David Hwang · Jubilee Church · Published September 14, 2025
0:06 All right, good morning, Jubilee. Great to see everybody here on this Lord's Day together as a Lord's family. So let's begin our time together properly by recognizing this blessing and truth that we are here for more than just he and me, that we are also here for he and we because he is making a family of us. So can we go ahead, take this moment, turn to our brothers and sisters all around us and wish each other a good morning in Jesus' name. Can we do that, please? Good morning. Ecclesia, good morning out there. Good. All righty. Okay. The day has finally come. The day has finally come where in this series concerning the violence of God, in this series that addresses the topic of whether or not we can justifiably think. that the Bible reveals God to have a violent side to Him or not. And this is important for again, what we think of God will directly affect how we live for God.
1:09 If we think that God is a taskmaster, trust me, you're going to be dutiful, that kind of thing, right? So yes, in this series, we have finally come to the day where we can and will start looking at some of the passages in the Bible that at least in the plain reading ascribe violence to God. However, if you've been following along in this series, you should know that what I've been presenting these past couple of weeks is a perspective that actually gives us justifiable options. Justifiable options to read and understand those passages actually differently. Where despite the plain reading of the text, when you read it, it says God did the violence. We can again, justifiably, read and understand those passages in a way where we can still see God as one who is not violent at all and in any way. Which means that this position is not some whimsical desire like, I wish God wasn't violent. So he's not violent. There we have it. Because you just want to imagine it away, the idea of God being violent. Though again, in the plain reading, there is clearly violence that is ascribed to God.
2:26 So this position is not some whimsical thing, but it's one that comes through a theological and biblical survey. of how faith has been received and understood throughout the history of the people of God. And in lieu of the most recent happenings in America, I say, thank God that we do have this justifiable option of of him being a nonviolent God. for even among us humans, imperfect humans, if we can say that violence is never the solution, at least not towards anything good. We always say this, even as imperfect humans.
3:07 Anyhow, yes, in lieu of all the violence in America, and of course, I'm mentioning not only Charlie Kirk and the murder that that was, terrible on so many levels, But we also had the violence of some Ukrainian refugee woman who was stabbed. And then you have ice and those battles there. And then you have more mass shootings at schools. I mean, on and on, right?
3:35 And this, not just in America, but in all the world. In all the world, everywhere you turn around, so much violence. And much of it, more or less, in the name of God. Much of it more or less in the name of righteousness. Being right. Therefore, I'm justified to do violence to another.
3:57 In the name of God. In the name of righteousness. Of being right. So even if we as imperfect human beings would say, violence is never the solution. Wouldn't or shouldn't this thought that violence is never the solution be all the more true for the Lord who we ultimately believe is the Lord of love? That in his righteousness that he would not exact violence?
4:23 Anyhow, yes, I hold to the statement that violence is never the answer towards any solution, at least any that are good. And therefore, I feel that this series is one that's all the more important for us these days. That each of us be truly challenged to really wrestle with the notion as to whether or not you believe that God can be violent. For again, what you think of God will definitely determine how you think of God. 100%. Therefore, for the past two weeks, I presented different theological concepts that are, again, biblically justifiable. We went through all that stuff together, and also those that have been tested over the history of the church. And we described that together as well, how this theology was accepted and understood throughout, again, the history of the church. Where together, they gave us a perspective and the tools needed to start seeing how the passages in question related to God and violence can be actually understood differently.
5:21 beyond the plain reading. Now, obviously, I cannot really explain everything to us now, everything that I've already shared. So please, if you have missed these prior messages, make sure you go back and check it out. I'm telling you, theologically, I don't know if there is a more consequential topic than the one we're talking about today or that one we've been talking about in this series. So I can't explain everything again, okay?
5:48 But I did make the effort to address the passages that we'll be sharing today in a way where even if you didn't catch the prior messages, you'll still be able to get the main gist of things, I hope. Okay, so I'm pretty sure you will. And another obvious point that I'd like to make before we get started in these passages is that we cannot look at every passage in the Bible where there's a connection to violence and God. There's so many. So what we're going to do today is to look at some of the main passages thereof. as those representative of the others, and we'll do so in three categories. As these categories that I think are ones that generally cover... all the various kinds of violence attributed to God in the Bible. So the three categories. One, violence that seems to be done directly by God. Two, violence done in the name of God.
6:45 Three, violence done commanded by God. Okay? I think in these three categories, we cover up pretty much all the violence in the Bible ascribed to God or attributed to God. And one more time, let me qualify and let be known again that, number one, I am not trying to convince you to believe everything I believe about God. Okay? I'm not trying to do that. Rather, my goal is to just present a challenge for you to think more thoroughly through your faith. So please be sure to do your own research, exercising your own freedom and your own agency. Please. Okay? If I told you I'm the only authority and what I am saying is true, and don't look at anyone else and don't listen to anyone else, Please, I hope this church is empty next week.
7:40 Do not come to Jubilee anymore. Okay? Because that is the way of the cult. That is the way of the bad things. I do the opposite. Look at everything. Read everything. Study for yourself. Check it out. Confirm, affirm. Find contradictions. Do what you need to do, but think thoroughly through your faith. Number two, also, please all know that you can believe in other positions than the ones that I'm presenting, that I've been presenting, the one that I will present today, and still very much be a sincere, Jesus-loving and following Christian. All right? You can. No doubt about that. So if you don't stand with what I believe, that doesn't mean that we're not Christians to each other anymore. All right? Many people think otherwise and still love Jesus, still follow Jesus, etc.
8:31 Good. But still, again, please do your research. To know why you think what you think and why you don't stand with what I might stand with. Because what you believe in God will determine how you live for God. Three, all the more since the perspectives that I have presented and are going to present today, Actually, I'm not here to tell you that they're airtight positions. They are not airtight. They are not perfect arguments. They are not airtight.
9:02 Bless you. Alright? They are not airtight. Otherwise, there will be no point or need for this kind of series. Otherwise, everyone would have already agreed and there would be no question as to the answers might be to this topic. It's not airtight on my side. It's not airtight on anyone's side. Therefore, people are always discussing this stuff, right?
9:26 But I will, though, as I present... what I'm going to present, I will also present what others may say as a refute against what I'm presenting as well. So you get a good view of everything. Alright? But there is one perspective the various ones that I've shared these past weeks that I would stand on to say is irrefutable biblical truth. Irrefutable.
9:54 And this is the cruciform method of biblical interpretation. that this is key to all biblical interpretation to see everything through Jesus on the cross because Jesus is the full revelation of God and the fullest revelation of God was when Jesus died on the cross. That is the ultimate display of the character and the work of God. And therefore using Jesus on the cross as an interpretive lens is the key to understanding everything in the Bible. That I would stand on as the irrefutable truth.
10:31 The cruciform method of biblical interpretation, for again, Jesus on the cross is the fullest revelation of God, not our scholarship, okay? Not our philosophy. And therefore, that is the key. You have a map, you don't use a key, you get lost. You have the Bible, you don't use a key, you get lost. We need the key. The key is the cruciform. This is why then that we've been having the conversations that we've been having. For when you look at all things Christian through the lens of the cruciform, it actually demands us to rethink quite a bit. Everything with the nature of God's judgment to the purpose of the cross, And of course the passages that seem to explicitly connect God to violence. because they seem to so contradict the cruciform. It does. God who was silent before his shears to die on the cross for sinners all of a sudden and then you that's the lens and then you look at God killing all the babies and children or commanding them I mean what's going on here so the cruciform key demands us to rethink quite a lot actually of our theology so again of all things please know that the cruciform method of interpretation is to me and many others, not just me, but many pastors, many scholars, is the main lens of interpretation concerning the Bible.
11:56 And therefore, the main motivation why we've been sharing about this topic over the violence of God for simply stated, the cruciform, the form of the cross, demands us to. If you're serious about this, the cruciform demands us to rethink things. So then here we go. Let's now look at the first category of God and violence. how we are to understand the passages where violence seems to be done directly by God. And in this category, I will highlight the following events. Genesis 6-9, the flood story. And I read the section. The Lord God saw how great the wickedness of the human race had become on the earth, and every inclination of the thoughts of the human heart was only evil all the time. The Lord regretted that he had made human beings on the earth, and his heart was deeply troubled. So the Lord said, I will wipe from the face of the earth the human race I have created. And with them the animals, the birds, and the creatures that move along the ground.
12:54 For I regret that I have made them. But Noah found favor in his eyes, right? The flood. God sent a flood, according to this passage, that killed everybody. Have you ever seen a flood? I think we have, actually, because we have YouTube. It's quite violent. Don't want to be there. When there's a flood. Okay? Genesis 19, 24 to 25. How about the judgment of Sodom and Gomorrah? Then the Lord rained down burning sulfur on Sodom and Gomorrah. From the Lord out of the heavens. Thus he overthrew those cities and the entire plain. Destroying all those who live in the cities and also the vegetation in the land. Incineration.
13:42 It's not violent, that's for sure. Okay? Exodus 7 to 12, the plagues against Egypt. I'm going to read a section.
14:21 And we know ultimately that ended up with firstborn baby dead. Ooh, think about that. Firstborn baby's dead. Exodus 14 to 26 to 28, the drowning in the Red Sea.
15:18 They bit the people and many Israelites died. Okay? Wow, you see? Wow. I mean, if you think through the details of what's going on there, that is not not violent. There's a lot of violence. I mean, it's like the worst top five ways you can die. It's like on right here. Right here. Now, if I didn't make this clear, let me be sure that it is now that when I present these kinds of passages in the three categories that I mentioned, it's not to go through them each exegetically. Meaning, the work of finding meaning is called exegesis. And how do you do exegesis? The point is to find the author's intended meaning. And you do historical study, grammatical study, language study, contextual study, all these studies to find the author's intended meaning. We're not going to do exegetical study for these passages. Too much work, too little time, etc. Right?
16:12 But rather, we're not going to do it exegetically, but rather, again, we're going to look at all of them through the cruciform lens. For this is how I'm proposing that we can reconcile all the passages like the ones that I mentioned, as well as the ones that I will be mentioning in the other two categories. To be able to see the option that God may actually not at all be violent. Not at all be the one who commits violence. Okay? Then for this category of violence that seems to be done by God, what perspective does the cruciform lens give us then to help us to see that God is not violent? That he was not the one acting violently despite the plain reading of the text? Because when you read the text, it's pretty plain. The Lord did it. The Lord God.
16:56 Yahweh. Jesus. Did it. Okay, when you read Read the plain text. That's what it says. Well, for this, I have to refer us back to an aspect of the cruciform method that states that God's judgment is not one that is active, but one that's passive. Remember this? Meaning that God's judgment is not a matter of him actively punishing people for their sin and evil. But that his judgment is one that is passive. Passive in the sense of God giving over to the people the sinful ways that they are asking for. The sinful things that they are asking for, which coincides then with the Lord removing his presence. Removing of his presence to give them what they asked for. To give the people what they're asking for. This is not active judgment, but called passive judgment.
17:50 where in a situation like this as the Lord says you want it then okay I give it to you while removing his presence in a situation like this Satan is then untethered unleashed to untetherly and unleashedly apply the full effects of his evil and his deceptions so in those moments of violence is actually Satan is the one who is active, the one who is violent, which is to his nature, not the Lord God.
18:29 Therefore, though the writers of the Bible wrote what they did the way they did in this plain language ascribing violence to God, and we'll get to a little bit later why they wrote it this way, okay? What actually happened from this perspective was that in those instances, in the perspective of the passive judgment of God, was that in those instances of violence in the passages mentioned, since the type of violence described in those passages are not natural but supernatural, you cannot say that human beings weren't like reinterpreting God and doing something bad. It was literally supernatural lack. So it's literally directly connected to God. So unless you want to believe that all those passages are just some metaphoric expression, which some theologians have, actually they have. But that's not where I stand. For when you read the text, the text is clearly written to be understood not metaphorically, but as a narrative. Not to mention the fact that historically through the church, they were accepted as historic narrative, not as a metaphor.
19:28 Okay? So yes, despite how the writers might have wrote what they did, the way they did it, ascribing violence directly to God. What actually happened... when those passages are viewed through the lens of the passive judgment of God in the cruciform method of interpretation, was that in those instances of violence ascribed to the Lord, in these passages, God was simply giving to the people what they themselves wanted. Which then coincided with him removing his presence, therefore allowing Satan to more fully unleash the effects. of his evil in his deceptions. Where then in this, God is not the violent one. It's Satan doing what he does. Being violent himself. So, with that said, let's briefly re-look at those stories in view of what I just said. Where again, despite what is said in the plain text, what actually was happening in the flood story was simply the natural consequence of sin unleashed.
20:22 Meaning, as much as God tried to talk to these people, the humanity, I'm just kind of interpreting with plain language. They denied the Lord, denied the Lord, they chose sin, they chose sin. Every inclination of their heart, sin. So God said, okay, you want it. Let me give it over to you then, what that means. Gave them over to the full effects of what they loved, but it was deceived because it was sin. And then he removed his presence. And all of a sudden, all hell broke loose. Where Satan, and we know that Satan can control supernatural powers. He's the prince of this world, the Bible says, and attributes that there's supernatural abilities that he has. caused all this damage, breaking open the skies and the ground, and there was a flood. Now, you may be wondering, but God said it's the water.
21:15 Why specifically the water? Like, how did that happen? Isn't God authoring it because he said it was going to be water, and then it was water? Well, this is where theologians would argue that the water is actually a display of God's grace. because God did not fully remove his presence where everything was destroyed. Clearly, Noah and his family was not destroyed. But he removed his presence in such a way to give over to the people the things that they wanted, which is sin, right? Where even the destruction that Satan caused was used as a foreshadowing of God's grace. Where that destruction was used as a foreshadowing of Jesus. Somehow that that destruction would still be used as a sign of something good. So that's how this is we're talking about here. Okay. So we have, let me keep going through this, Sodom and Gomorrah, same with the thing, same with Sodom and Gomorrah. Their hearts were totally to sin. So God said, you want it? You got it. I try to convince you, you still don't want it.
22:28 I'm going to remove my presence Satan comes and does what he does what he always wanted to do untetheredly but it was in such a way where still in God's sovereignty and grace the destruction itself was the type of destruction that could foreshadow something good I'm going to keep going and you'll follow hopefully you'll see it all the more clearly the plagues of Egypt are a great example of this there were 10 plagues in Egypt They would not, God tried to convince, but people said no. The Pharaoh said no. And therefore, this whole tug and push and pull between God convincing and the Pharaoh wanting to stay in the ways of sin is already, we can see the tension there. And if you read through that passage, you hear the hardening, God hardened the heart. Did he?
23:22 Well, yeah, in a sense, if he removes his presence, the heart of a human being will be hardened. But also there's the other place where there's places in that same passage that say Pharaoh hardened his heart. So he wanted that sin. So you have this, you see this interplay, this tension of God's removing presence and it's having its effect. Yet human beings wanting this for themselves.
23:48 Where in the plagues, God, as he removed his presence, he did it in such a way. where even the destruction done by Satan would ultimately be a glory to him as a foreshadowing of things. For instance, we all know that each of the plagues were associated with the various... gods of Egypt, right? If you didn't know, they are. They're representatives of the different gods of Egypt. So look at the gods you serve, they're killing you, is basically the message. The gods you serve, take a look at who they really are. That kind of thing. I'm giving you over to them so you'll see who they really are and they come to destroy. Kill and destroy. Where even the death of the firstborn If you read that passage, it actually, because it's a lengthy passage, so you get a lot of content in there.
24:46 It says, when it was time for the Passover, it was an angel of death that came. It says angel of death, not the Lord. So when you see this, you see that removal, you see all that stuff, and that's what you wanted, so that's what you get. but somehow even in that destruction God allowed that specific destruction to happen to testify of his grace to come which is ultimately about Jesus who himself gave himself as a sacrifice okay so So, I'm going to just finish up with the drowning in the Red Sea and and the judgment in the wilderness same thing with the drowning in the Red Sea at the end of the day they chased the Israelites the Pharaoh and his army thus forcing the hand of the opening of the sea. Or maybe the Lord would have done that for them. even if not because they would have still needed to cross.
25:40 But when Israel crossed, it was their choice. I want to kill them. They chased them. But the Lord said, no, it's time for the grace to be removed or however you want to see it where at the end of the day, it was their choice that covered them in the sea. And then the judgment in the wilderness where the snakes bit them. Same kind of thing. You want to go ahead and go back because in that passage he said, I want to go back to Egypt and the land flowing with milk and honey. Oh yeah. The land flowing. Let me show you what that land flowing on milk and honey is. I remove my grace. You see, you get what you get and you get snakes. Why snakes? Because again, that was the symbol of Egypt, the Pharaoh's head. Remember that? And then all of a sudden the salvation that God offered was put a snake on a stick and hang it up. Everyone who looks at it will be saved. Even using that destruction of Satan as a foreshadowing of the grace to come.
26:35 Ultimately, Jesus on the cross. Okay? And all of this, by the way, is indeed a biblically valid view. For remember, please know that any life that is happening, any life is already grace. For we are already those dead in our trespasses. We are already sinners. we could right now fully be contemned to the full unleashing of Satan's full evil upon us but we're not we still enjoy good food, wear clothes have fun you know, we're able to do it, why? because God's grace is holding it together that's why everything we have, everything good is from the Lord and everything good is by the grace of God where if there wasn't grace, we'd all be dead anyway. So yes, in these instances, God gave the people what they wanted and removed his grace.
27:38 But did so still with grace, to even allow the destructive ways of Satan to be ultimately turned to testify of God, foreshadow the things to come. Okay? Okay, good. Here we go now. We're going to keep going. Keep following along. Now, for the second category of violence done in God's name, And for this, I refer us to passages like the story of Samson in Judges chapter 13 verse 16. I read a portion. Then Samson prayed to the Lord, Sovereign Lord, remember me. Remember Samson? Do you guys know who Samson is? The strong guy, right?
28:19 Strengthen me just once more. Let me, with one blow, get revenge on the Philistines from my two eyes. They burned it out. Not to mention, he forgot he killed a lot of other Philistines. Anyway, then Samson reached towards the two central pillars on which the temple stood, bracing himself against them. His right hand on one and the left hand on the other. Samson said, let me die with the Philistines. Then he pushed with all his might and down came the temple on the rulers and all the people in it. Thus he killed many more when he died than when he lived.
28:48 Samson, in the name of the Lord, killed a whole bunch of people. Elijah, fire from heaven. 2 Kings 1.10. Elijah answered the captain, if I'm a man of God, may fire come down from heaven and consume you and your 50 men. Then fire from heaven fell from heaven and consumed the captain. and his men. Or Elisha, Elisha's successor, calling on the bearers. You guys know this story? 2 Kings 2, verses 23-24.
29:36 What the heck? Did you even know this story was in the Bible? Well, now you do. Wow, you know? So how can we understand violence like this? That though these men acted violently in the name of the Lord, that the Lord was not actively complicit in supporting this type of violence in his name. Well, this can be understood and reconciled when we recognize that along with the provision of gifts, God also provides us with autonomy.
30:08 So just like wealth can be a blessing of God, to be stewarded in a manner pleasing to the Lord, to help redistribute that, to help those in need, it could also be misused in a way not pleasing to the Lord, to be hoarded for selfish pleasures and gains.
30:29 Likewise, can all other provisions of the Lord be misused by God's people? including supernatural gifts? And this because of the autonomy God gives us when he gives us gifts. We see this in the New Testament. They misuse prophecy. They misuse tongues. They misuse all sorts of things. So in this perspective, that's what happened here. It's not God being complicit, but testimony of God's autonomy. Samson, you know, before, he had this great gift, but as I already alluded to, all his life, man, he misused it in any which way he could to violently take revenge on a whim for his own desires. He was a womanizer. I mean, like all of this was just Samson on his own with the gift that the Lord gave him, but him being autonomous with it because the Lord grants this. Elijah, Elijah as well. Somehow they had this kind of supernatural power to manipulate even nature.
31:23 Yet somehow, not somehow, they chose to misuse gifts just like anyone else can misuse any gift that the Lord has given us. Okay, there you go. That was a category of violence done in God's name. So then how about this last category, violence commanded by God. And for this, we'll refer to the following two examples. Deuteronomy 7, 1 through 2. When the Lord, your God, brings you into the land you are entering to possess and drive out before you the many nations, the Hittites, Gershites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites, Jebusites, seven nations larger and stronger than you. And when the Lord, your God, has delivered them over to you, and you have defeated them, then you must destroy them totally. Make no treaty with them. Show them no mercy. Wow. Show them no mercy. The Lord, the Lord merciful.
32:17 Show them no mercy. Hmm. What's going on? 1 Samuel 15, 2-3. This is what the Lord Almighty says. I will punish the Amalekites for what they did to Israel. when they waylaid them as they came up from Egypt. Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy all that belongs to them. Do not spare them. Put to death men and women, children and infants,
32:47 cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys. Think about this. How can we then reconcile that God is not violent in light of passages like this? Because if you allow your imagination to go, think about how this looks. We kind of see it a lot in other religions, other sects, in the name of God, killing people. It's around, right? Like literally violently killing people. Think about this in the name of Jesus. Same thing. In the name of Yahweh, give me that baby. Someone say, I don't think we should kill that baby. No, we should. Give me that baby in the name of Yahweh. Hallelujah. Hallelujah.
33:25 That's what we're reading here, okay? Okay? I mean, I'm not trying to even exaggerate. That's most likely, strong case that's what happened. Okay? How do we reconcile this? Well, herein lies the reasoning that not only helps explain the question that I just posed, but it's also the one that's fundamental to help explain more the other categories as well. For this explanation addresses how divine inspiration is both given and received. for the content thereof to then be considered God's word in the first place. This is the crux of it. How divine revelation is given and then received for that content to be deemed God's word. and then be carried forth that way
34:17 So as I started to do last week, I continue now the challenge for us to consider more deeply how divine inspiration, how divine revelation is both given and received. So let me first start with the question of how divine inspiration is received. And this beyond the general structural names of like, oh, God's revelation is given through visions and dreams and prophetic words. No, no, I'm going deeper. Or in terms of the nitty gritty of how that content, the content in those things is actually received. And the answer is frankly, no one really knows except the person that receives it. no one really knows. That's why it's so dangerous to claim revelation, what God told me. Well, it can never be confirmed. It can never be checked. It's so dangerous, this thing called claiming revelation. And nobody really knows.
35:09 Nevertheless, from the testimonies of those who have actually received true revelation, and there's many examples of this in church history, so I'm not going to go into all of them, but I think it's fair to say that we can surmise that revelation being received by the person involves any number of mediums. So this is what people have testified throughout the history of the church, that when God gives revelation that was confirmed, it was through a feeling or a thought or some premonition, or they got words or they got pictures, some sense colors. I mean, it's limitless actually. It's quite multimedia. God is quite multimedia. If I can just throw my hat in the ring, my own testimony briefly. I mean, I believe that I can't do what I do if I don't receive prophetic word, the Rema, the living word of God. I search for it every week when I preach, that I'm not just teaching you information, that I'm sharing with you what I feel convicted is from the Lord for us that week.
36:10 Whether it be on the pulpit or even when I minister to people, it doesn't happen all the time. Every week, hopefully, there's something that I felt convicted about for the Lord. But when I'm counseling people, I'm definitely searching in my heart, Lord, are you trying to say something? And sometimes I just give them my reasonable thought from experiences. But sometimes I do feel something I have to say. Now, trust me, I never put it, hardly ever, unless the Lord told me, Dave, say that to them that I said to them. Unless the Lord says that, I never say the Lord says, because it's so forceful. Like it's so, could be very manipulative. So I might say something. Hey, I think this. I don't know about that. I'll say it like that. But I felt something. A thought. A feeling. A premonition.
36:52 And guess what? Over the 20 whatever years that I've been doing ministry, people have come back and said, Pastor Dave, remember when you said that? Sometimes I say yes. Sometimes, a lot of times, I say no. Because I don't remember. They're like, well, this, this, this. And then there is confirmation that that was actual revelation. I had a dream one time. I've actually seen visions and heard and all that. I had a dream one time. Prophetic. Proved. I don't want to get into the details. But two years after I had this dream and I said it, it happened pretty much exactly the way I said it. And when I got this dream, like, how was it? It was weird. It wasn't like, like transcription and like I see it. No, it was like this morphing of sounds and feelings and little blurry visions. But it was clear enough for me to know what that was about. And then I went, spoke it, and then two years later, confirmed.
37:52 Yes. But one thing we can say for sure. So Revelation received is very subjective. But one thing we can say for sure, because it is subjective, is that it's always going to be personal to the person. Meaning that the various characteristics of the person involved matters. Therefore, that's why we can distinguish the different writings of the Bible. If you gave a scholar the Bible without any markings and they start reading it, they'll be able to tell you, oh, this is from this period. This is from this, probably this author, this author, because they have a different voice. It's not, again, like God in his voice, write this. Then it would all sound the same. Then we'd be like, this is God's voice because clearly he gave revelation and we have proof of it and all the other revelations given, he writes like, but it's not like that. It's very different. Every letter, every book in the Bible is so very different. Even within certain books, there's different styles and they're like, ooh, are there multiple authors?
38:49 I mean, if you want to go down into that rabbit hole. Yeah. And the knowledge of the people who wrote it, that was a factor in it. It's very personal. Their job, if you were a fisherman, you wrote a different way than a scholar, than a king, than a soldier. Your language ability, how you write this one thing in Korean to English is very different, right? How you wrote in Aramaic or Hebrew or Greek. Your language ability, some of us get 800s on our SATs for English and some of us not 800, you know what I mean? Do you guys remember? Whatever. Some of us are better at language and some of us are not.
39:27 That, you know, and then some of us know a lot about some of them knew a lot about the Bible, and some knew less. And then some are more pragmatic. They're more doers, and some are more thinkers. All that factored in. Certainly one's culture affected it. When a Hebrew person wrote it, versus a Gentile person, versus like, as I mentioned last week, why did Moses write the way he did? A lot of it was because he was Egyptian. The dude was Egyptian.
39:56 You see those Egyptian colors. Styles of writing. in the writing itself. And we also have to consider the fact that everything in the Bible was written actually after the fact. Again, it wasn't written like, oh, live the news, the Lord is doing this, and I'm writing. It wasn't like that. Revelation was given, things have happened in months, years maybe after it was written down. Therefore, it is implausible that there could have been the effects of the limitations of memory. Hmm, what was that again? Or even the benefits of hindsight. Oh yeah, that's what it was. the advantage of being able to then, oh, sit and think and write it in a way, in a format that's culturally appropriate and more palatable to the people of that time. Not to mention, these guys were not perfect, these prophets and priests.
40:48 Do we not know this? David, the great psalmist, was an adulterer and a murderer. All these prophets have super character flaws, super duper many, many character flaws, just like you and me. However, I would say that the Bible was transcribed well. It's the best transcribed piece of ancient literature in the world by far. Meaning, the copies of it were exact. That's huge. Meaning that it wasn't copied and then added on and then embellished and changed. And then where one copy from one period and another copy from another are vastly different. That's not what we have in the Bible. Thankfully, we know that the copies that we have are very accurate to each other. There's error, but not where we don't know what they're saying. Okay, what it's saying. So this is how Revelation is received. Again, it's subjective.
41:42 So then we have the next question of how Revelation is given. So how does God give? revelation? Well, believe it or not, this aspect is actually much more objective than how revelation is received. For in short, we have the model of the ultimate revelation. We have Jesus. And in such, we can know that when God gives revelation, he gives revelation incarnationally. Incarnationally. Meaning, when God communicates to us, he does so where we're at. Matching our contexts, our languages, our limitations, so that we may be able to have the best chance to understand what he's saying. And certainly, Jesus' life reflected this in every way, starting from his very flesh. He was born into our flesh. and then the life he lived as a child to under parents, vocation, learning language and eating food and et cetera. And then of course how he taught.
42:36 He brought cosmic teaching to say, you know this seed, kingdom revelation to, hey, fish your net. Incarnation. Incarnational Revelation. Now there's a theological word for this dynamic and it's called Divine Accommodation. Another theological term, Divine Accommodation. That is the idea that along with the reality of how our many limitations are part of how revelation is received by us. that when God gives revelation, he does so adjusting his communication to best fit our limitations, our capacities, abilities, et cetera, et cetera. That's why, like we hear in 1 Corinthians 9, 20 to 22, this is the Apostle Paul even saying,
43:52 this is the heart of the Lord this is how revelation is given but please note that despite all the Lord's incarnational and accommodating ways to us due to our limitations you know we still make errors in how revelation is received you know we still make errors misinterpret the revelation given to us as accommodating the Lord is. And Jesus is the prime example. He was living revelation. Yet many people misunderstood and misinterpreted Jesus. Even though revelation was given to them in a way they could receive, revelation was twisted up, understood wrongly,
44:35 testified of it inaccurately. And I mention this because this reality, and I mention this because does this reality not then give us the room to wonder if it could have been possible that what was written in the Bible by those who wrote the Bible, especially the parts where violence is ascribed to God and like the passages mentioned, you know. But by the way, progressive revelation is in here as well. So if you remember that, keep that as an undercurrent as well. That when Revelation was given, that they were written the way that they wrote it, due to this great interplay between the holy and the unholy. The combination of God's accommodation to speak in the ways of the people that they would understand, but those words then to be refiltered. Those promptings, premonitions to be refiltered through all the limitations. mentioned prior of the person receiving it.
45:33 And again, they're imperfect. For now, to have what we have. Where, because of the human part, there is some, here we go, inaccuracies. not in the author's intended meaning, but in God's intended meaning. here in the Bible. God might not have intended it that way, but they took it, refiltered it in their limitation, and now, brought it the way we have it in the Bible.
46:10 Hmm. For otherwise, the only other option is, if there was no mistake or inaccuracy in that way, then there's no other option. That God commanded all that violence. Yahweh, hallelujah, kill the baby. And then the cross. And then you're like, huh? Huh? Like, what do I do with this?
46:30 But again, the Bible is not the full revelation of God, actually. It's Christ, and Christ crucified. You know, the Jewish people, they had the Bible. They loved the Bible. But when Jesus came, they said, Jesus is the full revelation of God, not the Old Testament. Can you believe that? That's craziness. You think, some of us may be thinking, is this craziness? This craziness is nothing like the craziness of what the Jewish person might have felt. when they said Jesus is the full revelation not the Old Testament scripture. In fact, he's bringing in a new covenant. Making the old covenant obsolete? What? Like, yeah. So what shall we do about this? Ah, shoot. I gotta get through this, so please. I can't leave you here. You want to just end now? We could, just for the sake of time. No, we can't end here. Can we end here?
47:24 Nah, let's not end here. Let's not end here. Let's just go through, okay? All right, here we go. So what shall we do about this? Well, this is where I appeal to more than just theological reasoning. As reasonable as the arguments that I've made, it's reasonable. For real. If you're open-minded and you want to be reasonable, what I'm saying is reasonable. No doubt about that. All right? But I'm saying this not just from reason, but actually from biblical support. And thus I now refer us to our passage, Revelation 1, 17-18. Now needless to say, in the book of Revelation, in this chapter, there's a lot going on. But for us today, in short, I reference this passage for us because it's a prime example of what I've been talking about. The fact that how divine revelation given and received, that it is messy. that it is not a clean and perfect process. And frankly, how could it be otherwise when again, the unholy is trying to receive the holy, when the imperfect is trying to house the perfection of God.
48:23 And if you look here in our passage, you'll see this point clearly. For remember who John is. He was the beloved disciple. He was in the inner three. He knew he was loved by Jesus so much, he called himself the beloved unabashedly. He's the one who later became the father of the church, the elder of the church. So mature. From the son of thunder rained down fire from heaven on these unbelievers like Elijah, Lord, we do this. To now the apostle of love in his latter years. Writing the gospel of John. Of all the disciples, maybe arguably the one who knew Jesus best because he probably lived the longest.
49:05 Yet when this beloved one was given divine revelation, look what happened. If you read the rest of the passage, he's like searching for words. He doesn't, it's like this. It's like this. It was like this. And then he didn't even recognize Jesus. He turned around and saw, he's like, this is the one I knew a lot. But he didn't even know it was Jesus. In fact, he fell down as if dead.
49:29 And later, if you read in Revelation chapter 22, he actually starts worshipping angels. He's thinking it's Jesus. The angel, Revelation of this angel was so grand, he thought it was Jesus, started worshipping. The angel's like, get off fool. He didn't say fool. He said, probably though. He said, yo. No, he didn't say yo. Anyway, he said, I'm from Philadelphia. It's hard. He said, get up. I'm just a messenger like you. Don't worship me. It literally says that, Revelation 22.9. So you see, indeed, when the imperfect tries to house the perfect, when the unholy tries to receive the holy, it is a messy process. It is a messy process. Where on the giving side of Revelation, the images and the languages that the Lord uses to communicate with John, it was surely accommodating to John. Because for us, when we hear the words of Revelation, in the book of Revelation, you're like, what is this mumbo jumbo? But not for John. For John and the people of his day, it was much more understandable.
50:25 for the imagery and the language used in the revelations given to John. were those that he was already actually familiar with. Because they're drawn from the Old Testament. It's the language of the Old Testament. But of course, recast in view of Jesus' death and resurrection. So it was still new. It wasn't the same, but it was still familiar. God was accommodating. to somehow bring differential equations to algebra or to addition and subtraction. You know, trying to see. So in this passage, we're able to witness divine accommodation in action and in such. We can praise the Lord all the more for we are also able to see then the centerpiece of what makes God so awesome and worthy. We're able to see that. The centerpiece of what makes God so awesome and worthy. The truth that our God is a God who is not scared or intimidated by imperfections, that he is not one who shuns and shames limitations, but rather he's the one who's truly awesome and worthy, for he's the one who's able to work out his perfection, but through imperfections and limitations.
51:29 Hallelujah. This is the awesomeness of God, that he's the one, we can see it here, the one able to work out his perfection, but through imperfections. Despite imperfections, through imperfections, despite limitations and through limitations, hallelujah. And therefore, that's why you can still very much believe in the Bible to be fully the word of God as I do. Meaning that you believe that it's the only piece of writing in the world that can be considered the holy scriptures of God most high. Therefore, the only source and authority for the people of God to know who God is more and to become more and more the people of God. But, but, without having to fully accept or believe in theological concepts like inerrancy, that the Bible is without any error in its original writings, where all its content is accurate in all it affirms, as well as without having to ascribe to a theological concept of infallibility, yet the Bible cannot and does not fail to communicate the truth of what God intends.
52:30 For these concepts were actually modern, if you look at it, it's modern day theological concepts developed in response to the Enlightenment and all that stuff. Simply to protect and uphold the notion that God does not make mistakes and that his word is perfect. And we want to think that. It's nice. But the truth is, our capacities to receive the revelation of God and to communicate properly God's intended truth, despite God's accommodating ways, are exposed to be limited. Again, proved by Jesus that even clear revelation came, still misinterpreted. Still misinterpreted.
53:10 Pharisees, the disciples, still misinterpreted. Even after Jesus' resurrection, still they weren't sure. Still, many times, still misinterpreted because of their limitations. And in our passage, we see that happening again. For again, this what happens when the imperfect meets the perfect. When the unholy tries to receive the holy, things get messy.
53:37 Therefore, my brothers and sisters, we can read the passages that ascribe violence to God, but still be justified to believe that God is actually not violent. And this is because of the concept of divine accommodation. Because of how God incarnationally communicated with his people, who then also due to their limitations, could have easily jumbled some things up. For this is again the reality of what happens when the imperfect meets the perfect. When the unholy meets the holy. However, we can still trust that the Bible is the word of the Lord and not question His authority because, for remember, there's also the reality that in God's perfection He works out His perfection still despite through many of our imperfections. Therefore, we don't need to hang on to the constructs of perfection. our constructs of perfection, to honor the Lord, or try to protect our fear of being invalidated, that God's word is worthless, or we now have not as strong of a sense of knowing and control.
54:45 For again, God's perfection is that he's able to work out the fullness of his plan, despite our many imperfections. Therefore, as Swiss Catholic theologian Hans Urs von Balthasar stated, I love what he said, the Bible itself is a literary crucifix. Meaning, the Bible itself is a display of the tension of the perfect with the imperfect, as well as the display of God's glory to be able to still work out his perfection through imperfection. For the scriptures bear within itself all the marks of human limitations, brokenness, and even contradictions. Just like Jesus bore on the cross our weakness and suffering. Yet at the same time was a full display of God's truth and glory. Amen. Okay? So let me share with us now briefly some of the main arguments against this position of divine accommodation and its related positions. One, this position, divine accommodation, weakens biblical authority.
55:47 Well, in that construct of it being sure without error, yes, maybe, yeah, possible. Okay? Two, divine accommodation creates a canon within a canon. Meaning, because there are some passages more like Jesus, certain passages less like Jesus, then there are certain passages that are more important and other passages that are less important.
56:09 Divine accommodation people will be like, the closer to the cross it looks like, the more accurate revelation was recorded. The less it was close to the cross, the less accurately it was recorded. Yeah, so in a sense, yeah, okay, fine. Yeah, possible. Some portions more that we can read plainly and some portions that we have to maybe study more to read and understand. Another argument is that it's an inconsistent exegetical method. That if you're trying to be consistent, you're always trying to find the author's intended meaning. And in those passages of violence, the author clearly intended it for it to be, God said, do that violence. Inconsistent. In other places, you're trying to find the author's intended meaning.
56:50 Well, I mean, the argument is, yeah, technically, maybe that's true. So we have to sit with that. Okay? But again, the cruciform for me is the answer. But anyhow, you got to sit with that. And number four, it jeopardizes theological coherence. Does this mean that God misleads us? What does this say about the character of God? So anyway, I say all this because, as I mentioned before, I'm not presenting an airtight case. I told you it was going to be a little bit blurry, a little bit messy, all right? And their arguments, to be honest with you, are not airtight either. Or the other people are not there. But people who think otherwise, they're not airtight either. Otherwise, there would be no point for this whole series. So please, again, study for yourself and check it out. But nevertheless, if seen through the cruciform method of interpretation and its related concepts, passive judgment, progressive revelation, and now divine accommodation, then not only will we be challenged to try to figure out why God seems so violent sometimes?
57:54 We will also have justifiable room to understand why this might be so. Not to mention also, please remember in this process the reality of the divine mysteriousness of the Bible itself as well. Meaning, that I believe that it's something that we won't be able to fully understand anyway. We weren't living there in every context, in every person's heart. We would never be able to fully figure this out. Or in other words, we have to see that trusting the the Bible is God's word demands not inerrancy or infallibility, but just like anything else in Christianity, trusting the Bible that it's God's word, it ultimately demands us to have faith, not facts. not perfect arguments. For the purpose of the Bible is not necessarily to display divine authority, but rather to share the testimony of how God, how the perfection of God interacted with the imperfection of humanity.
58:49 to bring forth his perfection from that imperfection. And this in the context of his content reflects it, as well as his history. There were mistakes in how it was transcribed. It wasn't perfect. And there were people trying to kill this Bible off. All sorts of things. But, and so in a sense, you see this tension in the Bible and its content and how it survived throughout history. It literally is a literary crucifix. For like, Jesus is the victor. in that tension of sin and holiness. The Bible has, as much as it might be full of errors, we still have it today the way it was thousands of years ago somehow. That's true. Okay, I'm going to start wrapping up. I needed to get through that because I didn't know if you were going to come next week.
59:43 Who knows, since you were here, it would have been unfair not to finish. I'm really wrapping up here. One last point before I wrap up. And it's one instance in the New Testament where Jesus seems to have been himself violent. In the temple cleansing. Turning over tables, whipping things and whatnot. And this situation cannot be explained through progressive revelation or divine accommodation. that passage is simply a descriptive narrative that happened and all four gospel accounts is there. And we know it happened twice in Jesus' life, at least. So how do we understand this? Well, simple. First of all, we can't project. We can't imagine our imagination. We use it to think, wow, Jesus went butt crazy. Woo, look at him go wild. Kind of like maybe how you and I would go wild when we're angry. And this is because we shouldn't do this because the text actually does not mention anything of anger or violence towards any persons. if you read it, all the accounts.
1:00:40 And the whips were actually not for people like, you fool, take a lash before I have to take it for you. No, it was for the animals to drive out the cattle, right? And we also know that Jesus was clearly against any violence in other other situations. James and John wanted to bring fire from heaven. He says, no, that's not the way the kingdom of God works. Peter at Gethsemane, cutting off the ear of the serpent, that's not the way the kingdom of God works. Then he turns to the guards and said, I could bring, what did he say? More than 12 legions of angels to battle, but that's not the way the kingdom of God works. So we know that Jesus was anti-violence. And then of course we have the testimony of the cross itself. So you put all that together, I would say, no, we should not read that into that passage, violence, that Jesus was not violent himself. I think it's like, I would say like kind of like maybe a parent, if you're going to associate discipline from teaching from violence, sometimes our kids are acting out, you teach them, but not with violence. It might be firmer or stronger, but it's not violent.
1:01:53 That kind of thing. Okay. So then, through all this, if there's one takeaway, I pray that it is this. And again, it's not trying to convince you to believe everything I believe about God and the Bible. Again, this series is just to challenge you to think through this most important of topics for yourself. Especially the violence of God, because what you think of God will determine how you live for God.
1:02:19 And all the more, again, in light of today's world. So for us today, I pray that along with this challenge is also the encouraging reminder that what's central to God's perfection is that he works out, he works in our imperfection to bring forth his perfection. Now, as you know, my position is that this is displayed in the Bible itself. But even if you don't see this or you still need time to work everything through, share today and in this series, which I'm sure you need more time to think it through, surely, please, I highly encourage you to do so. But for today, I'm confident to say that this is a truth made most clear on the cross. If you're again looking at the cruciform, that indeed what's central to God's perfection is that he works in our imperfection to bring forth his perfection. This is what makes God so awesome.
1:03:10 He don't need error-free things to bring about his holiness. and I hope and also trust that this is something that you yourself can testify to that you are a living example of this to therefore be able to join the Apostle Paul in his confession in 2 Corinthians 12 9 that says my grace is sufficient for you for my power is made perfect in weakness therefore as the Apostle Paul says I will boast all the more gladly about my weaknesses. so that Christ's power may rest on me Amen that we are jars of clay, imperfect, cracked, yet we still hold treasures in these jars. Like, what a craziness. And this is the glory of God. The perfect from the imperfect. Can we get the title up?
1:04:01 Yeah. The perfect from the imperfect. Hallelujah. This is the takeaway. All the details, think it through. It's good for you. We should. We must. Okay? okay Okay. Technically speaking, it wasn't any longer than any other message, so I hope you're used to it by now. Okay, let's go ahead and respond to the Lord. Okay, we have our high school students are ready for the fundraiser. We're getting ready to wrap up, but let's not rush through this time of response. Let's take this opportunity to go before the Lord right now. Before I pray, I want to give you an opportunity to pray. Bow your hearts, my brothers and sisters, your minds, maybe even your bodies. and let's take it before the Lord. Do you see him as a violent God? Do you see him as a... If you do, that means in righteousness, if your righteous motivation is there, violence is an option.
1:04:55 I mean, that's what it is. Do you see that the Lord said, kill the babies? Show no mercy. Or is there something else going on? You may not fully accept or understand the options that I shared, But I pray that we can hang on this one point. That God is clearly the one who works His perfection through imperfection, despite imperfection. And from there, let's pray and worship the Lord. I know that this is true in your life. I contest it's true in the Bible even.
1:05:32 But we can clearly see it on the cross. So let's celebrate together. Let's worship together. Let's pray. pray. Thank you. Jesus, we thank you. I know that there's a lot of stuff that we talked about these past three weeks, probably too much for a message, I don't know. But nevertheless, Lord, I pray that we all sense that this is a worthy venture to explore this sense of righteous indignation that leads to even violence.
1:06:35 because this is going to determine so much of how we think and live our lives. But Lord, I pray that, I want to say thank you for giving us alternative ways to see, not to rotely believe, but to be challenged to really consider this. But Jesus, I pray that you bless all of us to know and see everything through you, especially you on the cross. And in that place, we can always be anchored. we can be anchored without doubt for you are the full revelation of the Father and what you did on the cross was not some philosophy and in the cross we see that indeed this is how you work you work to bring forth perfection from imperfection
1:07:26 And I pray that this will burn in our hearts. to help us worship you more and even treat each other with the love that you've called us to treat each other with, that this will inform the whole of our life as followers of Christ. Thank you so much for this time, and in Jesus' name we pray.
Machine translated from the source