Howard Thurman · Church for the Fellowship of All Peoples · Fellowship Church, San Francisco, California · Preached July 17, 1953
0:05 I would like to do something that I have never attempted to do in public before. I'd like to think for a little while about the great classic that has perhaps had a greater influence on the mind and the thinking. of our immediate and remote background in America and in the Western world than any other book perhaps. perhaps except the Bible. And that is Thomas Ocumpis, The Imitation of Christ.
1:00 At the very beginning of my own ministry... One morning, when I had returned from Cleveland, as I walked into the house, the doorbell was ringing. The telephone, I mean, was ringing. And when I answered it, it was a man with great tremor in his voice asking me if I would come over to his home immediately. It was about a quarter to seven in the morning. I got my bicycle and went over there.
1:55 and he met me, his little boy met me at the door, and took me upstairs, and he said, Mother and Dad are in the room, and I went into this bedroom, and there I saw this lady, a member of the church and friend. She had gone to sleep the night before, and in her sleep, she had a stroke. And when she awoke the next morning, she awoke. Paralyzed.
2:52 And the shock was so tremendous that... one could see literally her mind slipping out of its socket and then and I sat on the bed and I held the hand that was not paralyzed. with my right hand and with my left hand I thumbed through various pages of the imitation of Christ. reading at random and then being quiet reading some more and then being quiet that went on from 10 minutes of 7 when I got there until 2.30 in the afternoon And at 2.30, all the raving was over, and she dropped into a deep sleep.
4:13 Thomas the Kempis, The Imitation of Christ. Many people are frightened by the title because to them it is, the title suggests something with which they do not wish to have anything to do. But it is a great book. despite all of the things in it that are not a part of our thinking or not a part of our own outlook not a part of the materials that are meaningful to us yet there is a great body of richness and vitality and meaning that has almost no counterpart in our literature.
5:25 Now I'd like to... feel my way through it just a little. There is a great deal of confusion, of course, about who the author is. That's a part of being respectable, I guess, that there's confusion about Shakespeare and somebody else. Bacon, I believe, they say. don't know whether Thomas the Kempis was Thomas the Kempis or whether somebody else was Thomas the Kempis and somebody else wrote it. Well, that's a very wonderful exercise for people who are concerned about the jot and the tittle. But it has nothing to do with the insight. There was a period, the 14th and 15th centuries, a period when it seemed as if In one sense all the lights were going out, in another sense they were being born.
6:38 It's like the, it's like a certain kind of oak tree that has these leaves and the fall, all the light goes out of the leaves and then they turn golden and then they turn brown and a kind of stale brown. and they remain stale brown all the winter. The winds can't break them away. The hail doesn't seem or sleep doesn't seem to be able to pull these leaves away from the branches. They stick it out, defying the storm and the winter. And then the springtime comes. And when the springtime comes very quietly... What all of the organized violence of winter was unable to do, the quiet pushing of the sap inside the tree.
7:53 accomplishes. And these leaves fall off. Because the tree now turns away from the business of clinging on to the leaves that are old. and gives itself to the business of creating new leaves. And in the creating of the new leaves, the old leaves drop off. I think sometimes civilizations and cultures are like that. I think so. And such a period was a period when the imitation of Christ was written. There were rumblings all around.
8:59 rumblings of despair and rumblings of optimism. The sons of France have had a hard time, have lost their faith and their confidence, and then a girl, a girl who heard. The wind. Whispering in the mulberry tree and the sound of which became to her many-tongued voices. that broke into her spirit. and laid hold upon the movement of her mind. And Joan of Arc swept out to redeem her people.
9:57 That was the period. Columbus was dreaming about a new world. It's madness to sail an ocean that has never been sailed before. It's madness to look for land, the existence of which is a question. If Columbus had reflected thus, he would never have laid anchor. But with that madness, he discovered a new world. That was the climate. planet.
10:41 The church was in difficulty. And there were men who had withdrawn more and more from the traffic of life, from all of the struggle, and who felt that they could only find peace by withdrawing. I remember, I may have mentioned this to you once. ago, I was at a student conference down in the southern part of Missouri, and there were students students who came from Alabama, not Alabama, from Mississippi and Texas and Oklahoma and so forth. And I had appointments in the afternoon from 2 to 5. Well, and I noticed when I got my list that one person from Lubbock, Texas, A&M College down there, had signed up for the hour from 2 to 3 every one of the days that I was there. I wondered what does that mean? So the first day at 2 o'clock he came, tall, lanky fellow, the neophyte's vision of a cowboy. And he sat on the floor with his back against the wall, lighted his cob pipe, then introduced himself, giving me his name, asking me my name. And then he sat. For one hour he sat.
12:17 Not a word did he say. At the end of the hour he got up and thanked me for the time and said, I said, I'll be back tomorrow at 2 o'clock. The next day at 2 o'clock he came and sat. Nothing was said. And the next day he came. And in the middle of the third day, third hour,
12:39 some young woman came riding into the grounds on an Arabian horse. That is, he said it was an Arabian horse. and he looked at me and he looked out at her and the horse, he said what a tragic thing it is to keep any kind of animal, human or otherwise in a situation in which that animal can't be happy. and that was all he said that day and then the last day he came and he got up to leave at 15 minutes before 3. and he thanked me for he said I thank you very much for these four hours of communion we've had together it is a wonderful thing he said to sit together in an atmosphere that is not full of proying and conning He said, give, give my love.
13:43 to all your people, and I will give your love to all my people. And he shook my hand. and disappear. We all feel that, you know. This pulling away from the atmosphere of proying and conning, whether it is in terms of the traffic of life or whether it is in terms merely of the tensions by which we are surrounded. Well, this period was of that character. And we see reflected in the imitation of Christ the other point of view. Here is stark wrestling with an interesting kind of dualism, not merely or not in essence the dualism between darkness and light, between evil and that which is good, not the fundamental or metaphysical struggle of the human spirit as it wrestles for some kind of integration, some kind of completed light.
15:01 Not that so much. But the struggle in the imitation is the struggle between the world. with all the things in it. the good things and the bad things, the world, the details of living,
15:31 the responsibilities of experience. the struggle between those things or that thing and the spirit of God. Now from our point of view it may be a phony struggle, you see. But when we see what this man does with it... then we can relate to it in terms of our own struggle because the struggle that he defines is... It's a universal lie. stating it in an almost exaggerated manner, it would take a shape like this in our minds, in my mind in a way, that it is easy enough to take sides when the battle is clearly drawn between good and evil.
16:36 often it is easy enough to take a position. for right when the opposite position is clearly and accurately defined. But much of the confusion of my life... is rooted in the fact that again and again I must wrestle... with issues that are not clearly defined. Here are two things which commend themselves in terms of a total sense of goodness, but one somehow seems to me to have a quality that the other lacks. And I must make up my mind between two good things, not between two things, one of which is evil and one is good.
17:44 So that's what he's getting at, that we are in the world, we are involved in the world. But his answer is to withdraw. So his word is, in the imitation, is the classic and creative expression of the very genius of the monastic movement in Western civilization, in Western culture, in particular in Christian faith. Now, one comment about that, and then two other things I want to say, and I won't keep you much longer. There is something to be said, something to be said for the There's something to be said for the tendency that emerges in human history that seems to exaggerate some particular virtue and throw it all out of line with anything that is normal.
19:04 and natural. Because it is, it is, it was in the monasteries for instance, with its insistence upon celibacy and all the other things that went with it, that That it was possible for a new kind of reverence... growing basically out of the distilled essence of a distortion, a new kind of reverence to invade the common life. And that's important to remember. I won't explore it further, but it's important to remember. Now, in the imitation, there is a recognition of the place of authority. And I wrote a sentence down, if I can...
20:04 hands on it from the Yes, here it is. This is the key sentence. Go whither thou wilt. Thou shalt find no rest, but in humble subjection under the government of a superior. Many have discovered themselves imagining to find happiness. Many have deceived themselves, sorry, imagining to find happiness in change. Go whither thou wilt. Thou shalt find no rest but in humble subjection under the government of a superior. You believe that? Do you believe that? There is something in us.
21:01 that always wants to be bound. There is something deep within us that wants to surrender to some kind of control.
21:23 There is something deep within us that always wants to relate to something that is fixed. unchanging permanent solid substantial something that wants authority even as there is something deep within us that is always in rebellion against us And what the monastic movement provided, as expressed through the wonderful pages of the imitations, was the source of authority, of changelessness, to which the individual lost the traffic of the world of his time could relate and feel that at last under its shelter.
22:27 he will find strength and protection and stability. Now put over against that. Another line I like to read from almost the contemporary. This is the way Dante puts the same thing in another dimension. You remember after Beatrice takes him to a certain point, he's been dealing with, he's been under the domination of authority and control all along, and finally he arrives at a point where Beatrice says, this is as far as we can go, as far as I can go. From now on, you are on your own. no more sanction of warning voice or sign from me. Free of thy abitrament to choose discreet judicious, to distrust thy sense were henceforth error up to this time. To trust your sense was error. Now from this point on, to distrust thy sense were henceforth error. I invest thee then with crown and mitre sovereign.
23:54 over thyself now there is the issue and what the discipline, the sense of stability, the sense of emotional security that comes from relating ourselves to something that doesn't change, the feeling that at last... I am not ultimately responsible for my life. O thou who changest not, abide with me. There is that in us, and there is the other.
24:43 That there shall be no freedom, ultimately, until the authority to which the individual relates, the authority under the shadow of which the individual finds his emotional stability, is an authority that he discovers deep within himself That's the paradigm.
25:13 If we don't have courage, if we are unwilling to go through the discipline necessary to awaken within us. the authority that we must have to be free,
25:45 then our only alternative is to seek refuge in some symbol of authority, be it the church, be it the book, be it your mother or your father or the psychiatrist but the whole business of the relationship of any authority that we need at some stage in our lives. is so to work and need the material of our personalities until at last their emergence out of the essence of the air and flow of one's own vitality and being.
26:45 The authority. The mystic said that doesn't happen. Until at last the man discovers that the source of the authority that is deep within him is the God that he loves. isn't it? And when he relates to... that he has found. The peace that passeth all. mera AE Correct But I will stop. Thomas the Kempis. Give very precious. practical advice, practical suggestions.
27:48 And it is in this area that I found his book most useful. Over and over again. For instance, he says just one little thing and I really will stop. He says, And when you go to bed at night... Cast up your accounts, you know? That may not be a good accounting word, but balance your books. And when you go to bed at night, get your books straight. Look back all the day, get it straight. Then when you wake up in the morning, wake up with some kind of plan for your day, for your life for that day. It need not be a great elaborate dramatic something, but some plan that will guide you through the day when you don't have time to stop to make up your mind.
28:53 you're tearing in the bed early in the morning, a minute or two or ten minutes, so get it charted. And then he said, don't ever let yourself get too idle. He said, that's not good. then he says further find some find some way by which you can share whatever there is that is precious to you with somebody else so that in your joy. you will not be alone even as in your sorrow now he has much to say about the cross and what it means What does that mean?
29:59 of the sacrament of communion. But the one word. about the cross that wherever a man deals with the responsibilities and the burdens and the tragedies of his life There, he is reproducing, in some measure, the experience that is for him a redemptive one. Therefore, said he, shun not strange words for someone living in a monastery. not the encounter with pain.
31:00 for the encounter with pain opens up the way to redemption. And I'm grateful to God. that the invitation came my way. But I was still a young man. and has not deserted me through the year.
31:37 And if you don't have a copy... I hope someday you will get that.
Machine translated from the source