Dave Dwyer · Busted Halo · St. Paul the Apostle Church · Published December 9, 2025
0:00 Jesus would often use in his parables very obvious and stark contrasts. Probably can't imagine something more trumped up than this. I mean, really, how many of us, no matter how good we felt about our relationship with God, would walk in here to church and stand up and say, well, thank God I'm doing everything right. Not like these people, all these people over here on the right side of the church. I mean, it is a bit exaggerated. And yet, very interesting details about not only prayer, but our relationship to God. So if you notice, I work with somebody who's a real grammar shark, you know, that the Pharisee, the religious person, who by the way, is not lying, probably not even exaggerating. And from what we know, really did do more religious practices even than he was required.
0:59 He fasted more often than the law said, and he paid more tithes than he was required to. So in a sense, he was a good guy. But he says, I am not like this Pharisee. I pay my tithes. I He used the word I four times in a very short prayer. So whenever we're kind of, I don't know, checking our own spiritual life or our relationship to God, maybe the use of the word I so frequently might give us some pause. Now, the other guy, the tax collector, who again, in that society and culture, would not nearly be as righteous or observant as the Pharisee. objectively that one was a quote good guy and the tax collector was almost assuredly a bad guy. He does reference himself, sure, but he says, God be merciful to me, a sinner. Now my grammar shark friend would point out that I means you are the subject of the sentence. You do the action. Whereas when you say me, you are the object. That I think is a key difference that Jesus kind of slips into this parable. Because people will often call up the radio show that I host. On Monday nights we invite people's prayer requests. And people will pray for other people but oftentimes they'll get on the phone and go, well I feel a little bad. I feel a little guilty because this prayer is for me.
2:37 And I constantly have to say, don't feel bad about that. Don't feel guilty. We should ask for prayers for ourselves. Because notice again, the tax collector realized that he was in need of God. It is a humbling act to ask someone else for prayers. It is a very different thing to call up a radio show on Monday night and say, I just want to highlight all the ways in which I've been living my faith really well this week. So you can see there's the contrast. But there's another important piece that was pointed out by our Holy Father in his homily this morning. He had a gathering of folks all throughout the Jubilee year. It's still going on. It feels like it's a long year. But yes, every 25 years we have this Jubilee and different groups are invited to come to Rome. They had the Jubilee of Youth and they had one for priests and seminarians. And this weekend they had folks that were involved in that synod process. Now we certainly could have involved a lot of you because I'd say this parish probably was in the top, I don't know, one or two percent of parishes in the United States that really actively engaged the synodal process and had listening sessions and gathered feedback. In fact, I think you know this, on the Vatican website they used your parish as an example. So that was a couple years ago, of course, under Pope Francis, but what he tried to introduce is that this isn't just something we do once and then we're done. It's really how we should be church. So Pope Leo had in front of him this morning for mass, he had folks that had been involved in that process and had been organizing. And he was preaching on these readings. It was regular Sunday mass. So, and in fact, I was almost tempted just to use, his homily was so good. I was like, oh, let me throw out the silly stuff I was going to say. But we'll do a, We'll do a little Pope Leo nod. So this is what he described, interesting about comparing the two men.
4:31 Pope Leo said both the Pharisee and the tax collector find themselves together in the sacred space, yet they are divided and there is no communication between them. Notice the one guy references the other, but he doesn't actually talk to him.
4:53 Both take the same path, but they do not walk together. Both are in the temple, but one takes the first place and the other remains behind. Both pray to the Father, but without being brothers and without having anything in common. The Pharisee is obsessed with his own ego and ends up focused on himself without having a relationship either with God or with others. We should, however, focus our attention on the tax collector. With the same humility that he showed, we too must recognize within the church that we are all in need of God and one another, which leads us to practice reciprocal love, listening to each other, and enjoying walking together.
5:55 Pope Leo is astute and realizes that within our own Catholic community, we don't always agree, don't always walk together. And of course it would be foolhardy to think that 1.2 billion people from all different countries on the planet would all be of completely the same mind. Well of course not. But we've seen lately an increasing division among those who like this particular form of prey versus those who like that form. Those who advocate for this church teaching in politics and those who advocate for that one, or any number of other ways. Pope Leo is saying, look at these two that Jesus uses as an example in this parable. Yes, they are extreme characteristics, caricatures, if you will, and yet they can teach us about ourselves, what we're doing. How do we not even listen to one another? How am I so focused in my own prayer on Dave, on I, that I miss those in my life, those in my ministry, who need prayers. Sometimes people ask, sometimes they don't. I bet there's folks in the pew next to or in front of you that could really use some God love this week, really use some blessing, some grace this week. Do we come to church and just kind of think, what am I going to get out of it? I'm having a tough week, so I need a little shot of the gospel? Maybe. Sometimes we come and say, okay, I'll do some service after church. I'll go help out at the festival. But we gather together, as Pope Leo said, in this sacred space together, even when they're all different individuals who don't know each other. It's important that it is we. Yes, God is the subject of the sentence and gives us blessing, heals us, forgives us, not I doing it, but it's also we who gather together and are in need of God's love,
8:07 in need of God's forgiveness. So I think the point that Pope Leo was making is when we have this mindset of what they're now calling this synodal way, kind of walking together, we can move away from this temptation that we saw in the parable of the two, not being with one another. So if there's anyone in your life this week that you might be thinking, well, thank God I'm not like blank, in this case tax collector, but you know, do a little Mad Libs, fill in your own blank there. Thank God I'm not like that person who likes that kind of music at church. Thank God I'm not like that person who watches that news channel. then this parable is for you and me. We are called to find common ground, to be together in the sacred space, even people that aren't at this mass, to be together on this road, this walk, journey of synodality, meaning becoming Christian community together. So whoever that is you might think of, think of a way like Pope Leo is encouraging us to walk together. Find common ground. You don't have to call that person up and say, I'm sorry. But imagine that you are praying together with whoever that is, that you think of yourself different from, or better than, or worse than, and take that humble position of the tax collector with that simplest of all prayers in our tradition. Oh Lord, have mercy on me, a sinner. Because we all are. In the very, I remember the very first, 13 years ago, the very first interview that Pope Francis ever did with any news outlet, you know, the interviewer's trying to be coy and says, who is Jorge Bergoglio? You know, one of those kind of techniques. And he said, his first response was, I am a sinner. And we all are.
10:13 I am, all of us gathered, those who aren't here, when we realize that humbly before God, we can allow God to be the subject of the sentence. And we can realize that there's not a lot of differences between our brothers and sisters, that we all are in need of God's love. So we learned a little lesson today from these two. How can we come together? How can we employ that humility a little more this week? How can we think of someone that we think we're really different from and maybe let God soften our hearts towards a person or a group or the other side or the other color, blue, red, whatever it is. How can God be the subject of the action and allow me to be more humble so that we may journey together.
Machine translated from the source