Michael Keller · Redeemer Lincoln Square · Preached October 19, 2025
Berean Standard Bible.
1:25 Good morning and welcome again to Redeemer Lincoln Square. We've been going through a series about our vision. Our vision is to be rooted in God's love for the joy of the city. And we're looking at ways that this vision, that's the vision of our church, is why we exist, intersects with different parts of our lives. And today we get to ask the question, how do we live with our convictions among those who disagree? And I think culturally, the inflection point where we are culturally for our entire society, not just New York, but here in America, is we're in this moment where we're splitting into different tribes. We're fracturing, we're othering, we're moving further and further away from each other. And this is one of our largest cultural problems because how do we actually live together with people different from us?
2:26 So no matter what you believe, this is a question. Even if you're not religious here today, you feel this tension. You feel this question that's underneath everything else that we're about. And so what do we do? Well, the first thing we need to do is we need to realize everybody has convictions. Now, a lot of folks will push back and say, well, listen, you're overcomplicating it, Michael. You should just, you know, live your truth. You do you. But the question is, is what happens when your truth is diametrically opposed to someone else's truth? And this is where people kind of revise to say, okay, fine, live your truth as long as you don't harm anyone else.
3:09 But you have to be careful, because when you use that phrase, don't harm anyone else, you're actually smuggling in a moral view that you can't prove. Because what gives you, your definition of harm is different than somebody else's definition of harm. See, everybody's value at some point, the reason why, we have this assumption, oh, we just all know what actually is right and wrong, but then why are we fracturing? Because we don't. because there are these moral assumptions we're living on. And whatever that is, that means you're actually operating at some level by faith. And faith is just trust, which means the only question left that we have to ask is what are we trusting in that's going to allow us to live with each other? That's the question I want to ask today. And I think our text helps. It breaks down in three parts. Let's see three things.
4:02 The way of wisdom, the way of witness, and the way of wonder. I'll say it again. The way of witness. Sorry, the way of wisdom, the way of witness, and then the way of wonder. Okay, first, the way of wisdom. Look at our text here. This is from Deuteronomy chapter 4. And the context of our text is this is Moses. He's been leading the Israelites. They've been wandering in the desert for decades, a whole generation has died out since they've left Egypt. And they're at the very edge of the promised land. They're about to go in. And so this is the pep talk. This is the last thing that Moses is going to say to them before they go in. This is like the most important thing, sort of the highlights of what he wants them to remember. And if you go to verse five here, he says, listen, I've taught you these decrees. I've taught you these laws. And then he goes, go to verse six. He says, therefore, observe them carefully. In Hebrew, by the way, this is a double imperative. So I actually think a better translation would be, you should keep them and do them. It's a double emphatic. And whenever you see that in the Bible, something that's, you know, doubled, it means really pay attention. This is really important. Which then, of course, begs the question, why does Moses think this is so important to follow these decrees and observe them? Is it because, well, that's how you get God. That's why then God will love you better if you do that, right?
5:36 A lot of people think that's what religion is really about, that you just, you know, follow the decrees, follow the laws, and then maybe God will love you. But again, go back to this local context, and they already had God's love. God was literally present with them. He was, you know, leading them with a pillar of fire and a pillar of smoke. And so there must be something else. There must be another reason why you should follow the rules. And I think the reason is this. It's because Moses knew, he knew somehow, that if you did not make this your wisdom, you were going to idolize and make something else wisdom to you. That if you don't follow this wisdom, you're going to follow something else as wisdom. Professor Ronald Niebuhr, who was a professor of religion, but also culture, he actually did a talk in 1937, right before World War II, to a bunch of leaders, because he was trying to identify and show what are the main wisdoms of our culture.
6:43 And he says, hey, in 1937, he says, these are the four main wisdoms and ideologies that, I'm going to quote him, that tend to be an object of unconditional loyalty. I'm just going to make the list that he gives. These are his definitions. He says, one, there's romanticism, which idolizes the individual. This view holds up and says, hey, you do you, live your truth, follow your heart. Because at the end of the day, your individual desires is the highest good that you should follow. That's the most important thing. You should either do that in the free market or you should do that with self-expression, but it's always about you. It's you, the individual. Number two, there's rationalism. This makes an idol out of science and technology. It basically says that there is no higher power. There is no larger view of morality.
7:36 It's just what we can observe. And through science and technology, that's going to save us for humanity. Number three, you have the third thing Niebuhr identified is nationalism, which makes an idol out of race, out of your people group, out of a nation. It says allegiance to your insider group will save us from the threat of the outsider. Number four, socialism. Socialism is the idol of the state in identity politics. It basically says that you are where you are, not because of your individual choices. It says everything basically is because of systems of oppression that have put you where you are. And therefore, we need to disempower the powerful.
8:23 Now, every single one of these ideologies, here's what's difficult about them. They all have truth in them. that there is something good about the individual, right? The individual does matter. Science and technology are gifts. That there is, that to love your people group or love your nation, that's natural. That there actually is systemic injustice in the world based in systems. See, those are all truth, but where you get problems is when you hold up any of these good things as the ultimate thing and say, this is how I'm going to look. This is the prism I'm going to look through to see all of reality. That's where things break. Why? Because when you idolize and demonize something good but fallen, because it's what each one of these views does, is it idolizes something as good, right?
9:20 The individual, the science technology, the nation, the state, the systemic issues, It idolizes but also demonizes another group of people. Well, the problem is the collective. The problem are people that are not scientific. The problem are people who don't hold up their nation. It always idolizes and demonizes something else which then others other people and then other people are not just misplaced. They're your enemy. They're evil. and I think that's actually part of our problem. The reason why we're fracturing and not just, see, bars used to be full of people with different ideologies and they would sit down, have a drink, and they would talk it out. Now, people are literally geographically splitting and going to different places. We're not even talking to each other. So now go back to our text. The Israelites are about to go into the promised land. They're about to go into a place of competing ideologies and wisdoms. Not the exact same ones that we have today, but ones that Moses knew were going to be around them and he was asking them this question. He was saying, what wisdom are you using? Have you been thoughtful about what you're going to use to look at the rest of reality? And I think that's a fair question that we need to ask ourselves this morning. A summary, if you want to do a summary of all the biblical decrees, right? The Bible actually gives us that into the two great commandments.
10:46 Love the Lord your God with all your strength, heart, and mind, and love your neighbor as yourself. and if you hold those two almost all the other ones is summarized into that and life therefore is to apply that truth wisdom is to apply that truth into the complexities of the world. So let me give you an example. How about marriage? If you take marriage and look at it through the romantic individualist view that view basically says marriage is just a way to enhance your own personal fulfillment and therefore you should just find somebody who will center on you. And there are a lot of people, that's how they see marriage. Or you have the rationalist view. The rationalist view of marriage says, listen, marriage is just a construct. It's something, you know, science and reason basically says it's not real. So just, you know, love is love. Find whoever you want. Do your self-expression. You know, that's all that really matters.
11:39 The nationalist view says, listen, marriage is to basically keep the bloodline strong. Find somebody that looks like you and acts like you, has all your same views, and marry that person. Socialism says, listen, marriage at the end of the day is about bringing down the power structures. And so there's marriage, there's power structures in marriage. So find one, find somebody that you can do that with, and then unite and be allies to go out into the world to bring down the other power structures that are out there.
12:08 And yet the Bible comes in and says, listen, what's marriage? The Bible says marriage is the relationship that best actually depicts the Trinitarian love of God. that in the Trinity you have equality but difference. In marriage you have equality but different. And yet what you're supposed to do, if real love isn't about what you get, it's about what you get to give, then we should not be seeking our own happiness, we should be seeking the happiness of the other. And if everybody was actually seeking the happiness of the other, that would make life good. See, notice all the other ones, reductionistically, tries to ram these views, these major issues of marriage and life into these ideologies, whereas the Bible is not reductionistic. It treats us as we are meant to be treated. It aligns with reality itself because it was made by the one who made reality himself.
13:07 And so I want to just ask yourself before we move on, where are you getting your wisdom? We literally are living at a time when you get to compare and contrast the different competing wisdoms of the world. And I have faith that you all can make these, you can actually make these assessments and see which ones are actually depicting the reality the way that it should be depicted.
13:31 In Christianity, to be really clear, you're not saved by following biblical wisdom. But if you're saved by the creator, you're going to want to live in line with what it means to be created. that would mean following these decrees and living in line with them and that's what Moses is trying to say here and he's saying these decrees they show us what it means to live the ten commandments the two greatest commandments and if you don't follow this particular wisdom that's given here in the Bible you are whether you know it or not you're following some other wisdom for your hope for your trust and the question is how's that working out for you? because I believe it tends to idolize some things and demonize some things or some ones. And that's why we're fracturing. Okay, number two.
14:52 If that's the way of wisdom, right, to find wisdom. Secondly, look at our text again, the way of witness. This isn't just about wisdom. It's about witness. At verse 6, it says, observe them carefully. But why? Why? What does he go on and say? For this will show your wisdom and understanding to the nations. See, interestingly, he doesn't say, hey, follow this because then you'll be in. Follow this because I say so. He's saying, no, follow this because it'll be a witness to the nations.
15:30 See, he knows we live in a world of comparative wisdoms. And he's saying, if you actually live this out, you will show the goodness of this biblical wisdom. I think, stop for a second. I think a lot of people today believe if you live out a distinctly Christian life in this world, if people know that you are Christians, a lot of people think that's going to, that's, that's, that's sort of arrogant. Because it imposes your morality out on the world. And so what our culture says is that tolerance means never claiming that your way is actually better. Of course, the problem with that is that the minute you say, hey, you shouldn't claim that your view is better, that's a view that's saying that view is better. And so it does the very thing it says that you shouldn't do. And this is my main problem with our culture is that it says, hey, you shouldn't push your morals on other people.
16:24 But the minute you say that, you're pushing a very particular Western individualistic view that you shouldn't push your morals on people. my point is this you can't get away from living out your life the minute you move outside these doors and wear a certain thing or act a certain way, you are literally showing what you believe you're actually showing your truth of how you think you should live and therefore we need to ask ourselves what truth are we living out see real tolerance is not you know, hiding what you believe. It's actually living out what you believe, but doing it in a way that actually serves your neighbor's good and not just your own. I think that's one of the ways that you can tell and evaluate these wisdoms. See, look back at our text. Moses doesn't say, hey, just preach to the nations. Just tell them what you think. He says what? He says, live. Observe them. Right? For this will show you the wisdom.
17:31 Live it out. And maybe be very careful. He's not saying perform. He's not saying, hey, just pretend. Living here in New York, I know that New Yorkers can sense out inauthenticity. We can smell if somebody's being hospitable and nice just out of pleasantries. Moses is saying no don't do that he's saying that the only thing that will give credibility to the idea that there really is a God and that he really did come and that he really is here is if we live with and for each other communally if we actually live this out which is part of our vision to do it together telling people the truth is nice but living out the truth is better because if you go back to the history of how the early church operated, it was the way they were living, the early church, the way they were living, people started saying, I want that.
18:28 Something about that is different. Something about that changes things. And that's the power of witness. And without it, why would the world should, why should the world take our words if they have no impact on how we treat others? Years ago, there was a memoir that came out actually recently, but years ago, a man named Tom Skinner, who is an African-American raised here in New York City. In his memoir, he talked about how when he first became a Christian, I think it was around high school, he had heard, you know, growing up about love your neighbor and turn the other cheek. He'd heard that stuff before, but it didn't have a real impact on his life. and he talks about how it wasn't until he was playing a football game and he was blocking I think in one play and he made a really really great block against the opposing team and that player took umbrage against that block, got up, started screaming at him, punched him, started calling him racial slurs and Tom Skinner says you know what he would have done previously, before his conversion Tom said listen I would have destroyed this boy I would have just completely annihilated him.
19:44 And yet after he became a Christian, he was able to say very calmly, looking at him, this boy, what he did, the meanness, the anger, the rage, the racial slurs, he looks at him and says, you know what, I love you. And because of Jesus, and what Jesus did for me, and I love you anyway.
20:05 After the game, Tom was coming out of his locker room, and that boy was right there, and he said this to him. because Tom wrote it down. He said, Tom, you've done more to knock prejudice out of me by telling me that you loved me than you would have if you had socked me in the jaw. Now, why is that? It's because the boy knew. He knew, he's like, I deserve to be socked. I deserved that. That's how the world works.
20:32 But he got grace instead and that changed his heart. And it can change yours if we let this actually into our own heart. it's the way of witness to the nations because why? because how do the nations work? how do we usually work this way? if you sock me I'm going to sock you if you hit me I'm going to hit you
20:52 And yet that's why this is so impactful because it's a witness because folks, we're always looking at each other. We're always seeing each other. Back when I was doing college ministry years ago, I met up with a student who was a student leader of another ministry. I was like, okay, why are you meeting up? Why do you want to meet up? Okay. We get coffee, and he started telling me about how he was going to leave this other ministry that he was a leader of because the staff worker who was paid, who was outside of college, who was a great speaker, very charismatic, he had gotten to know this staff leader and he says, I know actually how he treats people, his friends, his marriage, his kids. He ignores them. He belittles them. He makes snide remarks about him. And so when I listen to him, when I see him, I can't stand him. I'm gone, I'm out you know what my first reaction was?
21:48 my first reaction was hey, here are my kids look how beautiful they are I love my wife she's great now why did I do that? because I very acutely in that moment felt watched and the truth is this is that we're always being watched the social media world knows we like to watch people which is why it's always funny when people say oh you know Christians, you know witnessing I don't know how I feel about that I don't want to witness as a Christian guess what? you're always witnessing the question is what are you witnessing with?
22:27 or what wisdom are you witnessing with? that's the question because we're always witnessing is it these decrees or is it some other ideology? is it some other set of statements? All right, lastly, it's the way of wonder. What does Moses think will allow us to witness to the nations? All right, keep going through our text. We're walking through it. Look at verse 7. Moses says this. He says, what other nation is so great as to have their God, their gods near them, the way the Lord our God is near us whenever we pray to him? This is a profound statement. I'll say it again. What other nation is so great to have their God near them the way the Lord our God is near us whenever we pray to him. You see, for Moses, the difference is the nearness of God. He must have been thinking about all the times that God was showing up in a pillar of smoke or a pillar of fire. He must have been thinking about his own experience of the burning bush.
23:30 And so what Moses is doing here is he's saying, listen, I know that God is near. And what's beautiful about this in the sort of history of redemptive truth that we find in the Bible is as near as Moses knew how God was here, we actually know he's actually even nearer, don't we? Think about what it took for God to get near to you. You have to dwell on this.
23:56 God didn't just come near to us. God became us. The incarnation is the moment that God came in the flesh so that he could be both holy and gracious at the same time. Holy because he had to actually take the penalty of sin. Gracious because he's the one who does it and pays for himself. Now, I know that word sin is a word a lot of people don't associate, so we have to kind of unpack that for a little bit. It's a foreign concept. When I talk about sin we're not talking about just bad things. People always define sin as doing bad things. Biblical sin is not just bad things. It's anything that we make ultimate and more important than God, which by the way is often good things. Think about all the good things that you can take in the world, right? Power, approval, comfort, control. Those are good things, but when you make them ultimate, that's when we break. If you take individualism and rationalism and nationalism and socialism, these are good things, but you take them ultimately, they break.
25:01 It's fine to want approval. Approval is okay. But when you can't live unless you have it, that's when it kills you. That's when it breaks. And so sin isn't just bad things. It's good things that you've made too important. And guess what? Every single one of us in this room, at some point or in some places in our life, every day, we're doing that. We're prioritizing ourself. We're prioritizing our values. We're prioritizing something that's too important. And so what Jesus does is he says, listen, whether you know that or not, you're actually hurting yourself and you're hurting others. And so I've come to die for that. On the cross, the consequences for breaking the law that we deserve get poured out on him so that we can get the blessings that he deserves. He's come near. So the last question left is this, is do we want to come near to him? the night before Jesus died he washed his disciples feet in John 13 but right after that he says this phrase that I think a lot of people don't dwell on enough.
26:03 he says a new command I give you, love one another as I have loved you. why? by this everyone will know that you are my disciples if you love one another this is powerful because what Jesus is saying is this the way Christians should be known in the world it's not primarily through your doctrinal precision it's not primarily through your moral superiority it's not primarily through anything else other than how you love each other being communal which is a love being modeled on his love which is, you know, how did he love us? He died for us and that's by the way this is where wonder comes in this is why this can be a wonder wonder is when you just take the time to say, listen the same God who dwelled in the temple the same God who walked in the cool of the Garden of Eden, the same God who spoke on Mount Sinai, that God now dwells with us.
27:02 That's what we have with the Holy Spirit. That the key to getting this wonder is to not believe conceptually that God died for humanity. The key is to experientially, personally say, he died for me and my mess, my specific mess. And so now we don't obey and follow his decrees so that God will come near. We obey because we know he already is near. We don't obey to get his acceptance. We're already accepted. And so now we want to live out the decrees. We don't love to get God's blessing. It's because we already have his blessing.
27:43 That's a fundamentally different way than every ideology that I know. Every other ideology says you have to obey and do it and follow it and perform and succeed and act. That's how the world works. And yet what you see here is God's already come near to you. before you even asked for it, before you even knew you needed it.
28:04 So the only thing keeping you from him right now is, do you even want to get near to him? That's the only thing that's keeping us. The God who came near doesn't look at you and say, clean up your life and then you can come near to me. Think what it cost for him to get near to you. Go back to our text. And what you have here is Israel. He's about to go into the promised land, a land filled with these competing ideologies, the Canaanites, the Jebusites, the Amorites, all these other ideologies. You know what ends up happening? They go in. And they fail. At actually holding on to their wisdom. They fail over and over and over again. And so they're eventually exiled. They're eventually cast out. And we don't know the answer of what will ever bring them back in until Jesus shows up and becomes the ultimate exile, being cast out so that we could be brought in. Folks, let the Father's presence that we now have access through, through Jesus, move you. On that cross, Jesus' hands weren't just open to you. They were nailed open for you.
29:14 unable to close him, unable to protect himself, unable. He did not come down from that cross. You know why? Because by doing so, now you can go up and be near, not just to him, but to our Lord as well. And when we grasp that, that's when we have our life changed and we will be able to have our hands open to this city and move out into this world, despite what nails and things people throw at us. Now, even though we're surrounded by competing wisdoms and ideologies, which have aspects of truth. We don't have to fully throw ourselves into any of them, knowing that none of them offer what we are actually being given. in the presence and nearness of God. So folks, what are you struggling with today? What addiction are you hiding? What relationship that's still broken? What achievement that you think will be enough?
30:08 What fear that keeps you up at night? What shame that you can't get yourself over? whatever that is, Jesus is already near to us in that. He's not waiting for you to fix that to come to him. Why are you waiting to have it fixed to go to him? What are you waiting for? Make this your identity. Make this your purpose and your reality. And if we did, let me just give you one practical application. If we lived as if God was near to us, when you're tempted to demonize that other group or that other person, that co-worker who has it out for you, that family member who votes differently from you, that person who you just can't stand, whatever it is, when you know that God came near to you, to the people who killed him, and you place at the core of your life, the core of Christianity is a man who dies for his enemies, and if you place at the core of your life, you will die for your enemies too.
31:06 And that will change the world, and it will change you, and it's completely different than how anyone else lives. That's real wisdom. I've been re-watching the first season of Ted Lasso and I love this scene where when Roy Kent, he's a washed up athlete, he's not as fast, not as good and he's having this identity crisis because his whole life had been built on, I knew who I was because I was the soccer player. But now, what am I? and his friend tries to help him by bringing his six-year-old niece and asks the six-year-old niece, hey, when you think of your uncle, what do you think of? And this is what she says. She says, his beard is scratchy, he's funny, and I love him.
31:56 And I love that because it's not based on what he's done. It's not based on his performance or what he's going to do for her. It's just who he is. and it's beautiful and yet it wasn't enough. Not in the show and not in real life because it's just a six-year-old girl. It doesn't matter if it's a six-year-old or a six-year-old or whoever. It's never going to be enough unless the God who's near looks you in the face and says, I see you and I know everything about you. I know more than even you know about yourself.
32:30 And I'm not pushing you away. I brought you further in. I've loved you and accepted you in the person of Christ. Folks, it's the only way that I know of to have a balance and to have a presence and to have an ability. to not divide and to not go out there and not to get into these other ideologies, to understand all of them, to appreciate some of them.
32:52 And yet sit yourself and situate yourself on the acceptance of Christ. Make this your identity. Make this your purpose and hope. And let's do it together. Let's do it communally. And we'll take this wisdom and live it out and it'll be a witness to the world. And while we see him, then we'll be able to sit in wonder and sit in joy. I want to do it with you. Let's do it together. Let's pray. Heavenly Father. everybody in this room is coming from different places. We're tired. I'm tired. We're all tired. We have these different... things in our life that are begging for attention. A lot of them are important.
33:39 I pray that we would see that none of them are so important as us to see how you've come near to us. Like Moses, begging us to observe them and hold these decrees, not out of obediences to get salvation. No, because we've already been saved and loved. and this is how to live in line with how we were created. Help us to do that. Help us to be curious. Many of us are not curious to open the Bible and just say, Lord, what do you have to say to me? We're not curious enough to just pray. We don't even know where to start, but help us to start saying, Lord, I pray. I pray that I don't know how to pray. Help me to pray.
34:19 I pray that we would feel confident and close enough and near enough to you because we already know that you're near to us. Turn our hearts and minds towards you in all that we do.
Machine translated from the source