Guest speaker · Church of the Resurrection · 13720 Roe Avenue, Leawood, Kansas 66224 · Preached May 23, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
41:14 You like to figure things out. Or maybe you've signed up for one of those escape room experiences. Okay, if you haven't done it, here's how it goes. You go to a room, usually in a mall, and you're locked in a smaller room with a series of hidden clues and puzzles, and you have to figure it out really quickly to a ticking clock before you're released from the room. But then about 10 minutes in, you immediately figure out who has an anxiety disorder and who needs a snack and who's probably going to ruin the experience for everybody else. And then you realize, oh, wait, I have paid for my own hostage situation. We say that we love the mysteries of life, but we don't. Not really. We don't love it. We don't love the feeling of unresolved experiences. Neurologically, our brains actually hate mysteries. We like to know what's coming.
42:19 We feel most ourselves when we're acting like humans, which is to say pattern seeking, recognition seeking, prediction seeking, constantly looking out at the world, looking for clues that we know what's ahead. We love coherence. So when we get something, some kind of feedback that doesn't make sense to us, our nervous systems don't relax. They tighten. We feel kind of itchy, like brittle, worried, nervous. We don't know what to do when we can't fix it yet, or we don't know what's coming. We feel strangely out of order.
43:15 Psychologists have spent a lot of time researching and figuring out our need for cognitive closure. and how very affected we are by not having it. And it even has an interesting name. It's called the Zagarnik effect. In a famous series of experiments, people were given very simple tasks, like let's say they were given a puzzle to finish. And the psychologist would allow everyone to work and work and work on that puzzle. Half of the people were allowed to finish everything. Thank you, you did it. All done, good job. The other half were told, sorry, you can't finish your puzzle. But thanks, like thanks for your time. Have a good day. because psychologists are evil and enjoy the suffering of others.
44:03 I want you to imagine what the different people experienced. So the people who finished their puzzles forgot about it basically right away. When they were asked later, they barely remembered the experience. But what happened to the people who were interrupted? They did not enjoy the experience of being stopped. But further, they couldn't stop thinking about the puzzle later. In some versions of the study, the interrupted people were up to 90% more likely to still be deeply annoyed by it later on, thinking about it, mulling about it later that day, because that's who we are. We love having a finished feeling. When we have a finished feeling, we forget about it. We relax. We close that loop. We love the resolution we experience.
45:06 So we might like to puzzle and mull for a little bit every day, like, I'm a Wordle girl. I just, I love a good Wordle. I love going to the New York Times and pretending I'm about to read the news, but then actually just playing a game but feeling very productive. because I like to puzzle for a minute. And then I love the relief of it being over. That makes us feel calm. That makes us feel safe. So our wiring is really not very much help when it comes to embracing paradox. So that word paradox is used very frequently in the Christian tradition. so it's worth taking a minute to remember what it really means. A paradox is a statement or a situation that appears contradictory, something that shouldn't be true.
46:00 It just can't be true. And Christianity is full of them. Mark 8, whoever wants to save their life will lose it. 2 Corinthians 12, when I am weak, then I am strong. Or how about this? the kingdom of God is here and still coming. Okay, why can't it just be one of those things? Like God, pick a lane, this or that. Whoever wants to save their life will save it. Great, congratulations. When I am strong, then I am strong. New Year's resolution complete. And the kingdom of God is here, and now I don't have to read the newspaper anymore. Christian theology demands that we have an extremely high tolerance for contradictions, paradoxes, that reveal a greater truth. And there's one in particular, one paradox, one seemingly contradictory truth that has been at the heart of how I've experienced God.
47:02 It's been a mystery, such a mystery to me that I felt like I couldn't grow as a person, grow as a Christian, grow in my faith, until I understood a little bit more of what it was like to live with that contradiction and for all of it to somehow be true. So today I want to talk a little bit about joy, joy as a paradox, joy as a contradiction, but joy that increases our own capacity to change our lives if we treat joy like the miracle that it is. I don't know if you've ever had like a really big spiritual experience, like something that you just unmistakably, undeniably point to when you think about what it means to have faith. But I had one of those. It was a moment where God felt more real, more technicolor, more beautiful than anything I had experienced before.
48:11 And it came at a really awful moment right after I was diagnosed with cancer. I was 35 and I had just out of the blue received a stage four cancer diagnosis that just took it took my life apart. It took my world apart. Everything I loved was suddenly just stripped down to the studs. And I was angry. I was heartbroken. And I was completely confused about what it would mean to live, like, meaningfully, I guess, if everything I'd done to that point hadn't changed my future and I was just stuck with what is. I felt like that that feeling you get when you know you can never get what you really really really want I felt like I was hungry and I would never be full again.
49:16 And somehow, in the middle of all of that heartbreak, I had the strangest experience I was dying cancer was everywhere and I was terrified And also, and this bit, I just honestly didn't really know how to explain to anybody, but I felt like God's sticky, sweet love was just being poured over everything. Like everything. And it was like being in love with the world again. In love with the world that was just like breaking my heart. But all of a sudden, I just, like I couldn't gossip anymore. Like I just couldn't gossip. I just, not even when I was grouchy at faculty meetings. I just, everyone was beautiful. All of a sudden, I stopped swearing.
50:11 Don't worry, it came back later. But man, I, uh, it was just like the weirdest. realization of something that became a motto, and I started saying it over and over again just to make sense of what I was going through, I just realized life is so beautiful and life is so hard.
50:33 And living with that, where God could be somehow so real to me and yet... not solving a single one of my problems created this kind of cracked openness to the world itself.
50:55 I guess I realized that everything that I knew about God had to be true, even then, even though it was not the life I wanted, it was just the life I actually had. Now, one thing about spiritual experiences, and no one tells you, but they don't last. I asked around. I work at a divinity school. I sort of wandered the hallways having theological thoughts, asking spiritual questions to wiser people than me, and they're like, oh, Kate, these are beautiful moments, but they're moments. These are temporary, gorgeous feelings of wholeness. and they are not rewards for good behavior. But it was a kind of sweetness that sort of introduces you, reintroduces you to God. And it gave me the closest I have ever had. to a feeling of proof, like spiritual proof that God exists and that he loves the brokenhearted.
52:02 Sometimes I imagine that this feeling of spiritual everythingness is what it would be like. for all of us, for the church this whole time, if Jesus died and rose again, and then that was the end of the story. and there would be no tears, and the kingdom of God would be here, and it would be a moment of wholeness that would last for eternity with God and with each other.
52:41 It would be like it was Easter, and then it was Easter, and then it was Easter again, and then again, and again, and then maybe there was snacks. But that's not what happened. Easter came with this incredible promise that death is conquered, that someday we will be with God whole and forever.
53:08 And that we would feel just a surging hallelujah, hallelujah, hallelujah. Also, why am I talking about Easter so much when it was last month? I take your point, but I do want you to look back on what it was like that morning when you woke up. You came to church, you have a really good one. Good choice on that one. You came to church and it was Easter morning and you woke up and maybe if you have kids, you did the cute thing with the chocolate and the bunnies and then you rummaged around in your closet and you found all of your pastels and guys found their khakis and their one fun tie and maybe like the one fun blazer. And women realized that all of their kids have outgrown everything they bought them last year and that it's really not good timing for that because we were all trying to get it together for what is definitely going to become the Christmas card photo. But then you came to church and it was beautiful, right? And the songs and everyone is like brimming with Easter anticipation. And then we say the biggest claim that we have, that Jesus died and rose again, that he is alive and his love for us will break every story that says that the world will come undone. And then in our spirits, we feel this surge of joy, right?
54:46 Because Easter is the season of joy. joy is the way we feel it. It's this big, bright, enlivening feeling. It's a soul-filling moment where we feel the overwhelming love of God and we're just in love with the world. And our soul cries, yes, it is so good. It's so good to be alive. Not just somebody else, us in this one ridiculous, beautiful life. Joy is this gift from God and also a feeling that bubbles up from wherever our soul lives, which I'm fairly certain I'm just gesturing here because I'm guessing it's somewhere next to my intestines, which is where I experienced my deep and abiding love of ketchup potato chips, which is a Canadian delicacy. Thank you for asking. You should definitely try it. But yeah, my theory is the soul is somewhere over here. It's not technical, but we feel this sudden, strange, helium wholeness that says, yes, thank you. God, thank you.
56:08 but sometimes we want to feel joyful. We look around and other people are experiencing joy. We know that God is good. We believe that Jesus died for our sins and rose again, but we wake up the morning after Easter just noticing that maybe there is some heaviness in our hearts. Maybe we look at the headlines. Again, it is not thrilling. We have the same unanswered prayers. We're stuck maybe in an unhealed relationship or the same grief or just that same achy feeling that things are not enough. And that can be a really confusing feeling. Like, shouldn't we feel better?
57:06 Wasn't Easter enough? Am I not a faithful Christian because I can't seem to feel the Christian story? it does feel like I should admit to you, I've been a Christian my whole life, this whole time. And I'll tell you, one of the great secrets of the Christian life is we don't tell each other, but we do not always feel happy. I don't know if I brought this up earlier. So maybe if you wonder if I have a job, I should probably tell you that I am a historian and my job is to, I look at American cultural scripts, these stories that we tell, particularly about happiness and suffering and really what makes life meaningful. So let me tell you that there is enormous cultural and spiritual pressure to feel happy all the time. And look, if you check your social media feed, it's actually, the debate has been settled. Yes, you can be happy all of the time. In fact, other Christians at this moment are probably living beautiful, effortless, fulfilling, joyful lives. And it's really just embarrassing that we haven't joined them already. Happiness is very simple. I just made a list for us. Use this moisturizer. Do you have summer plans already? Okay, we'll just check for that. Did you get everyone a birthday card? Beach bodies. Are we getting one of those this year? How's your relationship? Is everything perfect? Oh, are you always having your time with God in the morning because all the perfect people do? Oh, and at this moment, and I know We can both probably feel it, but there is a 99% chance that your photos have not been synced with the cloud and you are at risk of losing them forever.
59:16 It's the feeling that we get all the time of intense emotional and spiritual pressure to be happy is because we live in a country whose founding myths are about having it all, about health and wealth and happiness. And so American culture has drowned us in popular theories about how to build that happy life. From the Puritans of New England and their advice books to Benjamin Franklin's, he had this lot of charts for personal improvement. All throughout the last couple hundred years of new thought movements and the rise of self-help books and all the way to our present day guides to manifesting and pretty much everything you find on TikTok. For centuries, Americans have been the number one consumers of stories about how to build a happy life, how to have that best life now. They'll tell you that everything is possible if you will just be happy, master your emotions, start manifesting, buy the essential oils your one cousin is always going on and on about or commit to a new series of time management strategies. For some reason, I was in the airport recently and I found that I will unironically buy a book called The Happy Inbox. I don't know. I don't know why I keep rebuying the same story about how infinity is found at the end of my inbox. But what it says is that this form of emotional perfectionism is something we're all capable of if we just pay the right emotional, mental, and physical price.
1:01:09 And that if we say that we're settling for anything else, it's just low self-esteem. For the last 50 years, we have been inundated with stories, cultural scripts about how there are no setbacks, just setups. God is always closing doors and opening windows apparently. and if something looks bad on the outside, it's only because we really haven't worked on our mindset. These are stories about bootstraps and silver linings and the sun will come out.
1:01:42 So we are now up to our eyeballs in bright siders. and people handing you reasons about why you should be better by now. but I want to tell you a wonderful secret about happiness. I've been studying happiness and joy for a while now, so this is well-researched, so let me tell you the secret. it's fine. I mean, happiness, it's fine. It's nice. It's great. If it happens to us, lovely. I'm not mad at happiness, but did you know that it's not at all the same thing as joy?
1:02:29 Happiness, historically speaking, is about good things happening to us. Nice, lucky things. The word itself comes from hap, which means chance or luck. Happiness is what happens when things go our way. When your coffee's the right temperature, your friend is going to call you later, the right song's on the radio, maybe you got a promotion at work, maybe nobody's fighting, maybe your kid even compliments you on the way out the door. Things are just, they're just coming up you. Happiness. is lovely. It's a feeling that neurologically we experience as ease. It will feel relaxing. It will feel like in the context of our lives, if we're just going about living our days, it will almost feel like you're kind of climbing a ladder and things, and you're just getting a nicer and nicer view. And it's great. And it's great. But happiness is very fragile, right? And you can hear it in my description. If it takes all of these things to go well, what happens when something knocks it over? It also really helps explain why it's so hard to make other people permanently happy, right? If it's all just made up of a thousand tiny little things, what would it take to make everybody happy all the time? I know that women can hear right now that they have become professional happiness managers. And if you don't know if you are one, then just ask yourself how many times you were like, do you need a snack? Is the temperature okay? Do you need the music down? Do you need a snack? It's never ending. Happiness is made out of a thousand tiny details. And if you have it, it's wonderful. God loves us to be happy. And there's nothing wrong with happiness. But joy, joy is something different altogether. Joy is not
1:04:38 the feeling that everything has been fixed. Joy is not happiness. Joy is a big, bright feeling that will make us feel temporarily, temporarily, and mysteriously whole. And like I told you before, it took me a long time to realize that that's what was happening in the hospital when I was sick. That's what came to me in a moment of heartbreak and fear and anger. I felt God's gift of temporary, mysterious, beautiful wholeness. That was not happiness. Things were not going my way. But did I feel like suddenly it was so good? just so good to be alive? Joy has this incredible ability to surprise us. It's partly why, I mean, just neurologically, it's just so interesting because like happiness, it hits our reward system, but it also engages our stress system, which helps us explain why you can't be happy and sad at the same time, but you can be joyful and sad, which is a super neat trick. But if you look back on moments like you're at a funeral and you can't possibly be happy, but the pastor has mispronounced your dad's name for the fourth time and suddenly feel this like lightly hysterical feeling of helium.
1:06:19 What is that? Oh, wait, it's joy. It's strange technicolor. It can come out of anywhere. It can sneak in sideways. It can come straight through the front door. Joy is a gift and a surprise, and it will remind us of how deeply good it is to live inside of your actual life. But joy is extremely annoying because you can't schedule it. You can't earn it. I certainly didn't in the hospital room. I was at my least performative self. What is it like then to feel like your life is suddenly beautifully whole? Now, I just want to go back to that Easter moment for a second because I just want to make sure this is hammered into you for next time around. But when we wake up on Easter morning and we come to church and we hear the music, I think a lot of us get confused and we think, I should be happy right now.
1:07:28 But are you happy right now? I mean, have you fixed everything about your life and the lives of those you love? Are you just climbing every rung of a ladder and tra-la-la-la, everything is working out? I mean, no. If it is, I'm very happy for you. But most of us can't fix our own lives, and we certainly can't fix the lives of the people that we love. So if you're not always happy, let's stop feeling like bad Christians or unfaithful people who can't prove that Jesus as Lord with a huge smile on our faces. but what if we tried being joyful instead?
1:08:16 Joy is such a relief for those of us with complicated lives. Joy, when it comes to us, like I said, it engages our reward and our conflict systems. It will enlarge our capacity for hope and gratitude and delight. And joy isn't fragile the way that happiness is. It's not going to wait for perfect circumstances. It will surprise us right when life feels most chaotic or frightening or unfair. This really helps me understand why joy has such a special place in the Christian story. Why it's such an incredible glimpse into the divine mind, where we can feel the goodness of our having been created by a good God who loves us, who enjoys us, who wants us to look at our own lives in all of their absurdity and say, yes, thank you. It's beautiful. I can see that now. The broken pieces in us can hold together in these beautiful moments of transcendence. And look, I wish that we only needed happiness, but we need joy. Christian joy, Easter joy, Pentecost joy because that kind of joy is not the feeling that everything has been fixed. It's not happiness. It's not resolution. It's not emotional closure. We need joy that carries us in trust and anticipation through all of the hardship and sorrow. And scripture is honest about this. Jesus weeps at Lazarus's tomb, even knowing resurrection is coming. Paul speaks of the sorrowful yet always rejoicing faith. Revelation promises a future where God will wipe away every tear. But that promise is not the same as pretending that we're not crying now. That is where Easter joy lives. It's not joy instead of grief. It is joy
1:10:27 with grief. Not joy that rushes forward, but joy that allows us to remain human in the meantime. Easter joy is not going to require that we feel happy all the time, and it will not tidy up our sadness or hurry us through disappointment. Joy gives us permission. God gives us permission to love what we can, to mourn what we've lost, and trust that God is still at work in ways that we can't always see. And isn't that good news that our joy is better than optimism and it's truer than plain happiness?
1:11:10 Easter joy is the grace to be able to say, this is hard, I am waiting, and God is still good. Not because everything changed, but because one day, poof, everything will. If we go back to those poor people who are forced to do puzzles for evil psychologists, I just want you to picture all of the people who got to finish their puzzles as happy people. Things added up, no ambiguity or unresolved feelings. It's all coming together. Good for them. But joy is for the rest of us. With prayers that haven't always been answered, with relationships that are still raw, with grief that washes over us when we wish we could just watch a movie. Look, I'm not gonna lie to you.
1:12:04 Christianity, our great mysteries, the beauty of our faith is really hard on our nervous systems. The kingdom of God is here and not yet. When we are weak, we are strong. Christ is risen. Christ will come again. But I have come to believe that joy is what God gives us so that we can live like this with the unresolved puzzle of our lives. That we can live beautifully even when life is so beautiful and life is so hard. Even when there's no cure for being human. Because if there was a cure for being human, we would have found it already. So maybe we can't always be happy, it's true. But I believe that we can be joyful.
Machine translated from the source