Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached May 3, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
2:00 Amen. Thank you, Tracy. Good morning and welcome again to Redeemer Lincoln Square. we are starting a new series on the Apostles' Creed. And for those of you who don't know what that is, it's the statement that we read about every other week before communion. It's on page 9, so we'll be reading it today. And it is considered one of the main historic uniting creeds that we have. We're going to go through each phrase, phrase by phrase, to understand and look through this creed so that we know, what do we actually believe? What are we actually trying to say when we say these things? This Apostles' Creed was made around 180 AD. So from the second century, billions of Christians have said this creed. It unites us across continents, languages, time, space, Catholics, Protestants, Eastern Orthodox, Russian Orthodox.
3:00 it is the main, again, historic document that we say together that unites us. That when I go across traditions, I can say, you know what? We hold the Apostles' Creed together. Now, why are we doing this series today? Well, one, it's always good to know what you believe and what we say in our services. But the second reason why we're doing it today, there's multiple reasons, but another reason why we're doing it today is that the Harvard Business Review in 2025... doing an analysis of how we use generative AI, the top three ways that we use generative AI is no longer about productivity. The top three ways are companionship, therapy, and purpose, meaning and purpose. We go to generative AI in 2025 for therapy, companionship, and meaning and purpose.
3:54 And that means this, we're going to machines to find out who we are. We're going to these algorithmic predictive models, these formulas. And what they're trying to do is they're trying to tell us or predict what it thinks we want to know about who we are and what we want. Now, the problem with that is this. What you want is not always what you really need. What you need is often not what you want. And so what we have with AI now is that we live in a world where we are the most informed generation ever. Everybody now has in their pocket, through their phone, a PhD. We have access to knowledge that most generations could only dream of. We're the most informed and the least formed.
4:50 That means we are a generation where we have the answers to everything, but we're rooted in nothing. And so what I want to do with the Apostles' Creed is that the phrase, the first phrase we're going to look at today is the phrase, I believe. And what's great about that, when you say that, you are, A, it's in the present tense, B, it's you, you have to say it. And what you're doing in saying that is you're saying, this is what I'm going to root myself in. Everybody has to begin here. Everybody has to say, this is where I'm going to stake my life. And so in a world where right now we're outsourcing what it means to be human, where it's blurring the lines of our human nature, we're doing the series sort of as an act of stating what we actually believe. So if you're not a Christian here this morning, you're in luck because we're going to go over the core tenets, the essence of what Christianity is about, and you get to compare and contrast.
5:48 If you are a Christian, you're in luck as well, because we're going to go over the tenets of Christianity for you to be able to compare and contrast what it means to say, I believe. So today, let's get started with the first phrase. What does it mean to believe? And we're going to look at John chapter 20. We're going to see three things here. The universality of belief, the posture of belief and the object of belief. So I'll say it again, the universal nature of belief, the posture of belief, and the object of belief. So first, the universal nature of belief. Living in New York City now as a minister, the most common phrase that people say to me when they meet me and they find out I'm a minister is this. They say this, oh wow, it's great that you believe, that's cool. I wish I could believe. I just don't have enough faith. They say, hey, I would love to believe. I just don't have enough faith. And there's an assumption in there that they're too rational. They're too, you know, scientific and therefore they can't actually do it. What they don't realize is that actually belief is not their problem. Because I want to argue before you today is this, is that everybody believes in something. Nobody actually comes to reality and functions through just pure unmediated observation. We all are trusting. We come to reality with trust because we're living out our commitments that we can't prove
7:22 and we can't actually convince necessarily everyone else what we believe as well. And so we're functioning on trust. I'll give an example of this. Right now, you believe that your memory of this morning is real. How would you ever test that actually your memory of this morning actually works? You'd have to use your memory to remember that, and therefore you can't test something with the thing you're trying to test. You can't use your memory to see if your memory works. It's the same thing with your five senses, right? We all have five senses, but how do you test if your five senses are actually telling you an accurate depiction of reality or just telling you what you need to be told so that you can pass on your genes to the next generation?
8:11 You would have to use your five senses to test your five senses, which you can't do. I'll give you another one. The view that everybody has intrinsic worth and value. We believe, many of us believe, that humans, no matter what they produce, have intrinsic worth and value. Now, where does that view come from? Where does it come from? Where does the view of human rights come from? It doesn't come from biology. It doesn't come from chemistry.
8:41 What you find in biology is the strong eat the weak. That is not intrinsic value. In other words, to hold that position, that is a huge, massive faith in a metaphysical claim that you can't prove. Empirically, there's no way to prove it. And yet we all hold it.
9:02 Belief then is just another way to say trust. I want to de-spiritualize that phrase. We throw around in circles like a church the phrase faith and belief. but the essence of those things is really trust. Now faith and belief is more than trust but it's at least that. We are trusting and if you don't trust in the Christian faith what you need to realize is not that you don't trust anything you're just trusting something else. You're trusting that in scientific materialism. You're trusting in the arc of progress. I'll hear people say all the time well I just don't believe that belief really matters but that's a belief. To say I don't believe, belief matters that you can't prove that, but you hold it. There's no way around this. Everyone holds something, trusts in something that you can't necessarily prove. And in that context, now let's turn to our text. We have Thomas here. Look at verse 25. Thomas says, unless I see the nail marks on his hands and put my fingers where the nails are and put my hands into his side, I will not believe.
10:13 And a lot of us, we applaud Thomas. We say, oh yeah, good man, empirical evidence, great. But look carefully at what Thomas is actually doing here. By demanding empirical proof, he's making his own sensory experience the final arbiter of reality. He's saying, I have the ability to be able to, through my own sense perception, ascertain literally God. I have the ability to do that, and that requires a staggering amount of trust in his own cognitive supremacy. He can't prove that, but that he believes that. But that's it. Unbelief in Jesus is never just the absence of faith. It's always the presence of a different faith. And Thomas has it too. The Greek word that John uses here for belief is the word pisteo, es. Pisteo is the phrase belief, and es is into.
11:07 It's always belief into something else. Imagine you're standing on the side of a frozen lake. And you're trying to figure out, should I walk out on that lake? Now you can test it. You can know the chemical composition of that ice. You can throw some rocks out on it. You can see it. But until you step on that ice, you're not putting your faith, you're not putting your trust into that ice. You're still holding it. When you stay on that shore, you know what you're doing? you're still holding up yourself. And so the question I want to ask is this, if faith is universal, if everyone's trusting something, the question is not, can I believe? The question is, what am I already trusting in? And by the way, just because you say you believe, something doesn't mean that's actually what you believe, what your functional faith is in. That's a whole nother question.
11:59 But I want to ask you, what are you every day stepping your weight onto? Is it your career? Is it your family? Is it your own sense perception? And for those of you who are skeptical, if you're suspicious of Jesus here, this is a church that we value questions, those who ask them. That's fine. But I want you to also be equally suspicious of the alternative commitments. that you would put your faith in. The phrase we say around here at Redeemer is, it's okay to have doubt, but you also need to doubt your doubts. Are you willing to do that? Because like Thomas, every single one of us has a faith. And the question is, can that faith bear up the weight of you when you need it? Does it actually do that? All right, point two, fine.
13:22 If everybody has belief, the posture of belief. If faith is not about choosing between having faith and not having faith, but just the transfer of one type of trust and faith to another type of trust and faith, how do you know that's actually happened? Go back to our text. Look at verse 25 again. The disciples say, hey, we've seen the Lord. but he says, unless I see the nail marks, I will not believe. See, Thomas here is not just asking for evidence. When he says, unless I see the nail marks, he's actually giving terms. He's giving requirements. I believe this is actually the default posture of the human heart when we approach God.
14:05 When we say, Lord, I will believe if. I will believe, Lord, if you get me through this. if you heal my child, if you show me why I'm suffering. When we say phrases like that, you are giving God conditions and requirements. And again, one of the things that we say at Redeemer here is that whenever you say, God, I'll believe in you, God, if your functional God is whatever that is on the other side of if. I'll believe in you, God, if I'll be successful in life. Success then is your functional God. You'll use God to get that. but that's who your functional God is. Let me give you an example to illustrate this. Imagine you create a spiritual prenuptial agreement with God. You can imagine, I know, just try to imagine. A spiritual prenuptial agreement with God, where you say, God, I will marry you spiritually if you make sure I don't get terminal illness at the end of my life and die quickly.
15:04 And if you give me six-figure salary for the rest of my life so I'm comfortable, then I'll believe in you. Now, if you, that's a spiritual prenuptial agreement. You know what? If somebody actually did that to you in real life, if somebody said, hey, I'll marry you if you just guarantee me a six-figure salary, I'll marry you if, you know, you give me a good life, you would know you don't, that person doesn't really love you for you.
15:30 They love you for the lifestyle that they want. They love you maybe, they might even use you to get that lifestyle, but they don't love you for you. We're doing the same thing to God. How often is that our posture? When we say unless, that is not just a throwaway statement. Those are conditions and requirements. And these conditions and requirements, they tend not to be said in dramatic statements. You don't need to be like, God, this is my view. Most of the time, these conditions live in small, persistent negotiations that happen in the back of our minds that we're not even cognizant of. Sure, Lord, I'll give you my faith, my finances. Let's not talk about that. Sure, Lord, I'll give you part of my Sunday, but don't ask me to start, don't come for my Mondays.
16:25 Sure, Lord, I'll give you this thing, but not over here. Those things are mine. That is what Thomas is doing. That's what we're doing with that phrase, unless. And so what does Jesus do? Look at verse 26. It says a week later, the disciples were in the house again. The doors are locked again and Jesus appears. But this time he goes straight to Thomas, not to shame him, not to lecture him. He says, put your fingers here. See my hands here. Put your finger here. See my hands. Reach out your hand and put it into my side. And what does Thomas do? I find it endlessly interesting that the text doesn't say he touches him. And John, by the way, is super meticulous. Later on in this gospel, he talks about 153 fish being on the beach with Jesus and the disciples.
17:21 John loves to be descriptive of every minute detail. And so the fact that Thomas, who's asking to touch, doesn't actually touch, it means he didn't. It never takes place. which means he dropped his condition. He dropped his condition upon looking at Jesus. He doesn't pause to inspect. He doesn't say, let me, you know, let me break out my apparatus. Let me gather their data. He just cries out. What does he say? My Lord and my God. In verse 28, my Lord and my God. Notice the posture of belief is not asking you for certainty. I think we confuse that. I say this a lot to you all as congregants, that faith is not certainty. Again, we already said everybody trusts something. what real faith is though, is it's dropping your conditions.
18:21 Not because you stopped using your mind. Notice Jesus still addresses the intellectual problems that Thomas has. He validates Thomas's questions. No, the move though, that is being asked of us is this, is moving from a transactional contract of I'll believe if, unless. that is a contractual contract. That is a, sorry, that's a transactional contract. Moving from that to a covenantal, I'll believe because this is who you say you are. I'll believe because this is who you are. Will we be able to do that? Not because everything is explained, but because you end up trusting him more than anything else. folks what are your conditions for belief what's your posture what is the thing that is actually the barrier for you?
19:23 Non-Christians, they tend to be very specific and articulate exactly what those things are. But if you're a Christian here, you have those things too, and you might not even be cognizant of it. What are those things? Because our text is showing us this. You don't need that proof. Thomas didn't actually ultimately need it. So the question left is what would it take for you to drop your conditions? What is needed for you? That's what I want us to actually figure out. And so last point, the object of belief. Look at verse 27. Keep moving down. In verse 27, Jesus says, put right. He says, put your finger, See my hands. Reach out. And what I want us to ask, if you read this text enough, you realize, you start asking a question, wait a second. This is the resurrected Jesus.
20:14 Why does Jesus have wounds in his resurrected body? This man has conquered death. He's been through heaven and hell. He's here. He could appear in any way that he wants. In fact, a lot of scholars say that actually the assumption is that he would have appeared in some sort of perfected, glorious state. Instead, he shows up with wounds, which means there's something about the wounds that matter. There's something about those things that we need to see. what is that?
20:54 I believe it's because of suffering. Everybody in this room suffers. Everyone has or will. And I've said it before, but I want to say it again. There's only a few possibilities about how to handle suffering. That all the world faith and philosophies boil down to essentially five different ways of handling suffering. Number one is what secular humanism says, which is this. suffering is meaningless because ultimately there is no right and wrong. And so either you try to stoically suppress your feelings or express your feelings, but either way, ultimately, if the world was formed out of randomness and meaninglessness, and then when you die, there's really nothing after that. It's just meaninglessness. You can't have meaning in between. So suffering is just meaningless. It's just the way it is. the other view that's out there, second view is karma, Hinduism, the idea that if you're good, you'll get good things, and if you're bad, you'll get bad things. Now the problem with that is that we all know that there are many bad people who get good things, and there's many good people who get bad things. It doesn't work. Buddhism and Eastern philosophies roughly say that the problem out there is desire, that suffering is caused by desire. So solution, don't desire. The problem with that is that actually it invalidates your feelings. It doesn't make us more human, it makes us less by having to push away and detach. There's another view, it's more like a fatism. It believes that either God or God's or fate itself is in charge.
22:34 And you're just suffering because that's just the way it is and there's nothing that you can do about it. The problem with every single one of those four views, and again there's many more views that just boil down to those, is that every single one of them asks when suffering hits, that view or God keeps their hands clean while you bleed.
22:55 Christianity, the fifth view, is the only view I know of where God bleeds for you. He does not stay above it. He plunges himself into it. So contra-secularism, your suffering is not meaninglessness. God enters it himself. Contra-Eastern faiths, your suffering is not an illusion. It's real. It matters.
23:21 Contra fatism, God does not stay outside and distant from all your suffering. He enters into it. Contra karma, suffering is not always fair. But every single time, God plunges himself into it. He looks at our brokenness. He looks at the bleeding world that is around, and he's drawn into it. So every single loss that you felt, every loss, every hurt, he has too. Every injustice, every amount of abandonment that you've ever experienced, he has too. Every other belief system that I know of does this. It says, you must shed your blood. It is up to you to exert the effort to prove your worth, to earn your identity. It's all up to you.
24:13 New York City runs on this. What you put in is what you get out of the world. Only Christianity I know, only in the gospel does God shed his own blood. It's not your blood, it's his. And he comes back, not in a sanitized, perfect state, but he comes back with those marks of death still on his hands.
24:37 So go back to verse 27. Jesus comes to Thomas. He says, see my hands. He says, touch them. But realize this. How did Jesus know that Thomas needed that? He wasn't with Thomas a week ago. He wasn't in the same room. It must have meant that, again, somehow Jesus in his state had heard every single one of Thomas' needs. Every single one of his doubts. And the response is not a rebuke. It's an invitation.
25:13 Years ago when the Broadway show Dear Evan Hansen was still on Broadway, it became a movie as well. I went to a couple of those shows and there's this scene when Evan is this teenage boy who tells a bunch of lies. He ends up hurting everybody around him. And there's a scene when the lies have come out and he's doubled over. He's shaking. He's full of shame and self-hate and the me-centeredness, his selfishness, everything is now before him. And he believes his future is only going to be rejection. And he sits in front of his mother,
25:54 the mother that actually a lot of his hurt that he caused has landed on her. And she looks at him and says this, Evan, I know you. I know everything that you've done wrong. I see how much hurt that you have given me, that you've hurt me and hurt everyone else. And I still love you. And I will never leave you. And there is nothing that you can do to lose my love.
26:26 I went to a couple of those shows. I tell you, in that moment, there is never a dry eye in the audience. Never. And here's why. Because we're witnessing, just the witnessing of the transformational love of the mother. It moves us. Not just because we all want it. Not just because we all need it, but because there's a taste in that moment, particularly that it was given to someone who doesn't deserve it. And here's the best part, is that if a mother's love, limited and finite, and imperfect can do that, what would it do? What would it do if you and I truly understood and experienced and believed? that the God of the universe, in the person of Jesus, look down at all of our hidden shame, all of our me-centeredness, all of our selfishness that we pretend is just ambition.
27:19 And we pretend that it's just us having a hard work ethic. But ultimately, it's our three best friends are me, myself, and I. When the God of the universe sees all those things, knows you to the court and says, I'm going to die for him and her. I'm going to save them and love them for all of eternity. the deepest problem I think all of us have is that deep down in all of our hearts, no matter what you say, no matter where you are on the spectrum of belief, is that we think at the end of the day, what's most important is our commitment to God, my devotion to God, my love for God, and yet... If you look at Thomas, if you see this, his conditions were still there and Jesus still came for him.
28:12 Faith is not ultimately about your commitment to him. Real faith is your understanding how ultimately he was committed to you. faith is not so much about how much your heart is set on him. It's actually over time, deeply understanding how much his heart was always eternally set on you. Think of your own life. Think of all the places that you felt most abandoned, most alone. I think we can all go there. And what you're supposed to do, what this text is telling us is to look at his hands. look at his wounds. Because when you look at them, here's what they're saying. They're saying this, I never did abandon you. I was abandoned. I never did forsake you. I was forsaken. I never did leave you. This is proof that I went in, that I paid it.
29:09 And that's why Thomas doesn't touch. He doesn't touch. Because when you see that the price was paid, when you finally experience that, you don't need to put your finger in for verification. You just fall to the ground. And like Thomas, you would say, my Lord and my God. And what's beautiful about that phrase, a lot of people don't know, is that in all four of the gospels, that is the highest Christological confession of Jesus. That the person who had demanded the most proof at the sight of his wounds, all he could say is Lord and God. Kairos, Lord. Theos God What will you say? What can you say? What will you say? Jesus kept his wounds Because those marks are the message They're left for us For all of eternity For us to see Because every scar on the risen Christ Is proof of his love that he went in And so when you Start questioning, wondering And doubting If God cares, see his hands If you wonder if God is actually for you See his wounds If you wonder your place in this world.
30:24 See his love. Christianity does not give you a better philosophy for suffering. What it does is it offers you a God who bears the scars to end it, who comes back marked so that you and I can give up our conditions. Don't give up your mind. Don't give up your questions. Give up your conditions. and you will when you see his wounds. Because it's not about the intensity of how committed you are to him. That is not what we're looking for. It's about deeply experiencing and understanding how committed he is to you. Last point, or just to end, notice this all happens behind locked doors. I love this part is that the disciples were terrified. So what did they do? They locked the doors. They locked the world out.
31:15 They were scared of what the world might do to them. And you know what Jesus does? He doesn't wait for them to figure it out and say, hey, okay, I'm going to open up now. No, he walks straight through those doors and says, peace be with you. He offers them the peace that they were looking for. And because Jesus went in, because he took the nails and conquered the grave, that's what finally sends them out.
31:40 Folks, you and I, I mean, not to make too fine a point here, but we can be behind locked doors. We can shut the world out. We can be afraid of like what it might cost. And yet when we know that he's actually paid, that he bore the wounds for us, what exactly do we have to be afraid of anymore? He already took the worst the world could actually ever do. And that means you can handle today the cost of love in this world. You can step off the shore. You can walk on out. Whatever room you're in right now, folks, whether you're in a room of anxiety or grief or fear, maybe you're in a room of just quiet exhaustion because you've been living a life of performance that you were never meant to live. What this is saying here is that Jesus comes and stands in the middle of that room, see his hands, not for verification necessarily, see his hands because of what they're saying in those hands is it is finished.
32:43 You are not forgotten. You never were. And because of that, we can move out. We can go out and love and serve in ways that you didn't think you even had the ability to. We can love and serve others here in our midst, but also out in the world. Folks, I want us to be able to say and really experience. what Thomas did. Be able to say, my Lord and my God. The Apostles' Creed is not just some... statement that we merely recite. It is the basis by which we live from, that we serve from, that we move out from. And I'm looking forward to showing it with you, to work with it, with you. To declare at the beginning, I believe. Let's pray. Heavenly Father, help us to see the Apostles' Creed is not it's not just some old words, but it's a way to root ourselves into who we are.
33:44 Father, thank you for artificial intelligence because all it does is it forces us to ask the questions, what does it mean to be human? We've needed to ask that question because we don't ask it enough. We coast through life, but now we have to ask, what does it mean? Who am I? Where do we need to go? What's our purpose and meaning in life? Move in our hearts in profound ways. Show us your hands. help us to see the wounds so that we can move out and love and serve others we pray these things in your name
Machine translated from the source