"Hope Does Not Disappoint" · 2025 Discipleship Conference

Dave Pivonka · Franciscan University of Steubenville · Discipleship Conference · Published October 20, 2025

Watch on YouTube

Transcript

0:00 First off, thank you so much for being here. I was saying to Heather earlier, I love being Catholic. Amen? Yeah, we can clap. We can clap for that. Good. When I say amen, you have to respond amen. Amen? And I do that basically because it's four o'clock in the afternoon and I want you to stay awake. Amen? But one of the things I love about being Catholic, and there's a lot of them, I love the fact that when I look out, we look differently. You know, unfortunately, the word diversity has become a very political, divisive word, but I love the diversity in the church. You can go to some churches that aren't Catholic and everybody looks the same. They're around the same age. They're around the same color. They all look the same. But you come to a Catholic group like this and we all look radically different. And that's a great, great thing. Amen?

0:54 So amen. Let's cheer for that. Amen. The other thing is, is I'm going to do my best to try to share with what I think the Lord wants me to say. But I also want you to do your part. And that is to really be attentive as the afternoon is going on to what the Lord is saying to you. The reality is, I've had experiences where people came up to me and they said, Father, when you said this, it was so powerful. And I had no recollection of saying that, right? So that means that God's actually doing something. So you invest yourself, I'll invest myself, and hopefully something good comes about. Amen? So I had an opportunity a number of years ago to go to Bosnia. I was with a group of students of mine at Franciscan University. And we went into this one particular area, the Mostar region of an area that was in the midst of the war and had been largely destroyed.

1:50 And we went to a shelter. It was an old kind of a bombed-out hospital. And there were a group of individuals, about 75 people that lived there, and they had not had Mass for over a year. There was a priest that lived down the road. I don't know why he felt this way, but he said that they were the refuge, and he would not go and celebrate Mass with them. I remember when I walked in, this lady comes up, and she grabbed everything was through a translator, but she grabbed my cord, and she began to kiss my cord, and she said, I love this more than life itself. Right? So myself and a couple of the students were invited to an individual's room. His name was Slavko, and Slavko and his wife invited us in. The people that lived in this refugee center, their meals were largely cabbage soup. It's generally what they would have all the time.

2:42 They were hungry, many of them were ill, didn't have proper housing. And when we walked in, this individual, Slavko, he couldn't speak very loud, he had a very raspy voice. And he walked in and he said to us, to me and the students, you are my hope. I was touched by that. And he began to listen to his story. And whenever he spoke, he would always speak very quietly. And I noticed that on his neck, he had a large scar. He began to share his story. He and his wife were in their home. And the soldiers came in the front of the house. And the three kids went out of the back door. and the soldiers grabbed he and his wife. They separated him, and they beat Slavko. And they took barbed wire, and they wrapped it around his wrists and his ankles, and they slit his throat, literally left him for what they thought would be dead.

3:40 He and his wife eventually, a couple of days later, reconnected. They had not seen their kids in 18 months, assuming that they were probably killed. and this individual went on and he shared how grateful he was because god is faithful and that god is loving and that god has not abandoned him and that god has been close I found myself listening to their story, and I myself, I get frustrated. I missed a flight coming down Oklahoma City, and I thought God had abandoned me. Literally, in the middle of O'Hare, I'm just sitting there saying, why have you done this to me, Lord, right? You never do anything for me. And they who had every reason to despair or to be discouraged or be disappointed were actually filled with hope.

4:44 I had the opportunity later in the day to celebrate Mass with this community. and I shared with them that the individual had said that me and the students were his hope, and I said, but the reality is, is you're our hope. In the midst of everything that you've gone through, you still believe, you still worship, you still desire the sacraments, you still believe in a God who's a God who keeps his promises, a God who is close, a God who loves. I said, you're our hope and from the back of the little auditorium where we were a little lady else yelled out no father it's God God is our hope And it can only be him. The scripture that I was giving for this week, for today's, this afternoon, comes from 1 Peter 3.15.

5:41 And it says, always be ready to give an account of that which gives you hope. Or another translation says, always be ready to give an explanation to anyone who asks you for the reason of your hope. this today has been a conference that's been a day in discussing and studying what it is to be a disciple and now you're being sent out here's a remarkable thing the whole idea of having conferences about discipleship the church has been alive around 2 000 years we've been doing this for about 75 this idea of programs for discipleship and And books, I mean, it's a relatively new thing. It's hard to me to believe that the gospel was ever shared before the wild goose. I thought that started it all, right? I thought that was the beginning of it all. Paul actually did not have a set of DVDs to send people to, right? He didn't have a book.

6:38 He did have a couple letters. I'll give him that. How did they do it? They told people. they told people what they'd seen. They told people what they had heard. And now you're being sent out, again, with this text that says, be ready to give an account to anyone who asks you the reason for your hope. And the reality is, is that's how the gospel is shared. It's shared by a people that are filled with hope, and they're taking it to a world that desperately needs that hope. And that's the world that you're actually being sent out into. A world that is so oftentimes confused about where to find their hope. We live in a world that largely oftentimes sees their hope in their politicians. I'm not going to get political, amen?

7:36 Do we place our hope in the President of the United States? In our courts? In our Congress? No. No. A little aggressive there. we live in a world that becomes more and more disenchanted and frustrated and disappointed at the failure of our institutions you know of our government of our honestly our universities church even we live in a world and it's one of the struggles with social media is we know all the problems of the world but the reality is is we largely can't do anything about it. Sure, we pray. Of course we pray. But other than that, we're constantly being told what's happening here in this war and this problem. And it all kind of weighs in on us. And we find ourselves oftentimes frustrated and anxious and despairing. We live in a world that has no purpose.

8:37 The percentage of people that are not going to church is increasing constantly. We live in a world that desperately needs hope. And that's why I was so grateful to our Holy Father Pope Francis, when he's talked about being disciples of hope, when he called for this year, he's praying and he says, what does the world need right now? What the world needs right now is hope. And that's your job. You are now to be disciples. We're about to send you out to be disciples. I love in Romans 5.5, Pope Francis talked a lot about this. He says that hope does not disappoint, right? Romans 5.5. It says, hope does not disappoint because. And at that point, everybody should just take a deep breath. Well, why is it that hope doesn't disappoint? Because the reality is, is oftentimes I think we're disappointed. We find ourselves frustrated and anxious and angry at times. But Paul says, hope does not disappoint. Can we trust the words of the scripture. Are the words of scripture true?

9:43 So we need to listen. Hope does not disappoint because and everybody should be quiet. Why doesn't hope disappoint? Because the love of God has been poured forth into our hearts. I mean, why could Slavko in the middle of this refugee center of Bosnia, his sons, his two sons and his daughter have been killed, still talk about a God who's kind, and a God who's merciful, and a God who's loving, because the love of God has been poured forth into his heart. And I get to preach a lot all over the world, and I think 99% of the times I say something about God's love. Because when it's all done, it's what it comes down to. I wrote a book, one of the first books I wrote was a book on freedom, the spirituality of freedom. And I write this whole, I thought a pretty good book about freedom and God's created us to be free. And then the last chapter is that we live in the love of God. And a student came into my office and she said, that's it? And I said, what do you mean that's it? That's all it is? It's just the love of God? It's like, sorry, that's all I've got. I love Father Cantalamesa, who was the papal preacher, he said, if you could take all of the scriptures and put it in three words, it would be God is love.

11:10 Why aren't we disappointed? Because the love of God fills my heart. And what Paul is saying is it doesn't matter what's taking place anywhere else. It doesn't matter the circumstances of the world. It doesn't matter the suffering that you find yourself in. It doesn't matter the struggle that you find. That doesn't mean there's not pain. That doesn't mean there's not sadness. But what it does mean is that we can still have hope because the love of God has been poured forth into my heart. And brothers and sisters, this changes everything. and what I'm about to say may challenge you but when I say that some of you know exactly what I'm talking about you know what that experience is to be overwhelmed and enveloped in the love of God and some of you aren't sure And I suggest that that's oftentimes why we become disappointed.

12:10 Because we haven't encountered that love that changes everything, that radically changes us. but ultimately this is why i can have hope and what the scripture again that we're challenged with by the conference this week is that now we need to be able to go out and share that always be prepared to give an account of that which gives you hope so when people say why is it that you hope how do you answer i had an experience a number of years ago I was flying from Pittsburgh back to Arizona. We were flying and this woman she kind of went crazy on the plane and she started screaming and she was like walking up and down the aisle. I thought it was kind of cool but apparently it caused them to be anxious so we had to make a stop into Chicago. So we stopped in Chicago, the police came on and they dragged this lady out. I thought it was really interesting, I thought it was gonna be a great story in a homily, So here we are, right?

13:09 Well, this lady next to me was all frustrated. She goes, I can't believe this. Now I'm going to be late. This is ridiculous. So we take off. We get going. We're in the plane for about, I don't know, an hour and a half, two hours, heading to Phoenix. And the captain comes on, and he says, I have an announcement. Unfortunately, we're going to have to land in Albuquerque. And because we weren't scheduled to stop in Chicago, we didn't get fuel. And I'm not positive we have enough fuel to get to Phoenix, all right? Again, this lady next to me is apopractic. She is, I can't believe this. This is ridiculous. What are we doing? And I'm thinking, what's our option? come on captain let's give it a shot right so she looks at me she looks at me always be prepared to give an account of that which gives you hope she looks at me and she says how can you stay so calm right how can you stay so calm right you need to be able to answer that question and the thing is is it's it's my story how is it that i can stay so calm i mean i could say well the pope says this or i could say the archbishop says this or i could say you know my mother my mother loves the lord but she didn't ask about any of that always be prepared to give an account of that which gives you hope and I think we're facing a struggle in the church today because on one level people haven't experienced that we find ourselves and I find it interesting that they're often telling somebody else's story they're telling us again beautiful stories of Maximilian Kolbe and in the saints beautiful stories but the scripture says always be prepared to give an account of that which gives you, not Colby, not John Paul, not Mother Teresa.

15:12 It's because you hope. the question we have to ask ourselves is, are we able to articulate that? Have we experienced that? Have we experienced the one that ultimately gives us hope? Because in the end, brothers and sisters, it's Jesus. That's why we can have hope, because he has loved me, because he has rescued me, because he has saved me. And that answer has to be yours. You need to be able to articulate it. This is a homework assignment. Go home on a blank piece of paper and write it down. Write down your story. And if you don't have a story, if you're not sure what you're going to say, if somebody says, why do you have hope? You can't say, well, here's what Father Dave said. He told a really cool story on a plane. That's not going to move somebody's heart. And there's a moment in the time for doctrine and dogma and all of those things.

16:05 But all of that stuff can be debated. When you tell your story, this is what God has done for me. this is how he's rescued me this is how everything in my world seemed to be falling apart and I discovered and I found God in the midst of that that's why we can have hope be prepared to give an account of that which gives you hope and it's interesting when peter writes this if you look at the heading in the scripture it says christian suffering be prepared to give an account of that which gives you hope.

16:42 I shared with the priest this morning, did you, I don't know, in Oklahoma, was it COVID? Did COVID get to Oklahoma? Okay. Because it did, it did get to Ohio. It did get to Ohio. And when that whole thing was going down, we're having a million questions about what we were going to do. And I had this crazy idea because nobody knew if the students were going to come and if they're going to come back to class and their parents were going to let them go. So I said, well, what if we invited the new students to come and we wouldn't charge them? We would let them come for free. I thought this was a crazy idea, but when I was praying about it, I couldn't shake it. So I went to the guy in charge of our finance. I knew he would tell me, Father, that's a really stupid question, idea, right? And he said, wow, that's an interesting idea. Not at all what I was looking forward to, right? So we invited our students back. When most campuses across the country were saying stay home, we said come because I believed that the best place for them was to be together and to be in community and to be close to the sacraments.

17:45 It was crazy. In the midst of that time, I got emails that said, if children, not if, when kids die, their blood is on your hands, Father. I got a call from the governor of the state because I was choosing to let them come back and some other things that I chose to do. people were boycotting people were calling the health department about the university in the midst of all this every time a student got COVID bless the Lord when it was all said and done nobody got too sick and we were very very blessed but every time a student got sick or COVID I'd get nervous and anxious and I'd go in the chapel and say please Lord please just crying out to the Lord in the midst of this my brother was also diagnosed with cancer so I went home a couple of occasions to Arizona to try to visit him in the hospital they wouldn't let me in dressed up and looked as good as a priest as I could possibly look they were not impressed so my brother literally dying of cancer by himself his wife, my mom and dad, nobody could visit him remember I was sitting in the chapel just praying, frustrated anxious and wanting to be home and not sure what to do with the university.

19:01 And I felt like this trash comp practice, and everything was just caving in. and in the midst of that I heard the Lord speak something to my heart that was so beautiful and profound but at first glance it doesn't sound so great but he said Dave this won't crush you Have you ever felt like everything was caving in and you're going to get crushed?

19:32 I would have preferred, he said, Dave, everything's going to be great. Don't worry. My brother died a couple weeks after that. or he didn't crush me always be prepared to give an account of that which gives you hope as I get older,

19:59 just being with the Lord is the comfort. Rarely does he give me advice. but he sits with me and he sees me and he feels my weakness and my brokenness and my fear and my anxieties And he loves me in the midst of that. I shared that when we were kids with the priest this morning that when we're kids and you scrape your knee you run up to your parents and they give you a hug and they kiss you on the forehead and they send you off and that's all we needed but we grow up and the Lord wants to do the same thing with us and we think that's not enough always be prepared to give an account of that which gives you hope hope does not disappoint because the love of god has been poured forth into my brothers and sisters if we place our hope in anything or in anyone else we will always be disappointed my mom's got a mess she was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis when i was five years old and for 55 years you do the math i've been praying that the lord would heal her and he hasn't it's my prayer it's not my hope if my hope was rooted in my mother's healing i would be frustrated, angry priest.

21:41 And I like to think I'm a happy, joyful priest. Because that's my prayer. That's my wish. That's my desire. That's my dream. It's not my hope. My hope is in Jesus. My hope is in a God who keeps his promises. My hope is in a God who was risen from the dead.

22:04 My hope is in a God who said, Dave, I will not leave you orphaned. I will not abandon. My hope is in a God who's merciful. It's a thousandth time I go to confession that it'll be merciful one more time. Always be prepared. But it has to be your story. It has to be your encounter.

22:29 It has to be your experience. bury the lead in some ways. Again, Paul says, in Romans 5, hope does not disappoint because the love of God has been poured forth into our hearts by the power of the Holy Spirit.

22:54 Hope does not disappoint because the love of God has been poured forth into our heart by the power of the Holy Spirit. this becomes, brothers and sisters, the hinge of which everything else in our spiritual life changes. I love and I find myself praying and thinking about the disciples who had every advantage. I mean, think about this. They were with Jesus for a number of years, and they saw Jesus do remarkable things. They saw Jesus heal the blind, cure the sick, literally raise people from the dead, right? Raise people. I've never experienced a funeral where somebody has been risen from the dead. That would be fantastic. Amen? I would suggest that more people come to your church, that people would literally be raised from the dead. You hear a knocking on the casket from the inside.

23:47 Now, you would think this would have a pretty profound impact on them. Right? They saw all of these amazing things. Jesus had been even risen from the dead. And yet, where do we find them? When we go and take a look at the Acts of the Apostles, Acts 2, verses 1 to 4. Time of Pentecost is fulfilled, and they were all in one place together. The doors were locked, they were frightened, and suddenly a strong driving wind. Noise, like a strong driving wind, comes and fills the entire house. Then there appeared on them tongues of fire which parted and came to rest on everybody. Right? And the world is never the same. when we think of this that there's this all of the faith and all the stories and everything that Jesus has done it's this wide gap and it comes together at this point of pentaclops my suspicion is when Jesus was going to the cross he was not thinking I hope you go to a room lock the doors and hide that would be great I'm doing all of this so that's what you would do right in the book that I did on freedom one of the lines that I had stated I said Jesus is not enough.

24:55 And there's something about that that seems just, of course it's not, because he's trying. But these individuals had had these encounters with Jesus and they had seen all that he did, but they weren't able to actually be disciples until Pentecost. Until they experienced the Holy Spirit. I love when Peter gets up. The same Peter that was hiding gets up and he begins to preach. and people say he must be drunk and Peter says I'm not drunk it's only 9 o'clock in the morning because it's not possible to be drunk 9 o'clock in the morning. And those of you who are laughing have a story to tell. It's interesting. Acts 19, they're talking about the Holy Spirit. And he said, we've not even heard of the Holy Spirit. The reason I did the wild do is because there were too many people who had not even heard of the Holy Spirit.

25:54 The Spirit that enemies us, the love of God has been poured forth into our hearts by the power of the Holy Spirit. Everything changes at Pentacles. I think in my own experience when I was younger the experience was Romans 7 anybody like this why do I do the things I don't want to do anybody and I can't seem to do the things I want to do anybody for me this experience of Pentecost was an experience of power it was an anointing that radically changed me I was a 20-year-old kid. I was at a conference somewhere like this. And somebody comes up to me and he asked me about the baptism of the Holy Spirit. And I had no idea what he was talking about. Let me switch. I like what you did here. Amen? Oh, what is that? So a 20-year-old kid, and he asked me about this experience of baptism in the Holy Spirit, which we just read about in Pentecost. And I was talking to somebody, and they said, it's just Pentecost. I said, what do you mean it's just Pentecost? And they said, Pentecost isn't just this experience that happened 2,000 years ago. It's something that's supposed to happen today, right? One of the things that, if I was Pope, it's easy to say because it'll never happen. We'll never have an American as a Pope.

27:24 Our Holy Father, John Paul, established what he called the new evangelization. But the reality is there was no evangelization until after Pentecost. So John Paul, Benedict, Francis all spoke of a new Pentecost, this new outpouring of the Holy Spirit. I was a 20-year-old kid, had no idea what this Holy Spirit was, what this Pentecost was, all of this stuff. But it was a small chapel by myself. And I said, Lord, I don't understand this Holy Spirit. I don't know what they mean. But if you want this for me, then I want it. And I experienced the love of God that was poured forth into my heart. That I've never been the same.

28:18 Right? And I've experienced that many times since and before. This is, you don't have to answer this. You don't have to raise your hand. Have you experienced that? always be prepared to be prepared to give an account of that which gives you hope. And hope does not disappoint because the love of God has been poured forth into our hearts by the power of the Holy Spirit.

28:42 My older brother would say as I came back from this retreat, and he looked at me and he noticed something is different about me. And he would say to my dad that Dave is finally the person he's always wanted to be. right he could look at me and he could see that something was different and this is going to be the invitation to you is is to go back out in the world and always be prepared to give an account of that which somebody looks at you and they said there's just something different about you you seem happier you don't seem to engage in conversation that you used to engage in you don't seem to be so negative you seem to be so positive why are you smiling that makes me nervous And then we can say, let me tell you. we don't just say, well, I don't know.

29:40 It's a good day. I got a good night's sleep. Always be prepared to give an account of that which gives you hope. For the love of God has been poured forth into our hearts by the power of the Holy Spirit. Stand up. My lovely assistant, Heather, is going to lead us in a moment or two of just prayer. Do me a favor, just take a breath. I love in the Acts of the Apostles, the Holy Spirit comes with a strong driving wind, with fire.

Machine translated from the source