So tell us what You think: Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar or not?”Tell us therefore, what do you think? Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar, or not?”Tell us therefore, What thinkest thou? Is it lawful to give tribute unto Cesar, or not?Tell us therefore, What thinkest thou? Is it lawful to give tribute unto Cæsar, or not?
9 sermons cite this verse
May you have a seat. So, back in 1870, there was a girl born in Darfur, Sudan. We don't actually know her name. We don't know the name that her family gave her because when she was seven years old, Arab slave traders invaded her village, killed many people, and took her and others into slavery. don't know her name because she was so traumatized by the events that happened when she was seven years old that she literally forgot her own name. She forgot the name of her family. She forgot virtually everything about her. So the Arab slavers, they named her Bakita. Bakita is Arab for lucky or fortunate, which seems cruel in itself that they would name the seven-year-old girl that they took into slavery. They'd call her lucky. But for the next 12 years of her life, She was regularly beaten. She was regularly whipped, treated as other people's property. For the entirety of the rest of her life, she carried the scars of those 12 years. …
This is the word of the Lord. Thanks be to God. So, what's the controversial topic? Taxes. The Pharisees asked Jesus a question about taxes. Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar or not? Now, this is no innocent question. Just think for a moment about the stakes that came with how Jesus should answer it. On the one hand, if Jesus says to them, No, you shouldn't pay taxes, then suddenly he's opened himself up to the accusation of sedition, rebellion. He'd be seen as somebody who's opposing Rome, and so that could seal his fate before its time. On the other hand, if he says, yeah, pay your taxes, nothing wrong with that, then he alienates those among his tribe who are more nationalist and they're thinking, no, you shouldn't be doing that. We're not going to kowtow to awful Rome. And so in that case, he'll lose credibility with a number of his followers. So what should Jesus do? Either answer, either way that he responds to the question, it's going to get something wrong in the eyes of those who oppose him. …
… they try to trap him in their speech. Is it lawful to pay the temple tax? No, here's the census tax. Here's what I want Jesus to say when they ask him, is it lawful to pay the census tax? I want Jesus to say, no, taxes are bad. Taxation is theft. That's what I would say. But Jesus doesn't say that. Jesus is better than me. Jesus can't be trapped. What does he do? Show me one of the Roman coins. if you've ever seen one of those Roman coins, you know that on that Roman coin, there's an image of Caesar Augustus. On that Roman coin, there's an inscription. Caesar Augustus, his name, his inscription. So when Jesus says that, say, whose image is this? And they say Caesar's. That's Caesar apostrophe S. That means it's his. Jesus says, yeah, that means it's his. Let him have it. Easy. It's his. Let him have it. And I think about that. And I think, if only it was easy. …
I am representing the greatest of all. When we come to superior wisdom, what do you say to Matthew chapter 22, verse 16 to 22? Matthew 22, 16 to 22. Some people thought they can catch Jesus Christ, get him to say something wrong so that the government can grab him. and they ask, should we pay tax? If he says yes, they will say, it's an enemy of our land. If he says no, it's a rebel. He says we shouldn't give our money to Caesar. He said, don't let me answer your question. Bring me a coin. And the prophet came and said, whose inscription is on this coin? They said that of Caesar. Ah, give to Caesar. Somebody said what he was saying, he said, you have an opportunity to slap Caesar, slap him. Give to Caesar, what belongs to Caesar, but what belongs to God, give to God. In another occasion, they thought they could tie him up. In John chapter 8, from verse 3 to 11, John 8, 3 to 11, they found a woman and brought the woman to him. …
… They say, okay, tell us then what you think. Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar or not? The question specifically is this. According to the law of Moses, is it lawful for us to pay taxes to a foreign ruler, which is Rome? This is double trouble for Jesus. Because if he answers yes, then the Jewish crowds and the Pharisees will stir up against him and see he is for Rome. He is a traitor to the Israelite people. That's trouble number one. Trouble number two is if he says, no, then the Pharisees can go to the Romans or the Herodians can go to the Romans. And they can say, look, we told you, he's a dissenter. He's trying to start an uprising by getting people to not pay their taxes. And it was nothing to the Romans to just have somebody killed. So Jesus is in what's known as a leadership double bind right here. What we try to negotiate with God around tells us a lot about what we care about. …
… here's this idea that, you know, that, you know, Jesus is being asked, is it right? Is it lawful? Is it appropriate for us to pay taxes to Caesar? And by the way, most people resent that payment of taxes. And then there are a certain group of people like the zealots who are going to do everything they can not to pay the taxes. And actually, sometimes it'll go so far as to kill tax collectors or beat tax collectors or kill the Roman soldiers. And so whatever Jesus says, if Jesus says, yes, it's okay to pay taxes to Caesar, then you're going to have a whole lot of people who are pretty perturbed to Jesus because he's coming to Jerusalem riding on a donkey, you know, giving the sign that he is the coming king. And they're expecting he's going to raise up an army and a rebellion against the Romans. So he can't say, yes, it's lawful to pay taxes the Caesar. But if he says, no, it's not lawful to pay taxes to Caesar, then the Romans are going to look at him and they're going to say, well, look, he's coming and he's actually teaching them to rebel against us. We better arrest him now. I mean, Jesus is, it's, you know, darned if you do and darned if you don't, but that's what they've tried to do with Jesus in this moment. And I love what Jesus says. So it's a kind of a poison pill, but I love what Jesus says. He says, you hypocrites, …
… Well, from the time when Jesus said, they asked him, is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar or not? And he said, show me a coin. And he said, whose mug is on the front of the coin? They said, Caesar's. He said, then give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar. And give to God what belongs to God. They took that and construed it to mean, he's saying, don't pay taxes. So it was a lie. It was a fabrication. When Jesus was brought before Caiaphas, the high priest, they said, this man says that he's going to destroy the temple and then rebuild it in three days. Really, where'd they get that notion? Well, Jesus had once said, if you destroy this temple, I'll make it rise up in three days. He was speaking of the temple of his body, but they listened to that and said, he's claiming that he's going to destroy the physical temple and then rebuild it. Fabrication. Fake news. But they posted it. They published it. …
… Then they ask about His politics. Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar or not? Then they ask him a theological question about a woman who had been married many times, and they say in the resurrection, whose wife will she be? And then finally, a scribe comes up with a question about the law, which commandment is the most important of all? Four questions, four controversies, Jesus deftly handles all of them. So, look at verse 34. after that, no one dared ask him any more questions. Smart move. Don't ask Jesus any more questions. This is not getting us anywhere. Now their strategy, rather than to trip him up in his words, they're just going to make a plan to arrest him by force and have false witnesses at a sham trial. So they don't ask him any more questions. And then as Mark recounts, we come to verse 35, Jesus still teaching in the temple, and now Jesus asks a question. So think about this. They've been coming to Jesus with all of their controversies and questions, and now they don't dare to ask him anything else. So you think, what would Jesus, now that he can set the agenda, and he wants to ask them a question, what would he ask? Knowing, as Jesus knows, that his time on earth is soon coming to an end. …
What is the subject? The subject is money. And Jesus teaches that part of what you have isn't yours. It belongs to Caesar. Give it to him. And part of what you have isn't yours. It belongs to God. Give it to him. the only concept that the Jew had to work with, with this idea that part of what I have actually belongs to God is the concept of the tithe. It is not a gift. It is a payment that gives honor to him that acknowledges, I believe that Jesus Christ is Lord. Some will ask, you know, do you tithe on the... the net or the gross? What size of blessing do you want? I think there's only one answer, but I'll let you figure it out. So here we have this concept of tithes and offering. Here's what I find so fascinating for me in my own life. Is that this idea of being able to take something, I've shared this with you in the past, I know, but I heard years ago a little show on TV where they talked about, they said, it's hard to find a $20 bill in our country. …