Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached January 4, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
3:09 In 2023, the Harvard Business School began to do an investigation on one of their most highest paid professors and this professor was an ethic ethics professor who literally wrote a chapter titled, Dishonesty Explained, What Leads Moral People to Act Immorally? She was found to have falsified her data on at least four different studies. The world's leading expert on cheating cheated on her research on cheating. And when she was confronted by this, she didn't confess. She blamed bad researchers and assistants. She cited bad faith actors, and she sued the school for defamation. She sued for reputational harm.
4:08 Now, part of us love stories like this because there's a part of us that goes, yeah, I feel better about myself now. You know, at least I didn't do that. But researchers actually show that all humans actually have a gap between who we think we are and who we actually are. Behavioral economist Dan Ariely proved through experiments that actually every single person in the entire world actually cheats and lies a little. And we do so only so much so that we get enough benefit without actually losing our self-image that we are a good person. Everybody does this. And so what I want to ask this morning is this. Why do good people do bad things? Why do we have such a great ability to lie to ourselves about ourselves? Why is that?
5:08 I think the answer in our text today is right here. It's from 1 Samuel 15. Beginning today, we're going to start a series looking at the life of David this entire spring. But what we need to do before we get to David is we need to see the man that he's about to replace, and that's King Saul. And we're going to do this in three ways. We're going to look at, first, the excuses we make. Secondly, why we do those excuses. And then, thirdly, the love that will liberate us. So what are the excuses that we make? Why do we make those excuses? And then what will be the love that might liberate us? So first, the excuses that we make. In this chapter, this is chapter 15 in 1 Samuel, God had actually already given a command to Samuel. If you go to verse 13, sorry, to Saul. Verse 13, Samuel references that command. Well, sorry, actually, Saul references that command.
6:01 He goes, listen, I've carried out the Lord's instructions. Instructions to what? he was told earlier in this chapter to wipe out the entire civilization of the Malachites. Their livestock, everything. Now, for some of you, before you start mentally checking out, before you start saying, wait a second, this is what I don't like about the Bible. This is God doing terrible things. This is regressive. I can't believe something like this. I want to address this elephant in the room. And the question is this, is this actually genocide? Is this a war crime that God's doing? Earlier in the chapter, in verse 2, the reason for this proclamation to wipe out the Malachites was actually given. Way back when, the Malachites actually, when God's people were coming up out of Egypt, the Malachites attacked the back side of the column of people coming out.
6:57 And the back, it's always the slowest people. It was the most feeble. It was the elderly, the women and children. and they completely decimated them because the Amalekites were a culture built on that type of murder. They enriched themselves through violence. And so God makes a proclamation, actually back then he did, and it's here through Saul that God wanted justice to be done. And yet the way God wanted him to do it was to be completely different than how every other nation goes to war. Because every other nation then and today, when you go to war, you always benefit from it. You always take the plunder. You always take the livestock. You always take the slaves. But God says, no, you are not supposed to do that. To prove that this is actually divine, providential justice, you cannot take the plunder or the trophies. And so what does Saul do? He goes to war in verses 7 and 9, and he takes the plunder and takes the trophies. And by doing so, he ends up doing exactly what the people that he was sent to judge, he uses his power for profit. He ends up being just another country who goes on a smash and grab raid and benefits from it.
8:26 And by the way, over the centuries, when the Philistines, when everybody else starts trying to invade Israel, their justification is, well, listen, you've done this too. So they lose the moral high ground. And God says, that's the problem. And so when Samuel comes and confronts Saul, what does Saul do? He doesn't repent. In fact, he gives three classic excuses that every single one of us in this room actually still use today. I want to look at them quickly. He gives three excuses for the self-deception that we use. Excuse number one is this, the redefinition of reality. In verse 13, Saul launches what I would call a preemptive strike. Look at it right now. Sam's coming up and Saul says, the Lord bless you. I've carried out all of God's instructions. I love this because you can actually see it happen in your mind.
9:22 Like Samuel's like, wait a second, I didn't even talk about that yet. Samuel hasn't even opened up his mouth yet, but he's already launched into a preemptive argument for why he is actually in the right. Samuel picks up on this. Samuel sees how quick he's acting. Now commentaries actually are divided on if Saul's actually lying here. Does he know that he messed up? Is this conscious or unconscious? You know what I mean? And I actually decide on the side that I think he doesn't think he's lying. If you strapped on a polygraph to Saul, I think he would pass. Because he thinks he really has obeyed. You can tell because, I think, towards the end of the passage, he's like, no, no, I have obeyed. I really have. And I think this is the essence of self-deception.
10:15 And that's this. you and I don't know that we're lying because we've lied to ourselves first. We've lied to ourselves before we lie to anybody else. And we do this all the time, by the way. There's a very famous study that shows that, did you know this? 94% of all college professors think they're above average. By the way, it's statistically impossible. 94% can't be above average. That's called average. 68% of those same professors think they're in the top 25%. 25%. Also impossible. If you actually ask the average American if they're above average as a driver, most of us say yes, which is also impossible. You can't all be above average drivers. And so what happens is we, what's going on? We all are like this. We all think we're good people. Why? Because we focus on what's good and we ignore what we're not good at.
11:12 We redefine reality so that we always stay the hero of our own story. Don't look at my flaws. Look at these features over here, which, by the way, if you think about it, is the essence of Instagram. Instagram is what? The curated, filtered experience of who I am. Don't look at actually what I really look at. Look at this. This is amazing.
11:33 That's us all the time. And we play that out in the real world. How do we do this? We say, hey, hey, okay, okay, I might have looked at porn, but I I didn't sleep with anyone. We say, oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay, okay, okay. Well, you know, I might scream at my kids, but I still provide for them. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Maybe that's okay. But maybe that's not okay. But look what I did. Look what I really did. I'm over here. That's what Saul is doing. but sin always has a noise, does it not? If you look down here, Samuel says, okay, okay, if you really obeyed, then what's that sound I hear? The bleeding of the sheep. What we do always contains a sound still. You and I can spend our whole lives trying to redefine reality, making that an excuse, and yet that actually doesn't change reality.
12:28 You can redefine it, but you can't change it. All right, that's excuse number one, redefinition. Number two, blame shifting. When Saul no longer, when he realizes he can't gaslight his way out of this, in verse 15, he turns to blame shifting. Actually, he does it in verse 21 as well. You can see the difference in the pronouns. If you go to verse 13, he says, listen, I obeyed, I obeyed. And then by verse 15, they did it. The soldiers did it. Verse 21, the soldiers did it. Wasn't me. Saul, by doing so, this is what he's doing. He's saying, I want all the credit, none of the blame. This is a great episode in the sitcom, The Office. Michael Scott is a manager of a small town paper company and of one of their sites. And there's this episode where he He makes a decision that goes poorly, and he tries to get one of his employees to take the fall for it because he doesn't want the blame.
13:28 But then when it turns out that that decision makes the company a lot of money, and so now all of a sudden, now he wants the credit. And there's this great scene where, with no irony at all, he says this. He says, I just want all the credit and none of the blame. And I love that quote because that's actually every single one of us. We just want all the credit. Hey, whatever it is, just give me the credit and someone in the blame. because we blame, and that's why we blame shift, because what we're doing is what I think is one of the oldest excuses in the book, literally. Go back to the Garden of Eden. Adam and Eve are confronted. What does Adam do? She did it. What does Eve do? The serpent did it. That's what we do. We're always the victim in our own stories, are we not? Think about that. The market made me do it. It's not my fault.
14:20 The government made me do it. It was my family upbringing. I can't help myself. That's why I do what I do. That is the essence of blame shifting. And we do it as an excuse because it preserves our goodness without actually being good. It preserves our self-understanding that we're a good person without actually having to be a good person. Our excuse number three.
15:13 back to this week's sermon. I'm going to call this pragmatism. It's pragmatism dressed up in piety. If you go to verse 15, he does another excuse here where he says what? He says, hey, yeah, okay, fine. We spared the best of the sheep, but we're doing it to sacrifice to you, Lord. Okay, okay, maybe we didn't technically do what you said, but trust me, this is a better way because we're not going to just like, you know, slaughter everything and leave it out there. We're going to bring back the best, which by the way, it says earlier that he killed everything that was despised and weak, which is what the world always does, right? Prioritizes the good and holds up the strong and destroys what is weak. He says, hey, I have a better idea. Let's take this back and we'll offer it to you, Lord, in nice pious language. We're going to sacrifice to you. What's really happening here is this. At the essence of what Saul is saying, he's saying, God, actually, I have a better way. My way is more efficient than your way. My way is more economical. My way is better. And we do the same thing. It's no different when we say, okay, okay, yeah, I know there's a Sabbath, but guess what? This deal has to get done. I got to work. Yeah, yeah, I should probably spend time with my kids.
16:38 Or if you don't have kids, I need to rest. I need to, you know, sleep. And you say, you know what? I'm too busy, though, trying to prove my worth. Folks, when efficiency is God, God is not God. We've made something else God. And Samuel calls it out. If you go to verse 23, I've never understood this because Samuel starts going into poetry here. That's why there's a change in the style. But in 23, he says, for rebellion is like the sin of divination.
17:09 How's rebellion? Like, what does divination have to do with rebellion? Divination was what the ancient world would do to try to control God. They would, you know, it's witchcraft. It was reading the tea leaves. It would be trying to find the signs and the spirits. All of it was really trying to get control and power over God. And by the way, you don't need witchcraft to do that. Anytime that you do your own cause-benefit analysis, say, you know what? I'm going to do these rules and these things about what God says, but I'm not going to do these things. You're actually not obeying or worshiping or participating in a relationship with God. You're participating and obeying what you want him to be.
17:47 What is that? You are conjuring up your own idea of who you think God should be for you. That's divination. When you use, there's a popular book out there called Prayer of Jebez, which is really, it takes a part of scripture, the prayer of Jabez, and it says, oh, look, I'm supposed to pray for economical and material wealth. What is that? If I just pray hard enough, it's the prosperity gospel. If I just pray hard enough, then God will give me what I want. That's divination. If you're like, hey, you know what? I have a plan that if I just do this, this, this, and this and this, and then my life is going to go well. Whatever, if that statement is how we live out our lives, that's actually a type of divination because you're saying, I know how my life will go if I just do this, this, and this. That's not true.
18:39 You don't have that kind of control. And it's always dressed up in pious language. Which means this. We're not actually going to God to get God. We're going to God to get things from God. That's not God. That's divination. And some of you say, well, so what? So what? Everybody makes excuses, right? This is just part of being human. You know what's happening right there? You're making an excuse about making excuses. You're still being deceived about your own self-deception. You're still making excuses. And this is why around Redeemer, we always have this phrase. We say, self-deception is not the worst thing that you'll ever do.
19:19 But self-deception is always the reason why you will do the worst things. Where are you deceived right now? Before we move on to the next point, just ask yourself, where might you be, what are the excuses you use in your life? What are the things that are so deep in your soul, the shame, the guilt, that you can't even bear to look at them, you've buried them, because you're too afraid to actually address them? And you just sort of shuck it off, you say, well, okay, I won't look at those flaws, but look at these features. Where are those things for you? Number one. Okay, number two. Fine. Why? Why do we do these excuses? If we want to fix things, we have to actually first understand why. And let's look at Saul. And this is a great question. If you're king and you have everything, why do you need a little bit more? What is the thing that he needs so most that he has to have? Or what's the thing he's trying to hide from himself?
20:18 self. I think Samuel shows us in verse 17. In verse 17, he says, although you were once small in your own eyes, did you not become the head of the tribe of Israel? Connect that with verse 12, with what Saul actually does. After he gets this great victory, what does he do? He says he goes to Carmel, and there he has set up a monument in his own honor. Hmm. What's going on here?
20:48 Being small in your own eyes means that you have some type of imposter syndrome. In other words, Saul did not feel like he was a king on the inside. So guess what? He had to actually come up with the appearance of what it meant to be a king on the outside. You only build monuments if you are afraid people might forget you. You only build monuments because you want people to see.
21:15 Actually, ironically, not even just you. you want people to see your depiction of what you think you are God had actually previously anointed Saul, had made him king, had given him all the approval, and yet that wasn't enough for him on the inside. He still needed the acclaim and the praise and the attention of others on the outside.
21:40 And I think that's actually the root of self-deception. This is the why. Why do we do this? It's because there's some part of us that has to say this. I have to take, make, bake, whatever it is, because if I don't, it won't ever be given to me. I have to have more because as I am is not enough. That's the essence of why we do excuses. That's the essence of self-deception.
22:09 And that's why we build monuments. Folks, what are the monuments that you're building? We don't use stone anymore. We use status. The career monument goes like this. I am something if I'm successful. I am nothing if I'm not. The parenting monument is this. I am something if my kids are successful. I am nothing if they are not.
22:32 You can make an address a monument. You can make any success a monument. What's yours? What are you building? What do you want other people to see? What are you saying I have to have? Because I'm not going to get it myself. that's what Saul does, and yet it's actually what everybody does. We build monuments to matter.
23:00 And so why do we do excuses? Excuses happen when the monuments that we're building are no longer working, and we can't cover the shame, and we can't get away from the truth that's breaking through, that's this, that there's nothing on the outside that you could get or build or make that will make you feel on the inside enough. That's it. And so that's why we redefine reality. That's why we blame shift. And the truth is that if you're too small in your eyes, if you are small in your own eyes, no amount of success, no amount of monuments out there are going to make you big enough.
23:35 You will always need one more deal, one more victory, one more monument. Folks, this is what New York is about. Some of you are here to build monuments. and everybody in this room is that we are taking a record and feeling either we're doing well or not doing well in that monument building right now.
23:57 And so what's the answer? Is the answer then to become great in our own eyes? Right? Oh, no, we're not great enough in our own eyes. Saul wasn't great enough. So become great in your own eyes. No, don't do that. We know people who are great in their own eyes. You know who they are? they're called narcissists we don't like them they're insufferable So, let's go. there is a survey that actually comes out every year that shows that americans are either number one or number two of the of the people in the world that have the highest self-esteem our problem is that we're not great enough in our own eyes we know we're great enough in our own eyes that's not going to be enough ironically what this is texas trying to say to us is that the goal is actually not to look in our own eyes at all. You don't need to be small in your own eyes or great in your own eyes, you need to see your greatness in the eyes of God. That's what this is saying here. Only when you see how God sees you, only when you see how he loves you, how he cares for you, will we be able to have on the inside a sense that I am enough. We spend our lives, folks, the tragedy of the human condition is we spend our lives building monuments, hoping that one day if we just build it high enough and big enough and great enough, then someone somewhere will finally notice us, and it never happens. And so last point, what's the solution? Like, look at the logic here. We make excuses because our monuments aren't working. We build monuments because we feel empty on the inside, and we're empty on the inside because we don't see how great we are in God's eyes.
25:45 And so here's the answer. Is the answer try harder to obey? Be careful. Sometimes when I'm up here, sometimes people are hearing, when I say, hey, you need to see how great you are in God's eyes, that's translated as, okay, okay, Mike's saying try harder, try harder. Try harder to know that God loves me. Guess what? That will just lead to more monuments. It will be religious monuments, but still monuments. By the way, Saul was religious. By the way, people around Jesus, all religious. And yet they still miss who Jesus was. Whatever Christianity is, it's not asking you just to get more religious. Then what will actually work? Last two things. You need to see something and see someone. What do you mean by see something? Some people still read this passage, and you still are saying, in the back of your mind, you're saying, man, why is God so harsh on Saul?
26:38 He's taking it easy on this king. He's being merciful. Like, why can't we give him a break? Why is this God all about vengeance and justice? And the problem is, is that you're actually not seeing something. And I didn't until like late last night. It was all of a sudden an aha. If you fast forward 500 years from this point, you go to the book of Esther, and the people of God are being oppressed and annihilated again. They're on the cusp of every man, woman, and child to be wiped out. And the reason, the person behind this genocide is this man named Haman. But I never noticed this. If you go to Esther chapter 3, verse 1, his full name is given. It says there that his name was Haman the Agiite. He was a descendant of the king that Saul spared.
27:33 and it brought generations later cruelty and hurt and hardship. See, we sit around going, oh, this is just one little sin. This is not that big of a deal. What's the big problem here? And we don't realize the ramifications of our actions of how they reverberate out into the world and what it does to destroy it. We don't see it. You know why we don't see it? Because we can't see how God sees things. How can you know? How can you possibly know You can't because you're not god. He sees things that we can't see. He knows things that we don't know He knows who should die and when they should die and he knows who should live and when they should live. He knows how your life should go and he knows how your life will go. We don't
28:20 And so there's something for you to see is this. Will you trust him or are you going to trust yourself? Do you know or does he know? See, we can't see how our one little, quote unquote, merciful thing that we do actually turns into genocide later on in history. But he can. Last thing. Don't you see something, see someone. We need a king, folks. Saul was the first one, and he wasn't good enough, but we have something that he doesn't have. Saul set out, and what does he do? He was small in his own eyes. He tried to make himself great. Jesus Christ, who comes as the true king, what is he like? He was great. He was the king of kings, and he became nothing, Philippians 2 says. Saul tries to earn God's favor through a sacrifice Jesus through sacrifice saves see Saul was trying to save his own life through sacrifice Jesus saves our life through his sacrifice Saul kept on trying to dress himself up in royalty with monuments.
29:31 Jesus was stripping himself of all things Saul wanted to have the glory Jesus gave up the glory Saul blamed others to save his life. Jesus took the blame to save our lives. Saul grabs the crown, and what does Jesus do? Jesus lays that crown down.
29:53 One of the beautiful things of this text is it says that Saul is condemned here. because he spared the best, the best sheep. Romans 8.32 says God did not spare the best, his own son, but gave him up and he willingly gave himself up for us. God did what Saul refused to do. He executed total judgment for sin, but he didn't bring it on us. Jesus took it. This is the only thing, friends, that's going to heal your heart. I'm positive. Only when the King of Kings lays down his crown for you and you see it and you experience that, you see that someone and understand your value, not through your own eyes, but through his eyes for you,
30:42 where you don't need to build any more monuments anymore. You can be small, you can be great in your own eyes, whatever it is, because you know at the end of the day how large you loom in God's eyes. There's a scene in Christopher Nolan's movie, Interstellar in 2014. It's a movie that some people love, some people hate, some people understand it. Some people have no idea what's happening in it. It's a sci-fi movie where this man named Cooper leaves the earth, goes on a mission through a wormhole into other galaxies to try to save the earth. And he returns, but the way wormholes and time slippage and all this other stuff happens, when he comes back, what happens to him was very quickly, he doesn't age much. Back on earth, his daughter that he left, who was a preteen, is now an old woman. And man, this scene always kills me.
31:40 Because he meets her in the hospital, and she says to him this. She says, nobody believed me. but I knew you'd come back. And he asked how, and she says, because my dad promised me. Always a tearjerker for me, but guess what? A couple weeks ago, I found out that actually in the original script, there was a line that went before this. This is what the line goes like. They ended up cutting it out, but this was the line. She says this, everyone wants a child, everyone wants a child, wants to look into their dad's eyes and know that he saw. But essentially by then, the father's always gone. That is so true. Everybody in this room, at some point in your life, as a child, when you grow up, you want to know that your father, your mother, that someone sees you in Saul.
32:37 Everybody wants to see their father see them. But by then, the father's gone. My dad's gone. Christmas is hard. I wish that he could see his son, his sons, his grandkids.
33:01 I'd like for him to know what he sees. I'd like him to know. I'd like to know that he saw what's going on. I think all of us are desperately hoping that someone or something out there sees us. We want to be seen. We want to be known. We want to be loved by someone or something.
33:27 But if you don't first see ourselves as great in God's eyes, first, you're always going to be looking to someone or something else. That the only eyes that really matter you is the Father who knows and loves you cosmically. you'll never be great enough in your own eyes if you don't know how great you are in the father's eyes the only father who really matters and ultimately matters as the song in the greatest showman goes all the shine of a thousand spotlights all the stars we steal from the night sky will never be enough it'll never be enough towers of gold are still too little these hands could hold the world but it'll never be enough it'll never be enough Folks, stop wasting the brilliance that's in this room on trying to be enough.
34:22 It'll never be enough. You are already great in God's eyes and all you need is an experience of that greatness. And you can see it in the person of Jesus. You might not know this in your head, but you need to get it into your heart. And so here's a test I'd love for you to do later on today. Just take five minutes and jot down the top five things that you have been going for that you've been looking to, to try to make yourself feel great enough, and ask yourself, do I really need these things? If I truly knew God's love for me, if I saw his eyes seeing me, would I really still need these things to the same degree? seek him out more than seeking those things out And so then the next time that you're slighted at work, the next time that you're not giving your due the next time that you need you can remember your status in the true king experience him experience him and live into that identity or you'll constantly be building monuments to matter.
35:28 And I don't want that for you. I don't want that for me. see yourself through the eyes of God who saw and loved and cared for you still. Let's pray. Heavenly Father, True Heavenly Father. Thank you. for showing us your love.
36:00 Thank you for Jesus who came and gave it all up for us. Thank you for him being the true king. No other earthly king will be enough. Help us to see the excuses that we make. We're so good at having self-esteem and building ourselves up, and yet we still feel hollow, not whole, but you've come to make us whole and right. move in our hearts in profound and purposeful ways. We pray these things.
Machine translated from the source