DNA: Where Do I Belong?

Matt Terrell · Redeemer Brooklyn · Published October 21, 2026

Listen to the podcast

Scripture reading: 1 Corinthians 12:12-27 0:06
12The body is a unit, though it is composed of many parts. And although its parts are many, they all form one body. So it is with Christ. 13For in one Spirit we were all baptized into one body, whether Jews or Greeks, slave or free, and we were all given one Spirit to drink. 14For the body does not consist of one part, but of many. 15If the foot should say, “Because I am not a hand, I do not belong to the body,” that would not make it any less a part of the body. 16And if the ear should say, “Because I am not an eye, I do not belong to the body,” that would not make it any less a part of the body. 17If the whole body were an eye, where would the sense of hearing be? If the whole body were an ear, where would the sense of smell be? 18But in fact, God has arranged the members of the body, every one of them, according to His design. 19If they were all one part, where would the body be? 20As it is, there are many parts, but one body. 21The eye cannot say to the hand, “I do not need you.” Nor can the head say to the feet, “I do not need you.” 22On the contrary, the parts of the body that seem to be weaker are indispensable, 23and the parts we consider less honorable, we treat with greater honor. And our unpresentable parts are treated with special modesty, 24whereas our presentable parts have no such need. But God has composed the body and has given greater honor to the parts that lacked it, 25so that there should be no division in the body, but that its members should have mutual concern for one another. 26If one part suffers, every part suffers with it; if one part is honored, every part rejoices with it. 27Now you are the body of Christ, and each of you is a member of it.

Berean Standard Bible.

Transcript

2:00 And thank you to all of you for your hospitality to me and my family this morning. It's really good to be here. I've actually been here one time before. I was here on Easter morning this year because a friend of ours was getting baptized here. And it was really sweet to be here then. It's really sweet to be here now. Because what we just read together is God's word and not my own. And I'm going to pray and ask for God's help, and then we'll dig into it together. So let's pray.

2:30 Father, we thank you for your word, that through it you speak your life into your world. And so we ask that you would do that this morning. Would you speak your life into us and into this city by your word and by your spirit?

2:50 It's in Jesus that we ask these things. Amen. So I want to begin this morning with a thought experiment that was proposed by a theologian and a writer named Rebecca McLaughlin. She invites us to imagine that your doctor hands you a box of pills, a box of medicine, and she says, take one every week, just one pill every week, and you're like, okay, that's easy enough, you know, not even every day, just once a week. And the label, as you're reading it, it promises increased life expectancy, greater happiness, significantly lower depression rates. And you're like, this seems a little bit too good to be true. So you start reading the fine print. You're looking for side effects. And the side effects start naming other things that are benefits. You see that if you take this medicine, you'll get a deeper sense of meaning. You'll be more sacrificial towards your neighbors, you'll be more generous, and all you need to do is take one tablet every week and it's completely free.

3:50 Now my guess is that if you were handed this medicine, you would be pretty excited about it. You'd be wondering what the catch is, but you also might even want to introduce other people to it because it sounds too good to be true. But the thing is, back here in the real world, there is a researcher at Harvard who tells us that this miracle drug actually does exist. Tyler Vanderweel is the director of Harvard's School of Public Health, and the data that he has collected in recent years shows that one thing in particular leads to all the outcomes that we just named regular church attendance regular church attendance people who go to church live longer report higher levels of happiness and meaning they're more generous and sacrificial in the way that they live now you might be thinking are you serious Guest preacher is here this morning telling a room full of people at church that they need to go to church.

4:46 Is that really what is happening here this morning? And the answer is yes. But I have reasons for it. Let me explain. I've got two reasons really quickly and then we're gonna dig into our passage. The first reason is really practical. We're lonely. The data on this is brutal. In the last 30 years, the number of young people reporting that they have friends upon whom they can rely has plummeted.

5:12 And at the same time, the number of people saying that life is meaningless has more than doubled. Those are not unrelated phenomena. The research strongly suggests that a lack of community in which to belong correlates directly to having a meaningful life. Loneliness and despair are linked.

5:34 They're linked. So if church is a place where people report high relational fulfillment and lower depression and despair, then it might be a place worth exploring. So first reason is practical. Second reason, theological. You cannot fully experience the love of God in isolation. You just can't do it. God pours his love into you through people. Getting God's love into your life is a group project, not a solitary one. And the Apostle Paul wrote the words that we just read. And in another letter to another church in the ancient city of Ephesus, he was praying for these Christians in Ephesus. And he wrote down what he was praying for them right there in Ephesians chapter 3. He says this,

6:34 filled to the measure of all the fullness of God. So he's saying, listen, the love of God for you is so vast. It actually surpasses knowledge. You can't know it. That's how big it is. And yet, I'm praying that you might know it, but you cannot comprehend this incomprehensible love of God unless you are together with all God's holy people. getting God's love into your life is a group project done in and through the church. If you want to live a more meaningful, flourishing, generous life, if you want to get a rich and deep experience of God's love in your life, you need all God's holy people. You need the church. And I do too. So what does that look like? Paul leans on a really interesting metaphor for us this morning. to talk about that question, the body of Christ.

7:27 There's lots of different metaphors employed in the Bible to talk about God's people. God's people are described as a bride. They're described as a building. They're described as a vine. And here, they're described as a body. So as we unpack this metaphor, we're gonna look at two things this morning. The church needs you, and you need the church. Very simple. The church needs you, and you need the church. So, the church needs you. Paul sets up this really kind of almost humorous thought experiment at the very beginning of our passage, he starts to wonder aloud, what would it be like if certain parts of the body started to try to exclude themselves from the body? So he's like, in verse 15, imagine a foot being like, I'm not a hand. Hands get to do all the fun stuff, right? They have opposable thumbs. They're not down in a stinky sock all day. Like, hands get all the glory. I'm just a foot. I don't really belong. And then again, in verse 16, think about your ear. An ear looks with jealousy to the eye.

8:22 Eyes are beautiful. People comment, oh, your eyes are so beautiful. Who ever said that about an ear? Ears get waxy. They get hair sprouting from weird places, right? Like, because I'm not an eye, I don't truly belong here. It's a bit ridiculous, but this is what Paul is driving at. It is so easy to look at others and think, if I were more like them, then I could truly belong. if only I had their faith like I look around this room at people worshiping God with their hands raised and their eyes closed and I think maybe I don't have what they have maybe they have some sort of like faith gene that I don't have maybe I don't really belong if only I had their bubbly personality if only I had their patience if only I had their kindness then I could truly belong here.

9:22 See, we all carry with us this deep ache to belong. And not just temporarily, but permanently, right? Not just until the marriage or the friendship ends or death comes and severs us from those that we love, but permanent belonging is what we ache for.

9:44 There's a psychologist named Kurt Thompson. He says that the deepest drama of every person's life... is looking for someone who's looking for you. The deepest drama of every person's life is looking for someone who is looking for you. We come out of the womb looking for someone to whom we can permanently belong.

10:08 And the only place where that deep ache can be truly satisfied is in relationship with God and his people. It's the only place. Now that is a bold statement, so let's interrogate that for a moment, okay? Let's imagine that the center of all reality is chance. The center of all reality is chance. We are here by accident, and our existence is just atoms colliding as our biology plays itself out. If chance is the center of all reality, then that deep ache that you have for permanent belonging is a farce. It's a farce. Like the joy that you feel belting out K-pop demon hunters at the top of your lungs at a karaoke bar with your friends at two in the morning, ultimately meaningless. And the searing pain that you feel at the betrayal of someone that you love, also ultimately meaningless.

11:14 It's just your biology playing itself out, that you were wired to react, to enjoy one thing and avoid another so that your genes live on. And that's it. And if that's all we are, then our ache for permanent belonging has no ultimate meaning. It's just a farce. let's try another scenario. Let's instead imagine that the center of all reality is some sort of like mystical, spiritual force.

11:41 But that force is impersonal, not personal. It's just out there. We can't really know it or relate to it. It's just an it. It's detached. If that is what's at the center of all reality, then your ache for belonging is ultimately futile. It's futile. You might find great friendships, but they will end. People will move. This is New York. It's transient. You will drift apart. You will hurt each other. Or eventually, even if you have the best relationships, the best friendships, they can go on for decades after decades, but eventually death will sever you. That relationship will end. Even the best love is temporary. Because if the center of reality is some impersonal power or force, then ultimately the end of your life is not belonging. It is aloneness. there will be no one or no thing waiting to embrace you and welcome you in the end. because if behind the veil is just something impersonal that you can't relate to, then that's it.

12:47 Your deep ache to be known and loved is ultimately futile, but Christianity says something different. The Bible teaches that your ache for permanent belonging is not a farce and it is not futile. It's a sign. It's a sign that you ache for permanent belonging because you were made for it. See, Christianity says this, At the heart of all reality is not chance, is not some mystical impersonal force, but personal love.

13:17 All reality emanates out from the God who is personal love. Not merely the God who has love or does the act of loving, but fundamentally who God is, is a community of perfect, perpetual, personal love. The Father loving the Son by the Spirit.

13:38 That is who God is. And that God who is love made you because he wants you to experience that very same love. He sees you and he knows you better than you know yourself. And he invites you to find belonging in relationship with him and his family forever. Listen, you get hungry because there is such a thing in this world as food to satisfy you. You get thirsty because there is such a thing in this world as water to quench your thirst. And you ache for permanent belonging because you were made by the God who is love. to enjoy love with him in relationship with him and his people forever.

14:24 And this thing that Paul is referring to as the body of Christ here in this passage is where we experience that love. It is the place where God gathers up all those who are precious to him and says, you belong with me and because you belong with me, you also belong with all these other people who belong with me. And their flourishing can't happen until you're here. You are now essential to their flourishing. This is what he's saying in verse 18. He says this, But as it is, God arranged the members in the body, each one of them as he chose, that he put our physical bodies together with loving purpose, each part together, and each member of his spiritual body was also chosen. particularly, lovingly, by God himself. Think about it this way. There's a woman named Noemia here in New York City.

15:17 And she's from Brazil. And she's a visual artist. And she runs a nonprofit called The Gleaning Project that creates art. And as part of her work, what she does primarily is she gathers discarded items. So mostly just trash. Plastic bags, straws, milk cartons, the foil from around your burrito at Chipotle. She gathers discarded items, and then she works with people who have been discarded by society, the addicts, the unhoused, the poor. And she teaches them to make art together with her. You can actually see some of her art. I think we have it. Yeah, so she actually has it. I didn't know this when I was writing this sermon, and then I just went to her website. She's got a new installation coming up. It's going to be available. You can go see it in Chelsea, at a gallery in Chelsea, starting, I think, next week. So this is some of the stuff that she creates with these folks. And then she sells the art, and the proceeds go directly back to the people who helped her make it.

16:18 And what she's doing is she's taking discarded things and discarded people, and she's bringing them together to make something beautiful and new and life-giving out of them. And my friends, that is the church. That is the church. God gathers up spiritual orphans, those who are lost and forgotten apart from right relationship with the God who made them. And he places us into his family forever. And he says, listen, we need you here. We can't make something beautiful without you. You are essential to the flourishing of all my people. Think about that. The church has existed for 2,000 years. It stretches across time and around the globe. It is the longest lasting and most culturally and geographically diverse movement in the history of humanity. and it is not really even close. And God is saying, my family, my church is not complete until you are in it, until you are here.

17:16 Your unique gifts and strengths and weaknesses and struggles and story until all those are here, my family is not complete. Friends, nothing could be more dignifying than that. Whoever you are in God's economy, you cannot look around this room and think, Well, because I'm not an eye, I'm just an ear.

17:39 Because I'm a foot and not a hand or whatever it is, because I'm not like them, I'll never truly belong. When you ache for belonging, nothing is more dignifying than knowing that God does not overlook or discard you. He gathers you up and places you into his family so that you might play an essential role in his work in this world. The church needs you. and you need the church.

18:07 You need the church. Listen again to verse 21. The eye cannot say to the hand, I have no need of you. Nor again, the head to the feet, I have no need of you. In other words, you need the church. You cannot grow in knowing God and his love without it. And here's why. The church is the laboratory of God's love.

18:27 The church is the laboratory of God's love. You don't really understand a theory until you go into the lab and test it. I worked with NYU students for many years, many of whom were pre-med, and they always moaned and groaned about taking organic chemistry. You do not understand organic chemistry until you go into the lab and you're working with the compounds and you're putting it to the test. You do not understand theater until you feel the rush and the terror. of standing up on a stage, being vulnerable, and performing in front of a live audience.

19:03 You don't understand something until you take it into the lab. And the same is true with God's love. Let me just name a few examples of what I mean. God's love becomes real when you take it into the lab. of generational difference. When you take it into the lab of generational difference. Before we moved to New York City, we lived in Alabama for four years. and right before we knew we were coming here, we knew we were about to move, and we were in this church where I got invited to teach a Bible class to Christians, all of whom were over the age of 70. So we had two kids already. We had a third on the way. We knew we were moving to New York, and we were super excited, and we were also terrified. It was just like this crazy thing, and so week after week, I got to show up to this Bible class and interact with these Christians who'd been walking with Jesus for longer than I had been alive at the time, and they had seen some stuff. Like they'd been to war.

19:59 They'd have spouses died. They'd had children who passed away. They'd been through divorce. They'd lost jobs. They'd been through all of it. And yet there they were in their 70s and older faithfully, joyfully walking with Jesus. And week after week, I got to show up in that study and interact with them and I would think, gosh, like I would look at my own life and my own anxieties and my own fears and think if God carried them, he can carry me too.

20:34 I got a richer, deeper understanding of the love of God for me because I took it into the lab of generational difference. We need people not just of generational difference. God's love becomes real to us when we take it into the lab of cultural and political difference. We're about to get spicy.

20:57 Jesus, in his inner circle, he brought Simon, who was an anti-government zealot, and Matthew, who was a tax collector and a government employee. Both of those guys were in Jesus' inner circle of the 12 disciples. He bound them together so that they might learn from one another and learn how to love each other amidst the tensions. of being in close community together with someone who saw the world so differently than them. We need people from different cultural and political perspectives to help us see the blind spots in our own. Every cultural and political movement has areas of alignment and misalignment with God's kingdom. And without community, across these differences, we mistake our political agenda for God's political agenda. or our cultural or national preferences for God's cultural or national preferences.

21:52 But the church is God's people from every tribe and every tongue and every nation. So it is both small-minded and theologically wrong to winnow down God's people to my people and my preferences. And the only way to avoid this error is to go into the lab of loving across cultural and political difference. God's love becomes real when you take it into the lab of loving across all kinds of difference. I need my sisters in Christ to help me learn more humble and selfless ways. to relate to the power and privilege of being male in a male-dominated world. I need my single brothers and sisters to teach me how to put my hope in Jesus. and not in my marriage or my family or my children. I need my same-sex attracted brothers and sisters in Christ to teach me how to fight, to listen to and obey Jesus counter-culturally, especially when it is painful and costly.

22:49 none of us can say to any other part of Jesus's body, I don't need you, I'm okay without you. You need the parts of the church that challenge you, that confuse you, that make you uncomfortable, and so do I because that is where growth happens. That is where the love of God goes from theory to experience.

23:11 The church needs you. You need the church. One more thing we need to wrestle with. how? That is so hard. If you have ever tried to go into the laboratory of loving across difference, it is extremely hard. My preferences and mess collide with your preferences and mess, and things get ugly in a hurry. And Paul recognizes this. Look again at verses 12 and 13. He says, just as the body is one and has many members, and all the members of the body, though many, are one body, so it is with Christ. For in one spirit, we were all baptized into one body, Jews or Greeks, slaves or free, and all were made to drink of one spirit. So Paul here, he highlights the deepest divides in his day. He just calls them out. Jews and Greeks, slaves and free, they hated one another. And he names it. And he says, but listen, in Christ. We're all one. Those differences aren't gone, but the disunity is brought together.

24:20 There is something deeper that unites us all. There is something that levels the playing field and makes us one amidst our many differences. It doesn't obliterate those differences, but it unites us across them. What is that? Well, in a word, Paul here says it's baptism. I bet you didn't think I was going to say that. It's baptism. Now, that feels really random. So, what in the world does Paul mean? Well, here's the image. I'm a Presbyterian minister, so I have a lot of books. And that's just kind of our thing. And I have an embosser. If you don't know what an embosser is, it's basically like, it looks like a stapler almost. It's like this clamp. And inside the clamp is this little seal. And you can take a piece of paper from inside a book and stick it inside this clamp and press down on it, and it will create this raised seal on the page that says, from the library of Matthew B. Terrell. So cool. This is like such a nerdy Presbyterian minister thing to own, and I love it. But what that does is it marks that book as my own.

25:28 It marks it, it authenticates it as my own, and it seals it into my possession. You cannot pick up a book that I have stamped as my own and say, actually, this is mine. No, it's mine. It's got my name on it. It's sealed into it. And friends, that is what the Holy Spirit does. God the Spirit takes the work of Jesus and sticks it on us, seals us into it, permanently stamps God's love onto you and seals you into it. By the Spirit, God puts his name on you and says, I am yours. you are mine. I will never leave you or forsake you. It is the permanent belonging that we were all made for. And baptism is the outward sign that God has given to show us that reality at work. Baptism is God's embosser where he puts his name on his people and says you're mine. So when Paul says we're all baptized into one body and made to drink of one spirit, He's saying underneath all of our differences, race or class or background or culture or gender or any of that, there is a fundamental sameness.

26:41 And what is that fundamental sameness according to our baptism? Two words, guilt and gift. Baptism tells a story of guilt and gift. Baptism says we share the same guilt before God. Even though we were made for permanent belonging with him, each of us in our own ways have found different ways to say, you know what? I think I'd rather find fulfillment and satisfaction somewhere else.

27:12 That's all sin is. it's taking good things like a career or a relationship or your sense of personal freedom and autonomy and making it into a God thing. Looking at that thing as the place where you find safety and fulfillment and satisfaction in life. Taking a good thing and making it a God thing. We all share the same guilt before God for having sought real abundant life apart from him. But that's not the end of baptism's story. Baptism also tells the story of the gift that we receive from God. Jesus refused to let our guilt, to let our wandering away from him, get the last word. He gave himself as a gift. Through Jesus's perfect life, we get treated by God as though we never wandered and were always faithful. Through Jesus's death on the cross, Jesus was treated as guilty in our place so that we might walk free. By his atoning blood, we are washed and cleansed fully of all of our guilt. And in his resurrection, we too are raised to new life with God forever.

28:27 And the Holy Spirit takes every blessing that Jesus has earned and stamps it on us permanently, perfectly, forever. On all those who place their trust in Jesus, the Holy Spirit takes it and he applies God's love and God's name to you forever. And Paul is saying when a Christian is baptized, you are being publicly sealed into the community of all those who confess that fundamental sameness that only through the gift of Jesus can our deep guilt before God be taken away. that fundamental sameness changes everything about how we relate to one another's differences because now that person who is different from you is not a threat. They're a blessing. They have something to show you about Jesus that you would never know apart from them.

29:21 They enrich your experience of God's love precisely because they are different from you. That's what makes the church the laboratory of God's love. every time my selfishness, my preference, my mess collides with yours, I must remember and return to the gift of Jesus himself to cleanse me of my guilt. That I need Jesus so profoundly that he had to die. And that I am loved so much by Jesus that he willingly did so. So how could I arrogantly condemn or cut myself off from you as though you and I are not fundamentally the same. And not only do I need to return to that for myself, I need to return to it for you.

30:07 That Jesus's gift was also for you in your guilt. That you need Jesus so much that he had to die for you. And that you are loved by Jesus so much that he willingly did so. So how could I withhold patience or compassion or forgiveness or love from someone that my precious Savior also loves. Now, quick disclaimer here, forgiveness and reconciliation are not the same thing.

30:39 Abuse is real, even in the church. So this is not me saying that you must reconcile with someone who abuses you. Sometimes loving someone means putting up strong boundaries against their sinful behavior towards you. So please don't hear what I'm not saying. The point is, when our selfishness, when our mess collides in the church, and it will, it forces us to remember and return to our baptism, to our shared sameness, that we are all undeserving recipients of the profound gift of Jesus, his life and death and resurrection on our behalf. So we'll close with this. Three things this means practically, very briefly. One, go. Preaching to the choir here, you're already here. Keep doing what you're doing. right this very moment, right? Go. You need this community. You need the preaching.

31:31 You need the sacraments. You need this diversity. You need the discomfort that is here because this is where God meets you. This is where you receive his love in tangible ways. So go. Stay. Church life means a lot of repenting and a lot of forgiving if you're doing it right. And both of those are hard. But if you leave when it gets messy, you kind of miss the whole point. It's in the staying. It's in the learning to repent and forgive and reconcile across disagreement, across difference. That's when God's love becomes real and not just theoretical. So go, stay. Lastly, serve. Don't just show up, but serve. Ask yourself, where can I use my gifts as an eye, as an ear, as a toenail, like whatever it is that God has given me, where can I use what God has given me to bless the people around me?

32:32 Because when you serve, you stop being a dismembered part of the body and you start actually being a member of the body, serving the whole thing. So go and stay and serve. Join the laboratory of God's love because it is in the church in this diverse and messy community of misfits that we learn more fully how wide and long and high and deep.

Machine translated from the source