Living in Truth and Love

Pete Nicholas · Redeemer Downtown · Published February 9, 2025

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Matthew 5:33-48 0:44
33Again, you have heard that it was said to the ancients, ‘Do not break your oath, but fulfill your vows to the Lord.’ 34But I tell you not to swear at all: either by heaven, for it is God’s throne; 35or by the earth, for it is His footstool; or by Jerusalem, for it is the city of the great King. 36Nor should you swear by your head, for you cannot make a single hair white or black. 37Simply let your ‘Yes’ be ‘Yes,’ and your ‘No,’ ‘No.’ Anything more comes from the evil one. 38You have heard that it was said, ‘Eye for eye and tooth for tooth.’ 39But I tell you not to resist an evil person. If someone slaps you on your right cheek, turn to him the other also; 40if someone wants to sue you and take your tunic, let him have your cloak as well; 41and if someone forces you to go one mile, go with him two miles. 42Give to the one who asks you, and do not turn away from the one who wants to borrow from you. 43You have heard that it was said, ‘Love your neighbor’ and ‘Hate your enemy.’ 44But I tell you, love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, 45that you may be sons of your Father in heaven. He causes His sun to rise on the evil and the good, and sends rain on the righteous and the unrighteous. 46If you love those who love you, what reward will you get? Do not even tax collectors do the same? 47And if you greet only your brothers, what are you doing more than others? Do not even Gentiles do the same? 48Be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

3:33 Well, we're continuing the sermon series in the Sermon on the Mount, and we're thinking today about the issues of living in truth, living in peace, and living in love. I don't know as the passage was being read what you thought of it, but initially that first part about oath seems to be of a kind of historical... anachronistic importance but not relevant to us today. But actually, it's all about our relationship to truth. And I think when you start thinking about that, you can see that there's going to be some important things for us to think about today. Similarly, as we think about the issue of justice, which is a huge concern today, and the issue of peace, these are very live issues, and Jesus' teaching here is right on point. Now, in Dostoevsky's great novel, Crime and Punishment, the main protagonist in the story, Raskolnikov, towards the end, has a dream. And it's a dream which more than one kind of social commentator has pointed out was prescient and really does go a fair way to helping us understand a lot that's going on in our culture at the moment. and let me give you a praise of it.

4:34 The whole world in this dream was desolated by an unknown and terrible plague, Dostoevsky writes. Persons affected became immediately mad, but strange to say the stricken were at the same time imbued with a strong sense of their own good judgment. Never did they believe themselves so strongly, endowed with wisdom and vigor or scientific conclusions and moral perceptions that were as correct as they had now. Each believed themselves the sole possessor of truth. And looking upon their unenlightened neighbors, they beat their breasts, they threw up their arms, and they wept. They couldn't agree on anything. They knew not what to consider evil. What good. And so they fell upon one another in anger and killed. They formed great armies. But once in motion, they tore each other to pieces. In the towns, the alarm was great. Meetings were called. But for what? And by whom? No one knew. People gathered in crowds, agreed upon a common action, swearing never to abandon one another, then immediately rushed to something else, forgot their agreement, and ended in rushing upon and murdering each other.

5:43 It's a nightmare for Dostoevsky, of course, but it does have more than a resonance to today. Of course, not the killing one another part, that's deliberate exaggeration on the part of the dream, but this idea of everyone being sure that they're right. People getting together and forming agreements, then rushing into battle on social media to tear people down, only to realize that they're tearing the very group that they were just committed to down as well in it. Everyone's wrong. Apart from me, I'm right. but I'm not so sure what I'm right about. The relationship to truth today is very slippery. And how it then translates into our pursuit of justice, one of our great concerns today, and our lack of peace and love in that is very, very real. So let's look at this teaching from Jesus. We're going to take those in three parts. First of all, living in truth. Secondly, living in peace. And thirdly, living in love. And we'll see what Jesus has to say to us today.

6:37 Now, he's continuing to articulate this life of the kingdom that, as he said in chapter 5, verse 20, is one which should exceed the righteousness of the Pharisees. And so what Jesus does in this part of the Sermon on the Mount is he has this style of saying, you have heard it said, but now I say to you. And he says it six times. We've seen the first three in that is about anger and murder, about sexual integrity and about divorce. And now he's going to think about oaths and truth, peace and justice, and ending on love. And his aim in all of this is to take the Old Testament teaching as articulated by the teachers of the law of the day. and not to override it, not to throw it away, but to fulfill it, that is to take it to its logical conclusion, show you where it was always pointing, to show the richer, fuller spiritual life of the kingdom of heaven that Jesus has come to bring about, the fulfillment of the Old Testament, the foundations laid in the Old Testament, now the full architecture of the house articulated in his teaching and shown in Jesus' life.

7:47 And so he starts with oaths. Verse 33, you have heard that it was said to the people long ago, do not break your oath, but fulfill to the Lord the vows you have made. Now, we need to understand a little bit what's going on here. In Leviticus 19, God emphasizes the importance of being truthful. And therefore, for a people who are living within a theocracy, that is a kind of religiously ruled government, oath-making before God was the key area where truth was worked out. And what had happened was that the Pharisees were teaching that it's very important to keep your oaths, but there are different types of oaths. And depending on what you swear by, there were different levels of how binding that oath was. So, for example, to swear by heaven, where God symbolically dwells, is the most binding of all oaths. But to swear by earth, where God, well, you know, he doesn't symbolically dwell on earth in the same way, or at least only in the temple, would not be as important. And so you would have a situation where, for example, someone would vow by earth that they will pay you back what they owe. And then you come to collect your debt, and they say, ah, the problem is, is my family's in financial distress. And because I only swore by earth, not by heaven, it's not completely binding. So the Pharisees have said to me that I don't have to pay it back because I have to honor my family as well. And so suddenly someone scratching their head saying, well, hang on, was it an oath or wasn't an oath? It was a religiously manipulative way of being fast and loose with the truth. Now, we don't do that today, but I do hazard a guess that we are fast and loose with the truth. You know, we live in what has been described as a post-truth age. I've frequently commented on this. That doesn't mean that we're over truth, we just want deceit and lies. It rather means that we decide that we are the arbiters of what is true. I am the source of truth. You can't tell me what's true, it's true for me.

9:43 I'm entitled to my opinion is one of the great phrases we use when, of course, no one's really questioning whether you're entitled to an opinion. They're questioning whether the opinion is right or valid or true, right? Post-truth age. And the problem with that is to say that all truth is subjective, is down to the opinion of the person, is itself a self-defeating statement, right? I mean, ultimately, if all truth is subjective, is that statement subjective? Because if that statement is subjective, then you're overreaching because you've just said all truth is subjective, which talks about everybody else's truth. So, of course, we can't live in a subjective world. The judo flip of that kind of logic just doesn't work. But we instead rail and say, well, I'm entitled to my opinion and no one gets to question me and I hold to my fortress of truth. And one of the ways I think we see this today is we see it in the rise of opinions versus journalism. I was talking with a member of our congregation just a bit over a week ago, and I was commenting on how I've noticed, and more than one person has noticed, that in journalism, it matters now seemingly less what is true and more whether it's entertaining.

10:52 And this person who works in journalism said, yes, the serious investigative journalist is increasingly a rare commodity. Not because journalists don't want the truth, but because it doesn't sell as well. The rather salacious revelation or opinion or the entertaining opinion is more saleable than the truth. And the slow work of doing the investigation to find out what the truth is behind it, the type of thing that exposed things like Watergate, is no longer really the thing that's going to sell. Far better to write a quick headline with an overstated opinion, and if you have to, issue a small retraction on the back page ten days later, that no one's going to read anyway. You'll sell more papers.

11:37 Truth has become a casualty of our pursuit of our opinions or justice even. Truth seems to matter less. But the problem is, of course, if we give up on truth, then we really have no such thing as justice. We really will not have any such thing as peace. Alexander Solzhenitsyn, the Russian dissident who spent much of his adult life campaigning against the lies of the propaganda of Stalin's Russia, once said, one word of truth outweighs a whole world of lies. And it was just one word of truth. I wonder, do we value it that much? Now, let me try to bring this down to detail for us. I think the way that we see this is we see this in that we are no longer as committed to truth in our personal interactions. And so we think it's more important that we state an opinion, share something, and particularly if it's on the cause of being right, because after all, the other side is always wrong, then we just share it. We don't really question, is it truthful?

12:36 So we pass on rumors without doing the due diligence to really cross-check and see if they're accurate. We shave the truth in personal interactions. We exaggerate a story that makes ourselves look good, and we overplay a fault of another person if it makes them look bad, and ultimately they're the one who's wrong in the situation anyway, so there's kind of fair game with collateral, right? I mean, ultimately, we're pursuing justice. But I hope you can see how dangerous that is. And Jesus is saying here that he raises the bar on truth. First of all, he's implicitly rebuking the teachers of the law for trying to grade out truth and say that sometimes you need to be committed to truth and other times not. In Leviticus 19, the whole point is that we should always be committed to truth. He says in verse 33, fulfill to the Lord the vows you have made. Now, what's interesting about that is, of course, when you make a vow, you think you're making it to another person. But Jesus reminds us that when you're speaking to people, you're making a commitment with your words, and God is the one who's really involved. Fulfill to the Lord the vows you have made. My vow to you, my word of truth to you, is not just between me and you, it's between me and God. He will hold me to account for truth, and he sees all truth. Truth is not subjective. It is objective. There is a clear standard. There is right and wrong.

13:57 And God is the one to whom we will one day all have to give an account. Jesus' words, what has been whispered in secret, we shouted from the rooftops. Don't think that your private opinions are so private after all. Are they true? Secondly, Jesus says, God is in control. He talks about in verse 35 that it is the city of the great king when you swear. Now, he's emphasizing the city there because the city was one of the things that people would say, well, it was a lesser vow. And Jesus says, no, it's God's city. In other words, everything is God's. All truth is God's truth, and God is in control of everything. And I think this gets right to the psyche of why we play fast and loose with the truth. We play fast and loose with the truth, I think, because we want to be in control. I've decided that I'm going to tell the story my way, and I'm going to exaggerate it to make me look good. And I do that because I want to control your perception of me, and I don't trust that God's truth and letting God be in control of how you perceive me is enough. So I exaggerate and I just cast off in my mind as well as a little half truth or a white lie. I mean, it's not a big thing. It's just a story, right? Or I don't like someone else and so I exaggerate about them, but it's broadly true. I don't have to be accurate. Now, I was in a conversation not so long ago where a guy was telling a story, and about two minutes after he finished the story, he interrupted the conversation. He said, Pete, I'm really sorry. I just need to say sorry. I didn't tell the full truth when I was telling the story. It was astonishing to me.

15:28 Not that he had lied. That wasn't astonishing at all. But that was the first time I think I can ever remember anyone doing that, having the humility to correct themselves in front of other people. And my estimation of him and my trust in him went up, not down, because I suddenly thought, here's a person committed to truth. So committed he's prepared to be open a little bit of shame publicly to actually show his concern for truth. Here's a person who understands God's sovereignty. Would that I would do the same? God is in control of all truth, and therefore we need to think carefully about how we steward truth. Yes, you are entitled to your opinion, but dare I ask, is it true? Or are you just sharing an opinion just for the sake of it and doing damage and saying, well, who cares? Now, before I move on, let me just do a brief sidebar because I can imagine that in a thoughtful congregation like this, someone will come up to me afterwards and say, what about the Anne Frank scenario? What about you're hiding some Jews from the Nazis and they come knock at your door and they say, are you hiding Jews? Are you allowed to lie then? Okay, let me deal with that very briefly. First of all, I don't think many of us are going to be in that situation, right? So my concern with you asking that question is whether or not you're just trying to find a way of getting out of your utter commitment to the truth. I'm sure you're not.

16:47 I'm sure you're very intellectually honest. But just in case someone was, let me restate, God is raising the bar on truth. Let your yes be yes and your no be a no. In all situations, that's the first thing. Secondly, yes, I do think, according to Scripture, in some very limited, limited, watch the inner Pharisee, limited scenarios that you see someone commended for helping someone in need, even when it needs them lying. So you think of the midwives in Exodus when they're ordered by Pharaoh to kill the Jewish children, and they don't, and they lie about it because they are protecting life, which is the summum bonum, the greatest good. And therefore, in that situation, you don't have to give in to the deception of the Pharaoh. Ruth, similarly, when she hides the spies in the land of Canaan. Both groups are commended and blessed, which is usually Scripture's way of saying that they did right. But that does not give you a carte blanche, let me say again, to shave the truth in your lesser scenario and say, well, you know, it helped me get the promotion. That's between you and God. Okay, let your less BS and your no be no, living in truth.

17:54 Secondly, let's think a bit more briefly about living in peace. From truth to peace, verse 38. You have heard that it was said, eye for an eye and tooth for a tooth. But I tell you, do not resist an evil person. If anyone slaps you on the right cheek, turn to them the other cheek also. What do we make of this? Well, the eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth, I would go as far as to say one of the most misunderstood things that the Bible says is the law of lex talionis, law of just retribution as it's known. And it was never intended, and indeed it never was used, as a thing for a personal vendetta of revenge. It was always a social principle, and actually it's a principle that is about restraining people in terms of when it comes to action. It's a principle of proportionality which all of Western legal systems are founded upon. So proportionality, that actually the punishment needs to fit the crime, is really important because in the ancient world, then there were all kinds of other considerations. And for example, kings would like to be overly harsh because it frightened the populace and was a way of controlling. This was saying, no, the punishment must fix the crime. And so it was about social justice, not about you going out and seeking your personal vendetta and revenge, first thing. Secondly, Jesus here is affirming that principle of proportionality and taking it on. He's saying that when it comes to our pursuit of justice, we need to not only pursue justice, but we also need to pursue justice and peace at the same time. Let me try to show you how he's doing that. He's doing that here because when he says, I tell you, do not resist an evil person. If anyone slaps you on the right cheek, turn them to the other cheek also. There's a couple of really important nuances here. Resist here does not mean just be a doormat. That's how it's often read. That is not what he's saying. The word for resist here is violent resistance or opposition where you seek to oppose a person. It's a posture of being against someone. That is what Jesus is saying we shouldn't have. A posture of justice

19:59 and peace is not to be against someone. I can be for you and yet long for you to come to justice, right? That's different. Hatred is trying to tear you down. Justice, properly understood, is to be for you and to seek peace. And when he says, if anyone slaps you on the right cheek, just think about this for a moment. I don't recommend you act this out, though. Maybe my children might after the service. If someone tries to slap you on the right cheek and they're predominantly right-handed, they don't do it with an open palm. Slapping someone on the right cheek when you feel right-handed is a back-handed slap. And the commentators point out that that was a way in the ancient culture of treating someone as less than human. It was the way slaves were slapped. They would never be slapped with an open palm. that was only for free people, you would slap a slave, treat them like a dog or an animal with the back of the palm. So when Jesus says, if someone slaps you on the right cheek, turn to the other cheek, notice he's not saying, allow them slap you again in the same way on the same cheek.

21:00 He's not saying that, nor is he going to the other extreme and saying, smack them back, slap them back. He's not saying that either. He's doing something different. He's subverting it. He's saying, they are not treating you as a human being. They are looking down on you and they are being violent towards you. Don't strike them back, but raise yourself up with dignity. Recognize you're made in the image of God and say, you will not slap me and put me down. If you're going to strike me, you're going to strike me as a human being, woman to woman, man to man. I will not seek to tear you down, but I'm not going to be a doormat. It's actually dignifying and peaceable because you're saying you're not going to slap me with the back of your hand again. Now, of course, it's hyperbole. He's not intending us to go out and actually seek to be slapped or to do that. He's saying when someone pushes you down, recognize your God-given dignity. But as you inhabit your God-given dignity, don't seek to tear them down also, which merely perpetuates the cycle of violence.

22:01 This is the principle of nonviolence. And how important in Black History Month that we're talking about this. This passage and the prophets of the Old Testament was where Martin Luther King Jr. deduced his practice of nonviolence from, where he said, nonviolence is a powerful and just weapon which cuts without wounding and ennobles the person who wields it. Notice, it is a sword that heals.

22:30 Now, we need to remember that towards the end of Martin Luther King Jr.'s life, his path of nonviolence was no longer popular. I think we forget that, because after he died, we've turned him into a secular saint and so we think that everything he did was loved by everybody at the time. It wasn't. The last five years or so he was seen as too old his methods didn't work and actually people were choosing the path of violence instead. That's why the black power movement rose up and was younger, cooler, sexier and promised results. Results that Martin Luther King Jr. did not get in his lifetime. And so people were happy to trade the path of non-violence to rather seek violence at least in word if not in deed to get results. That to me sounds a lot like us today. I see it on the college campuses. We have young adults who are hungry for results, who are fed up with the injustice, but have maybe not yet done the work in community to realize that the way you try to win justice, will frame the type of justice you get.

23:31 If you try to win justice with the violence of your words, that's the type of justice you're going to create. Non-violence in this way, seeking the peace and the good of the other whilst calling out their wrongdoing yields to a peace of justice, yes, but restoration as well.

23:53 Seeking peace through violence leads to a scorched earth policy where no one wins. Let me just say, as I said last week, if you're a person who is being hit by anyone in a regular or even in a one-off way in a situation of abuse. This is never giving a mandate for you to stay in that relationship. and to be perpetually abused. Please talk to us. We're here to support you. This is not what this is talking about. This is talking about seeking peace, and there is no peace without justice. And so the person who's doing that to you needs to be brought to justice. for their good and certainly for yours. So please talk to someone afterwards. But it is worth us saying, are we going to pursue the costly, slow, often unexciting path of non-violence? Or are we going to seek violence in our words, tearing the other side down and leaving nothing but a scorchers policy? That's an application for us today, which leads us finally to living in love, verse 43 and 45. You have heard that it was said, love your neighbor and hate your enemy, but I tell you, love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, that you may be children of your Father in heaven. Now, in the Old Testament, there was a command, of course, to love your neighbor. There was never a command to hate your enemy. But what happened was the Pharisees restricted the application of the command to love your neighbor to only certain people who were like you, who were Jews, and who shared their particular beliefs. And therefore, everyone else, you were free from loving them. And so, de facto, you could love your enemies, particularly, I'm sure the Jews were thinking of here, the Romans, who were the occupying power. And Jesus says, no. He says, look, your Father in heaven, verse 45, causes the sun to rise and the evil and the good.

25:33 In other words, your father seeks the good of everyone and your aim is to be like your father in heaven. Therefore, you are to love everyone, even your enemies. Now, I know that some of you sitting here this morning have enemies. Someone at work, maybe, who's trying to get ahead and pushing you down. Someone in your personal life, maybe once a friend or someone in your social circle you've fallen out with and now they are at enmity with you. And you're thinking, really? Am I really called to love them? Well, let me talk a little bit about this. The rubber really hits the road here when we talk of forgiveness, because loving someone who is your enemy comes down to your ability to forgive them. And one of the things that's controversial today is that people have been told that forgiveness is actually, goes back to the being a doormat, is you being treated as a doormat. I was talking to my predecessor at Redeemer Downtown, John Lynn, the other day, who is the theologian of residence at Harvard Law, and he was doing a seminar on forgiveness.

26:32 And one of the things consistently that the students said there was that they said that being told to forgive is a tool manipulated by the colonizing oppressors to keep the minority group down. And it keeps them in the mud. And therefore, it's all a game. No, they need to be raised up. They need to take power, even by violence, if needs be. And with that position of power, now they can institute justice.

26:59 There's no justice that way. Let me just say this. Forgiveness isn't being oppressed. Forgiveness is actually empowering. Why? If you refuse to forgive someone, then you're already giving them power over you. They've wronged you, yeah. But what are you going to do with that? If you are seeking to get them back, you are merely acting out of what they've done for you, they're still controlling you. They've still got power over you. If you can't give up your anger, than they are having the last word in your life. The anger you carry around, the poison inside your system being brought about by them, they are now forcing you to carry it. No, forgiveness is empowering because you say, I'm gonna give up to the Lord this. I'm gonna entrust other people with justice. I'm not gonna be controlled by them anymore. It's the opposite of being oppressed. Forgiveness is empowering as you inhabit your God-given dignity and you make the choice as a free moral agent to raise yourself above the way they've treated you and to institute a new dynamic.

28:03 It's you taking control, saying they chose violence. I'm going to choose a better way, a higher way, a way of love. So when you choose to forgive and love your enemies, you're actually no longer being oppressed by them. You are free from them finally. Now I know it's not simple. I know it's not a one-day solution. it often takes many, many years of prayer and thoughtful work. And it certainly usually involves justice, of that person being brought to justice, if possible as well. But even if justice isn't available, you can still make the path of forgiveness. You might say, how on earth can I do that, Pete? I mean, is this realistic? How can anyone do this? Please know, none of this, living a life of truth, living a life of peace, and living a life of love is possible in your own power. You cannot do it. It's Super Bowl weekend, so you'll have to indulge me in a sports illustration. It would be a little bit like someone coming to me and saying, Pete, the Eagles are short of a linebacker this evening. You're subbed in. Off you go. How do you think I'd do? It'd be terrible, right? I can't do it. I've not got the ability. But if someone who was the perfect linebacker, If someone who had all the physical attributes could suddenly take my place and do it for me, well then the team would be able to win.

29:27 Jesus Christ does not come to you and say, you've got to live this life. You've got to do it in your own strength. You can never do that. Instead, he steps in and says, I will do it for you. He is the prince of peace and he chose the path of peace for you, going to the cross for all of the ways we've committed violence in our words or our actions. so that we might be restored. He is the king of truth who is so committed to truth that He's prepared to die on a cross for our lies. and for the ways we frequently shave the truth or exaggerate the truth and not cared about the truth enough. He is the Lord of love who when he's on the cross cries out, my God, my God, why have you forsaken me? And then looks at the people in that God forsaken moment and says, Father, forgive them. They do not know what they're doing.

30:15 he dies for all of your lies. He dies for your path of violence. He dies the ways that you are enmity with God and with other people to bring you into a new life of truth and peace and love. And when you get that, then his spirit comes into your life and empowers you to start to live differently. There is no other way to do this. You cannot do this in your own strength, but to the extent that you remember all that he's done for you, and to the extent that his spirit is empowering you and inside you, he will change you from the inside out. That's what it means for him to be the fulfillment of this teaching. he did it he lived it and now his spirit is alive and inside you if you trust in him so that you can do it too and so therefore will you seek truth will you pursue peace even when it's costly and will you love others even when you disagree with them? Maybe even when they've wronged you and pursue a path of love and forgiveness let it be so let me pray heavenly father Father, we praise you for these words.

31:13 These are tough teachings, Lord. So much here that's countercultural and actually counter to human nature. But Lord, in your strength, this is possible if we live fully for you. And so as we trust in you, may your spirit come into our hearts and minds and transform us from the inside out. We can't do this, but you've substituted your son in our place and he can live it on our behalf. And we pray that we'd be able to trust in him for Jesus.

Machine translated from the source