Pete Nicholas · Redeemer Downtown · Published October 4, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
1:49 Well, good morning. It's nice to have you here with us. Let me add my welcome to Mahler's. If I haven't met you before, my name is Pete Nicholas. I'm the senior pastor here, and particularly if you're a guest and you're coming to investigate this question this morning, thank you so much for joining us. Well, look, let's think about this issue of, is faith just a leap in the dark? I don't think it's overstating it to say that of all the kind of questions or areas of spirituality in general, and Christianity in particular, faith is probably the one that is most misunderstood. Or at least what we understand by faith in kind of popular everyday usage is very, very far from what the Bible seems to understand by faith. You'll know that there's a view out there that faith is kind of shutting your eyes, manufacturing up a belief in something which frankly suspends disbelief, frankly which is beyond what is reasonable to believe. I think one of the best examples for this is in the book by Lewis Carroll, Alice in Wonderland. And you remember, there's an interaction, perhaps you've read it, where the Queen of Hearts and Alice are talking, and Alice says this, I can't believe that, said Alice. Can't you, said the Queen in a pitying tone. Try again. Draw a long breath, shut your eyes.
3:10 Alice laughed. There's no use trying, she said. One can't believe impossible things. I dare say you haven't had much practice, said the queen. When I was your age, I always did it for half an hour a day. Why sometimes I believed as many as six impossible things before breakfast. It helps if you read that with an English accent, by the way. Now this view, of course, is the idea that, you know, we're believing impossible things, and that's fine if that's your thing, but don't expect me to be a reasonable, rational, intellectually rigorous person and also to believe in Christianity, the resurrection of the dead, Jesus Christ, things like that. That's not rational, you might say. And often this gets, I suppose, reinforced when people tell a story. They say, oh yeah, when I was younger, I used to believe those things. But then, you know, I grew up and went to college and did a science degree. And then I started dealing with facts. And now I'm not a believer anymore. You know, see the growth as we've grown maturity so we believe we're going to grow away from faith. Dare I say even sometimes churches actually reinforce this view. I interact with a lot of people who are coming from different backgrounds, and one of the things that puts off a lot of thoughtful people is they go to their churches or they go to some kind of religious expert and they ask questions, they get shunned for it. They kind of get the messaging through body language, sometimes explicitly, that this is not a place where we can ask questions. Can I just say, if that's your experience, that's a million miles away from the Bible. Because actually in the Bible, we see that actually so many of the patriarchs, the fathers and the women of faith who go before us are people who've asked great questions. Think of Mary, the mother of Jesus. When she's told by the angel Gabriel that she's going to be pregnant, even though she's never known a man, she's a virgin, she doesn't just say, of course, I trust in spite of evidence. So she asks a very normal question. She says, how can this be since I'm a virgin? Biology 101 there, right? She asks a great question.
5:07 And the angel answers her question. He doesn't say, don't ask questions, close your eyes and believe, Mary. That's just not what the Bible does. Or think of Job, who faces intense suffering and has over 50 chapters of questions. The Bible includes that because it's encouraging us to ask our questions when we're facing difficulty. Think of Jacob, who wrestles with God. Think of the Psalms which are all about big questions facing everything from joy to suffering, from sin to repentance and everything in between all with questions. No questions aren't the opposite of faith. Actually questions are a way to strengthen your faith. Just like going to the gym is about having resistance that strengthens your muscles, so questions and doubt is the resistance by which your faith is strengthened. A questionless faith will become weak and atrophying in pretty short order. So this is no place for saying that questions are not welcome. That's why we call this Questioning Christianity Sunday. And if you're here for the first time, you'll find that we're a curious bunch in more ways than one. Secondly, sometimes people see faith as a quality that some people have, but other people just don't have. And there's not much you can do with it. So I think people mean well with this, but often they will say things like this, Pete is great. You have faith. You have your faith. I've tried. I just can't. I guess I'm just not a person of faith. And there's something to that, but again, it kind of misunderstands it.
6:37 It seems to imply that faith is something you work up from within yourself, or maybe just a disposition. Some people like yoga, some people like sports, some people like faith, and if that's not your thing, then you just move on to your more rational endeavors. Again, that's not the biblical idea of faith. Why? Well, because faith, biblically speaking, is always faith in something. It always has an object. I could say, for example, that I have faith that that chair there is going to hold my weight. And you might say, looking at me and looking at the chair, well, you have more faith than me, Pete. But we could examine the chair and find out that it is actually structurally sound and well-made, and we could take a weight measure of me, and I'm better this side of Thanksgiving and say, actually, it's probably likely to hold Pete's weight. And therefore, we are able to strengthen our faith by examining the chair, because faith is always in something. It's not abstract. What do you have faith in? Do you have faith in science that's going to get you through life? Do you have faith in yourself that you're always going to be able to rise to the top like the cream? Do you have faith in your family and your friends? Do you have faith in some abstract moral authority in the world? Do you have faith in God? Do you have faith in Jesus Christ? What do have faith in? That's the question. Faith always has an object, and therefore it can be reasonable or unreasonable faith, valid or invalid faith, depending on what you have faith in.
8:00 Merely to play the postmodern game and throw our hands up in the air and say, well, the main thing is that you're a person of faith. Good for you. It's a bit like saying, well, the main thing is that you're standing on any old chair. Some chairs will hold my weight. Others won't. We need to work what we have faith in. Well, look, enough of preamble and so-called waggling on the tee, as the golfers would put it. Let's get into the meat of the text. And what we're going to see here is Jesus interacts with his disciples the night before he goes to the cross. We're going to see Thomas and Philip, who are two of his disciples, offer two very different approaches to this faith question. Interestingly, both of them are part right and part wrong, as we'll see. And then we're going to see how Jesus gently and graciously corrects them and shows us what true faith is about. So first of all, we're going to see the rationalism of Thomas and why that's inadequate. Then we're going to see the mysticism, the kind of experience focus of Philip and see why that's invalid. And then we're going to look at what Jesus Christ points to, which is himself as he puts himself up as the object of faith. Follow with me on this passage in your bulletins.
9:03 And we're going to look halfway down at verse five. Jesus says, this is the night before he goes to the cross. It's the last supper. And he's preparing his disciples who have been his friends for three years, who've seen remarkable things. He's preparing them for the fact that as he's put it, he is going away. That is, he's going to the cross and he's going to be crucified. And so there's a heaviness to the conversation. There's a sense of seriousness and sadness, and the disciples don't fully understand what's going on. And in the midst of it, Thomas, who's often that kind of guy who's first to speak and first to ask questions blurts out, verse 5, Lord, we don't know where you're going. So how can we know the way? Now, if you read through the New Testament, you will come to realize that Thomas is the kind of speak first, ask questions later type person. He's fiercely rationalistic. He kind of believes what he can see with his own two eyes. So for example, when Jesus says to the disciples that they're going to go to Lazarus's tomb in John chapter 11, Thomas just can't get why he would bother going. Lazarus has died. He's worried about the scrutiny that Jesus would get from the religious leaders at the time. And he says to Jesus, when Jesus talks of going there, he says, are we going so we can just die with him? Thomas is a very literal person. To give you the prime example, after Jesus has died and after he's risen from the dead, he appears to all of his disciples in a locked room, but Thomas is not in the room. And for a week after that, all of the disciples and many of the wider group of disciples, including the women, try to persuade Thomas that they have seen the risen Lord with their own twires. They've touched him. They've interacted with him. Now, just think of this for a moment. Imagine consistently that 10 of your friends were all there prevailing upon you about some profound reality that they've all experienced, all with consistency, all telling the same story, but because you've not seen it, you refuse to believe. Is that not remarkably stubborn? That's Thomas. For a whole week,
11:10 he holds out. He doesn't waver at all. In fact, he ends up saying, unless I see him with my own eyes, unless I touch his wounds with my own hands, I will not believe. And you read the New Testament, you realize, careful what you wish for, because he comes to believe. Thomas is that guy, the stubborn, rationalistic, empirically minded person. Don't think there's only modern people who ask tough questions. Thomas was the guy who asked all the tough questions. And so here, he's the first one to say to Jesus, Jesus, stop all this subterfuge, stop all this metaphors. You say you're going away, you're saying we know the way. We don't know the way. We don't know where you're going. Pull out a map. Show us. Where are you going? What are you talking about? Answer me, Jesus.
11:56 See, Thomas wants proof. I sometimes have people who come up to me after a service and they say, Pete, you know, some bits of what you said sounded compelling, but I can't believe unless I have, and here it comes, 100% certainty. Let me say a few things about that desire. First of all, I'd want to suggest to you that being rational is different to being rationalistic. Okay, rational is good. God is a God of reason. He's a God of order. Jesus is called in John's gospel the logos of God, which is where we get the idea of logic from. So God is not against reason or truth. That's why Jesus is going to say in verse six, I am the truth. The God of truth is not against truth. He's not against logic or reasoning. God is rational. The world is orderly. And God delights in people who ask good questions. God is a God of science and endeavor and expansion and reality and truth.
12:50 But there is a difference between being rational and being rationalistic. Being rationalistic is to say, I will only proceed when reason has given me utter confidence, utter certainty. And only then will I step forward. And dare I say, that's a fool's errand. You might say, why is that a fool's errand? Well, for a bunch of reason. Because there's lots of things that reason can't prove. Even the person who says, I will only proceed when things are 100% provable, you want to ask, is that principle itself 100% provable? How did you arrive at that principle? Did you get it from logic? No. Did you get it from a flow of reasoning? No. Did science give it to you? No. It's a presupposition. In other words, it's a faith posture. And this idea that I will only do things that are 100% certain misunderstands that you're a creature. You're not God. We're always uncertain because we don't see everything perfectly, because we don't have a perfect perspective. That's part of being a human being. Welcome to the human race. Only God sees everything with 100% certainty. Let me try to give you an example. Imagine that you have to undertake some serious surgery. And so because you're this type of person, you say, I'm only going to go with a surgeon that I can be 100% certain is going to be able to get me through the surgery. So you decide to audit her credentials, to question her about whether or not she really is able to do the operation, to ask all those questions. That's a good thing to do. But despite all the research you can do, and validate the credentials, and validate the track record, and all the rest of it, at the certain point, you have to admit, you can't be 100% certain.
14:28 At a certain point, you have to trust the surgeon. You know what that is? Reasonable faith. You put yourself, even in a life-changing situation, under the trust of someone when you don't know 100% certainty. No one does. You don't know how it's going to turn out. Frankly, the surgeon doesn't always know anyway. That doesn't mean you're being fiercely irrational or a blind leap in the dark. It just means you're acknowledging you can't know everything. There's a humility and a reality there. If you say, I'm only ever going to proceed when I have 100% certainty, you're going to find you're not able to do life, form meaningful relationships, take risks, step forward, embrace change, you're going to end up being an isolated hermit, sitting there shaking the fist saying, I will only do things when I can be utterly certain. It doesn't exist. Rational and being rationalistic are two different things. And so now we're going to look at a different approach, which is the mysticism of Philip. Because if Thomas gets rebutted with his rationalism, saying he needs to know everything, Philip shows us an alternative that is also wrong.
15:36 Verse eight, Philip said, Lord, show us the Father and that will be enough for us. Now, what does he mean by this phrase, show us the Father? It's a bit confusing. In the Old Testament, only a very limited number of people in very special circumstances got to see the Father. And they're kind of pretty famous examples. Elijah got to see God when God shook the mountain at Mount Carmel. Isaiah got to see God in a prophetic vision. and you can read about it in the first few chapters of Isaiah. Moses got to see God as God passed in front of him and hid him in the cleft of a rock. In other words, very few people got to see God, because the great fear was seeing God would cause you to die because he's so holy. And so Philip is basically saying to Jesus, Jesus, I know you're talking about going away. I need some reassurance.
16:31 If I had a unique and powerful spiritual experience of God, that would be enough for me. And then I'd be able to trust you. And then I'd be able to let you go and have confidence. Do you see how these two different approaches represent two views in our society? Some seek rationalism, others seek experience. We are often a society divided by truth and experience, and we pit them against one another. And interestingly, Thomas and Philip represent two sides of this divide. Philip says, I will only believe if I have some very powerful spiritual experience. So here's the question, why doesn't Jesus just give him that? I mean, if Jesus is a God of the emotions and of experience and of feelings, which he clearly is, Christianity has lots of that in it, why doesn't Jesus say, okay, sit back, wait a moment, and let me give you a very powerful spiritual experience, and then Philip is reassured we move on. Why doesn't he? Well, we need to realize the limits of experience. Let me try to give you this example. Imagine 50 years ago when Enzo Ferrari was alive that I said to you, if I was old enough then, I want to experience Enzo Ferrari. And so you say, well, you're in luck, actually. I've just bought a Ferrari. Let's go outside. So we go outside to the car and you rev the engine and we get that kind of high pitch, you know, lovely sound of the metal on the metal as the engine revs. And I kind of go, wow, what a powerful experience. You say, more than that, Pete, I'm going to let you drive it, which would be foolish, by the way. But anyway, we're in imaginary time. So I go off and I drive the Ferrari and I have a life-changing experience bombing up and down Fifth Avenue, weaving inside and outside of the taxis, right? And I come back and I say, that was incredible. I don't think I'm ever going to forget driving the Ferrari.
18:13 It's a life-changing experience. At the end of it, would I be able to say, I know Enzo Ferrari? No. I've just had a powerful experience. Because to know Enzo Ferrari would require him revealing himself to me, speaking to me, him giving me an experience of himself. That's what revelation is in the Bible. It's God revealing himself to us. Powerful experiences need words, logic, understanding, truth, to help us understand what they're communicating. A powerful experience might live with you for a long time, but does it help you to get to know God? And so it is. Lots of people say, well, I remember. but maybe it was a sunset, or maybe it was the cry of a newborn, or maybe it was a moment in church, or maybe it was a time when I was out walking, I just thought, this can't just all be here by chance. And you've had a very profound experience, but that experience needs content.
19:10 It needs revelation in order for it to be an experience of God. Otherwise, it's just an experience, and you can get those at Six Flags any old day. Thomas wants truth. It's not a bad longing, But rationalism will only ever get you so far. Philip wants experience, another good longing, but not ultimately enough to pin your faith on. Jesus gives an alternative, the experience of the truth in a relationship with him. Let's look at the object of faith, Jesus Christ, in verse six. You may well have heard this verse before. It's a pretty famous verse. Verse six, Jesus answered, I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me. If you really know me, you will know my Father as well. From now on, you do know him and have seen him.
20:06 Notice Jesus doesn't say, oh, stop being so rationalistic, Thomas. I'm not about truth. Get your head out of the books. No, he says, I am the truth. And notice he doesn't say to Philip, oh, stop going on about experience as if it's all about you and your feelings. No, he says, I am the way to an experience of God. I'm life itself. But he offers more than what they're seeking. He says, I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me. Now, we have to deal with that second part of the verse, which is rather uncomfortable for our postmodern New York ears, isn't it? We were fine with I am the way, the truth, the life, and then that last bit, we're like, I can't believe they read that at Redeemer Downtown. No one comes to the Father. It's so exclusive. Haven't they read the script? No one claims exclusivity and spirituality anymore. That's a no-no. Well, I'm sorry, Jesus does. Let me try to explain it to you. First of all, please notice that exclusivity, when it comes to talking about truth, is something we all do.
21:02 Let's say that I'm talking to you afterwards and you say to me, Pete, look, I think when it comes to religion, no one can really know the truth. I think therefore it's far better to say that all religions are equally true or all religions are equally valid. Did you know that that framing itself is incredibly exclusive? You say, I'm not intending to be exclusive. No, it's very, very exclusive. Because it actually contradicts almost all of the major world religions. Did you know Buddha founded Buddhism because he was rejecting Hinduism? He clearly doesn't think they're all equally valid. I've spoken with Muslim imams who don't think that they're saying the same thing as Christianity. They don't think it's all equally valid. Jews don't think that Islam is equally valid. In fact, most of the major world religions do not think that all truths are equally valid. So when you say all truths are equally valid, you're contradicting the major faiths of the world. And you're being exclusive.
21:54 So you see, we can all play the exclusive game. Because the problem is, it's not possible to make a truth claim without excluding the things that disagree with it. And notice here that Christians aren't being exclusive. Jesus is being exclusive. All right, so you might say, well, I don't like Christians. They're so arrogant and exclusive. We're just following what Jesus does. And I think the danger is, is that we confuse the character of Jesus or the character of Christians with the claim. Claim and character are two different things. Is it not possible for someone to claim truth but to do it with humility? Let's go back to my surgeon example from earlier. Imagine you go to the surgeon, you're investigating the surgeon's credentials, and you say to the surgeon, hey, got to be honest, I'm pretty nervous about this whole thing. how good are you actually? And they say, because they don't want to come across as proud, who could know? Some days I'm not sure which side of the scalpel I'm picking up. You better check my credentials.
22:49 And you say, well, are those? You say, well, who can know truth anymore, right? Is that going to reassure you? No, because we're confusing character, personal humility with the claim. It's helpful for the surgeon to say, you know what? Yeah, I'm good. I have great patient outcomes. I've been doing this for 20 years. and I've not had a major incident yet and I'm fully trained. You can have as much confidence as you like and you roll your eyes, you go, you're so arrogant. You see, you're confusing the claim with the character. A person can make a truth claim whilst being humble. You say, well, is Jesus humble? Oh my goodness. He's a strange reality. He makes these incredible claims about himself and yet he shows the most remarkable humility. He says, even the son of man, a name for himself, did not come to be served, but to serve and to give his life as a ransom for many.
23:42 One chapter before this claim, he's just washed his disciples' feet, something that only servants would do in the ancient world. He has a remarkable humility, but he doesn't confuse it with modesty and an uncertainty about who he is. He knows who he is and why he's come. And so he says, with all humility and grace and compassion, I am the way, the truth, the life. And he just follows the logic. And therefore, no one comes to the Father except through me. That's a kind thing to say if it's true. Please notice as well the nature of the claim. He does not say that he can show us the way. He does not say that he can reveal the truth about God. He does not say that he can give us spiritual life. He says, I am the way, I am the truth, and I am the life. It's incredibly egocentric whilst not being egotistical.
24:35 He's making a very personal claim about himself, but doing it with personal humility. That's why he says to Philip, don't you know me, Philip? Even after all I've been among you such a long time, anyone who has seen me has seen the Father. This is a different order of the claim. You can go to other spiritualities and you can say, can you reveal the truth about God? And many of them claim to reveal the truth about God. No other religion or person says, I am the revelation of the truth about God. You can go to other spiritualities and you say, can you explain the way for eternal life? And many will tell you, do this, do that, follow this path and you will attain enlightenment, heaven, we'll call it what you will. But Jesus is the only one who says, I am the life. You can say to other people, tell me the way to live and they'll be able to give you paths and follow this golden rule and do this and do that. But Jesus says, I am the way, follow me. Follow my example.
25:30 He is utterly unique. Here's the way C.S. Lewis put it in his book, God in the Dock. There is no halfway house. There is no parallel to Jesus and other religions. If you'd gone to Buddha and asked him, are you the son of Brahma? He would have said, my son, you're still in the veil of illusion. If you'd gone to Socrates and asked, are you Zeus? He would have laughed at you. If you'd gone to Mohammed and asked, are you Allah? He would have first rent his clothes. We may note in passing that Jesus was never regarded as a mere moral teacher. He didn't produce that effect in any of the people he actually met. He produced mainly three results. Hatred, terror, or adoration. There was no trace of people expressing mild approval. I am the way. I am the truth. I am the life. So the question here is, not do you have faith in general, but really, do you have faith in Jesus?
26:23 Do you know Jesus? You want truth? You want experience in the spiritual realm? You need the experience of the truth about Jesus to know him personally. This isn't just saying, do you know facts about him? I know lots of historians and theologians who know many facts about Jesus and have no idea who he actually is. They have no relationship with Jesus. And this isn't saying, have you had some powerful spiritual experience? You may have had that, you may have not. That doesn't define you. This is, do you experience Jesus? Do you know him? Do you know him in such a way that it impacts you and changes you? Will you say, like, I'd love to have that? How can I have that? How can I know? How can I know that I know him? Well, to know someone, you need to know what they're like. And that's why this passage is so important. In John's gospel, throughout the gospel, Jesus keeps talking about what he calls his hour of glory. Glory in the ancient world was the time when someone would do something so definitive that it would reveal what they're really like.
27:24 Be the final act of the hero, the great act or the great poetry of a poet. It would be that that would reveal their glory. Now you'd say, now I see what they're really like. What Jesus talks about is hour of glory. And it's not an hour of triumph in many ways, but it's an hour of defeat. He says that the cross is his hour of glory. The cross is what shows you what he is really like. Well, let's just ask as we close, what does the cross show you about Jesus of Nazareth, Jesus Christ? It shows you this. It shows you that he is so committed to opening up a way for you to have a relationship with God the Father through him that he was prepared to die to open that way for you. It shows you that he was so committed to you being sure about the truth about God and knowing God personally that he died for all of our lies and for all of the ways that we reject the reality of God. and push him to the periphery of our lives.
28:18 It shows you that he is so committed to you knowing life. life in his name, a life that starts when you have a relationship with him and carries on for eternity, that he was prepared to die so that you might be brought into that life through his grace and mercy and forgiveness. Jesus says, I am the way, the truth, and the life, but words can be cheap. He then backs it up by opening the way, by revealing the truth, and by offering us life through his death on the cross. And when you start to see that, then it stops just being abstract truths. It stops just being some random spiritual experience. And you start to say, I think I'm having an experience of the truth about Jesus Christ, the one in whom you feel drawn to put your faith in. That's why faith is not a leap in the dark.
29:13 It's about faith in a person, Jesus Christ, the one who gives us an experience of truth about God.
Machine translated from the source