Jon Tyson · Church of the City New York · Published September 22, 2025
Berean Standard Bible.
1:53 It has been a heavy week this week in the nation. A lot of things come to light and I think has left a lot of people confused. So before I address this passage tonight, I'd like to make just a couple of comments and then give us a time to pray. This week, Charlie Kirk, a 31-year-old man, was assassinated in Utah.
2:19 And this has, if you're on social media, this is just flooding every feed. And to be honest with you, there has been different kinds of responses to his death. How should a Christian think about it? well the first lens we should think about is that he was an image bearer of God a child of God made in the image of God who God loved and valued so every human being is worthy of dignity and respect secondly he was a father and a husband and you have to have an evil heart to cheer for the death of a husband and a father.
3:07 But more than anything, I want to remind us as Christians that we are never to let politics or sociology override our Christian convictions and our theology. The church is at its worst when it's caught up in cultural rage and animosity and loses touch with a steadying, other-loving grace of our Lord Jesus Christ. And so I know there's a lot of reactions to what's going on. For some people, anger. Other people, sadness. A lot of people all over the spectrum. But I want us to say the church cannot be rooted in cultural anxiety and fear. It has to realize that we are citizens of another kingdom and we cannot let allegiance to this kingdom override our deeper conviction to the kingdom of heaven. So wherever you're coming from, it's a reminder to be rooted and grounded in compassion, in love, and in sadness that somebody was violently killed. This week it also came out a lot of attention about Irina Zarutska, who was an immigrant from the Ukraine, a refugee who came over here and was violently stabbed and murdered. And people are looking at this sort of in disbelief at the callousness that was connected to. There's a school shooting. Children shot and killed in Colorado. All of these things should make us wake up and say, God, we need you to act in our world today.
4:46 We can get a little too excited when you see a few statistics about Gen Z coming back to church, and we can ease off and think, well, the job is done now. Job is not done. We need the kingdom of heaven to break into this disordered, violent, heartbreaking world more than ever. And so I want to take a few moments to pray that God will have mercy on our world and make us people of love in the midst of so much violence and so much hate. So let's pray together. Father, we come into your presence with just an absolute need to know you more and to receive your mercy and your love. Father, we just ask that you will have mercy on this nation. Father, I just pray that you would wake the church up to its idolatry. Lord, I pray that you would wake us up out of a slumber. Lord, help us to be people that overcome evil with good, that show the love of Jesus. Lord, your word says that if you love those that are like you, what good is that?
5:58 Even sinners love those who are like them. But I say to you, love your enemies. Pray for those who persecute you. Do good to those who harm you. Father, I just pray you would release in your church enemy love, Lord, love that crosses barriers, love that heals the divisions that we feel. And Father, I just pray you will pour out power on your church to witness to the better way of Jesus in the midst of so much brokenness. So we just pray, heal our hearts, heal our land. Have mercy, Lord Jesus, we need you. And we pray these things in Christ's name, amen. well we are continuing our series tonight called making sense of church this fall we're going to be covering different metaphors of the church and tonight we're going to be covering covering the metaphor of the flock that's a quaint word isn't it for some of you you're like what on earth does sheep and shepherds have to do with me in manhattan 2 000 years later for some of you your only reference of sheep is the sheep's meadow in Central Park, and that is about as far as it goes for you. But this is an important teaching of Jesus, because Jesus is answering the question which all of us are asking in the modern world, who can I trust? Who can I trust? There is such a loss of trust in society right now. Years ago, when we started doing Welcome to Church, the two questions I got asked the most were what does the church think about LGBTQ issues and what does the church think about women in ministry?
7:44 The number one question I get asked now is who's keeping you accountable? And that's happened because people have experienced a loss of trust in our world today. And so what Jesus is gonna do in this passage is actually give us really clear parameters about how shepherds should lead in the church and how people who are part of the church, the sheep, should act as a part of a congregation. And so rather than being some distant or quaint teaching from another era, this is fundamental to what it means to be the church and have integrity in a moment like ours. Now, just to remind you the context of this teaching, this is coming in John chapter 10. and in the previous chapters, Jesus has been hammering the religious elites, calling them thieves and robbers, strangers and hirelings.
8:39 Jesus claims to give living water and they say to him, you're demon possessed. He cares about the woman caught in adultery and all they care about is a religious trap. He heals the man who's born blind and all they wanna do is complain. The religious leaders wanna complain that he did it on the wrong day of the week. And so Jesus is frustrated with the religious leaders and establishment of His day, and He makes a claim to talk about what godly leadership actually looks like. What's your standard of godly leadership?
9:10 By what standard do you measure how the church should operate? Whenever you talk about the church and church leadership, there's different cultures, different backgrounds, different roles, different expectations. You probably came to church tonight with your expectations. Everybody has. But what I wanna do tonight is look at three core things Jesus says that good shepherds do. And then three things that people should do in response to that leadership. And I honestly believe by the end of our time tonight, you will have a biblical framework to understand how the church should function as a community that I think restores the integrity of Jesus and leads to people being blessed and brought to life and finding hope and having their destiny released inside the church. So let's jump in. Number one, the role of shepherds.
10:03 What are shepherds supposed to do? Well, the first thing I want you to see from God's Word is this, the role of shepherds, A, feed the sheep, feed the sheep. There's a fascinating encounter in John 21 where Peter has messed up. He's denied Jesus three times. He has gone back to fishing. He's full of energy. He's like, Jesus, I just want you to know if everybody denies you, I will not deny you. And Jesus is like, I appreciate that. You're actually gonna do that three times tonight. And he's like, no, I will die for you. And he goes, appreciate that. We'll just see how this plays out. A servant girl says to him, are you with Jesus? And he's like, I don't even know what you're talking about. It just wilts like that. Goes back to fishing and then he has this encounter where Jesus comes to restore him.
10:56 And here's what we read, John 21, starting in verse 15.
11:32 And then what does Jesus say? Now this is fascinating to me. Peter's internal psychological identification of how he sees himself in the world is as a fisherman. He starts out, he's growing up in a village where fishing was the family business. And his whole vision for his life is probably married, kids, fishing, death. And then he meets Jesus and Jesus says, I'll make you a fisher of men. But then in this scene, something fascinating happens because Jesus is reorienting him around his primary call of leadership. And the primary call of leadership is not fishing. It is caring for sheep. His identity has to shift to a shepherd. And this is hard for him. Now Jesus says, do you love me more than these? Some scholars say a lot of times they think that He's talking about the other disciples. I don't think that's it.
12:25 There's a pile of fish, if you know the context, 154 fish, I believe, sitting in front of Him. And I think Jesus is saying, look, do you love me more than the fish? You keep going back to fishing. Every time I see you, you pretend like my ministry has not happened. Do you love me more than these? And He answers, listen, then enough with the fish. I need you to feed my sheep. His internal psychological journey over the end of his life, you'll see it in 1 Peter 5 a little later on. How does Peter describe himself? Not as a fisher of men. He says he is as a fellow shepherd with you. His internal journey is orienting himself as a shepherd. And what is he called to do as a shepherd? Feed the sheep. So I want you to see this. the first task of godly leadership is to care about the spiritual diet that people in the community consume. You are feeding yourself on something.
13:23 Feeding yourself on fear, outrage, lies, distortion. All of us are on some sort of spiritual diet that we're taking into our hearts to try and nourish us, to give us sustenance to face life. what are you feeding on? Have you ever been in a situation where you see a mum and she's got a couple of kids and you're just thinking and then she says, come on kids, it's snacky time. You're like, okay. And then can you imagine a mum getting a bottle and just pouring Coke into the bottle? not Coke Zero, real Coke, right? She's like, here you go kids, here's an iPad and then the mum just gives them Swedish fish which have that red thing which is satanic that red chemical that's poisoning America just here, have red things, have more red things opens with Swedish fish, follows it up not with honey nut Cheerios follows it up with Cheetos and then closes it out with Frappuccinos from Starbucks.
14:37 Now, in all honesty, if you're at a park and you saw a mum doing that, what would you be thinking of yourself? You 100% would be judging that mum like, oh my gosh, you're gonna kill your kids. Your instinct is that a parent's role is to nourish their children and not feed them junk. The primary role of a pastor is to make sure that what people take into their spirits is not junk, but it is nourishment from God's Word to build them up and to strengthen their faith. Listen, I'm not here to say how long sermons should be, okay? You know, I tend towards a longer sermon, value for money, okay? The reason I care about preaching God's Word is because if you get 20 minutes of like a sermonette and the typical person doesn't even read their Bible four minutes a day, what are you feeding your spirit on?
15:35 Your inner being is going to be shaped on spiritual junk food that diminishes your heart over time. And so the primary role, I want you to see that, feeding the church, feeding the flock. First thing that a pastor should care about. Second thing, protecting the sheep. Now, this is important. The Apostle Paul, this is Acts chapter 20. The Apostle Paul is at a moment where he's going back to the Ephesian church. He's planted this church, you remember. They had a citywide riot when the kingdom of God broke into Ephesus. Timothy's gonna go on and pastor this church. But he knows that this is the last time he's gonna be coming through the city. So he says, hey, gather all the elders of the church at Ephesus. And you know this, the last time you see someone, they're telling you the deepest things in their heart. And look at what he says, Acts 20, 26 through 32.
16:40 Therefore, I declare to you today that I am innocent of the blood of any of you. Well, good to see you too, Paul. I've not hesitated to proclaim to you the whole will of God. Keep watch over yourselves and all the flock of which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers. Be shepherds of the church of God, which He brought with His own blood. Now this is a high exhortation. Pay careful attention. Watch yourselves. I've got no blood on my hands. I've taught you the whole will of God, not just the promise verses. I've given you the whole thing. Why is he asking for such vigilance? Look at what he says, verse 29.
18:16 So I want you to see that the role of shepherds and leaders has a protective component to it. They are to be on their guard and not naive about the nature of spiritual war against the flock. But protection from what? Here's a couple of things I've noticed in my own ministry that the Bible warns about over the years. The first thing is from the threat of sin. From the threat of sin. There's only two lives that you ultimately live on this earth. You live a life that Jesus calls the abundant life. Or you're living a life where the thief is stealing, killing and destroying. That's it, they're your two options for life. And I wish people could understand what sin does to damage people.
19:13 Listen, I'm not saying I don't struggle with sin, but I can tell you this, I hate sin. It does not appeal to me. I don't look at it and think, gosh, I'm really missing out living a Christian life. I really wish I could live like the world. That's where the energy is. That's where the joy is. But I guess if I want to go to heaven, I'll give up all the good life and suck it up for later. I don't view that at all. I look at the world with pity at the damage the world does to the human soul. And I can promise you, if you're a pastor and people, when people said, hey, I'd love to have coffee with you, it almost always means my soul has been damaged by sin. And if you were on the pastoral end of walking people through sexual sin, the sin of greed, the sin of gossip, if you were to sit down, you would not think the world is where it's at.
20:07 You would think, God have mercy, get me out of the world into the arms and mercy of Jesus in the church. Sin destroys people. Christ came that people may have life. And so as a pastor, my job is to try and guard and be honest and exhort you to fear God and hate sin and lean into the eternal life to which you were called. Sin is a threat to the spiritual prosperity that Jesus died to give you. You should hate sin. Second thing, from the threat of false teachers.
20:47 Verse 29, I know after I leave. What does he call them? What's these two words here? Savage wolves. That's a strong metaphor that an apostle describes a leader. Imagine being with Paul and I'm like, Paul, what do you think of them? Don't like them, mate. Why not? That's a savage wolf, mate. That's a savage wolf. Like have nothing to do with them. I'm at war with them. Savage wolves will come in among you and will not spare the flock. Even from your own number, men will arise and distort the truth in order to draw away disciples after themselves. Several years ago, I mean, more than several years ago, a long time ago, we had a cult infiltrate our church. and it was total spiritual chaos. And it was basically a bloke in Wisconsin that sent this kid, this young man down here into our church to sort of recruit people to his teachings.
21:59 And it was so deceptive and it was so hard to discern, but you could just sense something's unhealthy there. There's something not right there. And I sort of do a little research. And as it turns out, the pastors in the city of Wisconsin, where they're from, have all come together as a group of pastors and written a shared formal excommunication of this leader and warned every church in the city against this leader. And he's got people in our church, recruiting people from our church. And they got involved in the arts community. and they did so much damage. And I was in some of the most heart, heartbreaking meetings of my life watching people's lives be destroyed by lies. And we had another time where we had a sexual predator.
23:00 It was a horrible man trying to infiltrate our church. Same thing, we research back. Turns out in Washington DC, pastors have written a letter, if this man comes to your church, I have nothing to do with him. And in one of the weirdest pastoral meetings of my life, I'm meeting him to rebuke him and warn him to get out of our church. And a demon speaks through him in the meeting to me and comes at me. I'm not saying that to freak you out. I'm just telling you this passage is real and you do not want to be naive we are trotting around like I just love everybody churches are very porous communities people just come in and out and it is the pastor's jobs to care about the spiritual lives of the people who are in the church so you've got to hate sin but there will be false teachers that come in and they should be rebuke in the same way. Now, my apartment's very small, but if someone came into my apartment and was like, hey, I was just thinking about moving in, I'd be like, you got about four seconds, mate, till I unleash these killer chihuahuas, Frankie and Ella, on you right here.
24:17 Bro, don't come at Frankie. That kid is savage. I wouldn't just tolerate somebody who wanted to just ease their way in. No parent in a right mind. In New York City, they have playgrounds that you cannot enter if a child is not with you. You wanna know why? Because they care. And in the same way, part of his leader's job is to make sure that they are caring about the leadership and warning against false teaching and against false threats. And then the third thing is the threat of distortions and lies. Oh, real quick. Just checking on my notes. There's two ways over the years I've watched people manipulate people in the church, okay? So just to make you aware.
25:11 Number one, when churches are large, people move in on people's lives and they say the church doesn't care about people. You can't get any time with the leaders, but look how awesome I am and how much time I'm giving you. they insert themselves between spiritual authority under the guise of care to sabotage. The second way is they get in the leadership circle with an Absalom spirit that basically finds ways where people are unhappy, agitates those points and said, if I was in charge, I wouldn't make decisions like that.
25:50 And so much doubt, that's why gossip is a sin. And it's listed in the New Testament vice lists with the most intense sins the Bible talks about. Why? Because of the damage it does to a culture. And so anytime you get someone and all they're doing is putting themselves between you and spiritual authority and setting themselves up as a more loving spiritual authority, that makes me very, very nervous.
26:19 Number three, care for the... Let's skip that. not see protect from the threat of distortion and lies. Go back. Protect from the church, protect from distortion and lies. Look at 2 Timothy 4. Now again, this is the last chapter of Scripture Paul wrote before he was beheaded in Rome. And he's writing to Tim, who's his son in the faith. And I want you to note what he says.
27:52 Just a couple of observations here. I want you to note that he says, there'll be a time when you preach what the Bible actually teaches and people will not put up with it anymore. So it's not gonna put up with you believing that. I'm sick of that. I reject that. Second thing, they have itchy ears. And what that means is in a spirit of offense because of the demands the truth is making on them, they will look for another teacher to affirm the desire in their heart that is an ungodly desire. So they will have desire-driven doctrine. And what they'll do is find a bunch of people who want the Bible to say the same thing you want it to say, and they'll invent a new truth claim to affirm that truth. And it says there'll be a great number of them and they turn aside to myths. They're just gonna make up stuff that sounds good. And friends, I wanna say this to you.
28:47 This is why knowing doctrine is important. and this is why church history is important. The church didn't start this century. It's been around for a while and before that, the children of Israel were carrying the truth. I want you to know this. To be ignorant of church history makes you an option for heresy. The less you know about what the church has taught and what the scriptures believe, the easier you are to manipulate with bias and truth. the more a TikTok clip can shake your faith if you're not rooted in something beyond your cultural preferences. So we've got, and it's the leader's job to warn against this. Now, I wanna say this. People don't like people that warn against other people. Like, who are you to tell people? I'm not up here on my own making this stuff up. I'm trying to stand on 2,000 years of church history.
29:41 I'm trying to stand under God's word and under the great tradition. So it's not my thoughts versus your thoughts. It's us submitting to God's thoughts and debating about what God's Word actually teaches. So don't fall into the trap of saying, well, who am I to judge? It's not you that's judging. We're not in an opinion sharing exercise here. We're trying to discern truth. So there is moments when pastors need the courage to call things out. every community on earth feels empowered to call out their beliefs and challenge others in culture and the second Christians do it, we're like, shut up. What are you talking about? Imagine saying shut up to the LGBTQ community. Imagine saying shut up to African-Americans and their struggle for justice in the nation. You imagine, pick a group that is looking to express their core beliefs.
30:35 Why is it that only Christians don't have the right to do that? So I wanna say the greatest manipulation the culture has is to tell you what you cannot do while they do the very thing they say you're not allowed to do. I have no idea why you're clapping, but I'll take it.
30:57 Lastly, caring for the sheep's needs. 3 John 1 says this, it gave me great joy when some believers came and testified about your faithfulness to the truth, telling how you continue to walk in it. I have no greater joy than to hear my children are walking in the truth. Listen, I promise you,
31:27 the pastor's greatest joy is your life with God. I'm always, because New York's really transient, people are always coming in and out. People pop back in and you get reports. And I'm always, people are like, oh, did you hear about such and such? And I'm always just like, God, please tell me they're walking with God. And they're like, oh yeah, man, they're walking with God. And I'm like, yes, plugged into a local church. I love that. And then sometimes you hear stories that are like, ah, no, man, deconstructed, met someone, living with them, not walking with God, just living in the world. It's like, it grieves you. No greater joy than to know that people are walking in the truth. So Jesus warns about finding people who will actually care about the needs of the church.
32:22 Jesus talks about the danger of what he calls hirelings, and I just put influences in there just to update us. He says, I'm the good shepherd. The good shepherd lays down his life for the sheep. The hired hand is not the shepherd and doesn't own the sheep. So when the wolf comes, he abandons the sheep and he runs away. Then the wolf attacks the flock and scatters it. The man runs away because he's a hired hand and cares nothing for the sheep. One of the ways you should test church leadership is by how leaders act when things get hard. And when things get hard, if the leaders lean in to care and solve the problem, that's leadership you can trust. But if they start shifting blame and say, hey, it's not my fault, that's not a healthy sign. The reason, by the way, Jesus is going to be crucified for these attacks on the religious leaders.
33:13 Jesus is referencing Ezekiel 34. And in Ezekiel 34, all of the teachers of the law would have known that this is a rebuke to the shepherds of Israel. look at what it says woe to the shepherds of israel who've been feeding themselves shouldn't the shepherds feed their flock you eat the fat wear the wool butcher the fat and animals but you don't tend the flock you've not strengthened the weak healed the sick bandage the injured brought back the strays or sought the lost now by the way what is jesus ministry defined by strengthening the weak healing the sick bandaging the injured bringing back the strays and seeking and saving the lost. He says instead, you've ruled them with violence and with cruelty. This is what the Lord says. Look, I'm against the shepherds. I will demand my flock from them and prevent them from shepherding the flock. The shepherds will no longer feed themselves for I will rescue my flock from their mouths so that they will not be food for them.
34:11 Self-feeding, eating the flock, wearing the wool, butchering the fattened, not tending to them, using the flock for personal benefit. Now contrast that rebuke with proper care mentioned in 1 Peter 5. To the elders among you, I appeal as a fellow elder and a witness of Christ's sufferings who will also share in the glory to be revealed. Be shepherds of God's flock. That is what? What does it say the flock is?
34:44 I didn't hear you. Could be the fans. Under your care. Under your care. What a phrase. Here is Peter. He's exhorting these other leaders in the church and he's like, remember shepherds, they're not under your harsh judgment. They're under your care. Watch over them, not because you must, but because you're willing, as God wants you to be, not pursuing dishonest gain, eager to serve, not lording it over those, what are they? Entrusted to you, but being examples to the flock. And when the chief shepherd appears, you will receive the crown of glory that will never fade away.
35:37 And in the same way, you who were younger, submit yourselves to your elders. It is a role of care. Now, you know, this past week was 9-11, 24th anniversary. Was anybody here in 9-11? Yeah, a few folks were. I'm in New York because of 9-11. The first time I came to New York was after the attacks. And I was on staff at a church in Tennessee. And they said, we don't know what we can do. We don't know if we can be of any practical use. Everybody was flooding in to serve. The church rallied so well around the crisis. But our church said, let's just go and pray. And so we went out to Brooklyn Tab, to the Tuesday night Brooklyn Tab prayer meeting and just joined our voice with the believers who were there just saying, God, have mercy.
36:38 We cannot see how, but turn this together for your good. so I'm deeply marked by the impact of 9-11 not just on our city on the lives of so many people who lost people they love but our churches here is partly because of that and I was thinking about Rick Rescola who was one of the 9-11 leaders I think got a photo of him here I'm not sure if familiar with him, really a remarkable man. He was born in Cornwall, England, served as a paratrooper in the British Army, later joined the US Army, fought in Vietnam, distinguished military honours, ultimately ended up becoming a colonel. After he finished in the military, he worked in corporate security. And in 2001, he was a director of security for Morgan Stanley at the World Trade Center. Now, you know that in 1993, there was another attack on the World Trade Center. They put bombs under it and tried to destroy it. And so he had this inner sense as someone who cared about protecting others. I bet they're coming after the towers again. And so he continually worked to prepare his people in case there was a disaster. He would do fire drills and have people exiting. He did it with confidence. He did it with a non-anxious presence. So when the first plane hit the North Tower at 8.46 a.m. and he heard the impact in the South Tower, an announcement from the Port Authority says, everybody stay where you are. And he said, we are not doing stay put.
38:12 We are getting out of here. So we got a bullhorn and a walkie-talkie and he started walking people and directing them down the stairwells, keeping them calm. He says, don't use the elevators. We don't know what's going to happen. He started singing songs from Cornwall, England, where he was from. And he had prepared for a moment like this. And thanks largely to his leadership in the midst of a crisis, about 2,700 Morgan Stanley employees' lives were saved because there was a man who says, my job is to protect and serve these people. And the last time he was seen was on the 10th floor going up the South Tower right before it collapsed because he wanted to check if there were any stragglers who needed help getting out. Now, we live in a society that says heroes and leaders are those who are the best at sports.
39:08 And heroes and leaders are those who are entrepreneurs and make money. But you have moments of clarity like this when you realize the leaders we actually want are leaders who put others before themselves and who sacrifice themselves, not sacrifice others. And I was just reminded this week, just asking the Lord, Lord, raise up leaders in the church with this instinct. We need people who would care for the sheep like that again. Got it? Now, you probably have appreciated, maybe appreciated, up until this point of the sermon, because it's all about how leaders are held accountable. You're like, that's right, man. Leaders better feed me. Stop giving me that little snacky Swedish fish sermons. Feed me.
40:03 Let me eat. and but now I'd like to talk about what your responsibility is for a few minutes here and the obligations that sheep have to leaders in the community. I want you to know that sheep are of great value to God. They're not a commodity.
40:27 Did you know that shepherds measured their wealth? Shepherds rarely owned homes or land. their wealth was the sheep. And Jesus said that he would leave the 99 to find one because of the value they have for him. So I want you to know you have tremendous value to God and you have tremendous value in this community. The term sheep can be bantied around but it's not a diminishing term. It's a term of endearment if you understand it. so what are these obligations this this is not as long as the first half so calm down the first thing is that sheep have to submit to leadership people, how many of you guys love the word submit? You're just like, I'm just looking for a church where I could submit to spiritual authority. Do you guys have good spiritual authority?
41:21 No one, everybody bristles at the idea of submission. I don't know if it's something in the American spirit, like the revolutionary war. I don't know if that's hanging around in the ether or the constitution or something, but there's something that sort of says, who are you to tell me?
41:41 Hebrews 13, 17, look at what it says. Have confidence in your leaders. And what's that word say? Submit to their authority. Because they keep watch over you as those that must give an account. And do this so their work will be a joy, not a burden. For that would be of no benefit to you. Submit to their authority. it can be very very challenging in our world today to want to submit so but i want to point out two things there ready it says have confidence in your leaders and submit to their authority here's what i say you don't have an option as far as i'm biblically aware to not be under spiritual authority in your life everybody's under spiritual authority well i hate big churches i'm going to go join a house church i promise you your house church leader is just a senior pastor in small form. It's just, it's the same setup. Let me guess, you're going to talk about the Bible and sing some songs and then break up into smaller groups. Folks, here's what the church does. It gathers in big gatherings and meets in smaller groups. There's different sizes of that. That's what the church does. You can't get away from spiritual authority, but you should have confidence in the spiritual authority. So I want to say this, if you can't submit to your spiritual authority because you've lost confidence in it, you need to leave that church.
43:08 But then you know you need to go to a church where you can submit to authority you have confidence in. And I know there can be a lot of pain. I know there can be a lot of hurt in these sorts of dynamics. But the worst thing is that you just go out into the wilderness and think you can thrive. So I wanna say this. So here's the options. Lead and make the church better. Follow, submit to authority, or go to another church where you can lead or you can follow. I sensed it would resonate deeply in this service. people hate spiritual authority. They just, they love it until they need it.
43:48 Just people love to argue. And they listen to a talk on YouTube. And now you've done three years of seminary. But they heard a YouTube clip. And I was at another church preaching, not this one, this church is amazing. People here are so great, genuinely so amazing. I had a couple of people come up to me after this morning and apologize like, bro, was that me? No, man, I love this church. I love you. I had a guy come up and debate me so hard a couple of weeks ago because I triggered something in him about something he was super passionate and he was just actually 100%, like stake my life on it wrong on the issue. And he'd spent 20 years trying to be passionate about this issue that he was absolutely wrong on. And he said to me, you're wrong.
44:41 And I was like, hey, mate, with all due respect, I'm probably wrong on a lot of things, but this happens to be one of them that I'm right on. And it was on the history of the Hebrides revival. And I was like, bro, my mate pastors the church where it happened. Should we text him right now?
45:04 This is during the worship. This is not after the service. Thank you. and they ended up escorting me out of the room because he would not calm down. This is wild. So I say that the truth is that there is a history of leadership abuse in the church, but there's also a history of people rebelling against godly leaders in the church too. What about the children of Israel in the wilderness? Not strong. people say I want to go back to the New Testament I'm like to the church at Corinth what a disaster Paul pours his life out to serve them and what's their response they go get some other leaders who call themselves super apostles and like we don't like you Paul you're not good at public speaking these guys are amazing we're done with you and he's like you are literally the I am, he just doesn't know what to do.
46:03 So then they make him, he's like, look, I literally went to heaven. I've seen Jesus. Why do you make me prove my authority? So I want you to say this. It's important to have confidence in your leaders. They're not perfect people, but have confidence and submit. Second thing, it's learning to trust your leaders. Okay, look at Hebrews 13, seven. remember your leaders who spoke the word of God to you.
46:31 Consider the outcome of their way of life. Imitate their faith. So I want you to note this. Trusting leaders in the Bible is not about trusting quote unquote men of God who can do no wrong. No, you're trusting servant leaders who are trying to lay down their lives to care for you. have you noticed Paul's language let me just tell you how Paul talked about the church he says I'm writing this this is 1 Corinthians 4 I'm writing this not to shame you but to warn you as my dear children even if you have 10,000 guardians in Christ you don't have many fathers for in Christ Jesus I became your father through the gospel he says in 1 Thessalonians 2 we were gentle among you like a nursing mother caring for her children. We cared for you because we loved you so much. We were delighted to share with you not only the gospel of God, but our lives as well, because you've become so dear to us. He says, we dealt with each of you as a father deals with his own children, encouraging, comforting, and urging you to live lives worthy of God. The verse I used last week, my dear children, for whom I'm again in the pains of childbirth until Christ is formed in you. He's going to say in 2 Corinthians 2, I wrote to you out of great distress and anguish of heart and with many tears, not to grieve you, but to let you know the depth of my love. And if you listen to his prayers, all of his prayers in essence are him boasting to God about how great he thinks the people are in that church. So I want you to see this. You're not submitting to You arrogant spiritual elites.
48:20 You're submitting to leaders who are laying down their lives to serve you. Have confidence in your leaders. Submit to them, not to tyrants, but to servants. And then he says this, follow them. Follow them. Why? Look what he says. Have confidence in your leaders. Submit to their authority because they must keep watch over you as those who must give an account. And look at this. Everyone, I know it's hot. I don't like the heat either. Everyone tune back in. Look, do this so their work will be a joy, not a burden, because it'll be no benefit to you.
49:05 There's a way where leaders serve and pour themselves out and people respond to that leadership and it makes leadership a joy and it makes participation in the church a joy. and it benefits the people in the church. That's the heart behind it. So the truth is, without godly leadership, without people caring about your spiritual diet, without people fighting off the spiritual threats and attacks, without people trying to care for your soul, sheep are vulnerable. They're vulnerable. And if you've watched any nature documentary whatsoever, you know that lions and wolves go after isolated sheep. And again, that's why content is not the same thing as being a part of the community of God. And listen, often sheep without leaders do crazy things.
50:03 jump off a cliff. I saw this. Turkish sheep die in mass jump. And one sheep's like, sick of the shepherd, he sucks. Go on and get me some freedom. I'm gonna go do me. And he just goes himself right off a cliff and all of his mates are like, me too. And then 400 or something of them die. And the only ones that live, live because I land on the bodies of the sheep who've died and it basically comes very close to creating terrible financial hardship for this village.
50:42 I think that illustration speaks for itself, moving on. So I'm out of time, I'm closing now. church I want to say to you my job as a senior pastor of this church I want to say to you that I care about you I want to say to you I am committed to you there's no other church in the world that I want to pass and there's no other city in the world I want to do this and I want to do this here with you I love this church and I want you to know I'm committed to this church. And I just, you know, people said like, what's your wildest dream? I'm like doing this in the future with good health. That's like my wildest dream. It's like this, but older. I take this job seriously.
51:44 I'm not casual about this. It says in Hebrews 13, 17, that I'm going to give an account for your souls. I'm gonna have a one-on-one with Jesus and He's gonna say to me, hey John I want to talk about how you led church of the city New York I want to talk about your love I want to talk about whether or not you had courage I want to talk about if you ran towards the danger or you hid from it in fear I want to know if your life made people want to follow me or it made people not want to follow me my job performance review is going to come for Christ for how I've loved you and I'm going to be judged more harshly than you look at what it says not many of you should become teachers because you know that I will be judged more strictly. I'm going to have to give an account. I was praying this morning like, I will give an account for this talk before Jesus. So I want to take this seriously. And I want to say to you, I want to say as a pastor, if you've been hurt by the church, I'm sorry. I'm sorry that the church has been a point of pain and not a source of joy.
53:01 If you've experienced abuse under ungodly leadership, I ask for forgiveness on behalf of the church. I'm sorry that that's happened to you. Jesus hated bad leadership. And I'm sorry that you've been on the receiving end of that at some point in your life. I'm not perfect, but I can give you my word and my commitment that I will love and serve this church. Now, I'm still a person. I get cranky if you get me at the wrong moment, okay? I'm just, I take this seriously, but I'm still a person. But I want you to know I'm committed. I like how Eugene Peterson puts it. The biblical fact is there's no successful churches. There are instead communities of sinners gathered before God week after week in towns and villages all over the world. The Holy Spirit gathers them and does His work in them.
53:55 And in these communities of sinners, one of the sinners is called pastor and given a designated responsibility in the community. And the pastor's responsibility is to keep the community attentive to God. That's what I'm trying to do. But I also wanna know, speaking on behalf of the larger leadership of our church, that our church is committed to you as leaders. I know there's a big leap between churches meeting in the Greco-Roman Empire and churches meeting in New York City. I know there's a massive difference between organic apostolic structures in the early church and 501c3s and compliance laws. But we're doing our best to have integrity now to honour what the Scriptures ask of us. Folks, I can tell you this. If you were to be in one of our board meetings, one of our church board meetings, I honestly think at the end of it, you would give a standing ovation and you would say, I feel safe at the level of care and protection our board members are giving us.
54:56 Genuinely, I've served on all sorts of boards and I'm telling you the level of attention to detail and expertise and care our board members bring to our church is remarkable. And if you wanna see what I'm talking about, go to church.myc and look up the board members of our church. These are godly, gifted people doing their best to care about this church. The elders of this church meet to pray for your souls. we're looking for trends where the evil one may be attacking our church issues and topics that we can provide resources and care about these things these are people that spend their time trying to get above the fray of congregational life to care and advocate before the lord on your behalf they do the hardest conversations no one wants to have and they're trying to figure out how to present the truth to you in a way that honors you. Our senior leadership team, these are the best people I've ever worked with. They are extraordinary. If you saw the senior leadership team from our church and you saw how hard they work, they're doing investment banking hours without investment banking benefits. Until we get to heaven, they'll be like, how you like me now?
56:20 However, I'm telling you, their work ethic and commitment is exemplary. And then we have an amazing church staff. And all of the things you see, these are people who are pouring out their hearts to serve you. Listen, many people move to New York for work because they have a dream where they'll be successful and recognized or it's the best place for them to make money for their career. And in all honesty, most of the time for pastors, there is no financial advantage to moving to New York. In fact, it's a massive financial disadvantage. And so they're not coming here because it's better for them. They're coming here because they are sacrificially committed to serving our church and the mission of Jesus in our city. And they do this with joy.
57:08 So I wanna say this to you. We spend time thinking, praying how to get better at leading our church, how to have integrity, how to restore credibility, how to do things in such a way that people look at our church and they say, I believe that that is a God-honoring church. Now, I wanna close with two charts and then we'll be done, okay? And these are charts that I've used in Welcome to Church over the years because I wanna give you some actual tools of how to evaluate the leadership and culture of a church so you're not just running on preferences or instinct or whatever. So if we can pull the first one up. This is not a Christian chart. I was in a doctoral class on leadership and this came up and this is the best thing I got out of it, out of the class. Because it basically sort of analyzes where churches go wrong and how church cultures become unhealthy and toxic.
58:04 So at the top, it starts with leadership and it says that you get destructive leaders that get power in organizations. Listen, this doesn't look good on me, but if you understand like, vocations, narcissists, and psychopaths go into. Pastors are like in the top 10 up there. I mean, it's like, I hate to say it, but darling, is that true? My wife studied this, it's true.
58:30 So a lot of times people love leaders who are really charismatic. Like our past is amazing, charismatic. The leaders then accumulate power, not in structures, not even in culture, but in themselves. They create a fear-based culture where everybody's worried about offending the pastor. I have a friend who worked at a really large church that ended up having a scandal. And I said, what was the culture of the church like? And he said, it was 26,000 people that cared about what one person wanted and one person who did not care what 26,000 people thought.
59:10 Personal power. And then narcissism, a sense of false sense of self-importance. And then they have greed and control issues and they're driven by anger. And underneath all the bravado, they're deeply fearful people. Well, those people end up recruiting susceptible followers. Two kinds. The first one, they get conformers. Now, these are often people that don't have as much charisma to be the main guy, but they still have narcissism and enough charisma to serve the main guy. And they end up having bad needs, low self-esteem, or often pride. They want to be associated with something cool. And they're often radically spiritually immature, but they have strong gifts or charisma. And those people just conform to the culture the leader creates. And then you get colluders. These are people with ambition. They're deeply broken. They have the wrong value system. And then these people, the leaders and the followers, create unhealthy environments. Instability. Everything is a perceived threats. There's no accountability for leadership. It's driven by fear and the leaders often find themselves isolated. And this is the toxic triangle. And I want to say this, if you see this culture, this is going to undermine confidence in your ability to submit to leadership. So what's the alternative? Here's the alternative. Godly leadership.
1:00:34 so what you want is loving leaders you want leaders who have an orientation of servanthood you want leaders that don't have a false sense of self-importance and pay attention to others my wife always says to me whenever I meet different folks how did they treat the small people or those who could do nothing for them that's how you can tell who people really are are they are they sacrificing the church or are they sacrificing themselves for the church Are they motivated by care? Are they driven by love? Those kinds of leaders will raise up followers that they value. These were people who are called, who lead and model and empower others to do the work of the ministry. And they have a care orientation. They're gentle and they're patient and they have an other focus. And these people will create freeing environments, environments where there's genuine accountability.
1:01:31 It's where people are known, where people are loved, where people experience the truth spoken into them and there's grace that is associated with it. And I wanna say this, we are not perfect at this, but gosh, we are moving in this direction. And I gotta tell you as a pastor, I am amazed and grateful to serve on a team that is bringing credibility back to the church by the way that they lead. So folks how do we make sense of church? When it's described as a flock, well, the shepherds have a role. Their role is to feed. Their role is to protect. Their role is to care. And the sheep, the congregation have a role.
1:02:25 Their role is to submit. Their role is to follow. they've got a role not to criticize or condemn they got a role to care about what is happening inside the congregation so again if you've been hurt by the church I'm sorry I've been hurt by the church I was hurt by the church before I was a pastor I've been hurt by leaders in the church I've probably unintentionally hurt people but I also want to say this I've been loved by the church I've been loved by leaders and I've been healed by people on purpose and so the choice we have is not to react out of fear or hurt but to proactively lead out of vision and health so the church is built up.
1:03:26 People are well fed and well cared for and the church has credibility again. And so I'm asking you, would you commit to our church? Would you commit to making this a part of our church community? Our leaders are committing themselves to you, to love you, to pour themselves out, to serve you, to be accountable. I'm asking you that you would commit to respond and to follow and to be a part of what God's doing here. Let's pray together. Father, we thank you for your word. Lord, thank you in a world of so much chaos, anxiety, mistrust, fear, that your word, which is timeless, gives us vision, clarity, and hope. And Lord Jesus, we just say that ultimately, all authority is under your authority.
1:04:27 You are the head of the church. You are the chief shepherd. You are the one that we voluntarily submit to. And so Father, I just wanna pray that you will protect this church. Father, I ask that you will strengthen this church. Father, I pray this will be a house of healing where the wounded and the weary come in and they find life. Lord, I pray this will be a house of salvation where those who are lost come in and find life and freedom in the name of Jesus. Father, I pray that this will be a church where the destinies of people are unleashed, where they will find who they were created to be in your house amongst us. And Father, we just pray that in the middle of New York City, you would do something that glorifies your name and strengthens your people and makes people trust the church again And Lord, Your Word says, now unto Him who is able to do exceedingly abundantly above all that we can ask or imagine, according to His power that is at work within us, to Him be glory in the church.
1:05:37 And so we just pray You would be glorified in our church, in Christ Jesus and in this generation.
Machine translated from the source