David Lee · Redeemer Brooklyn · Published October 8, 2026
Berean Standard Bible.
1:29 I don't know if it's just me, but I feel like every single year, Christmas comes faster and faster. And the year goes by faster and faster. Maybe you feel that way too, where you're like, I can't believe it's not only December, but that it's almost the end of December and we're already talking here about Christmas. And this month, probably for a lot of us, is like the holiday sprint, right? You are just so busy with holiday parties and gifts and cookies and planning and decorations and all of these things that just leave us with a sugar rush that I think can leave us feeling like we are doing so much around Christmas. that we often forget the reason why we celebrate Christmas in the first place. That's why we need the season of Advent. I don't know if you guys have heard of Advent, but Advent is the four weeks leading up to Christmas that's actually meant to help us to slow down. and to anticipate the hope and the joy that is to come.
2:24 It is meant to be a season where we are waiting in expectation. for the true gift that Christmas is all about, the gift that Jesus is to bring hope and joy to the whole world. But a lot of times we forget all about that. and we focus on the trees and the lights. We get stressed and we're distracted and we're not prepared for the hope of the world, for the joy that is to come. Now, that in and of itself can help us miss just the busyness can make us miss the whole point of what Christmas is about. But there's another reason and a real big risk of why we can miss the real gift of what Christmas is all about. And that's because inherently in the Christmas story, as well as the Christian faith, the Christmas story can often be written off like it's just some fairy tale. Things that we read about, a virgin birth, angels coming up in the sky, to the point where we can start to think of it as just some mythical thing that happened a long time ago that isn't real or has no real impact on our lives, right? That it's all about Santa and not about what Jesus is doing. And even in our passage, right, we see this angel coming down telling Mary that she's going to give birth to the son of God that's going to be the savior of the world and it's going to happen through this virgin birth.
3:34 And even Mary says in this passage, well, how will this be? Because this even in and of itself to me feels unbelievable. What you're going to do, God, in the history of this world feels hard to believe. That's what makes it really easy for us to miss the true message of Christmas because of how God tends to work to bring about his salvation for the world, because it's never intuitive to us. And what we're going to look at today is the heart of the Christian message, which is to say that the extraordinary has happened in the utter ordinary things of life. Christmas is all about this humbling paradox. The same thing as the entire Christian faith. And so we're going to miss the hope and the real joy of what Christmas brings. if we are too proud to believe it. Either we will write off the extraordinary, or a lot of times we will just completely overlook the ordinary nature of Christmas. So for any of us who might be too proud or too distracted or too busy, we will miss what Christmas is really meant to bring.
4:34 But to the humble, to the lowly, to those who are like Mary here in our passage, you will receive an immense gift of hope and joy and peace to the whole world. So let's look at that. Let's maybe slow down what Christmas season typically is for us. And let's look at Mary as a model to prepare our hearts for Christmas. And let's look at three things at this passage today. Let's first look at why it's so hard to believe the Christmas story or the Christian message. We'll look at why it's hard. Then we'll look at why you can actually believe, what reason there is to really believe. And then finally, let's look at Mary and her response to that belief. So let's look at why it's hard to believe, why you can believe, and then what's the response to belief. So first, let's look at why it's hard. The Christmas narratives, maybe for a lot of you, are really familiar. But then therefore, we can kind of miss how remarkable this is. This passage is a famous passage called the Annunciation.
5:29 Leonardo da Vinci actually has a painting of this, where God is sending an angel to Mary to let her know that she's going to give birth to a son, Jesus. And of course, it's a virgin birth that she's going to give to a son. And it's not just any son. But look at starting in verse 31. The angel says that he's going to be the son of the Most High. He's going to inherit the throne of King David and that his kingdom will have no end. Now, to Old Testament hearers, this language would have immediately sparked, oh, this is the long-awaited Messiah. This is the one that we have been waiting for, which is an incredible claim to make, right? I know there's a lot of moms out here, and I know that we all think our kids are special. This is different, right? This is Messiah. This is divine language that you're going to give birth to the Son of God himself. That's going to be the hope of the world. That's going to heal everything that is wrong.
6:26 That's going to bring real peace. And that that is going to happen to you, Mary, through a virgin birth. Now, let's just name it right off the bat, right? We got angels flying in the sky, right? We have the Savior of the world being born, who is God himself. We have a virgin birth. These are very remarkable things to believe. This is a very unbelievable kind of a thing. These are extraordinary things. This is not normal. And then we just have to name that because for a lot of us, maybe not some of us in this room, but also in the world, that creates a particular problem for us in our belief. The extraordinary can become a barrier to belief, right? Nicholas Kristof, who's a writer for the New York Times, like every other year or so, he always writes around Christmas time and Easter time. And he says, you know, I love the message and the figure of who Jesus is, but I just think it is irrational and goes against science to believe in miracles and things like the virgin birth. And so he goes around during that time interviewing like professors and pastors and things like that in the New York Times. It's a fascinating column that he writes typically around this time. But he kind of inhabits this common narrative that many of us too might inhabit, that back in the day during Mary's time, things like the supernatural, things like a virgin birth or angels, they were much more believable because we were ignorant. We didn't have a lot of information. We weren't that smart. We weren't enlightened yet. And therefore, things that we couldn't explain, we would just say is supernatural. But now in our modern world, now that we are enlightened, now that we do have science and technology and reason, we can give a reason for anything in this world. And therefore, we will not believe things unless we can understand it completely and explain it fully, which is a very man-centered way of thinking, which makes belief almost feel like it's impossible when it comes to things like miracles or the supernatural.
8:28 happening here in our very imminent world. And so when you look at the virgin birth and the claims of Christianity or even the resurrection itself, the extraordinary nature of these things can make it very hard for us to believe. And maybe that's you here in this room. But if the extraordinary nature of this story or of Christianity doesn't put you off. The very ordinary nature, too, can also very much put us off to belief. As much as there is the extraordinary going on, here in this scene is a very, very ordinary picture. Think about this. Where would you expect the most important birth in history to take place? You would expect, especially in those times, If it was a religious birth, you would expect it to be in Judea or Jerusalem, which was the center of religious life. Or you would have expected it to be in Rome, the center of human power and human history is being written in Rome.
9:27 You would expect earth-shattering, history-moving things to be happening in those places. But where does this particular birth happen in our passage? Nazareth, a town in Galilee. Do you remember in John chapter 1 where they're talking about Nazareth? They say, Nazareth, like what good could come from Nazareth? Nazareth is basically this backwater, very small town that nobody really knows about, that nothing good really happens, nothing important happens. That is where this birth is going to take place. And so the most influential event in God's entire history of the world does not happen in New York City. It does not happen in Hong Kong. It does not happen in Paris or Jerusalem or Judea or even in Rome. It happens in the equivalent of a place like Smyrna, Delaware. Do you know where Smyrna, Delaware is? Exactly. That's where I grew up.
10:23 There is nothing really there, and that's also the only town that I can pick on without you getting mad at me because I'm from there. It is a backwater town where nothing really happens. It's not a meaningful place on the map. But that is where the birth of the Savior of the world is happening. But not only to where, but to who. We know Mary, but do you realize that in this particular passage, Mary would have been like 14, 15 years old, most likely illiterate. She was really a nobody living in that town. Married or engaged to the local carpenter. So here's what one commentator says about Mary. From all indicators, her life would not be extraordinary. She would marry humbly, give birth to numerous poor children, never travel far than a few miles from home, and one day die like thousands of others before her. A nobody in a nothing town in the middle of nowhere.
11:21 Nobody in a nothing town in the middle of nowhere. There is nothing impressive about this scene. This is not a place of power and credentials. right? Which is why people like us here in this room who gravitate towards cities like New York to make an impact can so easily overlook what is happening because God is actually working in the humblest of places on the margins of society to the poor and to the overlooked. That is the place that God is doing his most important work, the birth of the long-awaited Messiah to be the hope of the entire world. And so friends, do you realize why it is so inherently hard to believe and take in the Christian message, the Christmas message? It's both in its extraordinary and its ordinary nature that challenges our very modern, prideful sensibilities and the paradigms that we typically live into. And especially here in the city, we are wired to see the world through the lens of status and power, right? If you want to make things happen, if you want to change the world, if you want to be a mover and a shaker, what do you got to do? You got to get into power. You got to be in Washington, D.C., get into politics, or move to be in the C-suite of Fortune 500 companies that are right here in this place. That's where change happens. That's where meaningful things and places happen.
12:44 And when we think that way, we will miss what God is doing. He comes only to the lowly, to the needy, to the humble. You see, everything about the Christmas story is allergic. It is absolutely allergic to human pride. The Christmas story is absolutely allergic to human pride because it is fundamentally a message about God doing the extraordinary. Not you doing it in your power, but God doing the extraordinary.
13:20 And so therefore, only if you are someone who's come to the end of yourself looking for hope outside of yourself, will you actually be ready to receive this extraordinary hopeful message. But also that God does it in the complete ordinary. That if you think too highly of yourself, you will not be looking in the places where the Savior is born. You will not be trafficking in those communities.
13:43 And you will miss what God is doing entirely. When we put ourselves at the center of the universe, as we think about writing history ourselves, the more highly that we think of ourselves, the more that we are guaranteed to miss out on what God is actually doing in history. That is why the Christmas message is so hard to believe, and therefore so easy to miss because it confronts our human pride on every single level. Thank you. and I want us to see this too this was not a message that was super easy for someone like Mary to just subscribe to either right so if you think about Mary in her context she probably wouldn't have had a problem with the idea of angels or the transcendent or even a virgin birth. But the fact that he said that the divine God, the son of God is going to be born to you. This idea of the incarnation is what Christmas teaches, that God in his infinite wisdom gets born as a baby in a manger to a human mother in Mary.
14:48 That idea in Judaism would have been like world shattering, completely unbelievable. That the infinite holy God would come that close to be born to someone like Mary. That would have been utterly unbelievable. And so she asks this question. She says, how is this going to be? You know, we often think that people in the Bible just like automatically ascribe to everything that God says, right? And we're like, oh, I'm not like that. But no, she asks questions. You know, faith and doubt and questioning are meant to go together. Those things are not diametrically opposed. It's good to have questions. It's good. It's okay to doubt. But here's the difference that we see in Mary. She is asking and doubting with a desire to believe rather than out of a heart of unbelief. She wants to believe. She doesn't have the kind of pride that we usually ask questions with. And so she asks.
15:42 And then the angel says, when she says, how will this be? The angel says that the Holy Spirit, and the word here is to, will overcome you. That God is going to impart life in you, Mary, even though you are a virgin and have never been with a man. And the deep question in her heart is like, how, is answered in verse 37 where the angel says, for no word from God will ever fail. No word from God will ever fail. The literal translation of that is this, that nothing will be impossible with God. That is why you can believe. That is why you can trust that everything that I said is going to actually happen. And this is why, this is the key to why we can actually believe and overcome our human-centered pride that a lot of us might inhabit. It's this worldview that Mary inhabits that in a world with God, anything, truly anything can happen.
16:43 Because here's the thing, you know, if you do inhabit the world like Nicholas Kristoff or someone who's like, this is just a materialistic world and there is no miracles and I can't rationally believe that. Here's the thing. In a world, you're absolutely right. In a world where you, mankind, are at the center of the universe, in a world where it's just the material nature of the universe and that's all that there is, you realize that many things are impossible. You realize that, right? I'm not just talking about miracles. I'm not just talking about virgin birth or the resurrection or angels. Many, many things are impossible. Joy to the world. A real peace that transcends the everlasting to everlasting world. The kind of unity and the healing in a world of love and justice and righteousness. You realize those things are as equally impossible as anything miraculous or transcendent that might transpire in any given moment.
17:40 And if you have doubts about that, look around as to the world that we have created ourselves in our human strength, in our own power, in our own wisdom, we think that we can create a world that's going to be a utopia. You know, that's why we invest so much in technology or pour so much of our lives into politics, because we think that if we can just get a couple of these things right, then the world will turn out to be a better place. But do you realize that we are the wealthiest, most technologically advanced nation in the world. And we are utterly struggling. We are polarized. Mental health is through the roof. We're struggling economically. We're divided. I mean, there's so many things that is wrong that shows that our human project of shalom, this desire to bring about the kind of peace and restoration that we all desire, has not worked in our own power.
18:38 And that is where we get ourselves when humanity only looks to ourselves when we live in a world as if God does not exist. This is where it gets us. But if you live in a world that has a very different starting point, if there is a God, if it's a world where a God is with us, if there is a God that not only just exists, but acts and sends a savior then what is possible changes entirely that if you now inhabit a world where there is a possibility of a God the possibilities and expectations of hope are completely different completely different because there is now an outside hope that can come in and here's the thing we tend to think there's this rationalist view and this spiritual religious view, and that the rationalist view requires no faith, and only the religious, the Christians, have to take a leap of faith. But here's the thing, both of those points of views, both completely require faith. One is not more rational than the other. I'm going to explain that in a minute. But here's the thing, one of those views will require and produce a lot more humility and hope, whereas the other view, living apart from God, can only produce pride and despair. One lives in a world where we are small and God is infinitely big and therefore can do infinitely big things. And the other lives in a view where we are big and God is small and it's all up to us. And you might say, okay, well, I still feel like it is intellectually dishonest to believe in God and miracles, that faith cannot win out over science and reason. Well, here's a challenge to that. Do you realize that our human scientific reasoning, do you know what it's based off of, right? There's some scientists in here. I'm probably going to get this wrong, so just don't come at me. Don't think too hard about this. We essentially have to always assume that if there was an effect, that effect has to be caused by natural and repeatable causes, right? So therefore,
20:47 like the scientific reasoning is like, you see something happen, you test variables, you make it happen again so that you can explain it and understand it, right? Does that make sense? Therefore, thank you. One person got it. Therefore, therefore, a miracle, right, which is by definition transcendent outside of nature, is an intrusion into time and space that is not along the same continuum, therefore is not a repeatable act. Therefore, it is something that cannot be tested and cannot be proved by definition. That is what a supernatural event is. That is what a miracle intends. Okay, that was very heady, so let me give a much clearer example. Here's a quote from Alvin Plantinga. He argues this. He says that to say that there must be a scientific cause for any apparent miraculous phenomenon is like insisting that you lost your keys, but it must be under the streetlight because that's the only place that you can see.
21:44 Okay, it's essentially saying, imagine you're in this big football field and it's dark and you lost your key somewhere and you have one flashlight. It is insisting that where you shine your flashlight is the only place that your key can be, as if you can see the entire football field. Right? There is a lot of pride and hubris behind that kind of thinking. And so belief in God is not less reasonable. In fact, it requires the same amount of faith to live in a world where there is no God, then there is one. If you guys were here last week, there was a great testimony that Joe gave. I don't know if he's here today, but at the end of Joe's testimony, who grew up a materialist, atheist, secularist, at the end of his testimony, he said, at this point now, it would require more faith for me not to believe in Christianity. Friends, reason is not only on the side of science. it requires faith on both sides
22:44 But if you live in a world where there is no God, you realize that it is completely up to you to find hope and meaning and the prospect of peace in this world versus in a world where God does exist and can do the impossible and man this becomes really really good news when you finally come to the end of yourself and you've tried everything and you've searched far and wide in relationships and money and career, whatever it is, and yet you still have a longing for something that cannot be filled.
23:19 That is only good news when you realize that real hope and real joy and real peace to the world, a real kingdom of justice and righteousness, a place where all of our wounds are completely healed and mended, is only possible with the hope of a God outside of us, not within us.
23:41 In this Christmas season, it's like we're supposed to be festive and act like we're having a great time, but a lot of us are struggling. There's a lot of things going on in our personal lives, in our neighborhoods, in our world. This is hard. Where do you turn to for hope? What do you look to? See, the Christmas story is actually saying this is not a baseless optimism that just closes your eyes and says, I hope that this will turn out for my good. But this story, the Christian message, is that there is a God and he has fundamentally acted. He has acted in love to the world that he created, toward you whom he created and loves. and he is on the move to save it, to heal it, to bring about the redemption that we are all looking for that we cannot achieve on our own.
24:34 And the incredible thing about the Christmas message is that the way that this God reveals himself is that the extraordinary, infinite God comes down to us in the very, very ordinary that Jesus gives up his throne, the miraculous, to be born in a manger, like next to farm animals, to a poor, illiterate 14-year-old girl that the rest of the world overlooks. Here's Philippians chapter 2 that gets at the very nature of this. It says, Jesus, who being in very nature God, he made himself nothing by taking the very nature of a servant, being made in human likeness. And he humbled himself by becoming obedient to death. even death on a cross.
25:25 The God that is revealed through the Christmas story is one who is powerful but yet does not use that power in order to come to show his glory and his might. that might wrap us all away in judgment. But this is a God who fundamentally uses that power to do the truly impossible of reconciling us to give up his power to come lowly and humble so that he might be near to us who are sinners. and in our pride are separated from God. And yet he comes to love us still, to save us who judge him by dying the death that we should have died in utter and complete humility.
26:04 No other God shows up like this. No other God loves like this. But this is the incarnate Jesus who comes to us, born to us this day as his savior in flesh and blood as a baby whom we can draw near to. That is why we can believe. Why I hope you would want to believe. But here's the final thing I want us to look at. Is the response to the belief that Mary gives and what that might mean for our response to belief. Because when you see Mary here in this passage, it is so full of that very humility. that Jesus himself shows. In verse 38, after she hears this, she says, I am the Lord's servant. May your word be fulfilled. Do you realize what Mary is saying and submitting to in that very moment when she says that? That means she is saying yes to being pregnant by the Holy Spirit before her marriage to Joseph.
27:07 Which means everyone would have thought that this was an illegitimate child. Either through adultery or out of wedlock. Both of those would have made her a marked girl, filling her with public shame, filling her with being rejected by the people all around her in exclusion. Not to mention the burden of carrying a child and raising that child. So this was not an easy decision for Mary. She was giving up what she had imagined her life to be because the angel just intrudes onto her life. And you realize that she could have said, no, this is going to ruin my life. I will not take that kind of a risk. Which is, again, a very human response that many of us might actually be falling into. But instead of that, what does she do? She submits herself and says, your will be done in my life in complete humility. And without that kind of submission, she would have never experienced the joy of life with Jesus, quite literally, as well as spiritually.
28:13 And instead of saying, no, I want to stay in control of my life and I don't want you to ruin everything that I've got. She says, I'm willing to lay down my life in service to your will no matter what the cost is to me because I trust you. The great humility of Mary that says, I trust you know what is best for me versus me thinking that I know what's best. And therefore, I'm going to trust and put my life into your hands. And I'm going to trust that you sending your son is for my good. and so I'm going to die even to myself, to the pride of what I think should be happening in my life. I'm going to die to the pride of what I think should be happening in my life. I'm going to finally take my hands off of my life. This is Mary's response to a faithful belief and it leads her to have this cruciform life that dies, that willingly goes down so that new life might come within her.
29:14 See, when we cultivate a kind of life where God is with us, that he is present, where he is big and we are small, you will find yourself dying to yourself daily and trusting the infinitely big God, learning to let go of our pride and thinking of how our lives are supposed to go, And finally, let God doing what he wants to do in order to bring your history as well as the history of the world. into a relationship with him. Stopping all the control that usually stops us from trusting him completely. And so many of us here in this room, in this city, do not know what that kind of freedom looks and feels like. To trust God and to know that on the other side of death, on the other side of submission, on the other side of obedience, on the other side of belief and faith, always comes life.
30:08 Always comes life. And if we ever need proof of that, it's not just in Jesus' birth that reminds us of this, but also, of course, in his death on the cross, where he proves to us once and for all that because he has taken on the ultimate humbling in his life, being completely judged by the wrath of God for us, that we will always now experience a true kind of life with him when we trust him, when we believe, when we live a life with him. And you see that not only in Jesus, but in Mary, who gives up her life. She says, I am your servant. And the Holy Spirit literally creates life in her.
30:54 Therefore, when we, too, when we have faith in Jesus, when we have belief in him, and belief in what Christmas is trying to point us to. The Holy Spirit comes into us and creates life in us. That's the gospel. That is the Christmas story. That the extraordinary, the hope that you're looking for has come. The salvation of you as well as for the whole world. But it only comes to those who are lowly, ready to give up their thrones, to trust in humility the God who comes in the most unlikeliest of places.
31:30 Friends, let me just end with this last quote from Bonhoeffer that challenges all of us here in this Christmas season. He says this, Who among us will celebrate Christmas correctly? Who finally, whoever finally lays down all power, all honor, all reputation, all vanity, all arrogance, all individualism beside the manger. Whoever remains lowly and lets God alone be high, whoever looks at the child in the manger and sees the glory of God precisely in his lowliness. And that is the wonder of all wonders, that God loves the lowly. He's not ashamed of the lowliness of human beings, but God marches right in. He chooses people as his instruments and performs his wonders where one would least expect them.
Machine translated from the source