Judas did not say this because he cared about the poor, but because he was a thief. As keeper of the money bag, he used to take from what was put into it.Now he said this, not because he cared for the poor, but because he was a thief, and having the money box, used to steal what was put into it.This he said, not that he cared for the poor; but because he was a thief, and had the bag, and bare what was put therein.Now this he said, not because he cared for the poor; but because he was a thief, and having the bag took away what was put therein.
6 sermons cite this verse
… Judas nailed it. Yeah, we should do that. Judas is so generous. What a good guy. He really loves the poor. But the verse continues on. It says, this he said, not that he cared for the poor, but because he was a thief and he had the money bag. Again, what did the world see? They see the external appearance. What no one knows, the heart, that's what Jesus saw. Judas proved, just like Pharaoh before him, that the same sun that softens the wax hardens the clay. And the more that Judas saw, the harder he became. And yet, in spite of all of that, Jesus extends the same love and forgiveness to Judas that he did to the other 11. In the upper room on the night that Judas would betray him, Jesus greets Judas with a kiss. Jesus washes Judas's feet, again, showing that he is a servant serving his disciples. He loved Judas. And prior to identifying Judas as a betrayer, it says he was troubled in spirit. He was troubled in spirit. And he said, one of you will betray me. And the disciples were perplexed. They said, Lord, who is it? Again, Judas was so good at pretending. He was so cunning that no one suspected him. It's not like Jesus said, hey, someone's going to betray me. They're like, we've got our money on Judas. We've been actually running like tabs on this. We've collected bets. Everyone thinks it's Judas. We've been telling you for months, Jesus. It's Judas. No, nobody knew he had fooled everyone except for Jesus. And when they …
We'll be considering most of John 12 today, but I'll only read portions of it for the sake of time. So please join me as I read John chapter 12, verses 1 through 11, and then we'll skip down to verses 20 through 26. I'll be reading today from the New Living Translation. Join me now as I begin at John 12, verses 1 through 11. a twelve-ounce jar of expensive perfume made from essence of nard, and she anointed Jesus' feet with it, wiping his feet with her hair. The house was filled with the fragrance. But Judas Iscariot, the disciple who would soon betray him, said, That perfume was worth a year's wage. It should have been sold and the money given to the poor. Not that he cared for the poor. He was a thief. And since he was in charge of the disciples' money, he often stole some for himself. Jesus replied, Leave her alone. She did this in preparation for my burial. You will always have the poor among you, but you will not always have me. …
In my 35 years of shepherding, I don't ever recall preaching on this text. Maybe I just have a bad memory. I do remember preaching a few times on similar texts from Matthew, Mark, and Luke, where Jesus is invited to a meal at a Pharisee's house, Simon the leper, where Jesus is anointed with a very expensive perfume by a sinner, and then the complaining begins. Simon quips, If this guy really were a prophet, he'd know who was touching him. In those accounts, the disciples all pile on this woman for the disgusting waste instead of helping the poor. But in this text, John writes that it is Judas who gets in on the act and jaws about how the expenses could have been used much more responsibly. though Judas conveniently leaves out the fact, though John adds it in, that Judas says such because of his own sinful habit of stealing from the kitty. Our text is not the same account as those in the other three Gospels. …
… Judas is the first to betray the silence with an ethical objection that clarifies his rightness in this matter. Why wasn't this perfume sold for a whole lot of money and given to the poor, he asks. John says he's a thief who uses the common purse for a common, for a personal expense account. He doesn't care about the poor, but he knows that Jesus does. So he says what he knows Jesus would have said if Jesus weren't so polite. What a waste. What an extravagance. Whatever you meant by it, Mary, this movement, it's not about us. It's about the less fortunate. Try to remember that from now on, huh? but Jesus can speak for himself he turns to Judas and says leave her alone to Judas and anyone else who might agree with him she was keeping it from my burial you always have the poor with you but you do not always have me it's an odd thing for him to say but Mary has broken more than a jar in that room she's also broken open the truth that Jesus is the first to see to speak to The poor are sturdy perennials in God's garden. …
Now, what a striking scene we've got here. In the midst of dinner, they're throwing a party for Jesus, you see. And in the midst of the dinner party, Mary takes this liter of costly perfumed oil as she bathes Jesus' feet with it. As she dries his feet with her hair, the artist has tried to capture the image on the wall there. Costly perfume. This oil cost a small fortune. Judas says it's worth over 300 days wages. That's nearly a year's worth of money. Now can you imagine putting your year's salary into a liter of fragrant oil? The gospel says it's pure nard, means uncut, undiluted. This is the potent stuff, the rich stuff. This means that the moment she breaks the flask on the liter jar, the fragrance escapes and it floods the whole room wherever you are in the house this is a conversation stopper people of God because the moment wherever you are in the house the moment you get a whiff of such fragrance such sweetness conversation stops and your nose wants to lead you to the source. …
He who has ears to hear the word of God, let them hear it. Let us pray. Father, open now to our understanding and to our instruction the words of this text that we have just heard. For we ask it in Jesus' name. Amen. Please be seated. When I was in graduate school in the decade of the 60s, one of the books that troubled the theological world was a small book published by a Harvard professor entitled, The Secular City. It put Harvey Cox's name on the map at that time. And in that book, The Secular City, Harvey Cox gave a sociological and theological analysis for the decline of America into its present form of secularization, and he talked about the shape of the American culture. And he defined the shape of American culture as being determined by America's really only indigenous philosophical system called pragmatism. And pragmatism as a philosophical system is born in a certain skepticism towards our ability to understand ultimate truth. And so the philosophers and pioneers of pragmatism, who ironically belong to the metaphysical club at Harvard, disowned any hope of discovering metaphysical truth. …