The Subtlety and Strategy of Sin

Rev. Andrew Field · Redeemer West Side · Published November 9, 2025

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: Genesis 4:1-16 0:19
1And Adam had relations with his wife Eve, and she conceived and gave birth to Cain. “With the help of the LORD I have brought forth a man,” she said. 2Later she gave birth to Cain’s brother Abel. Now Abel was a keeper of sheep, while Cain was a tiller of the soil. 3So in the course of time, Cain brought some of the fruit of the soil as an offering to the LORD, 4while Abel brought the best portions of the firstborn of his flock. And the LORD looked with favor on Abel and his offering, 5but He had no regard for Cain and his offering. So Cain became very angry, and his countenance fell. 6“Why are you angry,” said the LORD to Cain, “and why has your countenance fallen? 7If you do what is right, will you not be accepted? But if you refuse to do what is right, sin is crouching at your door; it desires you, but you must master it.” 8Then Cain said to his brother Abel, “Let us go out to the field.” And while they were in the field, Cain rose up against his brother Abel and killed him. 9And the LORD said to Cain, “Where is your brother Abel?” “I do not know!” he answered. “Am I my brother’s keeper?” 10“What have you done?” replied the LORD. “The voice of your brother’s blood cries out to Me from the ground. 11Now you are cursed and banished from the ground, which has opened its mouth to receive your brother’s blood from your hand. 12When you till the ground, it will no longer yield its produce to you. You will be a fugitive and a wanderer on the earth.” 13But Cain said to the LORD, “My punishment is greater than I can bear. 14Behold, this day You have driven me from the face of the earth, and from Your face I will be hidden; I will be a fugitive and a wanderer on the earth, and whoever finds me will kill me.” 15“Not so!” replied the LORD. “If anyone slays Cain, then Cain will be avenged sevenfold.” And the LORD placed a mark on Cain, so that no one who found him would kill him. 16So Cain went out from the presence of the LORD and settled in the land of Nod, east of Eden.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

2:57 This is God's word. Well, good morning. Great to see you. We are looking at the book of Genesis all fall. And just like people have for literally thousands of years. And so this story was told mostly in an oral fashion. So you can imagine 3,000, 3,500 years ago, people sitting around a campfire. You know, the old man, the old woman in the village who knows the story is telling everybody about the creation of the world, right? And how God made all things. And then he made human beings. Very particular kind of creation in his image and how glorious it was. But then human beings rebelled against him, broke the one tiny little rule there was to say, in a sense, we matter. We're our own independent kinds of creatures. And then you get to the first two people born, Cain and Abel.

3:53 And then Cain beats Abel to death. Like, wow, that got dark real quick, right? How did it go from this glorious creation to the very first human being who ever died, didn't die of old age, didn't die of disease or an accident or eaten by a bear, but his brother took him out to the field and beat him to death. And it is told this way because this is how the very beginning, this trajectory of sin from human beings of just deciding to alienate themselves from God, setting themselves up as a rival, turned into this rivalry between all human beings now. And this seed of violence and self-centeredness is planted right at the beginning.

4:48 And if you were to look around yourself, not just some story in the past, but if you look around what's happening today, if you looked around what happened 3,000 years ago, 2,000 years ago, 1,000 years ago, right? We see this story of Cain and Abel playing itself out every day, all the time. Why? Because it's baked into who we are in the beginning. And that's what this passage here in Genesis 4 is meant to do to us as a warning. So here's what we're going to do today. We're going to look at this because this is essentially a crime, the very first crime, the very first death, murder, and so forth. I don't know if, do any of you like true crime podcasts? They're kind of fun, right? They're fun because you think, ooh, how could somebody do something like that? Well, let's look at this like a true crime podcast from the very beginning. So we've got five points.

5:41 Don't worry, I know you're thinking, I have brunch plans. We're going to look at these in order, but we'll look at them like a true crime podcast would. We're going to see about the actual crime itself, the backstory, which is everyone's favorite episode, the motive behind the crime, why'd he do it, the justice that happened because of this, and then finally, and uniquely, the restoration.

6:09 The crime, the backstory, the motive, justice that was given, and then restoration. Now, just in honor of our neighborhood, I think we would call this crime Only Murders in the Beginning. So here we go. The crime. What happened? So we see it laid out very specifically in verse 8. If you'll take a look at verse 8, it says, Now Cain said to his brother Abel, let's go out to the field. And while they were out in the field, Cain attacked his brother Abel and killed him. Not a lot here. It's a very simple society. It's a stone age. Who knows? right, not a whole lot going on, but Cain is able to convince, I'm sorry, yeah, is able to convince Abel in some way to go out to this field. Now, the NIV says, Cain said to his brother Abel, let us go out to the field. That quote from Cain is actually not in Scripture. It's a very confusing verse. It says, you know, Cain said to his brother Abel, that's the end of the sentence. We don't know what he said to his brother Abel, but he said something that essentially lured Abel out to this field. The field that Cain, of course, was agricultural, had been tending. And there he attacks him with enough force to kill him. Apparently it was a very horrific bloody death because there's blood all over the ground that God calls out. That's the scene, right? But then we have some eyewitnesses, and the key eyewitness, of course, is God himself. And he says in verse 9, Then the Lord says to Cain, where's your brother Abel?

7:48 And this is where Cain does something incredibly foolish, right? He's trying to kind of act like he has no idea. Like, I don't know where Abel is. You know, am I in charge of keeping track of him? He's trying to make an excuse to God himself. He's not his keeper. But then the Lord says in verse 10, what have you done? And if he puts a question mark there, it probably should be an exclamation point. God is not asking for information, okay? He knows full well what has happened. What have you done? Listen, your brother's blood cries out to me from the ground. So here we've got Cain, right, trying in this conversation to backpedal and to remove himself from this actual crime. But God is not only, of course, the judge here, but we see very clearly that God is an actual witness to this. He's hearing, like he does throughout Scripture, that he hears the blood of Abel, just like he hears all over the scripture, the cry of those who have been attacked, mistreated, the weak, the poor.

8:53 Their cries, their prayers, their talking to God, it comes into him and burdens his heart. He loves and cares for people like Abel. And Abel, as he's dying the first death ever, I'm sure is speaking to his maker. So here you've got what's going on here. Now, what can we see? What kind of facts can you draw out from this crime? First of all, there's absolutely no question about a guilty verdict, right? We've got clear evidence. We have a witness by God himself. And as the story is written, we know full well Cain did it. Besides, who else would have done it, right? Second thing we see here is this description of violence as the next level expansion of sinfulness. The very beginning sin in the garden was just not eating a particular fruit on a particular tree was what they were told not to do, and they did it.

9:57 But in so doing was to separate themselves. And then we see the fact that human beings are placed outside. of the Garden of Eden, and bam, it escalates all the way to this incredible murder. So there's something going on here, right? The fact of this event is implying something, right? We don't see it necessarily just by looking at it. So he's guilty, there's death, and God hears the cries of those who are weak. Now, here's the modern implication of this. Look at just one example. It doesn't take long to kind of see how this plays itself out. Here's one example.

10:41 Some news story happens. Somebody from some perspective writes something on social media about that news story. Just their opinion. it. You start reading the comments section. I think the comments section is a great example of Cain and Abel played out in our world today, because it doesn't take very many comments deep before somebody is like, I totally agree with you, man, and then bam, people come in, you're a complete idiot, how dare you say that, and it just gets worse from there. Pretty soon, and everybody in the comments section is attacking each other.

11:22 It's like the worst way to start your day is to pick up some social media and start reading comments to news stories. Because you see in there not actual murder happening, but the vitriol, the hatred, the character assassination, the destruction of one another. You're different than me, and therefore, how dare you even speak? And that just blurts out of people. And, of course, the trouble now is the amplification of that in something like social media. This is just in the last, what, 10, 15 years. This has been going on forever. But now it's just magnified. And, of course, the danger we see in our society is the virtual hatred and violence is turning into, actually, death. Assassinations and killings and so forth.

12:17 and we are afraid of that. Why? We're afraid of something that's just baked into us from the very, very beginning. And so to look at Cain and Abel, if you're looking at it with open eyes, you can see this crime and you don't think necessarily, how could that possibly have happened? You think, oh yeah, I get it. I get it. Okay, let's leave that there. That's the crime that's seeing about as much as we can see into that. Episode two, the backstory. The second episode of almost every true crime podcast, it tells the little bit of the backstory. It's my favorite, most people's favorite episode, because it kind of answers the question like, whoa, how did that guy get that way? What's the story behind all this? And we see this, go back to verse one. And I'm not going to completely blame the parents here, but everybody wants to know, like, who were that guy's parents?

13:20 Not always their fault, but, you know, there's always some question. So here's Eve, right? And it says Eve gave birth to Cain, and she said, Oh, with the help of the Lord, I have brought forth a man. And then later she gave birth to his brother Abel. And then it says this, you know, interesting little story. Abel kept flocks. Cain worked the soil, right? So Cain's into agriculture, Abel is a rancher. But let's pause for a second on what Eve says. Because if you brushed over it really quickly, you think, well, that's cool. Eve is acknowledging God into this. But it's actually a really odd phrase. Because Eve is saying, essentially, I am the creator of this man. And thankfully, God helped a little bit. This is a long distance from what the relationship that Eve and Adam had with God when they were in the garden, and they hung out with him in the evening.

14:21 Now she's saying, I'm a creator, and God helps me. the essence of our human nature is now elevating already. So the other thing we know here is at the very tail end of chapter three, this is after the fall and God is speaking into the destruction that's going to come. He says something that the offspring of Eve will be the one that will strike the heel of the serpent, right? go after Satan. Now, we know now, of course, because the whole Bible expands that story out, we realize the offspring of Eve is eventually Jesus. Eve doesn't know that in chapter 4 of Genesis. There's no doubt that the first child born that she's super excited about, she's thinking, God just says, my offspring will be the Savior, will go against this evil Satan.

15:26 So Cain is born, and Cain, the first child, has this complex given to him of being the key person, the Savior of all things. Abel comes along, younger brother, right? Not so cool as the oldest. And there is a relationship there. We don't know what's going on here, but we know at least this much, right? You've got parents who have put themselves above God. You've got a child now who has this pressure and position of being like the new king of all creation, the savior.

16:08 And then a tag along. Now, I don't think there's much you can make from the fact that Cain works the soil and Abel works in livestock, right? That's just the two core vocations of ancient humanity, right? It's great. But they're off there doing their thing, farming, ranching. But you can see in this backstory that there is something just twisted about everybody.

16:39 This family, the very first little family here, is bent somehow, in a way that all of us now experience in different degrees. C.S. Lewis talks about it in Mere Christianity in a way that what he calls this, his phrase is this central twist in ourselves. And he uses the example of anger, which works perfectly here, and it's very on point. And he said, you've got two people. One of them is an angry man, but he's a powerful person. He is somebody with great violence and intensity. And then you've got another angry person who's actually just a weak, meek person. So he's angry inside his core, but he doesn't really express it because he can't get away with it. And we think of the powerful, angry person as somebody who's horribly violent.

17:34 But he said they're both, they are both twisted. And he says, each of them, however, as they express inside their hearts something wrong, will continue to get more angry, more violent, more twisted. Unless, he says, he seriously turns to God, then they can have that twist and the central man straightened out again. And each is, in the long run, doomed if they won't. And the bigness or the smallness of the thing, meaning the sin pattern, seen from the outside is not what really matters. The big, bold, strong, angry person is not worse than the weak, quiet, angry person. They are both twisted until they get that twist straightened out by turning their life instead of themselves towards God.

18:35 And so we see this story playing out in this family. So that's episode two, the backstory. So we've got this horrific murder. We have this family that something's wrong with them from the beginning. But now let's go one level deeper. This is the motive. This is really crucial here. Like, why did he do it? This is not kind of accidental. This is not just manslaughter, right? We're not robots. Cain isn't acting just directly because of something that Abel does. He's making a deliberate choice here. Now, this is where it's super helpful in this passage, because Genesis 4 is something that much of the Bible refers back to, and particularly the Old Testament. So if you're wondering what's going on here, we have Hebrews 11, verse 4 to tell us. And it's always great to have a question about the Bible that the Bible answers clearly later. Hebrews 11, 4 says this, By faith, Abel brought God a better offering than Cain did. And by faith, he was commended as righteous when God spoke well of his offerings. So here's the clue. Abel and Cain gave an offering. And it was the way that God reacted to that offering that was the seed of what drove Cain to kill him. The question here isn't what they brought to offer. In the Bible, it is not better to bring a livestock offering than a grain offering or an agricultural offering.

20:21 They're both appropriate, so that's not the issue. But here's the key thing here. When you look at what they offered, it says that Abel brought the fat of the first fruits of his flocks. So the best portion of the beginning, the earliest ones. Whereas it says that Cain brought some fruits of his labors.

20:48 So you get the difference? For Abel, it was to say, this is a risky offering. You don't know how many babies your livestock are going to have that year. And when you take the very first of them, and out of gratitude and joy and worship, those are offered to God. It is an act of incredible and intense faith. Whereas Cain, you know, I was great and he had some, he just gave some to God. As a, you know, offering-ish of thanks, but you can see what's going on is what's in their heart by the way that they do this. Tim Keller puts it this way, there's actually only two reasons to give God an offering. One is to give God an offering in response to salvation, right, in gratitude towards salvation, and the other reason to do it is as a means of salvation, as a way of getting God to bless you, as a way of getting God to reward you, as a way to answer your prayers, or to take you to heaven.

21:51 And that's what's going on here. Abel says, God is my savior. You have given me everything, and I give it in thankfulness. Cain's like, hey, let's make a deal, God. I give you something, you give me something back. And so much of history of mankind and down to the day, sees this kind of act of worship as transactional. I will give God things if he gives me something in return.

22:28 And the difference there is this subtle strategy at the heart of sin, right? We see it already in how Eve has talked about this, right? I'm actually the one that's important. I'm the center of the universe. What happens to me in my life is what is crucial to me. and God, he can help me if he wants to. And I hope he does. And if I bribe him, he will.

22:58 And that kind of self-centeredness is, you know, really at the core of what Adam and Eve did when they sinned. And it works itself out already. So that's it, right? You've got this core, core motive of I'm in charge and God is my helper. But then it goes on because the self-centeredness results in an envy.

23:23 Because what does God say, even in the text? Well, God liked Abel's offering better than Cain's. Cain knew full well that what he did wasn't what God wanted. And here he is looking at his brother who was his brother. Now he's like, oh man, God likes Abel better than me? Suddenly they're rivals.

23:51 Cain wants God's favor. He felt like he just bought it. What does Abel get to do? He's just the younger brother. He's the kid who's been hanging around his whole life. What's he up to? Now God likes him better than me? Something's wrong. And that envy, that desire to possess the same thing that the other person has is what triggers this anger.

24:15 Well, then, if he is in my way of getting what I want, I'm going to have to take him out. I'm going to have to remove him. I'm going to have to destroy him. And so we see this incredible progression from self-centeredness to envy, to anger, to murder. and that pattern, if you look around, is everywhere, right? It's this warning that God gives us in verse 7. The sin, Cain, sin is crouching at your door. If you don't recognize what's going on now in your thoughts, it will overtake you and result in something. And of course, Cain ignored it. Now, if you're here and you're thinking, well, Cain's a bad guy.

25:14 Or, boy, I sure hope that I don't get, you know, attacked by somebody like Cain in my life. I feel like Abel. I really, you know. Yeah, no. That's not what this passage is about. The reason we know that is 1 John 3, 12 and 15. 12 to 15 says this, a great other passage in the New Testament about this exact story. John writes this, do not be like Cain, who belonged to the evil one and murdered his brother. And why did he murder him? Because his own actions were evil and his brothers were righteous. In verse 15, then, anyone who hates a brother or sister is a murderer. And you know that no murderer has eternal life residing in him. Why is John giving us this warning? It's not to protect us from people like Cain.

26:10 He's saying, we're all Cain. that that same seed of hostility, that same seed of self-centeredness is in every single one of us, and sin is crouching at the door of all of our hearts. Now, you know, in a recent survey just a couple of months ago of urban professionals, they were asked, you know, do you ever experience anger, envy, jealousy at your workplace? 80% of the people said yes. It was a frequent and common thing. 20% were lying and said no.

26:49 So here's the question. I mean, reality. Is that you? are you in the 80 percent? Can you think of any time in your life that somebody that, you know, you were a peer with, you know, you weren't, you weren't, they weren't part of your family, they were just somebody out there a peer, and you both were working hard, and they got this incredible reward that you didn't get, and you were just like, oh, I'm so happy for them.

27:17 No, you're thinking, I deserve that. Why do they get something I want? That thing is just in there for all of us. And John writes, we have to watch out for this, because Genesis 4 says, this is the warning. This is what we're all like.

27:41 And that's not great news to hear, but it's reality. And if we think about it for five seconds, we realize it's true, right? So, here we go. That was the motive. Episode 4, this is the quick episode. The justice. We see this in verses 11 and following, and I'll just kind of paraphrase, right? God says to Cain, you were gonna be driven from the ground, right? Now all the things that you work in the soil will be fruitless, which is a horrific curse because the entire point of humanity was to be fruitful and to fill the empty world. And he's saying to Cain, yeah, you're no good at that from now on. And then the worst thing is, you will now wander away from me. They were in the garden. They hung out with God. That was humanity. Now they are kicked out of the garden. They are east of Eden in this already world of separation. And he says to Cain, go further east.

28:36 Your job is to have no home ever. Your curse is to just wander into the land of Nod. And Nod is... the land of wandering, literally. You're going to wander in wandering forever. And Cain, right, realizes how horrific that is. He's like, no, I can't stand that. So if you're thinking, why didn't God just kill Cain outright? God gave a worse punishment to Cain. But yet in the midst of that worse, terrible punishment, God does something really wild, which is he puts a form of mercy on him. Because here's Cain now saying to God, well, wait a second, if I start wandering east, someone's going to kill me. Like he's just discovered like, whoa, humans can die if you beat them over the head with a stick and a rock, right? That's going to happen to me because he realizes everybody else is going to be violent like I am.

29:36 Now, pause. Big question. Who are all those people over way in the east in the land of Nod that he's going to run into? Here's the definitive answer from Bible scholars. We have no idea. No idea. So it's either like hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of years have gone on because, you know, Adam did lift at 930. And yet even in the description of that, like, it seems pretty clear that only Cain and Abel and then Seth were born. And then they had a, it says a bunch of other kids. So, you know, thousands of children, who knows? But at this point, I don't know who those people are. Did God just make a bunch of other people in the east. It's entirely possible. It doesn't say. No idea. But they're there. Okay, let's move on. Unpause. So he's saying, though, I am going to put a mark on you to protect you. I'm going to do something that keeps you from suffering the way that you destroyed Abel.

30:42 It's incredible mercy. Well, let's turn now to the fifth point, which is the restoration, because this is the beginning of us leading into this. the story of Cain and Abel and the story of Jesus' life and death and resurrection are actually set up in the Bible as opposites of each other. That Jesus comes to undo what Cain did. And let me just give you a couple of these key parallels.

31:20 And John Stott puts it this way. This is the ultimate contrast, right? We've got Cain's hatred issuing in murder, but then we've got Christ's love issuing in his self-sacrifice. This is a huge story of Scripture. You've got in verse 10, the blood that cries out from the ground from Abel. And then Hebrews 12, 24 says, it's Jesus' blood. His blood speaks a better word than the blood of Abel. The blood of Jesus is mercy and forgiveness. The blood of Jesus is to undo all this violence. The second thing is, 1 John 3, which you already looked at, said that Abel's death was the death of a righteous man. Abel wasn't perfect, but Abel lived a Godward life.

32:12 Whereas Jesus, of course, is the righteous one, who actually was righteous and lived a Godward life, but also never sinned. It was perfect. And they were both murdered unjustly for no reason. Then we see the mark of protection, right, that I mentioned there in verse 15. This is a mark that God puts on Cain to protect him temporarily, right, in his life so that nobody would kill him. But Cain eventually, on his own, died. And none of that indicates, as far as we can tell, that Cain actually ever repented or came to any kind of permanent relationship back restored to God himself. But Jesus on the cross says that the ultimate mark, right, this seal of the Holy Spirit is placed on those who are in Christ Jesus. And this mark lasts forever. It's not just a mark of temporary protection from harm. It is a mark to our spirit, to our souls to say, forever you are safe in Jesus. And then the last thing, of course, is this alienation and exile that we see in verse 16. Cain, and basically everybody from now on, is in some kind of state of wandering away from God.

33:42 None of us just spend our whole day in the presence of God. But what Jesus does is to reverse that. He brings the reconciliation. He brings the re-inclusion back into a relationship. He restores what it means to belong to him. He undoes the wandering for everybody who's in him. that is part of this great story of the gospel, right? Jesus's life and death and resurrection is to restore everything to all of God's people. Now, here's a way to kind of apply all this. So it's not just a theory and it's not just a story, but it becomes true to you. Three thoughts. And this is something you can just practice for this week. First would be, say, journal at the end of the day for a few minutes. And if you don't like journaling, I don't like journaling, actually. You can think about it and not write it down. It's okay. What, not what did you do today, which is kind of easy sort of journaling, but what did you desire to do today that you didn't act on? What were your jealousies and your envies? What were your hatreds and your anger towards other people? What is it because you're kind of a civilized human being you didn't really act on, but you wish you could have said that, right?

35:06 Spend a week just thinking about that. The second thing you could do as another experiment would be to unfollow something for the sake of your heart, which is to mean, in particular, unfollow somebody or some news source or something on social media. that every time you look at it, you just get enraged. Or you get so jealous. spend a week not looking at that. On purpose, just unfollow them. You can follow them again if you want to. But what happens to your heart over the course of that week? where you're not jumping on the bandwagon of attacking somebody else? The other one would be actively loving and keeping a neighbor, like an actual neighbor, like a real person who lives on your floor or on your street or in your workplace who you don't know really at all, but you do something over the course of the week that begins to kind of break down that barrier and care and love and serve them.

36:17 Because it's hard, right, for some weird reason to do that. So you do any of those three things for a week or so, and then you can look back and say, yeah, that kind of proves what I deeply knew down here, I just didn't want to admit, which is I am just like Cain. but because of the gospel, I have Jesus.

36:46 That the story doesn't ever have to end at Genesis 4 for me. And it goes from being an abstraction, I understand these stories, I get the theory of the gospel, I know some theology to, oh, wow, at the very core of my being, down to my bones, I really need Jesus.

37:13 Because there is nothing on my own that I could do to uncover and undo and be straightened out from what's twisted inside of me. That's good news. Good news that you actually have to feel and think. And that's what doing something like this for a week could help you do. Now, Jesus and Jesus only entered into our world to redeem us in a way that Cain and Abel and Adam and Eve and your neighbor and your parents and you and everybody around you just keep doing. he can undo it all.

37:58 So let's do this. I'm going to pray, and then we'll continue turning our attention in worship, true worship towards him. Let's pray. God, thank you that we have this story before us that is here not only because it happened, but it's here in this way because we need to hear it. We need to know how things fell apart.

38:25 And we need to know how things fell apart because we need to know how you can put it back together again. and what you've come to do and how you entered into our world and suffered, like Abel, only worse, for the sake of people like Cain and us and all who are in you eventually. And Father, we lift this up and gratitude and thankfulness in Jesus' name.

Machine translated from the source