Justin Adour · Redeemer East Harlem · Published March 24, 2026
2:43 If you have been with us over the last several weeks as we've been working through the book of Mark, you know that time and time again we have returned to a very similar theme. The book of Mark has constantly brought us back to the reality that Jesus is always having to push against. those who are seeking to mischaracterize him as some kind of revolutionary Messiah. We've seen it over and over again. We saw back in Mark 6, there was a crowd that followed Jesus looking to make him a king and to restore the greatness of Israel. And Jesus said, no, I'm not that kind of king. We saw in Mark 8, Peter proclaimed Jesus to be the Messiah, Son of the living God, and yet he was so wrong in understanding what that meant that Jesus called him Satan.
3:38 We saw in Mark 11 that when Jesus entered Jerusalem during Passover, that's on Palm Sunday, what we call Palm Sunday, which we'll celebrate next week, the people cried, Hosanna, which means save us now. But in that, they wanted a Messiah who was going to come and crush the Romans, the Roman occupation. And every time, Jesus has essentially had to say, I have not come with a sword. I will not take up the mantle of this messianic revolutionary, at least not in the way that you assume. And now all of this comes to a head as Jesus now stands before not the religious leaders of the day, which we've seen happen over and over again, but now after his arrest, Jesus now stands before Pilate, the political ruler of the day, which reveals, if we pay attention, a very different perspective on Jesus. Because in this interaction, we see the consequence of a brewing tension that's been happening throughout the entire book. And I'll give you the tension right up front. What this passage helps us see is that Jesus is not a political revolutionary, but this text also shows us that Jesus is a political revolutionary. And that tension, holding that tension, we're going to see is what actually helps us make a proper decision about what we believe about Jesus and how we follow him.
5:12 So to show you what I mean, let's consider three things. Let's first consider a paradox, second, a decision, and then third, an exchange. Okay, so first, a paradox. Okay, so Jesus, he's standing before Pilate, governor of the region, and there is this charge being leveled against Jesus, some are saying that he has claimed to be the king of the Jews. Now, it's important to note that Pilate couldn't care less about the religious implications of that claim. And what I mean by that is Jesus, he's made the religious leaders of the day furious with his various religious claims, especially his claims of divinity, which they viewed as heresy of the worst kind. And to be fair, yes, someone claiming to be God is speaking heresy of the worst kind. But now he's in front of Pilate, and Pilate doesn't care about those religious frustrations.
6:11 Pilate is a proxy for Caesar, the divine king of the Roman Empire. And all he cared about was political control. And so in verse 2, when Pilate asks the question of Jesus, are you the king of the Jews? we need to recognize that this is an explicitly political question for Pilate. In other words, is what everyone is saying about you, is it true? Are you going to attempt some insurrection, some revolt, some coup? Are you here to overthrow Rome? These are the kinds of things Pilate has in mind. Now you would think that given everything that Jesus has said thus far about himself, in all the different times that Jesus has resisted that kind of assumption, how do you think Jesus would respond? I think it would make sense that Jesus' simple response would be, no, I'm not that kind of Messiah and King.
7:09 But that's not what he says. Look at verse 2 again. Pilate says, are you the King of the Jews? And in response, Jesus says, you have said so. What is that? You know, again, Jesus, you know what he's asking. You know what he's thinking as he asks that question. Why would you respond with such an indefinite, vague answer, given everything that you've said already? Because Jesus, once again, is refusing the boxes that everyone keeps trying to force him into. Jesus refuses the disciples' boxes, the crowds' boxes, the religious leaders' boxes, and now he's refusing Pilate's box as well. And here is the reason for the tension that I described earlier. Even though Jesus rejected being a military or political messiah, he never said that his kingship would not bring radical political revolution.
8:15 The paradox is this. It is true. Jesus was not a political revolutionary. But it was also true that the movement of Jesus was a profoundly political revolution. And we see this in how Jesus understood the role of the state, the Christian's relationship to the state, and how that relationship ended up creating an entire movement. Let me explain what I mean. Consider how Jesus thought about political power back in Mark 12. In that passage, there were those who were trying to trick Jesus. And so they wanted to trip him up, and so what they did is they brought a coin with Caesar's face on it, if you remember the story. And they tried to trap him in a tax question, and they asked him, should we pay taxes to Caesar? They figured if he said that they should not pay their taxes, that he would then be guilty of sedition.
9:14 yes, you should pay your taxes. He would then be complicit in the oppression of his people. And so either way, Jesus was seemingly destined to fail. But knowing that they were trying to trap him, do you remember what his response was? He essentially draws a very interesting line. Jesus' response is to say, render unto Caesar what is Caesar's. and render unto God what is God's. In other words, while you live under Roman occupation, be a citizen and participate in this political reality.
9:57 And so in this way, pretty clear, Jesus is not a political revolutionary calling for sedition and rebellion. But that's not all he said. He said, render unto Caesar what is Caesar's and unto God what is God's. That is, give to Caesar what is Caesar's, but never confuse earthly authority with ultimate authority. You still owe obedience to God and his law before you owe anything to Caesar. In other words, never let any government, any party, any flag, any movement occupy the place in your life that belongs only to God. And friends, if we take that seriously, we see Jesus beginning something that will absolutely turn into a major political tension for those that follow him. Because unless we are ruled by a perfectly holy, righteous, and just ruler and government, we will live at constant odds with the political power of our day.
11:06 Always. That means that the church, the people of God, rightly being the people of God, will bring revolution, or maybe it would feel better to call it a movement of resistance to every political context. We will always stand in stark contrast to the political movements of our day. But it's also important to note that this revolution, this resistance, will not come through strongmen or through violence, but through a commitment to embodying the character of the kingdom of God. And in the first few centuries after Jesus' resurrection, this is exactly what happened in the Roman Empire. You can read historians like Rodney Stark, who wrote a book called The Rise of Christianity a number of years ago. And in the book, he chronicles how the Roman Empire went from this pagan, anti-Christian empire to becoming the religion of the empire.
12:09 You can see that Christians, they took seriously what it meant to embody the belief that they served a Savior who laid down their life for them, and who then calls his people to do the same. These early Christians, they gave their lives for the good of the most vulnerable, regardless of who that person was. Famously, you had Christians that were caring for Greeks and Romans and Gentiles and Jewish people. These Christians cared for children that others had thrown away. They cared for and protected women against physical and sexual exploitation. They stayed in cities that were ravaged by disease, putting their own lives at risk so they could care for the sick. And all through this, as a result of this, the political order of the empire was flipped upside down. The Roman Empire went from a pagan nation to a Christian nation, or empire, as a result of Christians embodying what it meant to follow Jesus.
13:16 And it didn't just stop there. Tom Holland, not the actor, he wrote a book called Dominion a number of years ago. It's dense, but it's very good. Holland, he's not a Christian. He's a historian, but he makes the case that Christianity didn't just influence Western civilization. It also created the moral world in which we live. The way we think about morality is shaped by this, Christianity. He shows how the ideas that we take for granted all trace back to Christianity. The Enlightenment's belief in human dignity and worth is Christianity. The scientific revolution is rooted in the biblical idea that creation has order and can be understood. This is Christianity. You know, you fast forward Marxism and its proper concern for the poor and the oppressed. That concern doesn't exist without the Bible's prior concern for those same people, which is a deep irony since Marxism often rejects the very tradition that it borrowed from.
14:26 You know, he argues, Holland argues, that the Beatles song, All You Need Is Love, that song doesn't exist without Christianity. that the civil rights movement claims that people are equal in dignity. That's a biblical Christian claim that had never been seen in the world until Christianity. The Me Too movement, with its insistence on the dignity of women and the restraint of men, that is New Testament Christianity that had not ever been seen until Christianity. And here's the point. Jesus is not a political revolutionary in the sense that he comes with a sword and sedition. He is a political revolutionary in the sense that his kingdom and his people should always stand in stark contrast to the powers of this world. And when that happens, Christians will always be at odds with the political order of the day.
15:22 That's the paradox. But with that in mind, and with this decision that we may have in front of us, we do need to make a decision about the way we are going to live. The people of Jerusalem had to make a decision, and we too are also going to have to make a decision with all of this in mind. Let's consider that second. Pilate knows the awkward position that he's in with Jesus in front of him, meaning he can't let Jesus be seen as a political figure, because if Pilate loses control of the region, that's going to be his head. But he also can't be seen as treating Jesus unjustly. Otherwise, he could have a riot on his hands. These are the things that he's concerned about. So what does he do? He puts the decision in the hands of the people. Look again at verse 6. Let me work through 6 through 15 for us.
16:15 It says this. Verse 6. Now it was the custom at the festival to release a prisoner whom the people requested. A man called Barabbas was in prison with the insurrectionists who had committed murder in the uprising. The crowd came and asked Pilate to do for them what he usually did. Do you want me to release to you the king of the Jews? asked Pilate, knowing it was out of self-interest that the chief priests had handed Jesus over. But the chief priests stirred up the crowd to have Pilate release Barabbas instead. Let me pause there for a moment. So the release of a Jewish prisoner was customary before the Feast of Passover. The Roman governor granted clemency to one criminal as an act of goodwill toward the Jewish people whom he governed. And he presents, this time, two people, Jesus and Barabbas.
17:16 Now, who's Barabbas? We don't actually know that much about him, except that he was a violent insurrectionist who was guilty of murder. And then we have Jesus, the innocent one, the one who had done nothing wrong. We have Jesus, the innocent one. We have Barabbas, the guilty. And he presents it to them and says, you choose, who do you want? And what do they say? Verse 12. What shall I do then with the one you call the king of the Jews? Pilate asked. Crucify him, they shouted. Why? What crime has he committed? asked Pilate. But they shouted all the louder, crucify him. Wanting to satisfy the crowd, Pilate released Barabbas to them. He had Jesus flogged and handed him over to be crucified. Here's what's fascinating about the scene. Time and time again, Jesus refused to be what they wanted him to be.
18:12 but the people wanted him to be. Time and time again, they were looking for this revolutionary messianic savior. They wanted Jesus to be more like Barabbas over and over and over again. They wanted someone to take on Rome, but we've seen Jesus has constantly refused, and it seems that the people have finally had enough. Jesus, if you're not going to give us what we've demanded you to be. If you cannot be the strong man to crush our enemies, forget you. Give us the strong man, Barabbas, the violent insurrectionist. We don't care about your political revolution rooted in sacrifice and kindness and grace. We want domination. We want power. We want control. Give us Barabbas. Now we might look at them and think, how ridiculous is that? But friends, just so we're clear, this has not been a problem for just first century Israel.
19:18 It has been the persistent problem for the church all throughout church history, and even today. Christians with a desire for power and a strong man have consistently chosen the way of Barabbas, domination and control instead of the way of Jesus. I mean, we saw it the moment Emperor Constantine made Christianity the official religion of the empire, wedding faith and political power. There is very real debate whether or not that was a good thing for Christianity. You know, we saw it in the Crusades where men marched under a cross committing unspeakable violence, domination and control and power. We saw it in the Inquisition. The church decided the best way to protect truth was to torture people into agreeing with it.
20:13 Domination and power. We saw it in colonialism, which led to the exploitation of nations, all with the blessing of the church for the sake of domination and power. We saw it in the slave trade, where the Bible was twisted into a tool of oppression and where the American church in particular didn't just tolerate slavery, but theologized it. You know, we saw it in Nazi Germany, where huge portions of the German church looked at Hitler as the strong man and a savior of the nation. We saw it during the civil rights movement where many white churches protected their position and influence and privilege. They had power. Why would they give up that power? And friends, if I'm honest, if we're honest, and I say this with all soberness, we saw it in the election of President Trump, who at Dort University, a reformed school, by the way, a school in our tradition, promised a group of Christians that if they elect him, quote, Christianity will have power. If I'm there, you're going to have plenty of power. You don't need anyone else, end quote.
21:32 This is a bit of a side note, but even just recently, if you're paying attention to the news, Netanyahu's most recent statements, have you seen this? He said this just a couple days ago. History proves that unfortunately and unhappily, Jesus Christ has no advantage over Genghis Khan. Because if you are strong enough, ruthless enough, powerful enough, evil will overcome good. I mean, he's hardly a Christian, but many American Christians are lining up to support him. Jesus, no better than Genghis Khan. The pattern is obvious. The pattern has been clear. The pattern has happened over and over again. The church grows impatient with the slow, costly way of Jesus. And someone comes along and says, I will fight for you. I will crush your enemies.
22:27 you don't need anybody else. Time and time again, Christians like those in Jerusalem say, give us Barabbas, crucify Jesus. What then is the solution to that problem? Again, if we're honest, it's just the pattern that we've always seen over and over and over again throughout church history. So if we want something else, if we want to choose Jesus and reject Barabbas, what is the solution?
22:57 There's a scholar named Jonathan Rauch, interesting guy. He was, first, it was just important to note, he was actually very close friends with Tim Keller, if you are familiar with our church's history. But Jonathan Rauch, he's a gay, secular, Jewish writer who fairly recently wrote a book called Cross Purposes and in it he argues that if the U.S. is going to make it we actually need to return to what he calls a thick Christianity. And he frames the argument by describing three different kinds of Christianity that he sees in America today. The first he calls thin Christianity. And the way he defines thin Christianity is that it's a church so desperate to be liked, so hungry for cultural relevance that it has stopped saying anything that the culture doesn't already believe.
23:55 It stopped exporting values and it started importing values. It stopped forming people and it started following people. A thin church, he says, has no public value because it's nothing distinct from the rest of the culture. It has nothing distinct left to offer. And he notes that this tends to be a progressive Christianity problem. But then the second one is what he calls sharp Christianity. For him, sharp Christianity is divisive, it's fearful, it's partisan. This is a church that has decided the pathway forward is power. And what we need is a protector. We need someone to fight for us. We need someone who will crush the opposition. This is the crowd saying, give us Barabbas. And he sees this as primarily a conservative Christianity problem. So what's the alternative?
24:51 Well, Rausch calls the alternative thick Christianity. And I want us to notice that the secular Jewish intellectual figured out what the church is supposed to already know. Thick Christianity takes conviction seriously. It does not compromise truth. It does not bow to every cultural wind. But it also doesn't treat people with opposing views as enemies to be crushed. It treats them as neighbors, as fellow image bearers, people worth talking to. It treats people as though we owe them the giving of our lives, sacrificing for their good. And despite the assumptions, that is not weakness. That is the way of Jesus. That is what makes Jesus distinct and different from Barabbas.
25:46 the giving of our lives, even for our enemies. And for Rausch, that is the kind of Christianity we need today and that we've started to lose, if not lost altogether. And he's right. Jesus did not see his power. He came to give his life. He did not build a coalition to dominate his opponents. He washed feet. He ate with sinners. He died between two criminals. He prayed for those who were killing him. that is the Christianity we are called to. And the problem is that many might think that kind of Christianity will lose. If we don't fight, we'll be overrun. That the culture is too hostile, the stakes are too high, we cannot afford to be gentle. But I wonder, with all the combativeness that we've seen, and we've seen a lot, what have we won?
26:43 We chased power and we lost our witness. We chose Barabbas and we got Barabbas. And the name of Jesus is now often associated in the minds of many, not with love and sacrifice, but with anger and politics and the desire to dominate. This is not victory. This is a tragedy. The early church had no political power and yet they turned the world upside down. not by seizing power, but by being stubbornly, beautifully different. So different that the world could not ignore them. That is our calling. Not a thin Christianity, not a sharp Christianity, a thick Christianity, rooted in the convictions of scripture, open-handed enough to love people we are disagreeing with. It is time to stop choosing Barabbas. It is time to choose Jesus again. Now, with all that said, I also want to note that lest we make this purely about political power, we should make no mistake that we not only do this at the political power level, but we also choose Barabbas on the personal level as well.
27:59 Every day there are various ways where we choose the ways of the world. over the sacrificial, costly ways of Jesus. us. I mean, we choose Barabbas when we reject forgiveness and cling to bitterness. We choose Barabbas when we reject sex as a mutually sacrificial experience that occurs within covenant marriage, and instead we choose reductions like porn or self-satisfaction, sexual selfishness. We choose Barabbas when we reject sacrificial generosity and instead choose comfort and pleasure and leisure and control. We choose Barabbas when we reject the command to be hospitable to the foreigner and instead choose disdain and fear-mongering. We choose Barabbas when we benefit from systems that crush the vulnerable and never ask why those systems exist because we know asking that question and the answer that we might receive might be too disruptive. to our lives. We choose Barabbas every time we lack love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. Every single day, in a hundred small ways, we are standing in that crowd. Jesus is there giving us the way forward, and we say, nah, give me Barabbas.
29:31 But even if all this is incredibly confronting for us, there's one more dynamic to this story that we need to consider. We also must see that even though we're being confronted about the ways that we so often desire Barabbas, in this scene in Jerusalem, the crowd choosing Barabbas over Jesus actually shows us the insights of the very mission and purpose of Jesus. This exchange that happens is precisely what Jesus intended. I'll be brief, but this is important. Let's consider finally an exchange. So the passage goes on, verse 15. It says that wanting to satisfy the crowd, Pilate released Barabbas to them and had Jesus flogged and handed over to be crucified.
30:28 Here's what I need us to see. The cross of Christ emphasizes the key insight of this entire story. The cross is not about seizing power or selfish ambitions. The cross, the way of Jesus, is one of sacrifice and a willingness to lay down one's life for the good of another, even our enemies. Think about what's happening with Barabbas and Jesus. Barabbas is the guilty one, and he is set free. Jesus, the innocent one, hangs on a cross. Friends, that is the gospel. We are the guilty ones, the ones deserving of a cross. And yet we are set free because the innocent one chose to take that cross for us, the cross that we deserved. As much as Pilate, the chief priests, the crowd, Barabbas thought they were in control. They were merely part of what Jesus came to accomplish, to set the guilty free by taking their place. Jesus is treated like Barabbas deserved so that you and I can be treated like Jesus deserved. That is the way of our Savior. In Christ, you are undeservedly set free by grace.
31:53 And when that reality takes root in us, when we realize that, we ought to then become people of the cross, a people that recognize the way of Jesus, a way that requires patience and humility and gentleness and mercy and compassion. A way that might not result in immediate power and influence, but in a way that reflects the character of the one we claim to serve. That's thick Christianity. And you know what? I also want to just highlight this. Living in this way, in the short term, might mean losing power. It might mean losing influence. it might mean losing control. Faithfully following Jesus today might mean completely losing all influence in the political sphere.
32:50 It might. But that is the way, that is why Jesus reminds us the first shall be last and the last shall be first. This is my kingdom. It's a kingdom that is shaped by the sacrifice of the cross. And so my prayer would be that all of us would be so shaped by the cross. A cross that Christ used to set us free, that as we now move out into this world, we might be a people that reflect that same sacrifice, that same generosity of spirit, that same willingness to lay down our lives for the good of others, even our enemies. It is time for us to no longer choose Barabbas. It is time for us to choose Jesus, whether at the political level or in our everyday lives. Choose Jesus, for he has chosen us. Let's pray.
33:46 Father, we thank you that you chose us, that you chose us to be set free. We thank you that though time and time again we have been people that have said, give us Barabbas. You, nonetheless, out of mercy, have claimed us to be your own. We thank you for a Savior who willingly took our cross. We thank you for Jesus, the innocent one, who had done nothing deserving of that cross. We thank you that though he was innocent, he takes upon himself our guilt.
34:36 And Lord, we thank you that it's the cross that reminds us of the great love that you have for us despite our rebellion against you. And so Lord, I pray that as we look upon the cross and that we're again reminded of what Jesus has done, that we would become a people shaped by that cross, that sacrifice, that we too would be willing to lay down our lives, even for our enemies, to pursue their good, to recognize that whatever revolution is going to happen, it's going to come through compassion and mercy, that it's going to come through our willingness to follow our Savior, rejecting the Barabbases of this world. And Lord, I also recognize that that will come at a cost.
35:33 To follow Jesus means we will be at odds with the cultural pressures of the day, the political powers of the day. We will make decisions that will stand out. But Lord, help us see faithfulness to you is a far greater reward than anything we might get.
Machine translated from the source