Gentleness

Pete Nicholas · Redeemer Downtown · Published June 7, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Matthew 12:15-21 1:22
15Aware of this, Jesus withdrew from that place. Large crowds followed Him, and He healed them all, 16warning them not to make Him known. 17This was to fulfill what was spoken through the prophet Isaiah: 18“Here is My Servant, whom I have chosen, My beloved, in whom My soul delights. I will put My Spirit on Him, and He will proclaim justice to the nations. 19He will not quarrel or cry out; no one will hear His voice in the streets. 20A bruised reed He will not break, and a smoldering wick He will not extinguish, till He leads justice to victory. 21In His name the nations will put their hope.”

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

2:10 Thank you, Evie, very much for reading the passage. Let me add my welcome to Wills. I'm Pete Nicholas, the senior pastor here. I mean, what a joy-filled service it's been this morning, hasn't it? Amazing. I'm going to give you a spoiler alert. You definitely want to stick around if you're able for the postlude when the youth band will be back up playing that well-known Christian classic, Don't Stop Believing. So we'll enjoy that a little bit later. while we're continuing our sermon series, looking at the nine aspects of the fruit of the Spirit, and we're looking at gentleness this morning. And as we've been going through this sermon series, we've given it the title, The Power of Good. And that seems particularly poignant as we think about this virtue of gentleness. Because if there is a virtue, I suppose, which shows us the two paths that are available to us, particularly in the U.S. and in Western society in general, at the moment, and I think it's gentleness. On one hand, we all want to live powerful and impactful lives.

3:14 We talk of making our mark, leaving a legacy. You know, we want to be able to leverage and do things and transform the culture, and that seems very important. And therefore, in light of that, gentleness just seems like too weak a virtue for us to really inhabit. You know, we know the phrase, don't we? In order to make an omelette, you have to break a few eggs. It doesn't feel very gentle, but it kind of gets the job done. And I think that's what we feel in society at the moment. The world is a complicated place. There are significant forces at work for good and ill. And therefore, if we have to kind of sacrifice some of the less powerful virtues like gentleness to get the job done, so be it. And yet at the same time, that kind of leaves us with a sense that we're missing out on something. And we read these famous words describing the character of the servant from Isaiah picked up in Matthew to describe Jesus of Nazareth, that a bruised reed he would not break and a smoldering wick he would not snuff out. We find it intuitively beckoning and attractive. And so we want to be able to live powerful and impactful lives for Jesus in the city. And at the same time, we also want to be gentle because we find that attractive.

4:26 Is there a way of doing both? That's why this sermon series is called The Power of Good, because real power comes from the ultimately good life that Jesus of Nazareth lived and his death and his resurrection. And the power of the Spirit, he gives us to live this out, a life full of the fruit of the Spirit, including gentleness. So let's see why gentleness is actually probably not quite what we think and why it's so needful today. We're going to think about under three headings. First of all, the strength of gentleness. Secondly, the justice of gentleness. And then we're going to see how the gospel of Jesus Christ uniquely can gentle us, how we can become gentled. Okay, that's where we're going. Let's look first of all at the strength of gentleness. You can see gentleness here, beautifully and memorably described in Matthew chapter 12, verse 19.

He will not quarrel or cry out to the servant, this person of Jesus. No one will hear his voice in the streets. A bruised reed he will not break. A smoldering wick he will not snuff out.

5:26 The imagery here is of a reed by the reed bed at the banks of the Nile or something like that, and it's swaying in the breeze, and then the wind gets a bit too strong, and it breaks and snaps and bends over. And you know if you've seen a reed like that, it won't stand up again. You can try and stand up, but it keeps falling over. And so you might just snap it off and say, well, it's all done with, but not the Messiah. No, he restores and stands up those who feel beaten down by the sin and the ills of the world. A smoldering wick he will not snuff out. It's a picture of embers at the end of a candle. The flame has gone out, but it's just there. You can just still see the slight glow as the smoke mists off the top of it. A picture of faith. And here is a person who's doubting and struggling. maybe feeling beaten down or beaten up by the difficulties of life. And it would be so easy just for them to be snuffed out. Just a breeze, just a touch would do it. But not the touch of Jesus.

6:24 No, that touch is a healing touch. He gently kindles and fans even the faintest embers into the full fire of faith. So attractive, isn't it? So gentle, so restorative. We look at this and we think, what intuitively we want to be like that. And then you read the pages of the New Testament and you realize this is no hyperbole. This is not just beautiful poetry, but it's more memorable because it's a description of reality. As you read through Matthew's gospel and you see Jesus, you see the blessing of his words, that they bring life. They build up. They don't tear down. You see the grace of his demeanor, that those who have been most bruised, most pulled down and broken down by the world are the ones who run to him, little children, the marginalized, the wounded, those needing healing, they just gravitate towards Jesus.

7:21 Such is the grace of the way he carries himself. You see the compassion of his heart. He looks out on people and he looks through all of the facades and the masks and the filters and he sees you, the real you, and he sees that you are like a sheep without a shepherd. and he moves towards you in tender compassion, feeling with your pain, not distance from you, but actually the more you suffer, the closer he comes to you. You see the restoration of his actions. Whatever the need, whether physical healing, whether forgiveness, whether community restoration, Jesus steps in and always seems to know the right thing to say and the right thing to do. Never compromising justice, we'll see that. but moving towards us with forgiveness and restoration. Here is a God who doesn't come to tear down, but to build up.

8:18 Here is a God who doesn't come to bring death, but life. Not condemnation, but construction. Life-giving. This is gentleness embodied. You want to know what a gentle life looks like? Look at the life of Jesus. And so the call for us to be gentle is the call to have a tender disposition that seeks the restoration of others. Let me say that again. A tender disposition that seeks the restoration of others. Gentleness is all about restoration. Now, properly understood, gentleness, therefore, is not weakness. Actually, gentleness is true strength. You actually see that in the passage. After this description of gentleness, we get, until he has brought justice through to victory. In his name, the nations will put that hope. That's impactful. That's powerful. That's transformative. Justice brought. All nations seeing the impact of the servant. This is not a weak life. Far from it. No, this is a strong life, but it's the right type of strength. One of the words in the New Testament that's often used for gentleness is a word sometimes translated also meek. It's there in Matthew 5 at the beginning of the Sermon on the Mount. Blessed are the meek, for they will inherit the earth. The word is Prouse. And Prouse means strength under control, strength tempered by great self-control and skill.

9:42 The picture that's sometimes used for Prouse is of a powerful war horse ridden by a masterful rider who has it completely under control, such that it could touch its hoof just down, doesn't bring about death and destruction, but instead brings about healing and victory. That's the imagery here. And I think intuitively we know this. I mean, think of a more modern-day example. Let's imagine that there's a car crash, and the car is all bent out of shape, and someone is injured and inside the wreckage, and the emergency services are called out, and the fire crew are there, and they are highly trained and highly skilled to use very powerful instruments that can cut away the metal. But it's no good just kind of coming in there with a massive tractor and riding over the top of the car and crushing the car and crushing the person inside. No, they use great skill, great focus, great control to cut away through the metal and to release the person inside.

10:40 so that they can get the help. That's gentleness. And so it does for us in life. The many people that we will see in life, maybe ourselves included, sometimes feel like we're crushed under the wreckage of living in a life, living in a world that is this side of the fall, marred by what the Bible calls sin, our own appetite for destruction, the ways we turn away from God and all of the effects of that, broken relationships, broken souls, broken communities. It doesn't take long to walk around New York City and to see the wreckage, the kind of metal bent out of shape, and you can hear the cries of the people trapped inside the wreckage of the sin of this world. And to be a restoring and a healing presence requires great strength, but it requires gentled strength. The skillful counselor who can cut through the twisted up metal of a distorted life story and wrong narratives that people are telling them about themselves. The person who with great skill can marshal their way through a broken community which has become acrimonious as people are in dispute one with another, and they can't even really remember what they're arguing about or what started it. They just know that they unreconcilable with each other. The city problems we face, food insecurity, poverty, all effects of sin and the fall, and it requires gentleness, that is strength, tempered with great skill and focus, true gentleness to restore. We see it perfectly in the life of Jesus Christ, and that is the call of His people. Gentleness, properly understood, is this tempered strength, seeking the restoration of others. It is not weakness, far from it. Actually, it shows an immature power, an immature strength when people don't know how to wield it, when they just go ahead and leave wreckage behind them. That's why children have to learn self-control, learn gentleness, temper their strength as they grow up. Fathers, I'm looking at you particularly, mothers, model this to your

12:46 children. Learn even the simplest things of counting to 10 before you speak, lest an ungentle word come out of your mouth. Model it in the way you talk to another. Model it in the way you talk to yourself sometimes. Temper the power and the control. Hone it for restoration, for good, for healing. That's true strength, the strength of gentleness. Secondly, it brings us to the justice of gentleness. Next, we need to see that gentleness is not at odds with justice, but rather gentleness, properly understood, is the right deployment of justice. One of the areas where we frequently are most ungentle, and I think this is true of all of us, is when we have been wronged or when we see wrong. That's when the ungentle words come out, right? That's when the ungentle actions start to flow. That's when we need to restrain our power and our words and what we might say or do, and they need to be tempered. Because in those moments when the injustice has happened either to us or we see it happening to other people, the anger can be kindled, but it can be more than a hint of unrighteous anger, of excessive or over-the-top anger. And in that anger, we become ungentle and we start to tear down, break reeds, snuff out the embers of faith.

14:06 And so we need to understand how gentleness is also related to justice. As we've been going through these virtues of the fruit of the Spirit, we've been engaging with some of the ancients in their understanding of these virtues, and particularly Thomas Aquinas and Augustine. And interestingly, both of these great theologians spoke a lot about the way that gentleness related to justice. So Thomas Aquinas in his Summa Theologica talked about the way that gentleness is a temperance on excessive, hasty, or rash anger. Gentleness is a temperance on excessive, hasty, or rash anger. In other words, the moment you're wronged, and you throw your hands up in the air. You say, I can't believe she did that to me. I can't believe he cut me up in the road. Did you see what they did? Or when the social media pylon starts, that someone we're not even related to, we have no moral proximity or social proximity to, and we hear of an injustice, and suddenly everyone as the Twitter warriors are wading in with their cancel culture statements.

15:08 full of condemnation and not at all tempered by gentleness. In those moments when our anger becomes aroused, and to be clear, it's not saying that something wrong hasn't happened. It's just saying that our reaction is excessive. Then we need to understand how gentleness is about seeking the proper type of justice and is about tempering our anger and injustice. St. Augustine talks about this in the incident with the woman caught in adultery in John chapter 8. He uses it as one of the great illustrations where we see Jesus, therefore, in embodying gentleness. You remember the story, perhaps, in John 8. A woman is caught in adultery, and the Pharisees and the teachers of the law bring her before Jesus in a public setting to shame her and also to put Jesus on the spot. And of course, they're trying to catch Jesus on the horns of a dilemma.

16:03 To be clear, this woman has actually committed adultery, and therefore she has done something wrong. The Bible does not condone that at all. And the dilemma that they want to get Jesus on is, he's either going to have to uphold the standard of justice, in which case he will condemn her, and so his attractive, gentle demeanor that has been drawing the crowd to him will suddenly be gone, and he'll no longer be as popular. That's dilemma on one side. Or on the other side, he's going to be gentle and gracious to her and forgive her and let her go. But then what about the moral cost of what she's done? And it shows that the Messiah is not concerned about justice, as the Pharisees think that they have him. And caught in that dilemma, and all eyes train on him as this woman is there, dejected, thrown down at his feet, waiting for the sentence. With all of the Pharisees and the teachers of the law in the crowd looking on with condemnation, and excessive anger. And then Jesus remarkably says this, let any one of you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her.

17:08 At this, those who heard began to go away, one at a time, until only Jesus was left. Then Jesus straightened up and asked her, woman, where are they, your accusers? Has not one condemned you? She looked around, no one, sir. Neither do I condemn you, he declared. Go now and leave your life of sin. Please notice here, Jesus is not condoning sin. She had done something wrong. There was real moral accounting that needs to be done. We'll talk about that in a moment. He says, go and leave your life of sin. He doesn't say, you do you. Don't let anyone constrain you. Follow your heart. No, no. He says, leave your life of sin. It's very clear. God himself in human form giving her a clear command. This is sin, don't do it. He doesn't condone sin and the wreckage that it leaves about in lives and communities, but nor does he condemn her. Woman, where are they, those who are condemning you? She says, there's no one here. Then neither do I condemn you. The gentleness, the restraint on anger, not excessive, not hasty, not rushing in. What does the Bible say about anger? In your anger, do not sin, because that's when we often sin, because nothing arouses our propensity to sin like self-righteous anger.

18:31 Oh, we love to leverage that, and all the anger suddenly spills over, and all the breaking down on the condemnation. I can't believe they did this. Really? You've probably done it 20 times this week, right? We cut people up in the road when we're driving, and when people cut us up in the road, we're furious. We shoulder check people as we're going to the subway, but if anyone shoulder checks us, better watch out for them. We speak ill of other people, but then we take to social media to speak ill of others. And then if they speak ill of us, oh my goodness, they've got to be cancelled. Have you seen what they're doing? We're a culture full of self-righteousness and ungentled anger, and it's pulling us apart, not least of course in the political sphere. This is not saying that there aren't standards of justice. It's not saying there aren't important discussions. But those discussions are going to be more meaningful. They're going to build up, not just tear down, if we check our anger first.

19:28 We need to be careful about anger towards others. But a lot of the reasons we're so angry towards others, if I can put it this way, is because we are actually, deep down, angry towards ourselves. Let me give you an example. About two years ago, we were at home in the apartment, and I was just walking around, and I heard my oldest son just, he made a mistake, dropped something, and he just turned around and said to himself, he just, oh, you're so stupid. It shocked me, hearing him speak in that way to himself. And I went over to him straight away, I said, you know, son, we don't call each other words like that. Stupid. You're not stupid. You're great. And he said, oh, but dad, that's how you talk to yourself. And Rebecca was standing in the kitchen, and I went to justify myself. I was going to say, oh, that's okay, because I'm an adult, and you know, adults can talk to themselves that way, and you're a child, right? And just as I was about to say those words, Rebecca, knowing me well, kind of just looked out the corner of her eye, and I caught myself, because she wonderfully was catching me, and I just said, yeah, you're right. I'm really sorry. I shouldn't talk to myself that way. You know, we all have these voices in our heads, don't we? Often they're the voices that echo from and resound from our past. A lot of people in New York have this. It's part of what makes you good at the things you do, the unrelenting standards. Good enough never is. Try harder. Be better. Do more. And maybe it's different figures in our lives. Maybe it was a father who intended well for you, but it just got the better of him, and he was always giving you excessive standards, or a mother as well. For me, it was certainly lots of sports coaches. You know, you didn't win. Why didn't you win? Do better. Go train harder. And the voice gets embedded in your head. It's not a gentle voice, is it? It presses you. It pushes you down. It bruises you. It snuffs out your enthusiasm for life because even when the good things come along, it's never enough. There's never good enough.

21:26 There's always another mountain. There's always another horizon. Do better, be more. And so we impose it on God, and we think that's how God sees us. Oh, my friend, we won't be gentle with others until we can be gentle with ourselves. God is not looking at you as his son or daughter saying, do more, be better, keep my commands endlessly. No, he looks at you with grace and gentleness and restoration. Read the New Testament. See the person of Jesus Christ. Let his words correct your distorted, internalized words. Let his narratives correct your internal narrative. Be gentle to yourself, and you'll learn to be gentle to others. The strength of gentleness, the justice of gentleness. Lastly, how can we be gentled?

22:23 I know because I always enjoy interacting with members of the congregation after the service, and we talk about the sermon, and I know now that there'll be a number of you who are thinking, okay, but you've let a lot of the meat on this bone, Pete, because we've been talking about justice, and we've been talking about not condemning, but what about when people really do things wrong? I mean, think of the woman caught in adultery. She really did commit adultery. We don't hear about the family, but there was a family. And there is wreckage in that situation as a result of her actions. So it sounds lovely, doesn't it? Be gentle, go and be gracious, don't condemn people. But what about when people really do wrong? Or what about when the narrative of be gentle is used to get off scot-free when someone's actually really done wrong? How do we deal with that? I'm so glad you're asking thoughtful questions. That's exactly what we need to deal with. and this is why the gospel of Jesus Christ uniquely, uniquely gives us the resources to become gentle people, to be gentled because Jesus does not overlook justice. Hopefully you saw that in the passage. We're told that God will put his spirit on him, verse 18, and he will proclaim justice to the nations. He will be gentle, verse 20, until he has brought justice through to the victory. Notice how gentleness is framed either side with justice. Here's the thing that we need to know. We cannot be gentle unless we know that justice will be done or that justice has been done.

23:58 You know, sometimes there are parts of the world where there's no justice system, at least no functioning justice system. And what happens there? Vigilante justice. and vigilante justice is never gentle. It's never gentle. It's always excessive. It's always overstated. It always tears down rather than builds up because justice entrusted into our private hands is going to bring about damage because we are not the people who are going to best steward justice. So there's two applications at least from this. Number one, in order to be gentle in the community, we have to trust that the community has actually got mechanisms and processes of justice. That's so true in church. I know that many churches have decided to cover up injustice because they favor their own reputation. Let that never be said of Redeemer downtown. We have processes on this. We have a safeguarding team. If you see injustice being done, you don't need to be the expert. You don't need to share it with 100 people. You just need to bring it to the church leadership, and there's a clear accountability there. You can go to the website, find out more about how that happens. That's vital, because unless you trust that justice is going to be done, you'll try and take it into your own hands, and then gentleness and condemnation, sorry, condemnation and lack of gentleness spills over. But what happens at a micro level is so true at a gospel level. Romans chapter 12, verse 19, we're told this, do not take revenge, my dear friends. Why? But leave room for God's wrath, for it is written, it is mine to avenge. I will replace, says the Lord. You're thinking, that doesn't sound very gentle? No, actually, that's the very key to gentleness. You can't be gentle to other people unless you really know that God is just. You can't be gentle to other people unless you really know that God is just, and He will one day give a full moral accounting. And is that not what the cross is all about? The cross is God Himself in human form saying, I will pay for the injustice.

25:55 I will be condemned so that we can forgive sin without condoning sin. I will take on all of the righteous anger, all of the just implications of sin, of the ways we turn away from God. I will take them all on me. I will pay the price so that their full moral accounting has been done at the cross. And therefore, every human being will either have their sin paid for at the cross, or they'll pay for it at the judgment day, but they will be paid for. In God's economy, justice has been done and justice will be done. And therefore, because we live in the light of that, we can be gentle now. Because it's not down to us to be the enforcers of justice. Someone slights you, leave it in the Lord's hands. Someone wrongs you, trust the institution to deal with it.

26:51 and even if that's imperfect, one day God, the perfect judge, will deal with it. And it's only if you know that deep in your soul that you don't try to take justice into your own hands and become ungentle. But second implication of this, the cross is also the way that we become gentled. There's a man called Richard Sibbes. He was one of the great Puritans and one of my favorite preachers and authors. He was such a gentle preacher that his congregation in Cambridge in England nicknamed him the sweet dropper, the sweet dropper, because his words were so sweet and gentle. By the way, no nicknames here, please. Richard Sibbes preached a series of sermons, and it got turned into a book called The Bruised Read, all about this passage from Matthew and Isaiah. And he says this in his sermon, and we're going to close on this. God sees fit that we should taste of that cup of which his son drank so deep that we might feel a little of what sin is.

27:52 and what his son's love was. But our comfort is that Christ drank the dregs of the cup for us. And will succor us so that our spirits may not utterly fail under that little taste of his displeasure which we may feel. He became not only man but a curse, a man of sorrows for us. He was broken that we should not be broken. He was troubled that we should not be desperately troubled. He become accursed that we should not be accursed. Whatever may be wished for in an all-sufficient comforter is to be found in Christ. He's saying this, how do you become gentled? You have to drink a little, just a little of the cup that Christ drank. He drank it all to the dregs. He drank it all for you. But this means that to the extent that you have a sense of what he's done for you, that will gentle you. You know, when you're flying off the handle because you've been wronged, how do you restrain yourself?

28:48 You look at Jesus and you think, he didn't condemn me. He's died for me. He took the punishment for me. He took the anger that should be on me on himself. He was gentle and restorative for me. He didn't bruise me or snuff out my faith. Neither will I do that to another. When you have really got some wounds, they need to be bound up. You take them to Christ and you say, I've wounded you. And yet your grace is such that it binds up my wounds. Let me be a healing presence in other people's lives. When you're struggling to forgive because you've really been wronged, and your internal narrative is far from gentle, how do you approach the other person? And this is not easy. But with great prayer and support from your friends, you approach them knowing that you are forgiven, and therefore you're going to labor to forgive that person. Not because you've not done anything wrong, but because you're a sinner just like them.

29:41 You've wronged others like them. You've wronged God like them. You drink a little of the cup, and as you take that in, it starts to make you gentle and turns you into a person who lives in the power of good, a life of gentleness in the Spirit. Let it be so. Let me pray for us. Heavenly Father, thank you for this passage and this call for us to be gentle. Forgive us for all of the ungentleness of our demeanor and our words and our internal narratives and the ways we conduct ourselves. Lord God, may we see that gentleness is strength. Gentleness is about restorative justice. And then make us, in the power of your Spirit, a people who are gentled as we drink a little of the cup that Christ has drunk fully for us. We pray for his name's sake.

Machine translated from the source