Dave Pivonka · Franciscan University of Steubenville · Steubenville Youth Conference · Published August 17, 2022
0:23 You guys, I'm going to talk today about families. So I've asked some really, really basic questions. These questions, I do not want you to stand up. I do not want you to raise your hand. This is just for you to think about because it's going to give us context. I believe, I think, that I came from a really wonderful family. So again, just in your own mind and your heart, is that your experience? You know, a mom and dad that have been present in your life, basically things have gone pretty well. Is that your experience? Is your experience that you were raised without what we call a nuclear family, that mom and dad weren't necessarily in your life all the time? Statistics say that maybe upwards to 40% of the people, do not raise your hand, don't stand up, but 40% of you, probably that's your story. Is it you have a situation that your mom or dad wasn't present for one reason or another?
1:19 You find yourself in a situation that your family was profoundly difficult, profoundly dysfunctional, a lot of pain that goes into that. What I want to be able to talk about today is kind of the nature of family and what family is supposed to be, what it can be, what it could be, what it often is. And again, as I mentioned in the beginning, the title of this is supposed to be Messy family and I kind of wondered why I was asked to give this particular workshop because my family's I wouldn't consider it quote unquote a messy family and then other people might look into it and say okay that's a messy family. One of the most, I don't know, powerful memories I have growing up was when I was about five years old. My mom was in the hospital, and she wrote a letter to each one of us kids, and we went home that night. I remember we left home, and we were back at my house, and my dad was a physician, so we were used to kind of being around hospitals and those kind of things, but this was different because my mom was a patient in the hospital and she'd been there for a while. And what my mom had done that day, she wrote each one of us a letter and she basically wrote it in a way that we would understand. I was five years old, so I wasn't able to read, so my dad read the letters to us, to the littler ones. What the letter shared is that explained that my mom had a disease called multiple sclerosis. It's called MS. And what that caused is like sometimes it was really difficult for my mom to walk.
2:53 Sometimes it was hard for her to be able to get out of bed. Sometimes growing up, she had to use wheelchairs. She always had to use these crutches. They're called European canes. And it was kind of crazy because my mom, because of her legs weren't very strong, she had to use crutches and her arms would become really strong. So it was really funny when I was in high school, my mom would arm wrestle all our friends. My mom would just toast everybody, all right? Because she would always use a crutch. It's like, Mom, Mom, come here. And my friend thinks that my mom would like crush them, right? So as a five-year-old kid, my mom writes a letter, and she explains to me that she's got MS.
3:26 And I remember as a kid, we were around, we were sitting around in a circle with my family, again, my dad, my brothers, and my sister. And I remember my dad was crying. And it was really a scary time, especially as a little kid. You know, you're not used to seeing your dad cry. You're not used to your mom being in the hospital. And it was really kind of this frightening time for me. I remember I went back to my room and I was sitting in my bed I was just kind of sitting there and crying and I didn't know what was going on and I was scared and I'll never forget my older brother Jim he comes up to me and he gives me a hug and he says don't worry Dave if mom can't take care of you I will And that had a real impact on me and I think on my family, that my mom's disease was something that really caused and invited my family to come together. When I think back in my life, I mean, the greatest, greatest blessings, the greatest memories of my life are my family and what my family taught me and the fact that little things, like the fact that my mom couldn't always cook.
4:29 We all, there's five boys in my family, we all know how to cook. Because we had to. We had to care for each other. We had to take care of each other. Sometimes mom wasn't able to do it. But it wasn't just that that they taught us. My mom and my family, they taught us about mercy. I remember one time I was a junior in high school, and I don't know how my mom found out about this, but moms, just let me tell you, moms know everything. Amen? They see everything, right? So she comes up to me. I was going out. I was going out to a party, and she somehow knew, and she said, Dave, are you going to that party? I said, what party? She goes, the party for the seniors tonight. I said, oh, that party. No, I'm not going because I'm not a senior, Mom. I'm only a junior. I wouldn't go to a party if I was a senior. She goes, okay. So I went off to this party. My sister, yeah, and I was seriously, I was a pretty good kid. I'm not joking.
5:22 I did not lie to my parents to lie, but this time I flat out lied to my mom. Well, my sister finds out, and my mom says, you know, go get Dave. So my sister comes to this party, and she said, Dave, Mom knows you're at the party. I said, what do you mean? She goes, she just knows. I said, how does she know? She just knows. And I said, Mary, tell Mom I'm not at the party. My sister goes, I'm not going to do that. I said, if you just tell her I'm not here, I'm not here. She goes, I won't do that. So remember, I went home that night. My mom is sitting in her bed, and this is just the worst, all right? She's sitting in her bed. She's sitting up. Because of her MS, she had a rosary, and the beads were really, really big because she couldn't fill beads since it was a small rosary. She's sitting up, and there are tears that are flowing down her cheek, right? I think she actually took a water bottle and sprayed herself before I got in to make me feel horrible, right? So these tears. And she said the worst, right? I walk in and she says to me, I'm so disappointed in you. Anything but the disappointment card, right? So we talked a little bit.
6:15 And I started to go to my room figuring I was going to be there for the rest of my life. And she said, where are you going? I said, I'm going to my room. And she said, I thought I said you could go to your friend's house tonight. And I said, well, you did. But I figured because I lied to you, you wouldn't let that happen. She said something that had a really great impact on me. She said, just because I wasn't faithful, just because you weren't faithful doesn't mean that I'm not going to be faithful. So she said, you can go to your friend's house.
6:40 Crap, it was a horrible night. I felt guilty the whole night. I broke my mom's heart that night. And my mom taught me about mercy. She taught me about forgiveness. She taught me about kindness. families do that for us right when I think of my own life and my experience with my family the greatest blessings come from my brothers and my sisters and from my dad to this day my dad was always my best friend but my family wasn't perfect my older brothers kind of wandered away from the church for the longest time and and I watched that difficulty on my mom and dad wishing and praying that their sons would come back to the church, which they eventually did. But there was alcohol and there was drugs and there was all that kind of stuff that was a kind of a part of that and it had an impact on me.
7:32 My sister, whom I love today, drove me crazy when I was 17 years old. And we fought all the time. And today she's one of my best friends. The greatest blessings and at times the greatest difficulty. But I think what God wants us to know and what he wants us to hear is that families are a part of his design. Sometimes it goes really, really well, and sometimes it doesn't go so well. I think of the holy family, right? You've got Jesus, who is the incarnation of God. You've got Mary, the Immaculate Conception. You've got Joseph, right? Talk about never winning an argument. I mean, Joseph always lost. His son is God, and his wife is the mother of God, right? Joseph's like, whatever. I'm sorry. Whatever happened, I'm sure it was my fault.
8:18 But it was the holy family, and I found myself reflecting on that. We celebrate the holy family, not the perfect family. Not the perfect family. I'm not sure that there is a perfect family. And that's what we have to be able to reconcile. And that's why I asked the question, what does your family look like? Right? What does it look like to be in a family that's not always the way it should be? If you pay attention to the Old Testament, it's kind of cool, actually. In the Old Testament, you've got stories of families that are totally messed up. You've got the story of Joseph. Joseph was the 11th of 12 sons. His father had four different wives. And Joseph's brothers got to begin to get jealous of him. And they literally sold him into slavery. If you take a look at the Old Testament, there's over 25 families. In almost all of them, the families are totally messed up.
9:14 Totally dysfunctional. I remember a student here at the university, and she shared the story with me about her family. And she shared some things that took place in her family that I simply couldn't imagine. I remember one time she said to me, Father, I'm afraid if I start crying, I'm never going to stop. Now, that wasn't a college student just kind of being dramatic. That was an honest, honest 18-year-old girl that had been so profoundly wounded in her family that she was afraid that she would stop. You see, there's something about the brokenness of a family that's closer.
9:55 There's something about brokenness in relationships and the pain that comes with that, right? This violation that takes place. I was just reading an article about an individual who was raised, and she was raised without a father. And everybody told her, you know, you're going to be okay. You'll be all right. And she said she tried to really just suck it up because that's what you're supposed to do because everybody told her she was going to be okay. But she said, there was this hole in my heart that just longed for a father. You see, there's something about families that God wants to be able to reveal himself to us and show himself to us and teach us. What I learned about in my family is, again, my family isn't imperfect, so one of the things that I learned was about forgiveness. I hated the reality that my mom and my dad made us stand in front of each other and say, I'm sorry. It's like, I'm sorry.
10:48 You all been there, right? It's like, go tell your brother you're sorry. Alright, whatever you say, I'm sorry, right? But there's something about that. They tell us about sacrifice. I just watched what my mom and dad went through and what they had to be able to sacrifice for us, for us kids. My parents taught us about priorities. I remember as a kid, my mom and dad would always tell me that you are the third most important person in my life. First relationship was Christ. My mom and dad taught me that. Our family knew that, that if you were to think of a family in the center of my family was always God. And the next thing my parents would say, and then the next most important thing is our relationship with each other. And then finally, the relationship with the kids. And as a kid, I was like, what do you got to be kidding me? I'm third? Who wants to come into third? Now, I realized that my mom and dad had six kids, so I really was third.
11:43 And everybody else was like fourth, fifth, sixth, and seventh, eighth. I realized today is the greatest gift my parents gave me. but why is family so hard? Why is it so difficult? I want to suggest a couple of reasons. One, and I don't want to like kind of over-spiritualize it, I don't want to freak you out, but the evil one, and there is, if there's a power of God, then there's also a power of darkness. If there's Christ, God, the Redeemer, the Savior, there's the one who's trying to break us and destroy us. Jesus says he's a thief, and he wants to destroy and divide. the evil one I believe hates families if we pay attention to the scripture so oftentimes it's the evil one that moves into a family and tries to break it the very beginning the story of Adam and Eve the evil one begins to divide first Adam and Eve against the God and then Adam and Eve against each other and Adam and Eve against their children and Adam and Eve and their sons and sons being separated the evil one wants to break the family and we see that taking place in our country right now this whole interesting definitions of what is family and what is marriage and what is right and what is wrong and all of this kind of things the evil one wants to work in that and if he can discover there's a great quote by louis de monfort he's a saint and he says the corruption of that which is best is worst and by that he says if you have something that's really wonderful and supposed to be really good and if you can mess that up then you've totally messed it up. And I think that's the reality with the evil one. Is if he can mess up our families, that place that, I give the homily tomorrow and I want to reclaim the word safe. I mean we live in a world, this safe space that's just become kind of a caricature, right? But the family is supposed to be the place that's safe. And if the family can become a place that's not safe, that you can't be yourself, that you have to hide, you have to, the evil one wants that to happen. So I think that's the first thing. The second is that it is families, and this is self-evident, right? We're made up of people like you and I. It's made up of people
13:53 who are broken. The older I get and the more I realize, and it's why what sisters talked this, that she gave this afternoon was so important, was that each one of us needs to be healed, right? Everybody, everybody here, let's just be clear, everybody here in this auditorium has wounds from your family. Again, I think I have one of the best, most amazing families in the world. But there are still wounds for that. Why? Because my mom and my dad were not perfect. They weren't perfect. They were a great, amazing mom and dad, but they weren't perfect. And honestly, even if you are perfect, it doesn't mean that there can't be wounds, right? My father passed away just a few months ago. And there's a wound, right? There's a sadness in there because of that. That's not like, Dad, what the hell are you doing? Why did you go and die on me, right? that's not, I mean, people are going to die, right? But there's a wound there, and there's an emptiness there. It's nobody's fault. It just is. And the reality is, is no matter what your situation, no matter what your family is, there are going to be times that we're wounded. And the Lord wants to heal that. And this is why this is so important, especially you guys, you are so blessed to be here at this time. Because the more you can deal with that when you're younger, it means you don't take it to your family, right?
15:07 There's a saying that wounded people wound, right? So if you're going into a relationship, into a relationship with a boyfriend or a girlfriend or a mother or a father, and you haven't been healed, then you're going to pass that on to your kids, right? So it's important and it's a wonderful blessing for you as being so young to be able to take a look at some of these things. But the reality is, is unless we come to understand what some of that brokenness and woundedness is, we go ahead and pass that on. The other is that it's hard. I mean families are difficult. Living together, being together, spending time together, you just drive one another crazy sometimes. I continually say families are the greatest blessing and they're the greatest difficulties. And the crazy thing you guys is that we will do and say things to family members that we would never do or say to somebody else. And part of that is because we think, well they're gonna love me because they have to love me because they're my brother and my sister. And on one level I suppose that that's true, but the other level is it causes us and allows us to take advantage of each other. And obviously we work and we operate out of our anger or out of our fear or out of brokenness or out of our woundedness and then we begin to hurt one another. Amen? Remember I was giving, we were at a youth conference in St. East, La Salette, Massachusetts I think.
16:24 and I was talking about, it was an immense session, I was talking about being a brother. And I remember I was saying, you know, don't act like, just to guys, I said, don't act like you're all tough and all this and that if you're going to go home and you're going to pick on your little brother. Right? If you're going to pick on your little brother until he cries. And I was just talking about how we as brothers, particularly as older brothers, need to have a special care and a concern for our younger brothers and sisters because like it or not, they love us and they look up to us. And we model for them, right? So in the middle of this talk, I was just kind of talking about what is it to be an older brother, and this guy gets up and he walks out of the talk. He comes up to me later in the day and he said, you know, Father, you were talking about not picking on your brother. He said, my little brother and I had this huge fight before I came to the conference, and I totally just beat the crap out of him.
17:18 He said, when you were saying that, it's like, it really convicted me, like, what kind of a brother do I want to be? And he actually started crying, and he said, I walked out of your talk, and I went, and I called my little brother. And I said I was sorry. And I apologized. families are not going to be perfect we're going to make mistakes but the Lord wants to be able to be a part of that and bring healing to it I was at a conference in Minnesota again a youth conference in the twin cities and I was talking about a father and I was talking about my dad and the relationship that I had with my dad but not just that that we're going to hear in the scriptures tomorrow the spirit comes upon us and he reveals to us the father. And the guy comes up to me afterwards and he says, you talk about father, he said, let me tell you about my father. He said, my dad and I have never done anything by ourselves. I said, what do you mean? He said, we've never just done something he and I just by ourselves.
18:15 He said, one time we were going hunting and we're going to go hunting for some ducks. And it started to rain. We just put the guns in the cars and it's starting to rain. And he said, dad, he goes, no, no, no, I don't want to hunt in the rain. We'll do it some other time he said father I'm still waiting I'm still waiting just to have time with me and my dad there's a wound there there's a brokenness right right now that's that's a son that just wanted somebody to see him I think of my own life I remember when I was in eighth grade was studying Colorado history and we're studying Pikes Peak and I knew one fact about Pikes Peak right and I shared it with my dad I can remember where we are remember exactly where we are there was a restaurant across the street and I said, Dad, did you know that Pikes Peak was, I don't even remember what the fact is anymore, and my dad asked me a follow-up question of which I had no more information. All I knew, everything I knew about Pikes Peak I had already told him, right? I'd shot my whole wad right there and I said, I don't know. It was so cool. My dad just stopped and he looked at me and he said, Dave, you do not have to impress me for me to love you. I love you because you're my son.
19:25 Yeah, it was theirs and my family that I was taught things like that. But I recognized that not everybody was able to learn that lesson. So what do we do? What do we do if we find ourselves in situations that are complicated or that maybe aren't as perfect as they should be? Number one, and this is hard sometimes, but to be able to surrender, to be able to let Go. I think that we all have this dream of what this perfect family looks like and the reality is it doesn't exist. There's not a perfect family like that and I totally get that some of your families are more functional than others and some of yours are just really, really complicated and difficult.
20:13 And there's this part of you that just this desire that you want everything to be perfect but there has to be a moment that you just say, okay, God, I give you this. I surrender this to you. Maybe it's something we could do tonight when we pray during the holy hour. Just say, okay, God, I give you my mom. And I give you my dad. And I give you my brothers. And just go through each one of them. I give you my sisters. Or whatever your situation, whatever your family is, just to be able to surrender that and say, Jesus, I just need you to take this. And I need you to be present in it. Amen? So number one is surrender. Number two is sometimes we have to repent. It's interesting. I'm working on a new series, video series that I'm doing. I'm going to do the whole thing on the father, the fact that we have a God who is father. We're living in a culture that really radically needs fathers. One of the things I love about being a friar here at the university is the ability to be a father to our students.
21:10 I've heard a lot of people say my father was a horrible father. Rarely have I heard somebody say, you know, I wasn't a very good son. I wasn't a very good son. Rarely have I heard somebody say, I was just a crappy daughter. I was moody all the time. I was selfish. It was just all about me, right? Sometimes we have to say we're sorry. And that's really, really difficult. It's really difficult to have to say you're sorry to a brother or sister or mom or dad or son or daughter. But it's necessary. And sometimes it may not necessarily be going to that person, but maybe going to confession. And repenting for the time that you're not a great brother or sister, father or brother, son or daughter. Amen? Third one, sometimes you need to get help. Sister talked this morning about counseling, or this afternoon about counseling. Sometimes situations are so difficult and so complicated, you just need to get some help. I don't know who that might be, your pastor, maybe your youth group leader, maybe a friend, the parent of one of your friends.
22:08 Sometimes you just need to bring another set of eyes or another set of wisdom, some wisdom into that situation. so don't be afraid to go out and reach for help amen number four you have to persevere is the reality is that sometimes that's the situation that they're just complicated it's difficult but you just persevere I think of my sister if I would have been sitting here when I was many of your age what was going through my mind is my sister just drives me crazy we just were always fighting we're always at odds with each other and it's just Now, she was only about 18 months older than I was, and she thought she was my mother. I think maybe because my mom wasn't able always to be there, my sister was like, well, I'll be your mom. It's like, I'll pass. Thank you very much, right? We fought constantly. But in time and perseverance, I mean, my sister really is one of my best, most dear. Like, when something's going on, I talk to my sister.
23:03 It just took time. It just took perseverance. It just took growth. It took forgiveness, right? I had to forgive her, and she had to. sometimes we just did mean things to each other. But time heals a lot and perseverance heals a lot. Amen? And then the last one is to trust. It's to trust that the Lord is present in the midst of your family. No matter what the circumstances, no matter what the situation, that God is present there. And trust that he'll be present to you. One of the things that sister said that was really good is that God doesn't always fix things, but he always loves us. You know, I used to say when I was younger, you know God's going to be able to fix everything and I suppose on one level he could but for one reason or another that I don't totally understand he doesn't always do what I want him to do he doesn't always fix things the way that I think they should be fixed but what he does do is he loves us in the middle of it he reveals himself he shows himself he brings us a peace that is really supernatural there's a saying that we've heard a number of times it says it takes courage just to get out of bed well over the years I've met many many students like that. Their circumstances were profoundly difficult at home and it takes courage for them to get out of bed. Much, much more than I've ever experienced. But they're pretty remarkable by their ability to allow the Lord to into their own heart and into their own life, heal the messiness, not always of the family, but the messiness that they experience in their own life. Pretty amazing things. Amen? I'm going to invite Katie up. She's going to just share just a minute or two. I thought it would be nice a couple of things. One, to have another perspective on family, but also I don't know that you guys know this, but I don't have a lot of kids, actually.
24:45 I don't have any. Just a few thousand. Yeah, just a few thousand. I only have two. Yeah, but Katie's just going to share a little bit, and then we're going to answer some questions, if you might have some questions. My story is not so different from father's. I have a pretty amazing family. There's just two of us, and I'm here to defend the small Catholic family. My mom had to have an emergency hysterectomy not long after my sister was born. And so there were no more kids in our family. And I'll never forget the day that somebody at the college, I did not go to Franciscan. What? I know, right? Sorry. It was too far away from Southwest. I was registered, and then my mom told me, you can't come home for Thanksgiving, and that was the end of that. So we let her come, and she's such a blessing. She's such a blessing in our conferences, so we win. Yes, they did. They did. And somebody looked at me at orientation and said, oh, are your parents not Catholic? And they found out there were only two kids in my family. And it gutted me because there's a lot of external judgment at times of all the different Catholic families and what everybody carries and what everybody's struggling with or what everybody's going through.
25:45 And I think there's a lot of room for all of us to grow in honoring the stories that everybody has and recognizing that the journey that somebody has in their family is not the journey, is the very same, you know, the person sitting right next to them, but that there's holiness to be found in all of it. With that being said, my mom and dad are daily mass going Catholics, for the record, and my sister is a canon lawyer about to become a nun. So, like, we're doing okay in the Catholic department with just the two of us, but here to answer questions with Father. Good. Any thoughts, comments, questions? If you have any questions, just raise your hand and we'll come to you. Let's go people first one. Easy. Oh look there's a hand over there. I got one over here. What should you do if you see one of your siblings going down a very bad path and you want to help them, but you don't know what to do? That's a great question.
26:42 So the question, if you couldn't understand here, was what do you do if you see one of your family members going down the wrong path and you want to help them, but you don't know how to help them? That is, honestly, in some ways that is part of the story of my family. I saw my older brothers. And I think one of the reasons I was more, ah, that's not fair. One of the reasons I was more obedient was because I saw how it hurt my mom and dad. I didn't necessarily do things because I was necessarily virtuous, but I really loved my mom and dad and I didn't want to hurt them. So I saw what that was doing to my mom and dad. A couple of things. First off, my experience and then jump in. My experience is that oftentimes, maybe not all the times, but oftentimes your brother or sister coming back is not going to be dependent on a family member. It's oftentimes somebody outside of the family because a family often has a lot of complicated relationships and stuff, that it's somebody outside the family.
27:36 So one of the things that I always do and encourage people to do is pray that God would send somebody into their life that would begin to steer them back to the right direction. There was a piece of advice or something that a priest said to my mom and dad one time that my mom took great consolation, and that was when my brothers had left the church, they said that an apple never falls that far from the tree. My brothers were formed in the type of family that I was formed in, so that they weren't going to go too far away, and they prayed that, that they not wander away too far. The last thing, and this is just like really kind of personal for me, is when my older brothers left the church, I decided, and this is real simple, you do it if you feel it's something God wants you to do, I decided I was going to fast for my brothers, and I wasn't going to eat sweets. So I gave up sweets, actually, I gave up sweets for almost 10 years. I didn't eat sweets, desserts, ice cream, that kind of thing. It was a really, really simple thing that I was going to do just to pray for my brothers, and pray that the Lord would bring them back.
28:28 eventually they did the last one took a while it was actually in this auditorium the day i was ordained god just really touched my brother through my ordination and brought my brother back to the church somebody said that after that i should eat sweets every day for for 10 years but i chose not to do that but for something scripture says some things are fasting and prayer is important so i think praying Thank you. We thought, okay, well, then she won't want to come to our kids' baptisms, but we still invited, and we still said, please come.
29:25 Like, please see this joy of the faith that we have. And not long after our youngest was baptized, we got a phone call that they were, wasn't Catholic baptism, but they were going to do one of those Christian dedication ceremonies at their church in Nashville that they now go to. And I think there's power in witness.
Machine translated from the source