Howard Thurman · Church for the Fellowship of All Peoples · Golden Gate Seminary, Strawberry, California · Preached February 11, 1971
1:38 The new mother, when she looks at the head of the babe in her arms, whispers in her heart, my child, may you seek after truth. If anything I teach you be false, may you throw it from you and go on to richer knowledge and deeper truth than I have ever known. If you become a man of thought and learning, may you never fail to tear down with your right hand what your left hand has built up through years of thought and study, if you see it at last not to be founded on that which is. If you become a politician, may no success for your party, love of your country, or security for yourself ever lead you to tamper with reality and to play a diplomatic part.
2:44 If you become an artist, may you never paint with pen or brush any picture of external life otherwise than as you see it. In all of your circumstances, my child, fling yourself down on the truth and cling to that as a drowning man in a stormy sea flings himself onto a plank and clings to it, knowing that whether he sink or swim with it, it is the best that he has. Thy poor, unknown, unloved, a failure perhaps, but shut your eyes to nothing that seems to them to be the truth.
3:38 This morning, I will hopefully conclude my discussion on the minister as a religious professional. so that tomorrow I can... deal with somewhat the minister and the spoken word. It was pointed out yesterday that the technical source... book for the minister is the Bible. And that because the Bible is also used as one of the great binding areas of exploitation for homiletical material, it is very difficult and sometimes rather awkward for the same book to be used by the minister as a source of private, personal, devotional enrichment, a source for excavating a larger area in his inward parts, that the flow of the Holy Spirit of God might have a more comprehensive and fruitful outpouring in him. So that the dilemma between honoring the necessities of the homiletical mind and honoring the deep and abiding hungers of the human spirit as one turns to the book is the dilemma that I have in mind.
5:56 or the resource, as over against the source, the source of greatest... Utility, I guess. I suppose is the word, in terms of the enrichment of the private life, is the inner struggle, the confrontation of the minister in prayer, the developing of a disciplined interior life.
6:34 And I suggested that one of the problems created by this is that the minister is a professional prayer. And he has to have, by expectation, he has to have prayers on tap, ready to be turned on. as the occasion demands. And it is, I don't know whether you've ever had this experience, of
7:06 finding yourself leading in the Lord's prayer and not realizing that you were through until you'd said amen. You know, your mind moved around in interesting ways, but you, by rote, you had this thing down so that if you put your mind and yourself into it, you'd forget the words. Well, you know what I'm talking about. I don't have to. just wear you out with it. One of the great, to pick up the threads then, the last line in our lecture yesterday was this, and it well may be that private prayer at its best is most public.
8:06 public prayer at its best, perhaps its most private. One of the great losses and the disappearance of the weekly prayer meeting in many churches. is revealed here. For often it was in the weekly prayer meeting, once the minister was able to take for granted certain pat phrases. which were part of the prayer etiquette of some of his parishioners, that the minister could get an inside feel of the inner needs and concerns of his people. Stripped of the cant or devotional cliches, the central concerns, needs, and aspirations of the people were shared before God in the intimacy of the prayer fellowship.
9:06 If he knew his people and loved them, he would get more insight into their hopes and fears and joys and sorrows. by sharing with great sensitivity in their own struggles in their periodic or weekly prayer experiences. These insights, together with what has come to him from them in his counseling, placed a desperate content into the public prayer which he, the minister, offered on their behalf. Now the wider concerns of the country and the nation would also become a part of his offering to God in prayer. But having said all of this, at long last it is the minister himself, the struggling, aspiring, succeeding, failing disciple who stands at the altar on behalf of his people and himself.
10:15 in the act of purpose. prayer. It is my judgment then that it is easier to preach about prayer than to pray. The former draws upon one's professional skills and trainings and techniques and expertise. There are many books dealing with the problems of prayer, the psychology of prayer, and as one such book indicates in his title, prayer in an age of science, the list is long and easily available. It is entirely possible for a man to put together excellent and often inspired arguments on behalf of the meaning and significance of prayer in the life of a practicing believer, and to be sure these are very real problems that must be dealt with in objective, definitive statements or presentations, so that I'm not denigrating this.
11:12 but here the warning indicated at an earlier point in this series is most appropriate. The minister must not confuse the prayer experience with knowledge about the prayer experience. My interest is not to denigrate such concerns. He must know about the prayer experience. but from the inside.
11:42 They do provide excellent opportunities for teaching and for interpretation. There are critical questions that the thoughtful mind raises about prayer. Can it accomplish anything outside of and beyond the life of the man who prays, for instance? Is it therefore purely subjective? May it be merely the cry of fear and panic in the presence of the conflicts and contradictions of human experience. The list is searching and long, varying with the times, the cultural or personal crises, and the anatomy of the human situation. after all the words have been said, and all the problems carefully researched and analyzed by the preacher, the essential question remains as crucial as ever.
12:41 Is he the minister, a man of prayer? Or to state it very personally, am I a minister, a man of prayer? Are you men of prayer? My point is that it is not nearly enough minute to believe in prayer as a part of one's equipment, as a part of one's stock in trade, or as the necessitous tool of one's craft. Deep within, as a minister, you are convinced of the efficacy and the vitality of prayer, or you are not. Under the white heat of that inner Convincement technical questions having to do with the psychology the theology and the philosophy of prayer become academic in the light of the consideration before it was Pascal who said that it doesn't matter how many...
13:49 temples men erect to science There must always be hard by a little Gothic chapel for wounded and bruised hearts. This is what I'm talking about. In any discussion of the prayer life of the minister, perhaps the distinction must be made between his prayer life and the prayer life of a non-professional Christian. But I think the distinction is a gratuitous one. I proceed, therefore, in this aspect of my discussion with a curious sense of ambivalence. The minister himself is a committed Christian. while at the same time he is a committed professional Christian. For purposes of my discussion, it may be most helpful if the distinction between the professional and the layman at this point blimps or be obliterated entirely. What I'm saying is that the distinction in function between the professional and the non-professional Christian...
14:56 need not obscure the issue that is at stake having to do with the prayer life of the Christian. The discipline of prayer remains the discipline of prayer, applicable to lay and professional alike. Obviously for the minister there is a very exacting dimension that calls for consideration. It is important that he provide time for the deepening and the enrichening of his own inner life. and here I'm talking about the kind of preparation beyond that which goes into studying for sermons for lectures for discussion groups for study groups But I'm talking about the time that the minister gives. for the cultivation of the life of his own soul Here again, the great book from which material for meditation and prayer can be drawn is the Bible.
16:03 In it, he may enter into fellowship with men and women who wrestled with God in the sharp insistence of deep inner turmoil in an effort to understand his will. and to participate in his mind to draw upon the Bible as a spiritual source which may open up channels of communication with God creates at once one of the critical psychological stumbling blocks. in the development of the personal spiritual life of the preacher. He may be tripped, as I've said several times, by the wiles of the homiletical mind. and let me call your attention now particularly to the ministry of silence and of quiet there is in every man an inward sea and in that sea there is an island and on that island there is an altar and standing guard before that altar is the angel with the flaming sword Nothing can get by that angel to be placed upon that altar unless it has the mark of inner authenticity and authority.
17:27 nothing passes the angel with the flaming sword to be placed upon your altar unless it be a part of the fluid area of your consent. the fluid, the dynamic, the pulsing area of your inner consent. This is your crucial link with the eternal. We must find sources of strength and renewal for our own spirits lest we perish. at the risk of seeming pedantic or even mechanical, let me be very specific.
18:17 We must learn to be quiet, to settle in in one spot for a period. And this is very difficult in our kind of world. And it's been true a long time. In my first parish, There was a lady of mine who always said about three or four businesses from the front. And she was present and accounted for through the worship until the moment came. for the soup. And then she set it in. and had her Sunday morning sleep.
19:04 Now, I don't talk in a hurry. There's a lot of breathing spaces between my words, and this is very quiet in the house. And as soon as I said... and the final hymn was being sung, she was all present and ready to go home. Well, I took this personally at first, and then I had occasion to call on her. It was the noisiest house that I had ever seen or heard. And as I was walking out of the door, she was doing the credit for seeing me through the door, I said, now I understand the contribution that our church is making to you.
20:04 that at least once a week in the broad open daytime at 1130 in the morning, you can be in a situation that is quiet enough so that you can take a nap and be refreshed. refreshed. And this is perhaps a very important contribution to the kingdom of God. sometimes during each day everything should stop and the sheer art of becoming still be practiced for some temperaments this will not be easy because the entire nervous system and organism have been geared over the years to activity, to overt and tense functioning.
21:06 Nevertheless, the art of being still must be practiced until development and habit are sure. And one of the things we forget in this is that the nervous system is a living thing. And it can be conditioned, it can be trained, we can school it. Now we know this in rearing our children. We surround them with certain things that will condition them in certain ways so that there shall come a time when the habit pattern will be established.
22:03 And this is what we call training. But we forget that the same thing applies to our nervous system, our nervous system as adults. The first night, the first day that Mr. Thurman and I were in Colombo on our journey, pilgrimage in India many years ago, a friend had come over to talk to us about various things, washing, not eating any food, any raw food. and all the things about how to take care of yourself since you're not accustomed to that way of life. And then he told us about the cobra and the way the cobra functions, and that because the houses are open, they may move in and out.
23:01 So if you're thoughtful, you sleep with a flashlight under your pillow, so that if you have to get up at night for any reason, you can make a circle of light on the floor so as not to disturb the unsuspecting meanderings of some cobra or night watch. And so after he left, I remained in my chair and Mr. Thurman said, well, you know, tomorrow's a hard day. better get to bed. And I said, yes, I'm going to do that, but I have a little ceremony I've got to go through. I'm conditioning my nervous system so that after tonight, it will not be possible ordinarily for me to make a blunder that will cause me, for instance, to walk around in the dark without a flashlight, so that I won't have to refer it to a volitional act.
24:05 I will be conditioned. Now, this is what I'm talking about. And we do it all the time. Now, what I'm saying is that we should take our nervous systems, our nervous organism, and discipline it into stillness. so that it will get the habit. Now this is mechanical, it's psychological, whatever the word you want to use. But it is fundamental to the development of the inner life. The art of being still must be practiced until development and habit are secure. Now if possible, find a comfortable chair or an unmolested spot where one may engage in being.
25:09 And, well, I'll make a word, in easing. You know, just when you aren't reading a book or a paper, not thinking about the next course of action, no rejecting of remote or immediate mistakes of the past, no talk.
25:32 What you're trying to do is to quiet the silent noises inside of you. One is engaged in doing nothing at all except being still. At first one may grow drowsy and actually drop off to sleep. The time will come, however, when one may be quiet for a spell without drowsiness and with a creeping quality of creative lassitude, creative lassitude, that makes for renewal of mind and body. Such periods may be snatched from the greedy demands of one's day's work. they may be islanded in a sea of other human beings. They may come on at the end of the day or in the quiet hush of the early morning. We must, each one of us, find his own time and develop his own peculiar art of being quiet.
26:34 The fear of rest must be lost, relaxed. There are many of us in our profession who keep up our own morale by always being busy. We've made a fetish of fevered action. We build up our own sense of security by trying to provide a relentless, advantageous contrast between ourselves and others by the fevered, intense activities in which we are engaged. There's something very ego-stroking about a reputation for being busy working. many parishioners compliment us often in our absence by saying how busy and how hardworking we are because that isn't all that they say but again and again we must be reminded that activities may become very easily a substitute for the hard-won core of purpose, direction, and commitment the time will come But all activities become increasingly depressing and heavy.
27:54 Please hear this. The time will come when all activities become increasingly depressing and heavy, and the dreaded question, what's the use, will have to be faced and dealt with. The first step in the discovery of sources of strength and renewal is to develop the art of being still, physical and mental cessation from inner churning.
28:28 There is a special ministry of silence which is recognized in all religions. It is embodied most dramatically in the breathless moment before God reveals himself in the experience of prayer and meditation, as well as in those experiences in worship that are sacramental and character and quality. In the appendix to Otto's idea of the holy, there's a rewarding commentary on this point. It is well worth examining if you're not familiar with it. When silence is not a part of a particular tradition, it is apt to be sterile and empty and boring. Often it is even noisy. In Protestantism, we have given a complete monopoly on silence over to the Quakers. true is this that to think of Quaker worship is to think of silent worship.
29:22 It is interesting to observe, however, how silent worship is declining now, even among them. Personally, I lament the increasing disappearance of silent meeting because it is a constant reminder to the rest of the church that again and again, God speaks loudest. in the science. And one other observation in this connection that, I don't quite know how to put this, that there are things in our interior landscape that we can hear, can see, and sounds we can hear within that are there, but we do not know they're there until we are still enough to hear them.
30:31 One of my students who was an ex-deep sea diver for the Navy was telling me about an experience. experience that he had in the Caribbean, that he went down a certain number of fathoms, however you measure it, and he had some time on his hands before doing whatever it was he was sent down there to do. So he thought he would sit on one of the coral rocks and just relax and enjoy the scenery. And when he was comfortable, he said various fish would come up and look at him through these goggles, and he would wink his eye, and a little game was going on, and those fish would tell other fish, and after a while, a whole community. different kinds of fish that tolerated each other, were enjoying the visit. And then he suddenly realized that his time was gone. And as he looked around, he noticed that he was sitting in what was a kind of, well, it looked like a garden of weeds.
31:51 there were things about that high, and they were waving, moving with the flow of the tide, and they were very gated in color, reflecting the light from the sun. And he wondered why he hadn't seen when he first sat down. And then when he moved to get up, they all disappeared. They were in this mid passage between animal and plant. And when he became a part of the landscape, then the landscape became a part of him. Now this is what I'm saying, that there are things in you and me, there are urges, whisperings from God, I think, that we can't hear. until the traffic in us quiets.
32:57 and to miss this is to pay a great price with our spirits. My point is that our nervous system must be conditioned to a regular rhythm of quiet, and once this happens it will lay hold upon us with its healing without being bitten. This is the experience of all who have accustomed themselves to meditation, for after all this is in essence what this part of my discussion is all about. Isn't it interesting that literally thousands of our youth today have turned to teachers of meditation, to gurus, many of whom are outside of our own religious tradition and often are of no particular religious tradition. What has happened to us? We have been unable to meet the hunger of the heart which is manifest in this dimension of the behavior of our youth.
34:19 Conventional Christianity provides small room for this aspect of the religious life and this aspect of the hunger of the heart. Now. Now, I summarize this then by saying that the minister must devote time to his private, personal encounter with with God. I have a very good friend, a fellow clergyman, who is deeply exercised because the only time says that he has a real sense of meaning in prayer is when he is leading his congregation. in public prayer, particularly in services of worship. For him, the absence of a congregation somehow throws him out of the mood or the context of prayer.
35:21 As a religious professional, he can pray with a sense of holy presence. As a man, he echoes the words of Hamlet's uncle, my words go up, my thoughts remain below words without thoughts never to heaven go it is my experiential judgment then that the minister must devote time for his own private personal encounter with God there must be for him the sustained experience of waiting, of listening, of agonizing of muted or stirring ecstasy in the living presence of the living God. Now I will clip that short because... I have only one more chance at you.
36:27 And I want to do this. The major materials with which the minister works are the major resource. is this inner life, this life of the spirit. And the technical source book is the Bible. Now, the major materials with which the minister works as the minister of his flock are the emotions, anxieties, dreams, aspirations, inner needs of people, and the holy thing that go to make up the interior sacraments of the spiritual life. And this is why the minister must either become... more and more holy.
37:31 to correspond with and to the sacramental stuff. that he handles. Or he has to develop some kind of immunity against it. so that he can handle these things with detachment and not be involved himself. And that's why perhaps it is so hard for him to be a Christian. Now one of the persistent temptations, therefore, is to deal with his people as if they were abstraction. The ministers act very unconsciously to regard persons in his parish as his parishioners, his trustees, his officers, but not as persons.
38:38 When our younger daughter was on the threshold of her teens, I had occasion to speak to her about a concern of mine in which she was very much involved. any apparent premeditation, she turned to me and as I recall her outburst, she said, Daddy, when are you going to stop treating me like a daughter? I'm me. I'm Anne. I'm totally alone. In other words, she said, I'm not a daughter. A daughter, nobody's ever seen a daughter. A daughter's an abstraction. And I'm concrete. Now up to that moment, with becoming modest, I was sure that at least I was one of the rare fathers on the planet.
39:41 I was shocked to discover that she felt that I regarded her as an abstraction, not as a private person in her own right. This, as difficult as it is, the minister must deal with his members on the principle of concretion rather than the principle of abstraction. All the private personal feeling, tone, predicaments, desires with which he's acquainted in himself are the interior materials with which he is dealing in them. I suppose that the heart of my concern at this point is that the minister must love his people. And I know this is old to you. At the moment I'm not thinking about the insistence that as a Christian he is under obligation to love everybody. Or to love humanity.
40:36 It may be in order to insert here that there isn't any such thing as humanity. Nobody has ever seen humanity. Here we are dealing with another abstraction. Humanity is people who have names, who live in houses, on streets, who are weak and strong, good and bad, personal. Just as a minister is regarded as a professional prayer, he is also apt to be regarded as a professional lover. of the great betrayals of Christianity. of the gospel and the life of the master is the fact that the love ethic, which is so central to the genius of the gospel, has been permitted to degenerate into a technique, often into a methodology, into a dogma, into a metaphysics, Now, such a development is one of the catastrophic consequences resulting from the institutionalization of the creative genius of religion.
41:52 Now, to illustrate this from another religion, perhaps if we can get perspective looking at another great world religion, you can see more clearly what is happening within our own. We will take the doctrine of ahimsa, the doctrine of no killing, which is fundamental to, was for a long time fundamental to the ethic of Hinduism. But the Hindu religious experience worried, sort of, yes, worried all of the ethics out of this, and it became a dogma, a theology, taking a rather encapsulated term, reverence for life.
42:47 And this became the metaphysic, fundamental to Hinduism. And it is this degeneration, this draining off of the ethic of the doctrine of Ahimsa, was the thing that forced out of the bowels of a disintegrating Hinduism, Buddhism. with its concept of mercy. It re-established the ethical dimension in what originally was an ethical insight, but under the worrying of the institutionalizing of the religion, it was stripped of this and became a manipulative technique. Now, this is, I think, the kind of thing that has happened to us in Christianity.
43:48 Not only is the minister apt to be a professional lover or a lover by profession, but within the context of his religious community, he addresses himself to people who themselves, by confession of faith, are professional lovers. The result is the world, as distinguished from the Christian community, does not expect that the believer will practice the love ethic where the world is concerned, because there often is so little witness to the practice of the love ethic within the Christian community itself. itself. What I'm saying in substance is this, just as a man may be a professional hater or a hate monger without himself being a man of ill will as a person, so a man may become a professional lover, a love monger, without himself being personally involved and participating in the experience of love.
44:54 If the minister is genuine, he must learn what it means to love people in his own right an expression of his commitment to his master, in response to the pull of the will of of God in his life. So I ask myself in this context, what does it mean to love?
45:27 It may be simpler to try to put into words the inner feelings that a person who is the object of love experiences.
Machine translated from the source