Jesus asked a third time, “Simon son of John, do you love Me?” Peter was deeply hurt that Jesus had asked him a third time, “Do you love Me?” “Lord, You know all things,” he replied. “You know I love You.” Jesus said to him, “Feed My sheep.He said to him the third time, “Simon, son of Jonah, do you have affection for me?” Peter was grieved because he asked him the third time, “Do you have affection for me?” He said to him, “Lord, you know everything. You know that I have affection for you.” Jesus said to him, “Feed my sheep.He saith unto him the third time, Simon, son of Jonas, lovest thou me? Peter was grieved because he said unto him the third time, Lovest thou me? And he said unto him, Lord, thou knowest all things; thou knowest that I love thee. Jesus saith unto him, Feed my sheep.He saith unto him the third time, Simon, son of John, lovest thou me? Peter was grieved because he said unto him the third time, Lovest thou me? And he said unto him, Lord, thou knowest all things; thou knowest that I love thee. Jesus saith unto him, Feed my sheep.
15 sermons cite this verse
… what he's still going to do. From that place of faith, I want to preach a message today from John 21 verses 13 through 25. And I invite you to be seated as I read them because I want to take my time. No, no, it's not a trick. You'll think I'm trolling. You think now I'm going to fuss at you for sitting down on the Word of God. But as I thought about the Scripture, I thought, it is too nutritious and rich for me to rush through it. So if I'm worried about your feet hurting or your back being tight while you're standing, I might rush, but I just want to take our time today from John 21, where we were last week. We continue this week from a sermon I preached called Cooked. Did you like that sermon? Did you get something out of it? Did you take home leftovers? I try to preach with that Tupperware anointing where you have something you can take with you to work or to school or to the challenges in your life of the next week. This week we're picking up from the next verses in this story, which I have never preached before. I think I've been intimidated by these verses because they feel so personal, but today we're going to give it our best shot. I want you to think of this not as a presentation, but a conversation. In this conversation between Jesus and Peter, maybe you'll hear the Lord speak …
and Jesus recommissioned him three times just to make sure that he didn't lose the truth, that he wasn't done with him. There was restoration. There was responsibility. Peter was recommissioned and he had another opportunity to serve God. As best I know how to say it, holding in balance God's grace and God's justice, the truth of scripture is that God delights in giving people another opportunity to serve him. I'm not suggesting that consequences disappear or that every situation looks the same, but the principle throughout the word of God is that God forgives and restores those who truly return to him. Listen to the word of Jeremiah from the Old Testament. What a tremendous illustration this is. Jeremiah said, I went down to the potter's house, and there he was making something at the wheel. And the vessel that he made of clay was marred in the hand of the potter. so he made it again into another vessel as it seemed good to the potter to make. …
Would you notice Peter denied the Lord three times and Jesus recommissioned him three times just to make sure that he didn't lose the truth, that he wasn't done with him. There was restoration. There was responsibility. Peter was recommissioned, and he had another opportunity to serve God. Don't you really resonate with these stories? I mean, there's none of us who can look back over our record and say, we could have been better there. We should have done this then. And does God get upset with us when we don't do it the way he wants us to do it? No, he gives us another chance. God is a great teacher, and he wants us to be a part of his plan, and he will help us do that any way he can. Sometimes he'll use a whale, and as we'll learn a little bit later on, sometimes a worm. He doesn't have anything outside of the boundary of his tools when he's dealing with his people. Tomorrow we'll take the second part of this second chance, and I hope you'll be with us then. …
This might sound obvious, but unless you're a trained spy or a ninja, it's easier to hide in the dark than in the daylight. What's a little less obvious is that, as much as this is a good strategy for hide-and-seek, it's just as good for dealing with our sins and spiritual weaknesses. Keep them to ourselves, we think. Don't let anyone else see. Indeed, bringing them into the light is perhaps one of the most difficult parts of the Christian life. Our pride makes us afraid, and so, like the first humans, we hide. In one of the scenes before our text today, Jesus was arrested by a band of soldiers and religious officials. After his arrest, Peter pretended not to know him. He denied his connection to Jesus three times. He was afraid. An angry mob had been stirred up during Jesus' trial. What if that angry mob came after him? You never know when they might, after all. Now, it's likely that members of the very mob that shouted for Jesus to be crucified had welcomed him with open arms and ambitious dreams just days earlier, shouting, Hosanna, as he entered Jerusalem on a donkey. …
… but I want to point something out in John 21 verses 15 through 17. It's a famous account after Jesus had risen from the dead. Jesus says this. He says, it says, so when they came or they had eaten breakfast after a good meal, Jesus said to Simon Peter, Simon, son of Jonah, do you love me more than these? Now I want to pause there for just a moment. In the English, this doesn't, this is not helpful for us, but in the Greek language, Jesus says, do you love, do you agapeo, agape love? Do you love me more than these? And so Peter answered and said to him, yes, Lord, you know that I love you. You might be like, oh, great. Good job, Peter. No, that word love is phileo. It means a great affection for. Jesus says, I have great, Peter says, I have great affection for you. Verse 16, he said to him again a second time, Simon, son of Jonah, do you agapeo me? Peter said to him, yes, Lord, you know that I phileo you. Now, in verse 17, there's a change. Jesus said to him the third time, Simon, son of Jonah, do you phileo me? Now, it says Peter was grieved because he said a third time, do you phileo me? Now, reading it in English, you might think, oh, Peter's grieved because there's been a repetition of the same question. I actually think the grief comes because Jesus changed the form of love. …
do you all know the mission statement of our church maybe some our mission statement is we will be christ light leaven and salt in new york city and beyond we will be christ light leaven and salt in new york city and beyond and i love our mission statement it does a really great job of embodying who we are here at fifth avenue presbyterian church from beautiful worship to Christian education for all ages, to pastoral care, to outreach in New York City, and internationally, it's catchy, it's biblical, Christ's light, leaven, and salt. Now prior to coming here at Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church, I was a co-pastor at a small United Methodist church in New Jersey while I was in seminary, and their mission statement was catchy as well. It only had three words, feed more sheep. Feed more sheep. And honestly, it meant a lot of different things to different people. Sometimes it meant literally feeding the hungry. Sometimes it meant feeding our souls through worship and preaching. …
… They walk on. Again, Jesus said, Simon, son of John, do you love me? Peter says, yes. He says, yes, Lord, you know everything. You know I love you. And Jesus said, I want you to take care of my sheep. Points back. And on the third time he asked Peter this same question, do you love me? The text tells us that Peter was hurt because Jesus kept asking him, he asked him a third time, do you love me? Maybe he's thinking, well, doesn't he believe me? And I'm like, he's thinking, well, I know he believes me because he knows what I'm thinking and who could blame him if he didn't believe me? But Peter didn't push him back. Self-righteous Peter is gone. Argumentative, gotta make my point, have my way, Peter. He's gone. So he doesn't make a case for the fact that he loves Jesus. This is amazing. He simply appeals to the knowledge of his king. He said, Lord, you know all things. and you know in spite of what I did, you know in spite of the fact that I betrayed you, you know in spite of the fact that I didn't come through for you, you know in spite of the fact that I didn't try to defend you, you know in spite of the fact that basically I lied to you. …
You know the story of Peter and Jesus very well. You know, they've had encounters before. you know that when Jesus asks questions from the disciples and everybody is giving one answer or the other Peter's answer is always the correct one Like in Matthew chapter 16, from verse 13 to 19, Matthew 16, 13 to 19, when the Lord asked the disciples, who do people say I am? and some of them said, oh, some people say you are Elijah, another said you are Elijah, some say you are one of the prophets. Then he asked the other people, okay, you yourself, who do you say I am? And Peter said, oh, you are the Christ, the son of the living God. we got it correct then Jesus made him a promise he said I'm going to give you the key You will be the one who will lock and unlock. because of the revelation that you have received from God. The keys of the kingdom of heaven I am giving unto you. …
And then what does Jesus say? Now this is fascinating to me. Peter's internal psychological identification of how he sees himself in the world is as a fisherman. He starts out, he's growing up in a village where fishing was the family business. And his whole vision for his life is probably married, kids, fishing, death. And then he meets Jesus and Jesus says, I'll make you a fisher of men. But then in this scene, something fascinating happens because Jesus is reorienting him around his primary call of leadership. And the primary call of leadership is not fishing. It is caring for sheep. His identity has to shift to a shepherd. And this is hard for him. Now Jesus says, do you love me more than these? Some scholars say a lot of times they think that He's talking about the other disciples. I don't think that's it. There's a pile of fish, if you know the context, 154 fish, I believe, sitting in front of Him. And I think Jesus is saying, look, do you love me more than the fish? …
My subject is love steps in. And I am in John 21, verses 15 through 18. I am reading from the New King James Version. And my text says, so when they had eaten, let me give you context. Jesus has been crucified, resurrected, and now he is walking the earth. And as he's walking the earth for 40 days, he does a number of things. Some of them we know, some of them we don't. But in this particular moment, he goes out by the sea while his disciples are fishing. And there's one disciple in particular, Peter, who was out on the boat fishing. Now, for those of you who may still be learning different aspects of the Bible and the story, Peter was like, Peter, I liked Peter as a disciple because he was a gangster, I'll be honest. Peter had a cutting spirit on him and though I've been delivered every now and then I remind myself I've been delivered from the cutting spirit I don't know if that's been anybody else's okay y'all churchy now y'all sitting over here by the deacons and ministers y'all don't want to admit y'all had a cutting spirit a cussing spirit a cutting spirit but God I trust in God he didn't fail me delivered me but we know Peter did because when it was time to to take Jesus Peter cut off one of the soldiers ears it just sometimes that spirit just jump up on you you saved but you forget you saved and he didn't consult with God he let that cutting spirit …
… breakfast, Jesus said to Peter, Simon, son of John, do you love me more than this? I want you to consider Peter denied Jesus three times. How did Jesus restore Peter? He asked him three times. Peter, do you love me? The Bible tells us the second time. Simon, son of John, do you love me? The third time. Do you love me? Why? because love impacts not just the mind, not just the will, it impacts the heart. So my question to you is this. Do you love Jesus? How many of you love Jesus? Raise your hand. Let me tell you. Jesus is asking you, do you love me? If you tell me, if you tell Jesus you love him, then what should you do? If you love Jesus, what will you do? May I suggest, you will obey him. you will serve Him. If you love Jesus. If you don't love Jesus, serving Him is a problem. Worshipping Him is a problem. Sharing the gospel is a problem. …
I said we'd linger longer here in verses 15 to 19. So I tell the guys in the preaching class not to do this often. Yeah, I got sub points. All right, we're tracking with three glories of Jesus here at the end. And under point number two, I got four sub points for you about verses 15. I see the guy smiling. All right, yeah. There's not many always's and nevers in preaching. Four ways, mark these four ways that Jesus handles his humbled disciple. Number one, first, he calls him by his humble name. Three times, it's Simon, son of John. Not Peter, not Rock. It'd be really encouraging to be called Rock at this moment. But he goes back. This is the first way that Jesus called Peter back in John 1, verse 42. You are Simon, son of John. All the way back to the beginning. Remember your origins. Remember your beginning before you were rock. And now, having failed Jesus, genuinely failed Jesus three times, Jesus moves to reinstate Peter and to do this publicly. …
… he asked him do you love me if you love me feed my sheep verse 17 through 19 this is what happens Then he said a third time, Simon, son of John, do you love me? Peter was upset that he asked him the third time, do you love me? So he answered, master, you know everything there is to know. You've got to know that I love you. Jesus ignored him. He said, feed my sheep. I'm telling you the very truth now. When you were young, you dressed yourself and went wherever you wished. But when you get old, you'll have to stretch out your hands while someone else dresses you and takes you where you don't want to go. he was saying that you're gonna die like i died and peter was he was killed crucified upside down that's how peter died and so jesus was telling them one day listen they're gonna take you where you don't want to go you you're not gonna dress yourself you're not gonna have any power and he said this to hint at the kind of death by which peter would glorify god and then he commanded him follow me turning his head Peter noticed the disciple Jesus love following right behind him watch this y'all this is a good movie so Peter just found out uh Jesus Jesus just told Peter hey hey bro you ain't gonna die a smooth death but when you get older you gonna die a horrible death but it's gonna bring God glory you're gonna do some great things now watch it turning his head …
because you're going to go on a journey where you become known as like a super apostle are you going to love me more than the accolade and the power and the position that people show you are you going to love me Are you going to love me more than prominence? What others think about you? Because if you associate with me, it's going to get tough sometimes. Do you love me more than pleasure? Because you're going to experience some pain. And if you look to pleasure just to numb that pain, you'll end up addicted to things that will even cause greater devastation. But if you truly love me, and you turn to me, I can heal your pain. And I can give you a way through. Do you love me even more than the people and what they want from you and what they say about you? Because let's be honest, Simon Peter, you've already failed me three times when people approached you asking you. Are you one of them and you seem to be more concerned about looking after yourself than real love for me? …
"Peter was grieved because He said unto Aim the third time, Do you love Me?" John 21:17. THIS is a pointed question which demands a personal answer and should, therefore, stir up full and frequent self-examination. "Do you love Me?" It is a probing question that is likely to excite much grief when pressed home to the sensitive, tender-hearted disciple, even as Peter was grieved because the Lord said unto him the third time, "Do you love Me?" Yet it is a pleasing and profitable question to as many of us as can give a like solemn and satisfactory response to that of Simon Peter, "Lord, You know all things; You know that I love You." I. IT IS VERY NECESSARY THAT ALL DISCIPLES, EVEN THE MOST PRIVILEGED, THE MOST TALENTED AND THE MOST FAMOUS, SHOULD OFTEN BE ASKED THE QUESTION—HEAR IT IN THEIR SOULS AND FEEL ITS THRILLING INTENSITY—"SIMON, SON OF JONAS, DO YOU LOVE ME?" It must have been momentous, indeed, or the Savior would not have repeated it to Peter three times at one interview. He tarried on earth but 40 days after His Resurrection. The opportunities for conferences, therefore, with His disciples would be few. On what subjects, then, should He speak to them but those which appeared to Him of the weightiest import? Of the times or the seasons that must presently transpire, He refrains to divulge a secret. With the fulfillment of ancient predictions that prompted the curiosity of the Jew, or the solution of metaphysical problems that harassed the minds of Gentile philosophers, He did not meddle. I neither find Him interpreting obscure prophecy, nor expounding mystic Doctrine—but instead, thereof, I find Him inculcating personal piety! The question He propounds is of such vital importance that all other questions may be set aside till this one question is positively settled, "Do you love Me?" …