Michael Zeigler · The Lutheran Hour · 660 Mason Ridge Center, St. Louis, Missouri 63141 · Published April 26, 2026
Watch on YouTube Listen to the podcast
0:00 God is the God of second chances, not for himself, but for us. Love puts others first. As God sees it, the one who follows leads, and the second is greater than the first. Dr. Michael Zeigler talks about second chances and first impressions today on The Lutheran Hour. I'm Mark Isher. Glad to be with you on this, the fourth Sunday of Easter. The Lutheran Hour is listener supported. And for more on that, here's Lutheran Hour speaker, Dr. Michael Ziegler, with a special invitation. The Lutheran Hour is made possible by donations from friends like you. And during our spring giving campaign, a $75,000 match can double all donations, taking every dollar twice as far.
0:57 to this radio station, to listeners nationwide, and including those who stream the program online. If God has used the Lutheran Hour to encourage you, consider sending a donation today. online at lutheranhour.org slash give, or call us toll free, Monday through Friday at 800-876-9880. The number once again, 800-876-9880. The website is lutheranhour.org slash give. And if you've already given, thank you. And please keep praying for us. Now here is today's message. At the concert that night, Brian, the director of the choir, explains why this next song is so special to him.
1:56 The first time he had performed it, he tells us, he was a little nervous. It was a solo act he did years ago at his wedding. He sang it just for Stacey, his bride. Not with a microphone on stage, but quietly, in her ear as they danced their first dance. The song they had chosen for the first dance was popular at the time. You might have heard it on the radio. But Brian wasn't kidding himself. He did not sound like the radio version. He was young and nervous and just trying not to step on Stacy's toes. Trying to make a good first impression on his new bride. This is the best I got, he remembers thinking to himself. But Brian and Stacey were just getting started, and there would be plenty of second chances to come.
2:51 And tonight, Brian got one. A second chance. For this concert, he had taken the radio version of that 28-year-old song and arranged it for a chorale. And he dedicated it to Stacey, his bride. He didn't spotlight her in the crowd or anything like that. We didn't even know if she was there that night. If this was a second chance for the song It wasn't just about her anymore It included all of us The 30 high school boys Brian had taught to sing it, and the crowd in the concert hall sharing in the gift. It got me thinking about second chances Second chances and first impressions As it's said, you never get a second chance to make a first impression. I suppose it's a warning not to squander that first chance, because it may be the only chance you get, like in a job interview or a sales pitch.
3:51 But in other situations, everyone knows that the first attempt is not the one that counts. I usually burn the first pancake and the first marshmallow over the campfire. But when you burn, you learn. So it is the second that counts. And the many that follow. Like with a first job. Or a first car. Or a first apartment. There's a reason they call it a starter home. For teachers. There's a reason why they say you just got to get through that first year. A veteran kindergarten teacher was telling me that that first year felt like war. But the second year, she said, I was a rock star. What makes second chances possible and count even more than the first impression is the patient relationship that enfolds them both. In a long-term relationship, the first impression is just the start, and second chances mean commitment.
4:54 Like a parent who drives their 16-year-old back to the driver's licensing office for a second attempt at the driver's test. Or multiple second attempts. Like a principal who gives that first-year kindergarten teacher room to grow. Like a bride who gladly receives both gifts. The first song that was just for her. And the second chance that included us all. Now, as I see it, there are two ways that it's true, that it's the second, not the first, that counts. On the one hand, sometimes it's true because I need room to grow. On the other hand, sometimes it's the other person who needs room. It's just a fact of life that we all need space, we need time, we need room to grow. All my first drafts of these messages stink.
5:56 And the first time I tried that new recipe, it stunk. And sometimes I get the stink eye when I say, fine, I'm sorry. My first apology usually doesn't get the tone right. So I need second chances. You need second chances because we all need room to grow, room to mature. To be better. But, on the other hand, sometimes it's not about you or me. Sometimes it's for the other person. The first impression didn't count for them. Because they don't even remember having this conversation. Or covering that material. Or learning that lesson. They had so much else going on in their head. They didn't even catch a word you were saying. It went in one ear and out the other.
6:50 the first impression didn't stick. So they need your second chances. And maybe more than you were prepared to give. Maybe seven times more. Maybe 70 times seven. Because when the wedding is over, then the marriage begins. A teacher once pointed out this pattern to me in the Bible. With God, he said, it's not the first, but the second that counts. And once you start looking for it in the Bible, you'll see it everywhere. It's not the first son, but the second son that counts. It's not Cain, the firstborn of Adam and Eve, who does what is right in God's eyes, but Abel, the second. It's not Ishmael, chosen to carry the blessing for the nations, but Isaac. It's not Esau, but Jacob.
7:43 Likewise, it's not the first king who counts, but the second. Not Saul, but David. Not David, but Solomon. Not Solomon either, turns out. The Bible tells a long and winding story of second chances with this one-two pattern repeated with increasing intensity. First, Joseph suffers, survives, and thrives in Egypt. Second, his whole family follows. First, Moses is saved through the water, tested in the wilderness to meet God on the mountains. Second, all his people experience the same. And later in the Bible, we hear the same pattern from Paul, a follower of Christ, that final king, Jesus. Paul wrote a letter to some second wave non-Jewish followers of Jesus.
8:44 And these folks, they needed room to grow. Their first steps as baby Christians were clumsy and awkward and painful. They got a lot of things wrong. Now, part of their problem was that they had come from a culture that told them, you only live once. Death, they thought, was the end of embodied life. Maybe they thought that there was some ghostly afterlife, after death, but for this life, life in the body, life in creation, this is all we get. There are no do-overs, no second chances, no resurrection, they said. So Paul reminds them of of the gospel. He preached to them the good news. The whole point is resurrection. Remember, with the crucified and risen King Jesus, there is a second, better embodied life to come, and not just for him, but for all who belong to him. Paul calls Jesus the second human.
9:58 Adam and Eve, they were human 1.0, but this crucified and risen Jesus, he's the second version, the better version. And we who trust in Jesus and follow him, we will become truly human in him. Human 2.0 Paul's words are recorded in one of the most power-packed chapters in the New Testament. The first letter to the Corinthians, chapter 15. If you've been listening to our program over the last few weeks, you know that we've been exploring key themes in this chapter. How death is the last enemy to be destroyed. How Jesus is the first fruits, the prototype of the new humanity. And how because of him, our work in this life is not empty. It's not in vain. So even if you already heard some of this, I invite you to take a second pass with me.
10:59 Hear it all at once in context. Give it a listen. See what strikes you this time. Paul says to them, and he says to us,
18:58 That's from 1 Corinthians chapter 15. The song that Brian sang for Stacey wasn't at first intended to be a love song. The song is titled I'll Be. It hit the charts in 1998, peaked at number five, and has been trending on wedding reception playlists ever since. Maybe you recognize the chorus if you're around my age. It goes, I'll be your crying shoulder. I'll be love's suicide. I'll be better when I'm older. I'll be the greatest fan of your life. It might not sound like much, but apparently over one million Dr. Phil viewers voted it as the best wedding song ever written. The songwriter's original intention, however, was 180 degrees different than how fans have received it.
20:03 Edwin McCain wrote the song after a bad breakup. He was young, immature, mired in alcoholism and despair, and the song for him was a confession of sins and a prayer of hope. He said that it was his admission of his own self-sabotaged relationship failures, hence the love-suicide line. But it was also a prayer, a plea, that he could grow and be a better person. Today, Edwin McCain is in his 50s and I hear that he's still out there in concert halls playing music and sometimes doing double duty as a bus driver. Some artists feel resentful about being a one-hit wonder but Edwin is grateful for how the song has given him a second life.
21:05 He knows why they come People say to their friends hey, let's go hear the guy who sang that song. And Edwin says, to be able to put two or three hundred people in a room just on the back of one song is an unbelievable gift.
21:26 Now, as for Brian, the choir director I mentioned, he told me later that when he sang this song for Stacy during their first dance, he thought it was just a straightforward love song. But to his older self, the song does speak of grief over failure, but also hope, hope of being changed into someone better, someone more loving. And for me, in that crowded concert hall that night, hearing 30 high school boys belting out, I'll be your crying shoulder And Brian, their director, singing through them For us, for his bride, wherever she was I couldn't help but be grateful For Second Chances When the Bible says that God will be all in all, it does not mean that we are being dissolved into God like drops in an ocean of divinity.
22:41 When it says that everything and everyone will be put in subjection in service to Jesus, it does not mean indentured servitude. When it says that Jesus himself will be put in service to God the Father, it does not mean by force. Instead, it means that the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit are inviting you into God's love song for all people and all creation. This is the ever-expanding way of love, the way to be better, the way of God. It means giving failed and failing people second chances. God is the God of second chances, not for himself, but for us, for others. That's who God is and that's what love does.
23:38 Love puts others first. Love gives the self into service. Love is God's song for us. God, the Father, put himself into our service by giving us his greatest treasure, his Son, Jesus. Jesus put himself in our service by being born, by growing with us, by dying on the cross for us, by bearing all our self-sabotaged relationship failures, and he rose from the dead so that we could be changed, to rise with him to his second life with him singing through us so that God would be all in all everything for everyone. Brian told me later that Stacy, his bride, was in fact in the concert hall that night. She had requested that no attention be brought to her, so Brian didn't mention it at the time.
24:42 That night was for the choir and the audience, and she was happy to put them first. But she did love the song, though. Brian said he was a little nervous about that beforehand. In the name of Jesus, amen.
Machine translated from the source