Do Not Judge

Pete Nicholas · Redeemer Downtown · Published March 9, 2025

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Matthew 7:1-6 0:42
1“Do not judge, or you will be judged. 2For with the same judgment you pronounce, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you. 3Why do you look at the speck in your brother’s eye but fail to notice the beam in your own eye? 4How can you say to your brother, ‘Let me take the speck out of your eye,’ while there is still a beam in your own eye? 5You hypocrite! First take the beam out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to remove the speck from your brother’s eye. 6Do not give dogs what is holy; do not throw your pearls before swine. If you do, they may trample them under their feet, and then turn and tear you to pieces.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

1:54 Now, when you think about it, we have a strange kind of contradictory relationship with judging and judgmentalism in our society today. So on the one hand, we hear a lot of kind of phrases and aphorisms and things like that that are saying, you know, who am I to judge? It's not my place to judge. You're entitled to your opinion. You do you. Everyone's allowed to have their own perspective. And so as a society, we kind of have a very allergic reaction to any sense of judging and judgmentalism, right? But on the other hand, we have an obsession with judging and forming judgments. For example, think of that profound cultural phenomenon, Judge Judy. 25 seasons, I hear, that Judge Judy went through and is now the most successful rerunning show on TV. Or think of American Idol or America's Got Talent. You know, part of the reason that those shows are so popular is because everyone loves the judges giving their judgment.

2:51 And we desire that, actually, on a much more profound level. Think about all the congressional hearings, congressional committees that we see televised. What are they all about? For everything from vaccinations through to whether TikTok's actually sharing our data with China, we long for some kind of ruling, some kind of bringing all the evidence to bear and a decision, a judgment being made. So in this strange tension as a society, we hate the idea of judging and forming judgments. And on the other hand, we desperately desire. And I wonder if what's going on is it's a little bit like the moral equivalent of when you try to squeeze into a suit or an outfit, which you've long since outgrown. You know, the pressure kind of mills and it has to burst out somewhere, right? I wonder if you've had that experience. And I wonder if what's happening is by us suppressing any sense of discernment and judgment in society, it's spilling over in other areas, on our popular TV shows, and in a sense that we've got to form judgments to navigate what is an increasingly complex world, particularly in a city like New York, which is technically super diverse. How on earth can we function well with so many people from so many different perspectives if we're not able to form judgments. We don't want to be judgmental, but we do desperately need to form judgments. Otherwise, we're not going to be able to cope in life.

4:11 So let's try to look at the resources that Jesus gives us to navigate this tension as we come to this short but a brilliant passage. And as we come to it, I want to go through three points. First of all, we want to look at judgmentalism and realize that all judgmentalism is fundamentally rooted in pride. That's the first point. Secondly, we're going to see how Jesus shows us that judgmentalism is hypocritical. But thirdly, we're going to see how he balances all of that out by urging us to live lives of humble discernment. Humble discernment. That's where we're going to go. Look with me first of all at judgmentalism is rooted in pride. Now first, if you're joining us as we're coming into the Sermon on the Mount, let me do a little bit of a recap. We've been saying as we've been preaching through the Sermon on the Mount that the great theme of the sermon is the kingdom of heaven. And that's a kind of strange phrase, but what Jesus means by the kingdom of heaven is a sphere of authority.

5:05 As God comes into your life and works in your life in the power of his spirit, bringing his transforming power to change people and communities as he brings them under their authority. And Jesus is the great king of heaven. And so this is about living in relationship with him. under his authority and with his transforming power in your life. And as we've been talking about that, we've been saying that what Jesus is primarily focused on doing in the Sermon on the Mount... is inculcating, fostering, forming in his followers certain virtues of the way they're supposed to live. So the Sermon on the Mount isn't so much a set of new laws, though there certainly are some commands there, but it's much more about the Beatitudes being worked out as Jesus outlines these virtues which are to characterize those who follow him. Virtues of the spiritual life, Virtues like being merciful, being a peacemaker, being poor in spirit.

6:02 And really, the whole Sermon on the Mount is about fleshing out what those virtues, those beatitudes look like. And so today, I think when we're looking at judgmentalism, we are thinking about the virtue of being a peacemaker. As Jesus teaches, blessed are the peacemakers. Well, in order to be a peacemaker, you need to grasp this difference between being judgmental and forming good judgments. being discerning. And so that's what Jesus is doing here, I think. And so we come to verse 1, chapter 7. Do not judge, or you too will be judged. For in the same way you judge others, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you. Jesus is pointing out here that all judgmentalism, that is, all of this attitude of looking down your nose at other people, is about elevating yourself and putting yourself in the seat of the judge. And I use that kind of phrasing deliberately because what's fascinating is across all systems pretty much of justice, certainly in the West, the architecture, the dynamics of the courtroom give away what's really going on. You see, in every courtroom you go into, the judge is always elevated, is always seated above, is always seated on some kind of dais or in some elevated position.

7:14 Now, why is that? Even we use the phrase, don't we, of you can make an appeal to a higher court. A lower court appeals to a higher court. It never goes the other way around. As though the closer you get to the final judgment, the higher up the judge is. Why is that? Well, it's an important dynamic that's talking about perspective. A judge needs to be the person where he or she sees things truly, sees things accurately. And they also are the ones uniquely given, not only the perspective and the training, but also the authority to be able to make the judgment call. That's what we invest in our judges and our judiciary, right? That's why we represent it with them being elevated. So here's the problem. When a person is being judgmental, they are elevating themselves. We use the phrase, they are looking down their nose at another person. Or the old phrase of pride, a haughty spirit, a spirit that's elevated and thinks they know better than other people.

8:13 Now think of why that's problematic. You see, with a judge, before they can make any judgment in the courtroom, they need to receive all the information or at least as much as they can. They need to hear the arguments from both sides in a fair and impartial process. Great care and attention is given that their own biases are not brought to bear in an unthoughtful way. In other words, enormous amount of care and attention is given to make sure they do have the information and they do have the best possible perspective. And even with all that being done, our justice system is primarily set up to avoid wrong judgments, which is why the great evil in our justice system is an innocent person going to jail for a crime they didn't commit. That's what we're strut up to avoid more actually than sending guilty people to jail. That's the great evil to avoid. In other words, great care is taken, but when you are being judgmental, you do not have all the information. You are not vested with the authority to make the call, and you do not have the perfect perspective. And yet by elevating yourself, you are trying to claim implicitly that you have those things. And therefore you are saying, I know best, I can look down on other people you don't understand, I've got the perspective.

9:27 How proud. That's the problem with judgmentalism. It's rooted in pride. And I think we need to reflect for a moment on our own culture, particularly in the West, and think about how we are particularly prone maybe to this danger. I want to highlight two dynamics, individualism, and then social media. I don't have a downer on social media. I used to work in tech. I've written a book about tech, so I'm very pro-tech, but I also think we need to be aware of its dangers. Individualism, first of all. When we increasingly think of ourselves as individuals rather than a community, when we increasingly spend time on our own interacting with myself rather than with other people, you know we become very bad at navigating difference. We get reinforced in our own blind spots. One of the great ways to see your blind spot is to rub shoulders with people who are different to you. But if we are constantly being individuals who whenever we come into difference say, well, I don't like that perspective, so I'm going to go off and do me, then guess what?

10:29 We lack nuance, we get ingrained in our blind spots, and we're unable to navigate conversations of difference very well. So individualism leads to the type of pride-filled judgmentalism, if it's not worked very hard to undo that bias. Secondly, social media. When you're on social media, you're in what I've called in previous sermons a hidden echo chamber. Echo chambers have always existed where we gather together with people of same opinion. It's not necessarily an evil or a bad thing, but when it's hidden and when we don't realize that it is a bad thing, because we get the illusion on social media through our feeds that we're seeing everything. We're seeing all the arguments. We're getting all the information. Trust me, you are not. You are getting a very tailored algorithm geared towards you that caricatures the perspectives you don't like because guess what? That sells better and grabs your attention more and over-represents the perspectives you do like.

11:23 And so you become more ingrained in your myopia, your short-sightedness, your blind spots. And the worst thing about it is you don't even know that that's what's happening. So pair those two together, that individualism and the dynamics of the algorithms on social media, and what do you expect to get? A society where we do not navigate difference well, where we walk around highly judgmental, deeply proud, unaware of our pride, casting judgments on everybody else. Does that sound like the society we're in in New York City? It does to me. And this is why, dare I say, the church must strive to be so different. Because the church is a unique environment where it says, no, fundamentally, we are individuals living in community. It's about what the community is doing. And actually, the church should be defined and has always been defined by being diverse and different, heterogeneous, as diverse as its locality. Think of Acts chapter 16 and Lydia, the kind of sophisticated cotton trader, and then the jailer, the gritty blue-collar worker, and then the slave girl. And think of all the mixing together. They did not share the same perspective. They had to figure it out. And most of the New Testament is written into communities figuring out their differences. And so we have to be different as a church community saying, I don't get all the perspectives. I need to spend time with people who are different to me. I recognize that otherwise I'm going to become proud and ingrained in my own blind spots. And I don't want that. That doesn't lead to flourishing for me, and it won't lead to flourishing for one another. Judgmentalism is rooted in pride. Leads us secondly to judgmentalism is hypocritical. Now I've done a lot of research with ophthalmologists this week on this, because as we come into it, you see that Jesus has a grasp of how an eye operation is going to go. Let's look at it. First of all verse three. Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother's eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye?

13:24 How can you say to your brother, let me take the speck out of your eye, when all the time there is a plank in your own eye. I mean, this is a brilliant illustration. This really shows Jesus kind of, you know, with just such a fantastic parable that makes so many profound points. Let me try to draw out at least a few of them. First of all, he's talking here about hypocritical. I think as much as is being obvious that judgmentalism is hypocritical, but it's hypocritical in certain particular ways. Firstly, when we're hypocritical, our pride makes us heavy-handed. Our pride makes us heavy-handed. Well, how do you get that from this? Well, of course, if you have to do some kind of operation where someone genuinely does have a small speck in their eye, then first of all, notice the eye is incredibly delicate, right? If you touch it in the wrong place, you can do enormous lasting damage to the eye, which is why ophthalmologists are so careful and so precise. Secondly, to remove a speck, it's a tiny, small thing. So you've got a tiny object in a very sensitive context. So you're going to have to be enormously careful. But the person here trying to perform this type of eye surgery has got a massive obstruction, a plank in their own eye.

14:38 Now, you don't need to be an ophthalmologist to know that that is going to make them not careful and very heavy-handed. Fumbling, sticking their hands in all the wrong places, causing great deal of damage. That's what Jesus is getting at. So it is with pride. Pride makes us heavy-handed. I wonder if you've experienced this. You've probably had people give you feedback before, maybe at work or in a personal context. Take a humble person giving you feedback. Take a proud person giving you feedback. Very different experiences, right? A proud person is prone to overstatements. They're dealing with their own insecurities, so they wade in too heavy-handedly. You come away from it feeling battered and bruised and thinking, I hope they never speak to me again. A humble person, there can still be a sting of truth to it, but there's a delicate way about them. There's a patience about them. There's a thoughtfulness and a nuance about them. There's a precision about them. Pride makes us very overstated, very heavy-handed, but actually humility makes us careful and delicate and insightful and nuanced. Judgmentalism by being rooted in pride leads to this hypocrisy that leads to a heavy handedness. Secondly, our pride also distorts our perspective. I mean, that's obvious in the illustration, isn't it? That a person who has got a plank in their eye can't see clearly out of that eye. And so therefore, they don't have the right perspective, which is ironic because, of course, when you speak to a proud person or when we ourselves are grappling with pride, we convince ourselves that we do have the perspective.

16:20 You see this often frequently with people who are very competent or very insightful in one area, and then they feel the need to pronounce very strong judgments and insights on another area where they have no expertise at all. And they often get it completely wrong. I think a great example of this, by the way, is Richard Dawkins, the new atheist, who is a very, very gifted biologist, clearly a terrible theologian, because in his books he can't even define basic things like faith well. He just doesn't get them right. He's not even accurate at all. Why is that? Well, because he's presuming that because he knows about one area, biology, he can speak authoritatively in another area where he's had no training and clearly has done very little research, theology. I would tremble about entering into his field and speaking about biology. Technically, he should tremble about entering into a theologian's field unless he's done some training and work. Just because the books sell doesn't mean they're accurate, right? This is how pride works. It limits our perspective and it makes us think that we have the perspective when we really don't.

17:21 Therefore, there's a sense in which humility makes you realize, I might know about this, something in this area. I really know very little about this area. I need to be careful to speak into that. Otherwise, I'm going to become judgmental and hypocritical. So our pride makes is heavy-handed. Our pride in judgmentalism distorts our perspective. And third, our pride is often a racket. Now, a racket is an image from the prohibition era, where if someone wanted to buy alcohol when it was outlawed in New York City, they would kind of go into a shop, like a sweet shop or something that presents as a normal grocery store maybe, and they would say, you know, could you give me the real vegetables or the real sweets, please? And they would sell alcohol under the counter. Or at least that's how it works in the movies, right? And it was a racket. It presents as one thing, but actually, all the while, it's a front to trade alcohol under the counter. Well, psychologically, one of the most toxic rackets that we form is where we become hypercritical in a particular area that we ourselves are failing in. It's the best, worst, actually, diabolical distraction tactic. Become hypercritical about the very thing that you see in your own heart. We do that. It's a racket. Psychologists are well on top of this. It's a racket that distances yourself from it, allows you to condemn it, and present as the person who's very thoughtful about this area and very concerned about this area. And how many times in public scandals have we realized that the most strident critic in that area is a person who himself is failing in that area and living with that psychological dissonance. It's a racket. We must avoid that.

19:04 And one of the clearest ways to avoid it is to remember that God sees everything. And so this is coming out in the parable because notice that the plank and the speck are of the same material. They're both wood. A speck of sawdust and a plank of wood. I think it's such an insightful thing that Jesus is pointing at. He's saying they both have the same problem, but the problem that the person who's hypocritical is trying to point out to the other person is actually their major issue. That's how the racket of pride works. You point it out in other people because you detest it in yourself, but you've not dealt with it in yourself. And so you become strident and critical and over the top about it, and you lack nuance and patience and grace because you've not worked through your own issues. Jesus says, do not judge, lest you be judged. Remember, there is a judge and you are not him.

19:59 He sees everything, you do not. And he sees your own sin far more clearly than you see it or you see others. So do not judge. Now, if we just were to leave it there, I think we would go away thinking, well, I just need to avoid all kind of judgments, all kind of discerning complex situations because the risks are too great. But it's fascinating where Jesus goes with the wonderful balance that he ends with, where I think he's calling us in verse 6 to have humble discernment. Look with me. He writes, or he speaks rather, do not give dogs what is sacred. Do not throw your pearls to pigs. If you do, they may trample them under their feet and turn and tear you to pieces. Now what's going on here? Well, I think we can avoid a few things here. Clearly Jesus can't be name-calling. So he's clearly not saying that there are some people, let's call them dogs or pigs as a derogatory term. Why does he say he can't be doing that? Well, earlier on in Matthew chapter 5 verse 22, he's clearly taught against that type of treating of other people where he said, anyone who calls his brother Raka, as in you fool, is guilty of hell fire. So Jesus is no hypocrite. His disciples are very clear about this. They lived with him for three years. They say they never saw a hint of sin or hypocrisy in his life ever. So he's clearly not endorsing a kind of religious name calling of looking down on others like the Gentiles. I think that's what's going on. I think what is happening here is he is talking about some illustrations, some quick illustrations that show discernment. So literally the illustration is this. Imagine you had something sacred from the temple, some sacred food, some meat that was supposed to be offered to God, and the remainder of it was supposed to be given to the priests, or some ceremonial bread.

21:38 And imagine that you took that really valuable, really precious food, and you just gave it to a a stray dog, that would be lacking in discernment. Because you haven't realized that's not what that food is for. And so you're failing to understand and to read the situation, right? It's just an example in an illustration of discernment. And then he takes it one stage further. Not only would that be inappropriate, but he uses the illustration of pearls to pigs. Now, again, you don't have to be a farmer to know that if you chuck some pearls in a pigsty, the pigs will probably think it's food, and they will jump all over it, try and then trample over it as they try to eat it. And then if you are foolish enough to realize your error and decide you've got to go and retrieve these very valuable materials, these pearls, you're going to get trampled as well, probably bitten by the pigs, and it's just going to be very painful and very damaging for all concerned. So Jesus here is, again, teaching about discernment. He's saying, don't be judgmental, but do form judgments with a humble discernment.

22:36 Make the right call about when you speak into a situation, when you don't. how you speak into a situation and how not to speak into a situation. Be discerning. Just don't try to be discerning with a haughty spirit. Instead, be discerning with a humble spirit. I think that's what he's getting at. And implicitly in the framing of the Sermon on the Mount, he would want us to see that the only way we can have that type of humble discernment is if we really understand the dynamic of the gospel in our lives. You see, if we do not have the dynamic of the gospel, we will not be able to become humble and discerning. Think of the Apostle Paul, who writes in 1 Timothy 1, verses 15 to 16.

Here is a trustworthy saying that deserves full acceptance. Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners, of whom I am the worst. But for that very reason, I was shown mercy, so that in me, the worst of sinners, Christ Jesus might display his immense patience as an example of those who would believe in him and receive eternal life.

23:43 This gives you a window into the inner psyche of the Apostle Paul. And the thing is, when you read the New Testament, you realize that the Apostle Paul is incredibly discerning. He is the guy who is able to sort out these very complex pastoral situations. going on in churches. He's the go-to person in the New Testament for discernment. And you kind of think, well, how can he be so discerning and yet lack pride where he says, I'm the worst of sinners. This is the gospel forming in him. Now, some people read this and they say, oh, Paul, stop being so down on yourself. You're not the worst of sinners. See, this is religion gone wrong. He's beating himself up. Poor Paul. He's not psychologically well-formed. No, no, no. He's seeing himself with sober judgment. It's very different. He is humble and discerning about himself. Why do I say that? Well, because he really was the worst of sinners. Let's not exaggerate it.

24:36 Let's be very concrete. He says he persecuted the church. In the book of Acts, we see him presiding over the public execution of Stephen. He's right there. He did kill Christians. And he did it for the worst possible motivation, which is he did it in the name of God, claiming that he saw the true perspective, that he knew that Christianity was wrong. And you can see that he got it so wrong because you see it in the method that Jesus brings him to his senses on it. How does Jesus bring him to his senses? Paul is on the road to Damascus. You probably know the story. And Jesus confronts him and blinds him. Why does he blind him? Because that's Paul's issue. He thinks he sees. He's so proud. He thinks he knows. And his pride and his blindness has led him to do horrendous things, even murdering the innocent in the name of God.

25:30 It doesn't get worse than that. So Jesus blinds him for three days to wake him up to his ethical spiritual reality that he is totally blind. He does not see things truly. So when Paul says that he was the worst of sinners, it's not hyperbole. It is a sober assessment of his spiritual reality. Yet he does not leave it there. He says, but for this very reason, I was shown mercy. why for this very reason? Because this is the path to humble discernment. If you take someone, well actually, let's not make it abstract. Think about yourself. When you realize your own myopia, your own short-sightedness, your own pride, your own blindness, and how it has wounded people, when you realize how serious that is, and you realize that God is so concerned with that, that there was no other way for him to deal with it other than confronting you with your blindness.

26:24 and sending his son to the cross to die for you. When you look at that, you realize I am so sinful. I'm so proud that I can do enormous damage with my judgmentalism. Jesus had to die for me. There's no other way. I would never figure it out myself. He had to confront me like he did the apostle Paul on the road to Damascus. For some of us, he does it at a one-time deal. For some of us, he does it slowly over a period of time. But all of us have to go through it. When you realize that, it humbles you. It says, get out of the judge's chair. There is a judge and you are not him. You realize the verdict of the judge on you would be your sin is so serious that you would go to hell for it. And when he calls you on that, it crushes your pride. But here's the thing, he doesn't leave you there. It says here, but for this very reason, I was shown mercy. You're shown mercy, which is to show you that God takes sin so seriously and your pride so seriously that Jesus has to die on a cross for you, but he loves you so much and he's so rich in mercy that he was prepared to die for you.

27:27 And when those two things come together, both the humbling of the gospel and the mercy of God, it forms in you a deep humility and it also gives you discernment. How so? Because you are now aware of your blind spots for the first time. You are now starting to work through your own hypocrisy for the first time. And that gives you a unique perspective to help other people. Because you enter into a situation saying, hey, look, I often don't see the full perspective. That's the first thing. Recognize you don't have the full perspective. But you say, but nonetheless, it is important that I enter into this situation. Otherwise, damage can be done. So I need to be discerning. So you have a humble discernment. Let me try to give you a human illustration of this. I have the privilege of volunteering on a monthly basis at the Barry Mission, one of our mission partners here at Redeemer Downtown. It's one of the oldest charities in New York, has been there since 1879, serving three meals a day to those who are homeless and offering them a pathway to get off the streets.

28:28 And what is remarkable about the Bowery Mission, one of the things I love most about it, is that so many of the people who work for the Bowery Mission... are former clients of the Bowery Mission. And why does that make them so wonderful at working with those who are struggling to get off the streets? because they've walked the path. They have discernment. They know how complex it is. They know how difficult it can be to get off the streets. They know how easy it is, sadly, in the U.S. to end up on the streets. They've worked it through. They've been shown mercy and grace. And they've got their lives back together again through complex circumstances. And that makes them uniquely humble and discerning to help others because they can approach a situation with nuance, with compassion, with empathy. They know they don't see everything and they can work with people to get their lives back on track. If that is the case, humanly speaking, how much more with Jesus Christ who has shown us infinite mercy on the cross that if we really get that, will it make us humble and discerning?

29:31 Listen to this thought from theologian Sinclair Ferguson. The heart that has tasted the Lord's grace and forgiveness. will always be restrained in his judgment of others. It has seen itself deserving judgment and condemnation before the Lord, and yet, instead of experiencing his burning anger, has tasted his infinite mercy, which will always lead to humble discernment. Or as the hymn puts it, when I survey the wondrous cross on which the Prince of Glory died, my richest gain I count but loss, and pour contempt on all my pride. It makes us humble, it makes us discerning, allows us to form judgments without being judgmental. Let it be so. Let me pray for us. Heavenly Father, thank you for this teaching from the lips of the Lord Jesus Christ. Thank you for how practical, how insightful it is. And thank you that the gospel works in us increasingly to make us aware of our blind spots, of our judgmentalism, of our pride, to cause us to realize how serious our pride and our judgmentalism can be and the damage it can do, but not then to take away the desire to be discerning, but instead to give us humble discernment.

30:40 May the gospel so work in my life and the lives of my brothers and sisters here that you would form that in us and we ask it for Jesus' sake. Amen.

Machine translated from the source