Justin Adour · Redeemer East Harlem · Published March 17, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
Berean Standard Bible.
Berean Standard Bible.
3:27 the word of the Lord. Thanks be to God. So my wife and I, we talk about this all the time, but there is this cognitive bias that is known as the Dunning-Kruger effect. It's actually a category that she gave me years ago, but if you're unfamiliar with this effect, it's a bias where people with limited knowledge or competence in a subject greatly overestimate their own knowledge or skill in that subject. It's functionally a confident ignorance, and it's always fascinating. I will say, and my wife can attest to this being true, I've certainly been that person. I think we probably all have at some point, but I've also been on the receiving end of it over the years so many times in ministry and especially in some of my academic work. When I have labored to understand a concept, or I've read 50 books on a topic, it's always fascinating to have a conversation with someone who read a Reddit thread or a Facebook post or a blog post, listened to some pundit on a podcast, who then want to argue with you about that particular topic. We've all experienced at some level either as the giver of such ignorance or the receiver of ignorance, and it's always fascinating. This passage that we just heard read is actually a remarkable example of the Dunning-Kruger effect. It's a famous story of Peter confidently claiming that he would never deny Jesus, but as we're going to see, Peter spoke confidently about something he did not understand. There was a grave ignorance that he had to his own heart. He had yet to understand what it truly meant to follow Jesus. Peter assumed that following Jesus would require confidence, when in reality, what is required to follow Jesus is an experience of grace.
5:29 Now today we're going to be continuing our look at the book of Mark, the gospel of Mark, focusing on this passion narrative, which are the events leading up to Jesus's crucifixion. And today we see a story of grace that not only radically transformed Peter, but if we have ears to hear, is also a story of grace that will transform us as well. And so to see this story of grace, let's consider three things. Let's consider a betrayal, a grace, and a new confidence. A betrayal, a grace, and a new confidence. First betrayal, we need to start where Mark starts us. Peter has this confident ignorance. Look again at verse 29. It says this, that Peter declared, even if all fall away, I will not. Pause there.
6:22 In other words, Peter is saying, all these guys that are around us, they may be weak, they may be unfaithful, but me? Never. In other words, he's looking down on all those that are around him, and he puffs himself up. That's the confidence that we see here. But then in verse 30, it goes on to say, Truly I tell you, Jesus answered, Today, yes, tonight, before the rooster crows twice, you yourself will disown me three times. But Peter insisted emphatically, Even if I have to die with you, I will never disown you. And because we know the end of the story, we see that that's the ignorance. Peter, you don't know what you're talking about, Jesus is saying. You're so confident, and yet you're speaking out of ignorance. It's fascinating to see this in Peter, because there's this remarkable amount of pride and self-assurance here.
7:20 This is a little bit of a side note, but much of Mark's gospel centers on Peter, which we'll talk about more in a minute. But Peter is rarely described in the narrative, rarely described positively. As we've seen throughout our study of Mark, Peter is constantly being corrected and rebuked. And it is worth pointing out. It's easy for us to look at someone like Peter, or any biblical character for that matter, it's easy to look at their failures and puff ourselves up while looking at their failures. And we don't even just do that with biblical characters, we do that with people all around us all the time. And we're really good as people. We are really good at noticing people who are far more of a mess than we are. And we use their failures as a way of making ourselves feel better. It's not something we need to be taught.
8:12 We're all just naturally really good at doing it. And so it's easy to look at Peter and say, I would never be like Peter. I would never act that way. I would never be so bold or so ignorant or so lazy or whatever. It's so easy to look at these characters and say, I would never be like that. But you know, it's at least worth highlighting the irony of that kind of posture. I mean, this whole narrative is highlighting Peter's confidence that he is better than everyone else. It highlights Peter's confidence in himself. And this is not the main point of where we're going. But if we similarly look down on others who we believe are far more of a mess than we are, and we think, I would never be such a failure, That very posture often proves we fundamentally have the same heart as Peter does here. It is often a confident ignorance that doesn't take seriously what every single one of us are capable of.
9:13 Now, all of that said, how do we know that for Peter, his confidence in himself was ultimately an ignorant confidence? Well, it's because of what we know happens next. Jesus knew what was about to happen. After making this huge and frankly arrogant claim that he would never deny Jesus, after Jesus is arrested, Peter, on three different occasions, goes on to deny even knowing Jesus. It even says that he called down curses. And that doesn't mean that he's dropping F-bombs or something like that. Instead, what that's describing is Peter saying, may God curse me if I am lying about knowing Jesus. He's invoking the name of God into this swearing that he doesn't know who Jesus is. But of course we know, despite all of this denial, this is what Jesus knew was going to happen.
10:07 Peter had been confident, but Jesus knew this was going to happen. Peter only understood that his successes were going to be rooted in his ability to be fervent, and yet when push comes shove, here you have his ignorance coming out. He was not fully aware of his full capacity to fail. And that is why in the very next verses, verse 72, it goes on to say this, The confident Peter did not think he could fail, and yet here he is failing. And in that failure, I don't know about you, but for me, I really feel that last sentence, that he broke down and wept. When the rooster crows and Peter realized what he had done, he broke down and wept.
11:04 You know, betrayal, it's an interesting thing. I don't think I'm overstating that betrayal, especially from those that we're close with, might be one of the most disruptive, disorienting, heartbreaking experiences that we can have as humans. It's got to be toward the top. When we are betrayed, it can be so violating, so demoralizing. And we understand the impact that it can have on the one who is betrayed. It's devastating. But it's also the case that many times that betrayal can absolutely undo the betrayer as well. The guilt and shame that can wash over the betrayer can sometimes be too much to bear. What have I done? I mean, we see this later in the story with Judas, who's so overcome by the shame of betraying Jesus that he takes his own life. Now, Peter here doesn't take his own life, but the shame immediately overwhelms him, and he completely breaks down as a result. And so I have to imagine, again, a little bit of a side But I have to imagine that for many of us, maybe you're the one who has been betrayed and you know the devastation of that.
12:20 Or maybe some of us, we have been the betrayer and have experienced deep sadness, deep shame. There are likely a host of other emotions that come. We recognize that betrayal can often present to us more than we can bear. And that's the story of where Peter is by this point in the story. But the story doesn't just speak to the betrayal. Because not only is this one of betrayal, but it's also a story of grace if we look at it carefully. Let's look at that secondly. So to begin, we need to highlight the nature of what Mark is doing in his narrative, in the Gospel of Mark. Mark famously tends to sandwich stories together. He will start with one train of thought. He will then pause that train of thought, say something else, and then return back to his original train of thought.
13:17 It's called a Markean sandwich. And we have seen this happen over and over again all throughout the narrative of Mark. And the reason he does that is that the meat of the sandwich, the middle of the story, emphasizes the aspects of the story that he had previously started. It's a way of interpreting one story with the use of another story. He does it all the time. And we see it here. And I had to break up the chapter a bit so that we can see what he's doing. It captures it a little bit. In the first part of the story, we start with Peter's confident proclamation. And then at the end of the chapter, we see Peter's betrayal. But then sandwiched in between those two parts of the story, the meat of the sandwich is Jesus's arrest. And that's intentional because Mark is going to use the story of the arrest of Jesus to interpret the story of Peter. So what is Mark showing us? Well, starting in verse 43, we're told here that Judas comes, it says, with a, quote, crowd armed with swords and clubs sent from the chief priests.
14:27 He goes on to say that they have come to arrest Jesus and lead him away under guard. But then in verse 46, it says that the men seized Jesus and arrested him. Then one of those standing near drew his sword and struck the servant of the high priest, cutting off his ear. Here's what should stand out to us. Who is this quote, one who was standing near, who cut off the ear? You know, it seems like Mark is trying to keep that person's identity secret. But in the Gospel of John, John tells the same story in John 18. And in John 18, this is what John says about the same event. John says, then Simon Peter, who had a sword, drew it and struck the high priest's servant, cutting off his right ear. And then John goes on to say that the servant's name was Malchus.
15:25 So Peter cut off the ear of the high priest's servant, Malchus. Why? Why does Peter become violent in this moment? Well, remember what Peter had just confidently said. He had said to Jesus, I'm on your side. You are the Messiah, and I will fight these men now to prove my fidelity to you. This is functionally what's happening in his violence. And so when they come to arrest Jesus, Peter attacks, thinking that that's what he is supposed to do. And we've said this so many times at this point, but Peter is still convinced that Jesus is going to be some kind of liberator, some political liberator. And Peter is ready to use violence to advance God's kingdom into the world. But if you know the story, and again, we've seen this over and over again, that Jesus must then confront Peter's assumptions about what the Messiah had come to do.
16:24 And what we see in both Luke's narrative of these events, and John as well is that after this attack, after Peter cuts off the ear of Malchus, Jesus, before being taken away, turns to this servant, this high priest's servant, and he heals him. What is that? Why does Jesus heal this servant? Well, at minimum, it should be clear that Jesus is rejecting Peter's assumptions. once again. He's again rejecting Peter's tactics, assuming that violence was going to, in some way, usher in all that Jesus had come to accomplish. Peter still does not know Jesus and still assumes that Jesus, as Messiah, means some kind of political revolution or violent resistance for the sake of the kingdom. And so Jesus heals as a way of rebuking that assumption. Violence is not the way of the kingdom. Which, by the way, this is a super side note, but as long as the text is bringing it up for us, this assumption is still, has not died. It is still very much a strong assumption, and it is in particular a strong assumption in pockets of American Christianity.
17:42 Right now, we're living it. There are those right now still arguing that the war that has just started in the Middle East is the way in which God is ushering in the end times. I mean, some right now are arguing that God is using the U.S. to usher in the fullness of God's kingdom right now. Friends, just so that we're clear, there is no other word for that kind of view than heresy. We cannot advance or build or usher in the kingdom of God or the return of Jesus. And military violence that is tied to our own national interests is not the way of the kingdom of God. And if you and I maybe don't know what I'm talking about right now, I'm happy for you, but if you know what I'm talking about, we must reject the heresy being espoused right now.
18:41 It is the same assumption Peter had all these years ago. Now that said, there is a greater insight in this arrest and in this healing than simply rejecting the way of violence. There's another insight that colors the image that's being presented to us here, specifically in the way that Jesus sows compassion to this hurting man, Malchus. Let me show you what I mean. And it's kind of wild, but earlier this week, my wife, not knowing that this was the passage that we'd be coming to today, sent me a thread by a scholar reflecting on this story. And it's a pretty remarkable unpacking of what this scholar was attempting to show. He's emphasizing how this healing was more than Jesus' compassion, and it was even more than Jesus reflecting Peter's use of violence. Instead, it was a remarkable picture of God's grace.
19:41 There's another layer that we need to highlight, and it's in who Malchus was. Because Malchus was not just a random guard. He was a servant of the high priest, we're told. Which means that he was directly connected to the priestly household. And what the scholar was drawing out is that the priestly laws of the Old Testament, particularly in Leviticus 21, shows us that those who served in the priesthood must be those without bodily defect. That is, if someone wanted to continue serving in the priestly household, if they had suffered a physical ailment, they could not serve any longer. It rendered them ceremonially unfit to serve in the temple, which makes this healing even more striking. Before Jesus goes to the cross, this is the last miracle that Jesus is going to perform.
20:42 His final miracle before his death, Jesus restores the one who came to arrest him. And in doing so, to push it even further, Jesus ensures that this man is able to continue serving. in the household of the one who just ordered his arrest. His last miracle before the cross is not for one of his disciples. It's not for a crowd. It's for his enemy. He desires even for his enemy to be made whole. And the reason this matters and the reason why I'm highlighting it. is that this is a powerful picture of the grace of Jesus.
21:24 It is a grace that does not merely extend to his friends, but reaches out even to his enemies. And here's why this matters. Getting back to Peter. Peter had not yet experienced that kind of grace. Peter still lived in a self-delusion of self-righteousness, self-assurance, self-confidence, and ignorant confidence. He still functionally believed that he was worthy of God's favor or that he needed to earn it through confident pronouncements and zealous ambition. But over and over again, Jesus says, that is not the way of my kingdom. Peter did not yet know the grace of Jesus and therefore did not know Jesus. You know who did at this point, though? Malchus. Malchus knew Jesus because Malchus had just experienced an amazing grace.
22:22 Jesus' enemy knew Jesus better than Jesus' disciple knew Jesus. And here is why we need to return now to Peter's story. I said the way that Mark works is this story of the arrest is going to paint the picture of something broader that Mark is showing us. Back to the betrayal. Peter did not yet realize the extent to which he needed that kind of grace. until he absolutely came to the end of himself after the betrayal. All this striving, all this confidence, all this assurance completely fell apart the day he betrayed Jesus. And in that moment, he was undone. Why? Well, Peter had consistently, I mean, again, if you've been with us in this series, as we've looked at this narrative, Peter had been consistently dismissive of those to whom Jesus showed grace. Peter was constantly annoyed by how Jesus loved the tax collectors and the sinful woman and the Samaritans and children and now this servant of the high priest. None of them deserve the love and compassion of Jesus and yet they all received undeserved grace.
23:36 But now Peter, for the first time, realized he also needed that same grace that Jesus had shown Malchus. Peter was now at the end of himself with no great pronouncements, but only a realization of his brokenness and need for grace. And friends, that is the recognition we all need if we're going to be transformed by God's grace. We all need to come to the end of ourselves, realizing we have nothing that deserves God's grace. And so my question for us is how self-oriented are we before Jesus? Do we know Jesus because we have come to the end of ourselves knowing that we need grace? Or do we look at what we do or what we say or our religious zeal? Until we recognize that we can offer nothing and that we have nothing, until we recognize that we can't actually experience the compassionate grace of Jesus.
24:46 And as a result, if we haven't experienced that grace, we have yet to know Jesus. And you know, this is maybe, again, another little side note. I keep giving little side notes, it is also true. It is true that on the one hand we can certainly not know Jesus as a result of our pride-filled, self-oriented assumptions. But we can also be pride-filled and self-oriented, not in just our self-righteousness. We can also be self-oriented in our self-loathing as well. There is a self-flagellation that can serve the same purpose as self-righteousness. For some, we assume that constantly beating up ourselves is some sign of humility before God, when it isn't always. Instead of saying, look how good I am, we can say, oh, look how terrible I am.
25:43 And they're both rooted in the same reality. One attempts to get God's attention by showing how impressive we are. Another tries to get God's attention by showing how miserable we are. But friends, grace frees us from both. Because grace demands we stop looking at ourselves and instead start looking upon Jesus. And Peter, after his betrayal, finally begins to realize this. I mentioned this a bit ago, but Peter, again, features prominently in Mark's narrative, more than the other Matthew, Luke, or John. And of course, the question would be why. Why does Peter feature more prominently here in Mark? And in particular, what we see in Mark, more than the other Gospels, is Peter's failures are most prominent in Mark's Gospel. Why is that? Is it just because Mark wants to be mean to Peter and so he's highlighting his failure? Well, no. We know that from church history, that Mark was Peter's interpreter and scribe.
26:53 We know that Mark records different events where only Peter was present, and no one else would have known it except Peter. And the only way that Mark knew was if Peter had told him. In other words, the book of Mark is primarily the account of Jesus recorded by Mark, but told by Peter. Peter wants you to know about his failures and his betrayal. Why? Because he is a man that has been transformed. He has been transformed by grace, who at the time of this writing wants everyone to know about this grace. A self-righteous man trying to earn favor with God and others will keep his righteousness forefronted and his failures hidden. But a grace-saturated man keeps the undeserved grace of God in Christ forefront and forsakes all else. Peter has been liberated from his self-righteousness. He's been liberated from all the attempts that he's had at trying to earn God's favor, and now he is happy to put on display his failure. Because in that failure, God's grace is all the more highlighted. He's been liberated. And I wonder if some of us also need to be liberated as well.
28:17 If we desire such liberation, where we can come to the end of ourselves, no longer having to prove ourselves, but simply stand confident in the grace of God, how do we experience that new confidence? Finally. Simply put,
28:38 liberation and a new confidence comes because of the cross. on the cross, all of our failures, all of our self-righteousness, all of our guilt, all of our shame is taken by Jesus. It's one of the primary things Jesus is doing on the cross. He takes all of our sin. Yes. And amen. But that's not the only thing that happens on the cross. It's only half of what happens on the cross. Second Corinthians five. describes not only what Jesus takes from us, but it also reminds us of what we are given in return. Paul, in 2 Corinthians 5, says that for our sake, he made him to be sin who knew no sin. In other words, Jesus became our sin on the cross.
29:33 But why? So that in him, we might become the righteousness of God. He made him who knew no sin to be sin so that we might become the righteousness of God. Christ's righteousness is ours as we trust and rest and receive his grace. And it is that righteousness that brings us favor before God. Not our own attempts, not our attempts at living a perfect life, but Jesus' perfect, righteous life on our behalf. And also, unless we assume otherwise, being given the righteousness of Jesus doesn't then become some license for us to sin. You know, I think about this verse quite often, and I reference it all the time during our prayer of confession. But 1 John 1.9 says this. It tells us that if we confess our sins, that God is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and cleanse us of all unrighteousness.
30:39 And then John goes on to say this. He says, My dear children, I write this to you so that you will not sin, but if anybody does sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ, the Righteous One. Here's why I highlight this. Jesus is reminding us of the forgiveness that we have when we trust in him. But not only is it forgiveness for the sins of our past, but it's also forgiveness for the inevitable sins that are to come. John is saying, don't sin. But if you do, Jesus advocates for you. I recently heard a preacher highlighting the fact that this verse, it's important, does not say that God is faithful and merciful to forgive our sins. But rather, John, 1 John tells us that God is faithful and just to forgive our sins. Why is that important? Because for those who trust in Jesus, your sins are paid for on the cross, past, present, and future. And as a result, Jesus as our advocate can say to the Father, I have paid for those sins.
31:50 And it would be unjust for there to be two payments for those sins. And so as a result, Justin, despite his continued sin, it's clothed in my righteousness. I've paid for his sin. And justice demands that he remain in our love.
32:11 Friends, that's undeserved grace you cannot earn. And it's a grace that you cannot lose. We are in Christ. And he has forgiven us past, present, and future. And again, this is not some license to sin. But when we have experienced that kind of grace, we are truly transformed by it. We can no longer sin like we once did. Instead, our love and our desire to faithfully live before God, it just exponentially grows. Except now we live faithfully, not in pursuit of his love, but out of his love. And I'll close with this. The reason we know that Peter truly experienced grace, and the reason we know his life was never the same, is because of the way in John 21, Jesus inevitably restores Peter back to ministry.
33:12 If you know the story, Jesus, he asks Peter a question. He says to Peter, Peter, do you love me? Peter responds, yes, you know I love you. And Jesus again asks him, Peter, do you love me? Peter again responds, yes, you know I love you. A third time, Jesus asks, Peter, do you love me? And Peter responds again, yes, you know that I love you. What is going on there? Well, first, Jesus is asking three times, hearkening back to the three times that Peter denied him. But how Peter responds is remarkable given this context. Because the old Peter, when asked if he loved Jesus, would have started rattling off all the things that he had done for Jesus, all the ways he was deserving. But now after grace, he simply answers, yes, I love you. Because of grace, Peter is no longer striving to earn favor. He is simply now resting in grace and the love that Jesus has shown him. And the real power of that transformation is ultimately seen. I mean, kind of the event in Acts 2, if you know the story, Peter, the one who had denied Jesus, fearful of being associated with him in Acts 2, gets up in front of thousands of people, unashamed and free, and proclaims the gospel of Christ. And he does so with boldness and conviction. He has been liberated.
34:53 he has been set free because of grace. And so my encouragement would be for all of us, friends, have you been liberated by God's grace? Have you come to the end of yourselves realizing that you have nothing to offer but failure upon failure upon failure? And as a result, all you can do is receive the undeserved grace of our Savior, the one who has taken our sin on the cross, but has also given us his perfect righteousness that we might find that favor in God, in Christ. If not, lay it all down today. Be liberated and again receive this grace that Christ offers. Let's pray. Our Father, we come to you acknowledging the ways in which we so often desire to prove ourselves, whether that be through our self-righteousness or even at times just beating up on ourselves or just trying to get your attention, trying to prove ourselves worthy.
36:06 but Lord, it's also the case that until we have come to the end of ourselves, realizing we have experienced nothing but failure upon failure, and that there is nothing meaningful that we can offer you, until we come to that point, we can't receive grace. We'll always assume that the grace was deserved when in reality, grace is always undeserved. and if we have not yet experienced that grace, it might be the case that we have yet to know Jesus. And so, Lord, I pray that by your Spirit, you would lead us to lay down all those attempts. at getting your attention, and instead receive grace and rest in the righteousness of Jesus that is given to us, so that out of that new confidence, not in ourselves but in Jesus, out of that new confidence in his righteousness we might live as a faithful people before you.
37:10 Not in pursuit of your love but out of your love.
Machine translated from the source