Scott Black Johnston · Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church · 7 West 55th Street, New York, New York 10103 · Published November 2, 2026
0:00 Let us pray. Gracious God, open our hearts and our minds by the power of your Holy Spirit so that as your scriptures are read and your word is proclaimed, we might hear with joy what it is that you are saying to us this day. This we pray in the name of Jesus Christ, our rock and our redeemer. Amen.
0:37 This fall, Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church has been exploring biblical stories in which God taps someone on the shoulder and says, your life has purpose. There is holy work. for you to do. Many of the narratives that we've studied this autumn have focused on individuals. fascinating people like Esther or Gideon or Jonah. In today's text, though, our focus broadens. Today, an entire community gets tapped on the shoulder. From a prison cell where he was jailed for proclaiming the good news of Jesus Christ, the Apostle Paul encourages the Christians living in Ephesus to live into their calling as followers of Jesus.
2:42 and in all. This is the word of God for you, the people of God. Thanks be to God. So every so often the stars align and the church experiences a nexus Sunday, a moment when cultural strands, world events, and liturgical celebrations converge to create a sort of kitchen sink. Whoa, there's a lot going on this morning moment.
3:18 Today is a Nexus Sunday. Today we celebrate All Saints Day. We've read our necrology and honored the cloud of witnesses who surround us. Today we grapple with the fallback time change, a jolt to our circadian rhythms. Does it feel to any of you like it already ought to be time for lunch?
3:47 I'm just saying. Today is Marathon Sunday, a day when New Yorkers cheer remarkable feats of human endurance, although at the same time, because we're New Yorkers and we can do two things, at the same time we gnash our teeth as this grand event ties Gotham's streets in knots. Stars in your crown for making it here this morning. Today is the first Sunday of the month, a Sunday when we share the feast of our Lord. Today we continue our sermon series exploring biblical call stories. Today is the last Sunday before a consequential national election. There's just a bit going on. Fortunately, even though there's a lot on our plate, it's perfectly clear this morning where our faithful attention needs to focus. I'm speaking, of course, about baseball.
4:49 This past week, for the first time ever, the Milwaukee Brewers triumphed in the World Series. That's right. Now, true confessions, I have the hat, but I'm not what you might call a diehard brewers fan. Some might call me a fake fan, and I will freely admit that it's only in the past few years that I've followed this plucky team. I have a soft spot for the brew crew because they hail from the Midwest, mostly though. I've come to respect this team because they are a so-called small market franchise who has figured out how to prevail against a system that is tilted against them. As Michael Lewis famously points out in his fabulous book, Moneyball, the economics of baseball are wildly unfair. Larger market teams with massive payrolls, Los Angeles Dodgers,
6:07 continually siphon the most talented players away from smaller market teams. As such, it's very difficult for franchises like Milwaukee to find success. To win a championship, the Brewers had to trade away some of their biggest names. They had to nurture younger players. They had to keep everyone on the team's focus on the tiny details that add up to winning baseball. And to accomplish this, they brought in manager Pat Murphy, who himself brought high standards to the dugout. He instilled a code of radical accountability for all the players. And he coupled this discipline with a sly sense of humor and deep love for the game. It paid off.
7:02 The smallest media market in baseball just won the World Series. Milwaukee is delirious. They're dancing in the streets, and they ought to be, as Michael Lewis put it, the pleasure of rooting for Goliath, New York Yankees fans. is that you can expect to win. The pleasure of rooting for David is that while you don't know what to expect, you stand at least a chance of being inspired. You stand at least a chance of being inspired. I told you we needed to start with baseball. I personally take hope from the Brewer's Triumph. Now, in recent years, hope has gotten a bad rap. Some people equate hope with wishful thinking. Some describe any vague human yearning for a better life as hope. And here, modern psychology cautions us. The Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Mental Health recently issued a report on the rapid rise of online betting in this country.
8:20 Our obsession in this nation with gambling is reaching a crisis point. It's a scourge that undercuts family finances, and it's leading, says Johns Hopkins, to a significant uptick in mental health crises. In setting out its findings, the report makes a simple but profound statement. Gambling is not hope. Raw yearning without a plan or a sense of agency or honest wrestling with life's hard truths is toxic. Hope is not the act of buying a lottery ticket, sitting on a couch, and waiting for it to pay off. Hope is something different.
9:14 It's a yearning that draws us in, that gives us purpose, that shapes our vision. Consider, again, the Brewers. In their case, you might define hope as determination, as gumption, as grittiness in the face of a rigged system. The leadership in Milwaukee believed that it was possible through discipline, accountability, and a steady diet of joy to field a winning team. For this team from the great state of Wisconsin, hope became a vision worth pursuing. It was a challenge to rewrite the story. In today's passage, the Apostle Paul is also interested in rewriting the story.
10:15 And to do so, he evokes hope. From his prison cell, the old preacher exhorts his readers, I beg you, he says, to walk with humility, gentleness, patience, and love. You ought to behave in such a manner, the apostle continues, because you are called to hope. On this Nexus Sunday, this short excerpt from Paul's letter to the Ephesians raises, I think, three questions. for us to consider. Three good questions, and then we can make our way to the table.
11:00 Question number one, why is Paul begging? What's got him so worried? Here I think the answer is fairly simple. Paul is in prison, in his cell, curtailed in his efforts to spread the good news of Jesus Christ. He receives a report that there's a conflict in the Christian community in Ephesus, a church that Paul planted to correct their course, the apostle resorts to begging. He's begging because he feels like his friends in the faith have lost focus. He's begging because he knows that our souls are easily distracted. We lose the thread. We wander off the path. We forget the core of the faith.
11:54 Paul begs because he fears the conflict in Ephesus is turning the faithful away from God's inspiring vision for the world. Question number two. What inspiring vision? What is the vision that Paul exhorts the Ephesians to pursue? Again, the answer here is fairly straightforward. The Apostle Paul straight out states it. Down on his knees in the jail cell, scratching out a letter, he writes, The hope of our calling is one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is above all and through all and in all. Now that sounds good, a bit preachy perhaps, but typical fare from an evangelist, right? Basically, Paul says our hope is Jesus.
12:54 Our hope lies in the story of Jesus. Our hope rests on the faith that we have in Jesus. Our hope rises out of the baptism that unites us to Jesus. We dare hope because we're connected, says Paul, to God above, the one who is above all and through all and in all.
13:21 Question number three. What does that mean? How does that help? How does a vision like that help? What assistance do Paul's words provide as we try to navigate this absurdly challenging life? I say absurdly challenging because my calling puts me in a place where every week I'm made aware. in a tip of the iceberg way of the tremendous things that weigh on all of you. Twice this past week I've been in a group that's concluded in prayer. Twice I've found myself shaking my head as I've made notes, listening to people describe grave illnesses, lost jobs. shattered relationships, and in one case a family trauma that'll break your heart in a million pieces.
14:29 I've listed into descriptions of parents worrying over their children, an uncle worrying over a a son-in-law worrying over his mother-in-law, and everyone seems worried about the election and the direction of our country. How does hoping in one Lord who is above all and through all and in all?
15:03 help with all that weighs on us? This past week, our director of Christian education, Jamie Staley, who's downstairs right now with the kids, she encouraged me to watch a trailer for the new movie, The Magician's Nephew, the film set to premiere in February, is by director Greta Gerwig. It's set in the world of Narnia. and it looks really good. After watching the trailer, I went back to the source material. I pulled my old, dog-eared, bedraggled, 50-years-old, at least, paperback copy of The Magician's Nephew off the shelf, and I reread C.S. Lewis's book. The story, in case you need a refresher, like I did, follows two children, young friends, Polly and Diggory, who live in London. Early in the book, we learn that Diggory is struggling.
16:12 He's another soul straining under an absurdly challenging weight. The boy's mother is ill, very ill, near death. I don't want to give the plot away. You ought to read the book, see the movie in February. Still, I do want to read one scene from The Magician's Nephew to you. It occurs toward the end of the book. At this point, Polly and Diggory have been on all sorts of fantastic adventures. Along the way, young Diggory has made mistakes, some of them quite consequential. In his search for a way to help his mother, he's been distracted by flashy displays of power. But then Diggory comes face to face with Aslan.
17:09 Aslan is a magnificent golden lion who also happens to be the creator of the world of Narnia, the creator of all worlds, really. Aslan, to borrow the language of Ephesians, is the one Lord.
17:30 This is how C.S. Lewis describes the encounter. Standing before Aslan with a lump in his throat and tears in his eyes, Diggory blurted out, please, please, won't you? Can't you give me something that will cure mother? Up till then, Diggory had been looking at the lion's giant feet and the huge claws on them. Now, in his despair, he looked up at its face. What he saw surprised him as much as anything in his whole life. For the tawny face was bent down near his own, and wonder of wonders, great shining tears stood in the lion's eyes. There were such big, bright tears compared with Diggory's own that for a moment he felt as if the lion must really be sorrier about his mother than he was himself.
18:39 My son, my son, said Aslan, I know. Grief is great. Only you and I in this land know that yet. Let us be good to one another. And then Aslan taps Diggory on the shoulder. The great lion asks the boy if he's willing to go on a quest to retrieve a magic apple. Yes, sir, said Diggory. He didn't know how it was to be done, but he felt quite sure that he would be able to do it. The lion drew a deep breath, stooped its head even lower, and gave Diggory a lion's kiss. And at once, Diggory felt that new strength and courage had gone into him.
19:33 Rereading this scene, tears came to my eyes. Lewis gets it right. This scene took me back to all the requests for prayer that I heard this past week. And it took me back to Ephesians, to Paul, begging people to turn their eyes away from the world's flashy distractions to gaze again on the one Lord, the great lion whose presence is grace and who calls all of us to walk through this life with humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love. what if the tap that God has in store for you is this simple?
20:36 What if it's this radical? What if God's tap is the Spirit's ongoing attempts to cleanse us of the toxic coating that has infected our heads, the self-defeating visions of this world that make us angry and afraid and mean-spirited? What if God's tap is a lion's kiss, the gift of courage and calm, equipping us to face the absurdly difficult challenges of this world, assuring us that we are not alone, that we stand alongside one whose shining tears are at least as big and bright as our own. What if this is what it means to hope?
21:36 Friends, I invite you now to stand in body or in spirit and to join me in praying the prayer for the day which can be found printed in your bulletins or on your screen. Holy God, author of life, help us to see beyond our anxiety, beyond our confusion, beyond our anger, beyond all the conflict, cast a vision of your new creation for us. Call us again to hope and then empower us to approach each new day with courage.
Machine translated from the source