this because he knows something that we've forgotten. That's this. Ultimately, Saul's not accountable to David. Ultimately, Saul's accountable to God. He knows that Saul's real beef is not with him. Saul's real beef is with God. And so when Saul's throwing spears at David, we've already documented that in our past passages. David has an option and everybody has only two options you can either pick up the spear that was thrown at you and throw it back in self-defense to give them a taste of their own medicine so they know what it feels like or option two is you leave it on the ground the logic of the world the logic of David's men is pick it up defend yourself But David knew that if he picked up that and threw it at Saul, he would become like Saul.
18:23 He knew that if he used Saul's methods to defeat Saul, he might win the throne, but he would lose his soul. He'd become like him. And so look at verse 12. So David says, may the Lord judge between you and me and may the Lord avenge the wrongs that you have done to me, but my hand will not touch you. In other words, he's basically saying it's better to die in the cave than to let Saul's hatred become mine. And folks, this is, I think, the hardest thing to do in the world because when someone wrongs you, really, really wrongs you, there's a debt that happens and that hurt creates that debt and they owe you. You know they owe you. When they betray you, when they slander you, when they talk behind your back, when they gossip about you, you feel deeply that you're owed. I used to tell this to college students, I said, you know, imagine someone breaks your phone you have the same two options, right?
19:21 you can either throw the spear or you can leave it on the ground you can either say, you pay you broke my phone or else you'll have to pay someone always pays either they pay, how? with physical cash or if they don't pay you can still make them pay by talking bad about them by freezing them out by, you know, gossiping about them or you pay you have to either pay money for a new phone or you go without a phone That's still you paying. But this is, I think, one of the problems I think culture doesn't understand, that forgiveness is costly. To not ask for what was done against you, to get that debt back, you have to pay it, and it's costly. There's no such thing as cost-free forgiveness. There's no third option. Someone pays.
20:13 But almost never, almost never does the other person in your life, when you make them pay, feel like it's fair. Have you ever noticed that? That if you ever get back from them what they took from you, nobody ever says, you know what, that was a fair thing for you to do. The retribution and the way that you came after me after I came after you, that was fair. Almost never. You know why? They always receive it as an escalation. They always see it as actually you now actually taking more than you should. And now that injustice is done against them. Now they have beef with you. They feel like you created a debt that's unfair. And now, and the cycle continues. And that's what people don't realize, is that when hurt is done against you, that evil gets inside of you, and it doesn't actually just stop there.
21:06 You have, either it gets back out, or you absorb it and end it. and so what I think is fascinating is at the end of the day when a debt is done against you, the only way forward to not actually let that evil not just ruin you but ruin everybody else's life is to absorb it yourself. We think we're getting justice when we go back after other people, but we don't realize it's actually almost always vengeance. And there's a difference.
21:43 Vengeance inflicts punishment to satisfy your pain. justice seeks to restore not just the victim but the victimizer to do what's best for them And I think we confuse the two all the time. in our culture and in our own lives we think we're going for justice but we're actually going for vengeance and that's actually why everybody receives and feels it as escalation because they know you're not you're not doing what you just did for them you're doing it for you and that's actually why it's vengeance Next... justice seeks to restore, vengeance seeks to get payment. But I would argue, and I think what the text is saying, there's no way to get justice unless you go through forgiveness. You have to forgive first. And folks, this is where everybody always pushes back and says, that's not right.
22:36 It's unfair to require forgiveness. The one who's been perpetrated against, the one who's become a victim, now you're forcing them to have to forgive? That's unfair. and I would actually argue that's not true because you're confusing. You're thinking that if you forgive, you're not going to get justice. It's the other way around. Only if you forgive can you get justice because what forgiveness does, it's actually not about them. It's about you and your own heart. What you're doing in that moment is you're saying, I don't need the debt that you caused me. I don't need it back from you for me. I don't need it back from you. because I've been able to absorb it myself.
23:20 When you forgive, you're dealing with your own hurt first, releasing the need of the other person to pay for what you thought you needed for yourself. I would argue only then are you able to actually confront the other person. and do it not because of what you need, but because of what they need.
23:40 Not so that you will actually feel better, but to actually help make them feel better. and do better, and be better. I think this is the crux of the issue that we have everywhere in our lives right now. so let me ask you this question who haven't you forgiven this morning who is in your debt right now that you haven't released and because you haven't released them it's poisoning you it's twisting you you hold on to it to feel better about yourself against other people you hold on to it to judge them and judge others where are have you not released and it's killing you. See, when David says in verse 12, I won't avenge myself here, to be clear, he's not saying, hey, Saul, I want you to be able to get off scot-free. What he's saying is I'm not the ultimate judge.
24:37 God is. Merzal Wolf, a professor at Yale School of Divinity, says this. He says, forgiveness is not the substitute for justice. it provides the framework in which the quest for justice can actually happen. The number one problem in your community, in our nation, in your relationships, in our people groups, the people groups within each other, all human contact, the number one problem is that we move to justice before we deal with our own vengeance.
25:12 We're all in caves with each other, folks. Everybody has a knife and it is so easy just to stab and cut off. and David didn't do it he broke the cycle because when I stab then you stab I keep stabbing he broke the cycle and once David released himself from being the judge by the way that's not that's when he spoke truth to power he still said all the things he needed to say to Saul but he wasn't saying them because he needed it for himself he was saying it for him if you don't forgive first what you call justice actually is not really justice. You think it is, it's not. It's not going to be received that way. It's not going to act that way. It's just going to be vengeance. And I think we confuse the two all the time. Vengeance isn't justice. Justice isn't vengeance. I want justice. We need justice, but you can only get it through the path of forgiveness.
26:07 And the only way that you know that it actually is justice is that it's not truly for you, it's for them. And so where do we get the power to do this? How do you keep the spirit down? How do you have the power that when somebody has ruined your life and you have the knife and you can go over them, what's going to keep you from not stabbing them? Tom Skinner, an African-American who grew up here in New York City, wrote a memoir once.
26:37 And he talks about the time right after he became a Christian. He was playing sports. I think it was in high school. It was a football game. He was a kid. And there was a kid on the other team that got very angry at him. He made a clean block. It was a great play. And the kid got up so angry, he started screaming at Tom. He started punching him, shouting racial slurs at him. And Tom, in his memoir, says that normally he would have gotten him and destroyed the boy. He would have just completely annihilated him. And yet a strange thing happened after he became a Christian. He had this calm. He had this ability. He stood up and it was very curious to him. He just looked at the kid and said, you know, because of Jesus and what he did for me, I love you. that kid had no idea how to respond to that.
27:36 Instead, he actually ran off the field. That other kid didn't play the rest of the game, but after the game, he sought out Tom, found him at his locker, and this is what he said to him. He said, Tom, you've done more to knock prejudice out of me by telling me that you loved me than if you had socked my jaw in. Why is that? Because that kid knew that he deserved a right hook, but he received grace and it changed him. And it could change you if you let it. Tom went on, by the way, to become one of the great voices for justice of his generation. Forgiveness did not stop him from caring about justice, but it transformed how he went about it. And that's what I want us to get as well. Where did Tom get that power? Where will we get that power. Last point, the cost. Our culture says justice is very simple. It's this, it goes like this. The villains harm the innocent. The hero rises to power and destroys the villain. Every plot of almost every major movie does this, right? Avengers, Gladiator. We love the idea that a very simple good and evil and good beats evil. Done. Small problem. Alexander Sholzenizin says this.
29:04 He survived the Soviet gulags and he said this. He said, the line separating good and evil passes not through states, not political parties, but right through every human heart. if the solution to the world's problems is to kill the bad guys what do we do when we realize that includes us that we throw spears to. And I think this is our cultural moment. I think this is why our culture is stuck, is we want blood, but we have no way to wash the blood off our own hands as well.
29:45 I think we have to look at David. David is the hero. He has the power to kill the victim. Sorry, the victimizer. He has the power to kill the villain, but he doesn't win by taking the life. He wins by risking his own. And he makes himself, by how? He makes himself utterly vulnerable. He comes out of that cave. He's surrounded by 3,000 swords. And he does it to try to save one man, his eternal life, Saul's. Does this sound familiar at all? Centuries later, there would be another hero that would show up. the true king, who comes not to a cave, but to a garden. If you go to the garden of Gethsemane, what you find there is you find Jesus surrounded by swords. A bunch of his enemies show up with swords and spears.
30:42 And what happens is, what does Peter do? He takes out his sword, and he slices off the ear of the priest's servant. He actually does what David's men wanted to do as well. But what does Jesus do? He heals that man. He says, put your sword away. David. put his life at risk.
31:11 Jesus did so much more. What David did is he merely refrained from killing his enemy. Jesus actually let his enemies kill him. David cut the corner of Saul's robe off, but when they took Jesus to the cross, they didn't just cut a little bit of his robe. They actually stripped him naked. They threw every spear they had at him. why didn't Jesus call down the legions of angels that he had at his beck and call why didn't he just snap his fingers and say you know what I'm going to bring justice here the answer is this Jesus knew that someone has to pay all forgiveness is costly and so on that cross Jesus Christ absorbs the infinite cost of our spear throwing every betrayal every lie every spear of indifference every spear of self salvation that I'm going to take things into my own hands, that I'm going to do it in my timing, I'm going to hop on that boat, I'm going to press that fast forward button.
32:09 Jesus took every single piece of injustice that we do, that we might not even know that we're doing, but the people who it's been done against, they know our names. He took that injustice and paid for it himself. And instead of demanding that we pay, the king of kings steps off the throne and the spear that was meant for our own heart. went into the side of the son of God. why Because I think that the only way for us to go forward in this world, in the world that's pulling itself apart the world that's fracturing is to know that the King of Kings bled for you. when you were his enemy And that's the only thing that will drain the bitterness. that you might have in your own soul against anybody else who you might call an enemy as well it's the only way that you're going to be able to seek justice and not vengeance.
33:10 Folks, you'll never be able to forgive people who have hurt you by just trying harder to be nice, to will yourself into it. You can only forgive when you see how much you've been forgiven. Forgiven people forgive others. And the best way that you know that you're forgiven is by looking at the cross and looking at the cost of it. And when you realize that you threw those spears, you thought you were throwing at each other but actually you're throwing them to God himself. And then he took that spear and refused to throw it back at you. I think something breaks inside of us. Something, the grip of that knife no longer is as strong because we don't have to obsess anymore.
33:56 The grip of that knife, the rage drains. You no longer have to knife other people in the cave. You no longer have to obsess about them getting what they deserve and you getting what you deserve. you don't have to seek vengeance because the cross proves that justice has the last word. And the resurrection is the receipt, knowing that one day all things will be righted. We can seek the justice now, but we can do it knowing that one day it will come. And that helps us put down our swords, helps us put down our spears and seek the justice, not just for the victim, but for the one who did the violence in the first place.
34:43 Armed with that, you can right the wrongs of the world, friends. We can go out there for the sake of the world, not for your own sake. This is the core of Christianity. The core of Christianity, if you want to sum it all up, it goes like this. The God of the universe in the person of Jesus. dies for his enemies. and if you put that person at the core of your life, you're going to die for your enemies too. That's it. That's what it comes down to. Your political enemies, your co-working enemies, your family enemies. And so let's start where we began. If we're all victims and perpetrators, all in different forms, but we all have been hurt and hurted and yet we're fracturing and pulling ourselves apart, we all therefore need both justice and mercy. And I think the only way forward for us in this world as we're always thinking about what that other side did or that other group or that other person or that the only way forward for us to not live in perpetual hate of each other is if we come to the cross and see it as the inflection point where justice and mercy meets.
35:52 Because what happens there is it'll immediately, if you focus on the cross it'll humble you because you'll realize that you don't actually get what you deserve. And that will mean that I don't have to knife other folks, but at the same time, you'll see that God caring about all the hurts that we care about and that therefore it embolden us to move out and seek justice and not vengeance.
36:18 Folks, gospel is the only way I know forward. It's the only hope I think that we have. So ask yourself this, who's in your cave right now? who are are you holding that grudge against that's killing you and it's killing them drop the knife see the king See his love for you. And that will set you free. and then we can move out in powerful ways to love and serve not for us but for the world let's pray Heavenly Father this is such a hard word because we don't understand forgiveness We don't understand the costly nature of it. we're walking around wounded. Everybody has wounds against everyone else. It's just so easy. It's true, there's a debt. It was done. It's real.
37:10 We deserve to be healed, but if we try to take it from others over and over and over again, what we think might be justice, it's just vengeance. Help us see the love that we find in you on the cross. Help us to see our own needs, that we're, all the things that we've done wrong. Let it humble us so that we move out. both being humbled because we've been, we see that our own needs, but also fulfilled and realize that you will never throw that spear back at us. That lets us move out in different ways.
37:50 Forgiveness is not the enemy of justice. It's the beginning. Help us to do that first. Help us to see what you've done for us so that we can do it for others. We pray these things in your name. Amen.
Machine translated from the source