Biblical Proof of the Authority of the Catholic Church

Chris Alar · National Shrine of The Divine Mercy · Published August 23, 2026

Watch on YouTube

Transcript

0:02 So there are a few passages more convicting than this one of the authentic authenticity of the Catholic Church being founded by Jesus Christ. And I've done many talks on this passage that were just things that I feel are so convicting for us. as Brother or Deacon Ruben just read, is saying, whatever you bind on earth, you shall bound in heaven, is bound in heaven, and whatever you loosed on earth is loosed in heaven. That is so incredible that when you go into the confessional and that priest raises his right hand and says, I absolve you heaven has to forgive you or Jesus is a liar. You've heard me say this before.

1:07 If the priest cannot give you absolution, even heaven can't umbombs you. And there has been a couple of times I've had to do that with people who just said they couldn't even try to remove themselves from a mortal sinful situation. And I would talk about, does the priest have the authority to forgive sins? And everybody says, no. And I would say, yes. And that is not because the grace comes from the priest. The grace, of course, comes from God. But you heard me always say, who had ultimate authority to forgive sin on earth? Jesus. And when you have ultimate authority, you have the power to delegate that authority. And so Jesus did right here, whose sins you forgive are forgiven in heaven, whose sins you retain are retained in heaven.

2:05 But now let's go deeper. Something that I've never talked about, and I just found this morning in going through my seminary notes. So let's go back to seminary, because I've never taught this, and I had forgotten about it until I just found it this morning. The keys to the kingdom. I've never talked about that. I should, because Jesus says, I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven. Now, the image of the keys would have a very important biblical significance. Now, guess what? The background of this is from Isaiah 22, verse 20 through 22, and go to the first reading.

2:55 Where is the first reading? Isaiah 22, 19 through 23. I about fell out of my chair this morning. I'm reading my seminary notes, and Monsignor Toro, who taught me, and I had a lot of scripture classes, talked about the significance of the keys of the kingdom related to Isaiah 22. And I'm reading it going, well, why, why, why Isaiah 22? Yes, the king appoints Eliakim to an office of authority. And he says, I will place the key of the house of David on his shoulder. What he opens, no one will shut. What he shuts, no one will open. And this is exactly what brother read this morning. I will place the key of the house of David on his shoulder. What he opens, no one shall shut. What he shuts, no one shall open. Oh, wow. And I know only a priest get so excited over things like this. But this like made my whole day. Like everything coming together on our Catholic faith. And I've never talked about the keys to the kingdom. Here I find in my seminary notes, 15 years old, the answer in Isaiah, and that's the first reading. That's the beauty of our Catholic faith that all fits together like a puzzle. And so I will place the key of the house of David on his shoulder. What he opens, no one will shut. What he shuts, no one will open. The king remained the king. Jesus is our king, not the priest, but he appointed a steward with authority over the royal household. Now, Matthew 16 deliberately echoes this.

4:54 Jesus is the messianic king. He is the son of David, but he gives Peter the keys to the kingdom to be the steward with authority over the household. He doesn't replace Jesus. He acts in his name. This is one of the foundations of the Catholic Church's teaching on the papacy.

5:20 This is it. And as I'm sitting there in class, this was all coming back this morning. Wow, I remember Monsignor Toro talking about this. The Pope does not replace Christ. The Pope serves Christ as the chief earthly shepherd or steward of Christ's church. Just like we read in Isaiah. Catholics do not believe the Pope is the head of the church instead of Jesus. Christ is the head of the church. Peter and his successors exercise the office entrusted to them by Christ. So Peter receives this authority to bind and loose. Whatever you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven. Whatever you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven. Binding and loosing were terms associated with genuine religious authority. Authority to make authoritative judgments regarding teaching, discipline, and the life of God's people.

6:22 That line is directly from my seminary notes. I wrote every word in seminary. And I didn't even know what I was doing. I was like, I don't need to do all this. But something kept telling me my years of seminary, take it all down, take it all down. And now this is what I'm using to teach you. And so think about that. Notice here's something extraordinary. Heaven stands behind the authority Christ gave his priest. If you go in there to a Marian priest or any priest, and he says, I absolve you, you are guaranteed forgiveness. There's no hoping you're forgiving. There's no wondering, am I forgiven? Maybe I'm forgiven. You are guaranteed forgiveness, as I said, or Jesus lied, and nobody's going to claim that. But if you refuse to go into the confessional, the priest can't give you those words. If you refuse to go through the door of mercy, you're going to have to face the door of justice. We don't want that. I don't wish they'd had my worst enemy. And praise be to God that that, and I don't have a personal enemy, but all those people attacking online, right? And so here is the most important thing here. Jesus does not establish a church that just simply offers religious opinions. I don't agree with the church. You can't say that.

7:54 If it's official church teaching, it's not an opinion. It's real authority, speaking in the name of God. Later in Matthew 18, 18, okay, binding and loosing is extended to the rest of the apostles, because people will argue, is this just Peter? But in Matthew 16, what we just read here, Peter receives the keys to the kingdom personally and singularly. Peter has a unique office. While the apostles also possess genuine authority together with him, Peter is unique. This develops into the Catholic understanding of the Pope and the bishops in communion with him. Matthew 16 critical it also points towards apostolic succession how it was handed down well okay father I'll agree with you Jesus gave this to the Peter but he died why would God give it to one small few years in the history of the world and then abolish it forever. That makes no sense. Peter and the apostles eventually died, yet Christ intended his church to continue until the end of the age. He promises later in Matthew, I am with you always until the end of the age. Well, how is he going to do that? He died and ascended to the Father.

9:23 How is he going to remain? Through his church. The church's apostolic authority could not simply disappear when the apostles died. We already see the principle of apostolic successions in Acts of the Apostles. Judas, what happened to Judas? He died. He took his life, but the apostolic office that he had was filled. They declared it vacant, and Matthias was chosen to take his place. It didn't be left vacant, just like Peter won't be left vacant. And so what does it say in Acts 1 20? May another take his office. This is all the way to the bishops and the priests alive today. The Greek word for office is episcope, where we get the word bishop.

10:25 So the New Testament itself gives us the principle that this apostolic office can continue after the death of the person who held it. Jesus said it. This is essential to Catholic teaching about apostolic succession. Let's finish, go back though, to the keys. a church that possesses keys, which Jesus just gave,

10:58 I give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven. We just glance through that. What does it mean? A church that has those keys can either shut the door or open it, just like we said in Isaiah. It can bind or loose. It can make judgments. It can exercise its authority. And to do that, it has to have a visible structure, hence the church. Matthew 18, 17 makes this clear. Jesus says that when certain disputes cannot be resolved, tell the church. I don't need the church. Well, Jesus tells you you do. This command makes little sense if the church is just some spiritual reality. Well, I don't believe in religious, organized religion, Father.

11:56 I'm spiritual. Well, as I always say, that's too bad because Jesus organized religion. He brought together the College of Bishops. He ordained them to the Episcopate. He formed the magisterium. He put the chair of Peter, or the papacy, in place and put Peter upon it. Jesus organized religion, and we read it right here. Matthew 18, 17. Very important. Now, this command doesn't make sense, as I said, if it's just some spiritual thing. It's a real structure. There must be a recognizable ecclesiastical body capable of hearing a matter and exercising authority. You can't have 40,000 different truths. That's how many Christian religions we have now. The fullness of the church Christ established, including apostolic succession, the seven sacraments, the episcopacy, the Petrine office.

13:12 This all continues in the Catholic and only in the Catholic church. Matthew 16 gives us a remarkable summary that you just read. Let's go over this. My church. Jesus says, you are Peter upon this rock, I will build my church. Therefore, the church belongs to Christ. Not man. Next he says, I will build. Therefore, Christ has established a real church. You don't build a spiritual reality. I will build my church. As I said, you don't just build something that's some abstract reality. Therefore, Christ established a real church. Next, you are Peter. Therefore, Peter receives a unique vocation.

14:15 And upon this rock, Peter has a foundational role. He is the rock. And then I told this at the, we had a conference Friday night in Springfield, and I've mentioned this before. I got a lot of negative letters saying how you can say that Peter is the basis of the church because Jesus couldn't have said that. and a lot of the arguments, I want to say a lot, I mean I probably got six or seven letters on it, and they said if you go to the words in the original Greek, it says petra, not petros, which is the feminine. So we can't be talking about Peter. Jesus says you are Peter, petra, and this is the rock I build my church on, and that means little feminine pebble. well it would have said Petros if he meant Peter now have any of you heard my talks before what's the problem with that what's your answer to that because it sounds pretty convincing doesn't it your answer is Jesus didn't speak Greek he never spoke Greek to his apostles he spoke Aramaic And in the Aramaic, there is one word for rock, keppha.

15:37 Not masculine, not feminine, not little feminine, cute little pebble. It's keppha, rock. And that's why Peter's called cephas, the derivative of that, rock. So when somebody tells you that he couldn't have meant Peter because he says petra, and that's feminine, and not petros, you say, well, gee, Jesus didn't speak Greek. He spoke Aramaic to his apostles, and therefore, sephe, or kephe in the Aramaic. Then Jesus says, I will give you the keys. We just talked about that. He could open the door or shut it, and heaven will follow. Peter receives an office of authority, and then Jesus says, whatever you bind or whatever you loose will be bound or loosed in heaven. Therefore, the church possesses genuine teaching and governing authority. Christ follows his church. If the priest says you are forgiven, you have to be forgiven in heaven. That's why we have confession, so you can have that guarantee and then break away from that burden on your shoulders.

16:54 the gates of hell shall not prevail therefore christ promises to preserve his church despite our stupidity despite our idiocy the church is human and divine in her divine nature she cannot teach you and will not teach you in her official divine nature in her official teaching cannot teach heresy. But in her human nature, she's broken. You can have bad popes, bad bishops, bad priests. And the thing that we have to remember to this is, well, I told the other story last night, or a couple nights ago, that, you know, Napoleon told a cardinal back in the early 1800s, I'm going to destroy the Catholic Church. Those were the words of Napoleon. I'm going to destroy the Catholic Church. And the cardinal looked at him and he said, huh, priests and bishops have been trying to do that for 1,800 years.

17:57 What makes you think you can do it? So to finish, this is why Matthew 16, 13 through 20, the passage we just read is so important for Catholic ecclesiology. The passage does not portray Jesus simply leaving behind a book and individual believers interpreting it for themselves.

18:25 That's never mentioned. Jesus never talked about a book. The church's authority gave you the book 350 years later. Yes, they were written throughout, but it wasn't until 350 years later the councils of Carthage and Hippo in 393 and 397 AD that the determining books of what was inspired by the Holy Spirit were compiled into the New Testament. So this passage, as I said, does not portray Jesus leaving behind a book with individual interpreters, individual believers, interpreting it for themselves. He leaves behind a church built upon the apostles, with Peter given a unique office, possessing authority from Christ and protected by Christ's promise. You just attended seminary. God bless you, and let us thank God for the gift of our church.

19:29 despite our brokenness. And this is why we pray for her, our priests and our bishops, that we will be faithful.

Machine translated from the source