Guest speaker · Redeemer East Harlem · Published October 21, 2025
Berean Standard Bible.
Berean Standard Bible.
6:09 Thank you, Justin, for the kind welcome. It's really a great privilege to be here and to get to share in this chapter of God's Word with you. So David and Goliath. It's a really well-known reference, a pair of names. They belong together like Mercedes and Benz or Goldman and Sachs. And even in secular Western culture, where only a minority of people go to church or read the Bible regularly, even there, the names of David and Goliath are almost like a meme. People know them. People get that it's something to do with a small guy who has to fight a big guy. But, you know, sometimes you find people who only know that and don't actually know how the story worked out in the Bible. So I come from Scotland, as you heard, and in Scotland our big sport is soccer, we call it by its real name though, which is football.
7:15 We have this annual cup competition where you have all of the teams in all of the different leagues and they're all entered together and the very top leagues are full of, they have teams where the players are all millionaires, they play for their national teams, they're a really big deal. But then at the opposite end of the leagues you find players who are plumbers and electricians and builders and who play part time and do that for the love of the game. So we have this cup competition where occasionally you actually find that one of the huge teams is drawn to play against one of the lowest ranked teams of amateurs. So earlier this year I went into my car, it was a Saturday afternoon, I turned on the radio and it was the build up to exactly one of those games. And the coach of the huge team was being asked by this interviewer, how do you go about preparing your mega star elite players to play against a team of amateurs?
8:19 What's that like for you? How do you help them get into the right frame of mind? What kind of things do you say to your superstar players? So the coach said, well, you know, we're professionals. We treat every match professionally. We respect our opponents. But we're very confident with this match. And the interviewer said, so what kind of things do you tell your players then? And you could hear him, even though it was on the radio, lean into the microphone. And he said, well, what you can't forget is we are Goliath and they are David. And he said this. This is the kind of stuff he would tell his players. someone who didn't know, presumably, that David actually killed Goliath and that Goliath fell. And it made me think, wow, if any of your players have actually read the Bible, it's not great coaching on your part. Now, maybe, you know, you hear that story and, you know, your gut response is, well, how ignorant, like what a stupid thing to say.
9:18 And I am certainly not like that. I know the story. I know how it goes. And I know that the whole point of the story is not that power wins, it's that the underdog wins. And David is this boy with a slingshot and he manages to take out Goliath, the giant. And with that, you think you know everything that you need to know about David and Goliath. So maybe instead, if I were to turn on my car in Scotland and it's one of those big cup games with a huge team against some part-timers. and they're interviewing the coach of the part-time team, and you hear that coach say, well, it's going to be a really tough match. We're part-timers. They are big-time professionals. But we are David and they're Goliath. Therefore, we've got some hope. Maybe you're the kind of person who would listen to that and think, he gets it. He knows what he needs to know because he's taking this underdog story and he's identifying himself with David, and he's drawing inspiration from the story to face his own personal Goliath. So he's the guy who gets it. Now, if you resonate with that, I want to show you that the story of David and Goliath is far more important than that. That there's something profound here in this chapter that is really important and that if you grasp it, it will reshape your life in profound ways.
10:46 Now David is one of the most important people in the whole of the Bible. His life takes place in ancient Israel. As we were saying, he's this shepherd boy who becomes the king of his people and whose life is this really strange mixture of bravery and brilliance and creativity. He's also an exceptional musician and songwriter and singer. All of that, but also horrendous evil and sin. And in the Bible, he is the king through whom God chooses to send an ultimate king, the king of kings, the savior of the world. And in the Bible, that savior comes as Jesus, who's a descendant of David and who's born in David's city. But at this point in 1 Samuel 17, we are at a stage in David's life where he comes to fight Goliath. And David is the youngest son of a man called Jesse. He's a nobody who works as a shepherd, but even then in his life, he's remarkable in his own way.
11:49 You saw in the chapter that he is handsome, that he is brave, that he is strong. And outside his family, nobody knows who he is or what he's like. And even within his family, what you'll see by this point in David's life is that he's a younger brother, and his older brothers really don't have much time for him. In fact, his older brothers hate him, and they resent him. And it's kind of like, if you know more about the Bible than the soccer coach I mentioned, it's really like the story of Joseph and his older brothers. Joseph had all these older brothers who had very little time for him. And so by this point in David's life, the king is a man called Saul, and he's been a really terrible king, and God has rejected him. And when God did that, God sent a prophet called Samuel to find a new and a better king. And Samuel then was directed to the family of Jesse, who has all of these sons, and he goes through them one by one, rejecting son after son after son until he gets to the youngest, and that is David. And then when Samuel met him, he did something really strange, which is that he anointed David with oil.
12:58 And but when he did that, it showed that God had something really unique and special for David to do. But Samuel didn't announce to the wider world that this was the boy who'd been marked out to be king. so that is a secret that the young David is carrying within himself at this point in his life. And here, again, it's like an echo of the story of Joseph. Joseph's brothers also knew that Joseph was destined for something great, you know, because Joseph was that annoying younger brother who would tell his brothers, hey guys, I had another one of those dreams, and guess what? You guys were bowing down to me, right? So Joseph's brothers know that Joseph sees himself on some kind of trajectory like that, and they really resent it. And David's brothers are the same here. They've seen him be anointed by this prophet and that he's going to do something special that they're not. And they really resent him for that.
13:56 And in David's story, that's where we meet him there. So you know some of the details of the story because we've read through a part of the chapter. So what you have at this point in David's life is the Philistines and the Israelites, and they're lined up in battle against each other. And if the Israelites lose, their people will be taken as slaves. And the Philistines have this warrior that they wheel out to strike terror into the hearts of their enemies. And he's called Goliath. And superficially, Goliath is a picture of terror. And he looks like the ultimate fighting machine. He's covered in the best military technology. He's covered in metal. He's got the best armor. He's got the best weapons. He is exceptionally unusually tall. He's a really strange guy.
14:49 And in fact, if you read around the Old Testament and you look at 2 Samuel and 1 Chronicles, you actually find a sort of medical history of Goliath's wider family. So he has other family members who are also really unusually tall. Some of them, those chapters tell us, have extra fingers. So they have what we would now call polydactyly. So if they were around today, geneticists would be all over them, trying to work out what is going on in this family. And those other family members as well, Goliath's cousins, are also wheeled out as symbols of fear, to strike fear into the hearts of their enemies. And so we have Goliath, this guy from that kind of a family. And there's also a hint in our chapter that he doesn't have sharp eyesight, because David comes to him with one stick. But I don't know if you noticed this when Justin read that. Goliath asks, why do you come at me with sticks? Plural. So Goliath looks terrifying, but actually a lot of it is just for show.
15:55 You see, Goliath is a talisman of fear. He's a symbol that you could use to control your enemies through fear alone, just through how terrifying he looks. But the thing is, young David sees beyond that, and he's completely fearless, because he has spent his life in the wilderness fighting lions and bears to protect his sheep. Now, maybe at this point, you know, you listen to this, and you're kind of skeptical, but even about the character David, with all that I've described, how could one person really be all of these things? Someone who's a brilliant musician, and a singer, and a soul writer, and an athlete, and a lion killer, and maybe you just haven't met someone who could do all those things and David seems almost unbelievable in that sense to you. So if that's you, the place that you need to go is actually Edinburgh, where I live. So greatest city in the world. New York is just slightly beneath it. But in Edinburgh, every summer in August, we have this month-long arts festival. It's the world's biggest arts festival. And as part of that for the month, every year, we have this circus that comes from Gambia in West Africa and they are absolutely incredible as performers.
17:11 But the man who leads the circus is a truly remarkable individual. If you watch him, if you get to talk with him, he's just quite unlike anyone that you will probably have met before. When you see him, he is what we in the UK would call an absolute unit. He has muscles on his muscles. He is a spectacular athlete and can do incredible things. and when you see his cast around him he just has this charisma where he is a leader among men. and among really impressive people somehow this guy just shines and then midway through the show as well as all the physical things he can do, he comes out on stage holding a kora which is a West African stringed instrument 21 strings and he starts playing and he's a virtuoso performer and then he begins to sing and his voice is so great that you have a huge concert hall packed out every night for a month by people who all want to, who are just drawn to this man.
18:10 So if you had to ask me, have I ever met someone who could soothe my troubled soul by playing a complex instrument and then add his amazing voice there? And also someone who you would happily just elevate to all kinds of positions of amazing leadership. And if you really needed someone to kill a bear on your behalf, I haven't met many people who could do that, but I have actually, I know a guy. Okay, and so David is not meant to be sort of typical of all people, but he's a remarkable figure in the way that sometimes some people can do all of these things. So David is like that, and he's this exceptional young man who dares to stand up against this totemic talisman of fear in Goliath. And you know, there's a weird parallel between what you have in this chapter with how Goliath is described, and it was in the verses just before we picked up the reading, but Goliath is described in terms of all of the kinds of metal that he's wearing, and looks unstoppable because of that. There's a parallel between Goliath and what he looks like there. And another figure in the Old Testament, and it's a vision of the king of Babylon that the prophet Daniel saw. And that king also looked terrifying, and he's made of lots of different kinds of metal from the head down. He's made of gold and silver and bronze and iron. But that king had one weak spot. Maybe you know the story, and it's that he had feet of clay. So if you knew his one weak spot, it didn't really, the rest of it was just for show. You can just ignore that, and you hit the feet of clay and then that king will fall. But the thing is, Goliath is the same. He looks terrifying superficially, but to someone like David, he knows the weak spot. All he needs is one smooth stone and a slingshot. And it's an incredibly powerful story. And it's actually the same story that's told to great effect in Star Wars. So if you think about it like this, instead of Goliath, imagine the Death Star. And if you're not a Star Wars nerd, just rest your mind for about
20:17 90 seconds and then rejoin. But if you're a Star Wars nerd like me, please listen. So instead of Goliath, imagine the Death Star. The Death Star, it's no small moon. It can blow up planets. It can destroy entire civilizations. So you don't even need to use it to control the galaxy because the symbol of fear is so powerful. And you know the scene in Star Wars where the rebels manage to get the plans for the Death Star, and they discover that it has one weak spot, and it's only two meters wide, and the whole thing is massive. And there's a rebel pilot who says, two meters, that's impossible. And who's there, then who's the hero of the story? It's young Luke Skywalker, this remarkable young man from nowhere, who says, two meters, I used to shoot, I used to bullseye wump rats in my T-16 back home, they can't be much bigger than two meters. Do you see, it's the same story. And Luke Skywalker really is just an inferior version of David going to fight Goliath, where he can see the one weak spot. And he's been prepared for that by his own life as a shepherd boy. So what you have then in David and Goliath is that David ends up decapitating Goliath with his own symbol of fear, with his own sword. And David does all of this while he's young and unknown. And at the end of the chapter, you have Saul asking the commander of his army, who is this kid? So it's an amazing story. And I just said all of that to ground you in it, but I want to tell you two specific things about the story that will change how you see what it means for you today. And I say that if you're the kind of person who thinks, you know, I don't want to identify with Goliath. Who would do that? Who would be so stupid because Goliath lost? But I'm supposed to identify with David, and the point of the story is that it gives me hope when I'm the underdog, and I can draw inspiration from it when I'm up against some big foe, some Goliath in my life. So if that's how you read this chapter, buckle up, because you're about to see it in a completely different light. What I want to say is two things that together mean you cannot identify
22:28 with David in this chapter, okay? So you are not David here, and they're both things about David in the chapter. One is that he is a representative warrior, and the second is that David is a righteous younger brother. Okay, so first he's a representative warrior, and secondly he's a righteous younger brother. So David is a representative warrior. So culturally what's happening in this story, I'm guessing probably looks and feels very alien to you. You know, you're imagining rows of soldiers on both sides in a desert somewhere, and then you have these two guys who go out into the middle to face off to the death. And that seems really strange to you, very far from the life that you live in East Harlem in 2025. But what you need to know is, this is a way that wars could be decided in that culture at that time, where each army chose a representative warrior, and then they fought to the death. And then you, you were represented by that person and whether you lived or died depended on whether your representative warrior lived or died. If your representative died, the other side might kill you, they might enslave you.
23:41 It's a much less grave example, but to stick with soccer, imagine it's the final penalty shootout in the World Cup and you have a row of players and they're standing there arm in arm but only one of the players steps forward to take that final penalty. And that player is their representative. If that player scores, they score. If that player wins, they win. If that player loses, they lose. Or you could think about it maybe more gravely than this. And so one of the things that often shocks Americans when you travel to the UK, there are many, many shocking things. We're a pretty weird bunch. But one of the things that's always, that is often very counterintuitive and odd for Americans about British people is how universally antagonistic we are often towards our prime minister, regardless of whether we sympathize with the party that the Prime Minister represents. So it's not the case and so in British culture you you know, you go to a newsstand if you, you know, like, land at Heathrow Airport in London and you will find newspapers that are partisan in terms of the parties that they generally support.
24:54 But it still can be the case that every single newspaper across that whole spectrum will be just trashing the Prime Minister regardless. So there's a loyalty to parties, but not so much to individuals. But even in British culture like that, even if you're a sort of diehard loyalist for the party that your Prime Minister comes from and you really hate the Prime Minister and talk like that, even then it is the case that the prime minister represents you, and often in ways that you might not think about from day to day, but where your life is in that person's hands. So let's say the prime minister is heading into some cabinet room with the leaders of a bunch of international ally nations and hostile nations. You know, even if all of us British people really don't like the prime minister at all at any given moment, it's not really in your interests to think, and I hope he has the worst day at the office ever in his life today, because if that happens, it's really bad for you. It doesn't really matter that you don't like him. He's representing you. So, you know, however weird and alien the fight between David and Goliath superficially might seem to you, in terms of the culture that it's happening in, it is nonetheless the case that in East Harlem and in Edinburgh in 2025, you still live in a world where your life constantly depends on representatives.
26:20 And we don't think about that a lot because we're quite individualized and individualistic in Western culture, and we're always told the story that you're the boss of your own life and your life is in your own hands. But the reality is that your life is constantly in the hands of others and your destiny depends on them. So with that in mind, here's a tip on how to read David and Goliath. Do you think that the point of the story is that you are David? And that this story is just meant to inspire you to face up to the giants, your own personal Goliath in your own life? Well, if you want to say, I am David, okay, the chapter puts a question to you immediately. Okay, on whose behalf are you David? Who are you representing? Who are you saving? Because you can't just be David for yourself. You have to be a savior to someone if you are at the point that's just that you're a David. So who are you representing? Whose savior do you want to be? Whose representative warrior are you deciding to be if you identify with David and think that's all that's going on here?
27:37 I don't know if young people in New York say this, but in the UK, the kids would call this having main character energy, and that's not a compliment in British culture. So here's something for you that you need to hear from this chapter. You are not David.
27:58 He is not the person in this chapter that you are supposed to identify with. You are not meant to think, I've read 1 Samuel 17 and guess what? I am the true and better David. I am the fulfillment of his story. I am the one who's going to represent others and save them. You're supposed to read this chapter and think the opposite. I need someone to represent me. I need someone to stand in my place. I need someone to take Goliath down on my behalf. So the thing is, if you can't identify with David, whom can you identify with? And that takes us to the second point, that David was a righteous younger brother. Now, at this point, we're focusing, if you have a Bible there, in verse 28. So, you have David's three older brothers here, and they're in Saul's army, and they're playing that part really well. They're loyalists to King Saul. You know, they have volunteered to go to the front line. They're obedient, but not really.
28:57 They're volunteers to stand on the front line. None of David's brothers has said, you know, I volunteer as tribute, like I will go out and fight Goliath. None of them has done that. But the text actually focuses on one of the brothers, on Eliab, who is David's eldest brother. And the chapter shows us Eliab as someone who is cowardly and someone whose anger against his younger brother David is kindled. And hypocritically, Eliab says to David, I know what you're doing here and how arrogant and conceited you are. And you're just here because you want to watch the fights. You just want to stand here on the sidelines and watch these two guys. When that's exactly the thing that Eliab was doing. And David actually wanted to go and fight Goliath. Okay, so in the chapter, there's just this brief moment between this elder brother and a younger brother. And then it moves on really quickly and you go to David fighting Goliath.
29:57 And, you know, I would guess that probably for most of us, you know, if someone, if you think you know the chapter quite well, the David and Goliath story, and someone asks you to recount it, you might easily just have completely forgotten, just glossed over the fact that this exchange happened. And, you know, it would be, well, David got sent out by his dad with cheese and feed his brothers who are in the army, and he feeds them. And then, you know, Saul's looking for someone to fight Goliath and the armor and the slingshot and everything. And you might have completely forgotten that this exchange ever happened. But this exchange is essential in understanding David and what the chapter means for us. You see, the exchange between David and his elder brother, Eliab, puts this chapter into a whole series of elder brother, younger brother exchanges that you find running throughout the whole Bible. And where the elder brother is the unrighteous one, and where the younger brother is the righteous brother. Okay, you go back to the beginning of the Bible to Cain and Abel. You could think of Joseph's unrighteous elder brothers and righteous Joseph. You could think of, in the New Testament, Jesus and the story of the parable son and his unrighteous elder brother. And all of those stories confront us with something really important about Jesus and about ourselves.
31:21 There's a very famous photo that I'm sure many of you will have seen in high school history class. And it's from World War II era Germany, Nazi Germany. And there is a parade. And Hitler is being driven through the parade. And you have a whole crowd of people. And everyone is doing the salute, apart from one man in this whole crowd. and that one man is standing there like this. And he's the only one. And I once heard a history teacher talk about using this photo in his classes. where he said, every year I show this picture to my students and every year my students always tell me if I had been there I would have been that guy. Every single student. And he'd never had a student who said, yeah, if I'd lived then maybe I would have been one of the evil.
32:15 ones in that culture. And he would always tell his students year after year, what a remarkable coincidence that you are all the good one in this picture, and that nobody would ever dare to say that actually, well, what if you've been one of the evil ones? So counterintuitive to us. But let's say, moving from that picture into all of these elder younger brothers throughout the Bible, let's say the picture is a picture of Cain and Abel. Which one of those two would you be? Of course I would be able. I'm not evil Cain. I'm the good brother. Okay, what about Joseph and his brothers? Which one would you be? I wouldn't throw my brother down a well. Like, I'm good Joseph. I'm the hero.
32:59 Who would you be if it was a picture of Eliab and David? Of course I'd be David. I would go and fight Goliath. I wouldn't be the unrighteous elder brother. Who would you be in the story of the prodigal son? the prodigal who did the right thing eventually, or his miserly, ungenerous elder brother? Of course, I would be the good one, right? But the thing is, with all of these elder brother, younger brother stories in the Bible, they all come together in Jesus Christ. And what you have towards the end of his life and his passion and his suffering, when you have Jesus on his way to the cross, you have a crowd of elder brothers surrounding him, and they are the fulfillment of every Cain, every brother of Joseph, every Eliab, and they are crying, crucify him. So who would you be in that picture? Would you be one of the elder brothers, or what's the alternative. Are you Jesus? The perfect younger brother, the true and the better Abel, the true and the better Joseph, the true and the better David. You see, the way that 1 Samuel 17 teaches us to understand the gospel is that it shows you that you need a representative. You need a savior.
34:24 You need someone who will defeat the forces of evil and sin and death and free you from your slavery to them. And it shows you that in the story, you are Eliab, that you are the angry, unrighteous elder brother. And actually, the reason that you need a representative is precisely because you are an Eliab. So the reason for A is B. And you know how you're like Eliab in this chapter. The thing with Eliab is when he comes and talks to David, that's a repetition of something that you see right back in the book of Genesis, Genesis 4, where the unrighteous elder brother Cain fails to please God, and his righteous younger brother Abel pleases God, and then Cain becomes very angry. That anger starts surging in his heart, and he goes and he talks to his brother, and then he kills him. And this brief interaction between Eliab and David is like a repetition of that. It's the same story happening again. In Eliab's heart, the only thing that is surging there is anger for his brother. And in his heart, it was like he'd already murdered David.
35:40 Isn't it crazy that in this chapter, Goliath isn't the only one who wants David dead? His own brother wants that. And yet, David was willing to put his own life on the line to face Goliath, willing to die for an unrighteous elder brother who had already shouted in his heart, crucify him at David. You see, you have to identify with Eliab in this chapter if you are going to know who Jesus is. And that's because although throughout the Old Testament, it's the younger brother who's righteous and the elder brother who's unrighteous, the New Testament tells us that Jesus has made himself our elder brother and an elder brother who is the opposite of all those elder brothers in the Old Testament. Jesus is the opposite of Cain. He's the opposite of Eliab. He's the opposite of Joseph's older brothers. And all of those elder brothers were ashamed of their younger brothers because their younger brothers were righteous. But in the gospel, that all gets flipped. And we have an elder brother who is perfect in every way. And yet, he, Hebrews 2 tells us, is not ashamed to call us brothers. And in that way, he's the opposite of Cain to Abel or Eliab to David because in their hearts, those elder brothers, the only thing that was there was hatred leading to death. But the kind of elder brother Jesus wants to be to you is the most generous, loving elder brother that you could possibly imagine. And in his heart for you, all that there is is love leading to life. That's what he means when he comes and says he wants to give you life and life in all its fullness. He's being the opposite of all those elder brothers.
37:29 and that is everything that is offered to you in the gospel, in the story of David and Goliath, but it's something that you will never see if you only ever read this chapter thinking, it's there to inspire me to be the one who takes down some Goliath or other in my life. So let me close by saying this, that once you realize that you are Eliab in this chapter, and that the true David is Jesus, Jesus who in his life and death and resurrection and ascension and everything that he is doing for you in heaven right now, that that Jesus saves you by taking down a Goliath that you never possibly could, the world itself and this world of evil and sin and death, that Jesus has done that. it will put you radically out of step with the way that the world works all around us.
38:29 And the reason for that is, if you think back to the very beginning, when I spoke about that soccer coach, he said to his own players, remember, we are Goliath. I think he would encourage them. When you hear that, again, we can laugh at that and think, how ignorant. But the reason that that coach thought this was something that would make sense to his players, The reason that he'd only heard of David and Goliath but didn't know the biblical story, but when he had to put the pieces together, of course Goliath wins. That was his assumption. And the reason that he assumed that the story in the Bible must have worked out like that. is because the idea that power wins is something that is the water that we swim in every day in this world. So the idea is that if power wins, then you have to choose a representative warrior. well, of course you would pick Goliath over David. Of course you pick those who accumulate power instead of those who seem to give it away.
39:26 Of course you would choose Governor Pontius Pilate of the Roman Empire over the naked Jesus who is nailed to a cross. Napoleon used to say, God is on the side of the big battalions. Power always wins. That was his idea. So whatever you do, make sure that you get power. Make sure you align with power. And maybe you hear that and think you are more like Napoleon Dynamite than Napoleon Bonaparte. You're not trying to take over the world. Your life is far more humble than that. But trying to literally take over the world like Napoleon Bonaparte is not the only way that you can live by that philosophy. You can build battalions in many, many ways. By the neighborhood that you think you must live in, by the school that you think my children must get into, or the resume that you think you must have, or the bank balance that you think you need, or in the transactional relationships that you think you have to develop in order to get power, or in a political power that you think must be the representative warrior to fight for you in this world, and you cannot imagine life without it.
40:39 So there are so many ways that you can do this. Our world is full of Goliaths who are whispering into your ear, you need power, and I have it, and I can give it to you. But here's the thing, it's so easy to say in your head, I know that Goliath lost, and yet there's an intuition that guides your whole life that says, I think he kind of won, or he should be the winner. And that shapes your life. It drives you to try and take all these things, and you crush them by trying to squeeze power out of them. And, you know, there's an old political saying, power wears out those who don't have it. If you look for all of these things in your life to be your Goliath, it will only ever wear you out. But in the gospel, you're offered another way. Instead of telling you that you need a Goliath in this weary world, the gospel enables you to say, I'm an Eliab. and the true and better David, Jesus Christ laid down his life for me and took down the far greater Goliath and then having done so, what is his message to me in this world where the pursuit of power will only ever weary you? His message is, come unto me all you who are weary and I will give you rest. Praise God for the gospel in David and Goliath and Eliab. Let's pray.
42:00 Lord God, we thank you that you are kind and gracious, that you're a God who has sent light into this dark world, that you've sent Jesus into this weary world, and that your gospel exposes us, that it helps us to see that we are truly an Eliab. And yet we thank you that Jesus Christ is a different kind of elder brother, and that everything that he's done for us in laying down his life for us makes everything different. So Lord, we praise you for that gospel this morning in Jesus name
Machine translated from the source